KAYAK2U

January 25, 2008

Who’s the monkey?

Monkey see, Monkey do?  The story about the monkey who has a better "memory" than humans is making the rounds again after the ape beat a British memory champion in a video "memory" challenge.  Here is the setup in the poorly written story appearing in the UK Daily Mail:

Both chimp and man watched a computer screen on which five numbers flashed up at various positions before being obscured by white squares. 

They then had to touch the squares in order of the numbers they concealed, from lowest to highest. When the numbers were shown for just a fifth of a second – the blink of an eye – Ayumu got it right almost 90 per cent of the time. 

His human opponent scored a rather less impressive 33 per cent, Channel Five programme Extraordinary Animals will reveal. 

The story mentions the word memory six times, and calls the whole thing a "memory competition", but is it really memory being tested, or at a certain point, down around "the blink of an eye", is it instead a test of how fast the two contestants can see?  I would guess that the monkey is faster than the human in a wide array of physical reflexes, to include a faster visual perception.  But does a faster visual perception count as memory?  Mr Pridmore, the memory champion, can memorize the order of cards in a deck faster than most other people, but his feat isn’t one of perception, is it?  Two humans have the same capacity to perceive all the cards.  Where does perception end and the understanding (the locking away of the memory) of the card order begin?  Can one say that the monkey has the better memory solely because he arrives at the locking away more quickly, when a factor might have been that the monkey was able to perceive the numbers on the screen more efficiently than the human?

The story doesn’t tell, but it would be a good bet that the flash of numbers had to be shortened down to the limit of human perception for the man to lose.  Memorizing the placement of five lousy numbers is a trivial exercise, especially for a memory champion.  It would be interesting to know if the man can beat the monkey at half a second, or in trials with longer times and more numbers (or instead of numbers, shapes).  Until then, call me a monkey’s uncle but color me skeptical about the conclusions drawn in the story.

It is far more interesting to me to learn that the monkey can put the images representing numbers into the proper human-centric order.

MikeSoja - January 25, 2008 -- 07:22 pm    Filed in: The Spectacle  
« Stupid and Stupider…
Lotsa little pictures »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud