KAYAK2U

February 17, 2010

More questions

On the matter of the unsecured Exceptional Student Education survey (here, here, here), a person on the periphery has emailed:

You have to enter your child school's name, grade level , and date of birth, the data entered will be compared with the data the state has.  They accept only the matched data.  All other responses will be eliminated.

Of course, I considered the possibility of exactly that, deemed it unlikely, and while I have to give it further consideration because of the email, I have no way to ascertain the claim, and only more questions.

If the emailer is correct, then the survey really isn't anonymous, even though it was touted as being anonymous, yet perhaps people are being mislead in that respect.

Also, if the emailer is correct, then the survey is still ripe for abuse and fraud.  Anyone with a list of disabled children's birthdays matched to the schools they attend, could skew the survey results quite easily, especially with the survey's historically abysmal number of survey takers.  Even someone willing to work sequentially through all 365 days in the year would invariably have many of his entries accepted.  On the flip side, the slightest error in Florida's database, or the slightest error in a parent's entry would supposedly invalidate a legitimate survey offering, with absolutely no indication, either way, to the user.

Additionally, if some nincompoop makes a run at the survey, and picks schools, grades, and birth dates of real students who haven't yet been matched with survey entries, then those entries are counted as valid, and when the legitimate parent comes along, his or her entry will be thrown away.

Further, I find it highly unlikely that the programming was done so stupidly, though it is a government endeavor, and therefore we should all probably be immeasurably thankful that it has been done as well as it has.

Obviously, if one were to insist on the methodology conveyed in the email, school/grade/birth date, then one should allow/forbid prospective survey takers after they've entered identifying parameters, but before they've taken the survey.  Unless I've been extremely lucky (and selecting valid parameters may be easier than I think – with thousands of disabled kids per school district it's likely that several children share birthdays, every day of the year, even in the same grade), then everyone taking the survey, whether their entries end up being accepted or not, is thanked for taking the survey, and invited to take another survey pertaining to another aspect of the Florida government school system.  There is no way to know if one's survey is one of those that "will be eliminated."

Of course, it may be that the scripts at www.esesurvey.com are not connected to the big Florida database where the data is allegedly "matched", but that then suggests a two step process of validating the data, which also seems ripe for abuse, fraud, or failure due to incompetence.

And with all that, there are numerous problems with Florida's ESE Survey methodology no matter which way the programming has been done.

Sweet Cheeks offers the ancillary observation relating to the validity of the survey results in light of Assistant Polk County School Board Superintendent Nancy Woolcock's recent offer (since rescinded) of free iPod Nanos to survey takers, and how those survey takers might more favorably view a school system that hands out such extravagant goodies, however incompetent and inexcellent its educational offerings.  Read: bribes.

All in all, one giant, but typical, governmental clusterfuck.

MikeSoja - February 17, 2010 -- 11:47 pm    Filed in: Education, Incompetents  
« Elite incompetence (or is it malfeasance?)
“We were flying low, and hit something in the air” »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud