KAYAK2U

June 24, 2008

Alternative conservative

Over at National Review, the media portal for a gaggle of writers that one continually hopes will find it within themselves to keep at least one step ahead of the rising slime of modern collectivism, Jonathan H. Adler has decided to go a-swimming in the cannibal pot.  He calls McCain’s offer of three hundred million dollars prize money to the inventor of new battery technology, "A meaningful alternative to special-interest subsidies", and "what may be the most promising and important energy-policy proposal of the campaign".  I say that Adler is addled.

Adler coughs up two examples of prize offerings leading to technological advances.  Without adornment, he offers, "The British empire used prizes to spur innovation in navigation."  And then he mentions the Ansari X Prize.

Maybe Adler is ignorant of the full history of the "Board of Longitude" that was formed as the 18th Century prize committee seeking a reliable way to determine longitude aboard ship, but anyone taking up McCain’s challenge would do well to have a look at it.

John Harrison labored long years to develop an accurate and rugged chronometer, but despite satisfying the requirements of the prize challenge on multiple occasions, the Board never gave Harrison the prize money!  It took sundry acts of Parliament and appeals by the King and Prime Minister for Harrison to receive his full £20,000, and through it all the Board steadfastly refused to honor its commitment, to the point of rewriting the rules of the challenge.  Further, Harrison was only allowed to claim his money from Parliament after he explained the inner workings of his clocks, and turned them over to others to be copied.  See for yourself, here, here, and here.  Further, despite Harrison’s achievements, his clocks were still too expensive to produce on a large scale, and while proving a certain practicality, proved impractical for wide-spread, general use.  (Further still, for what it’s worth, the last link there purports that while the Board of Longitude never disbursed its main prize of £20,000, it did manage to toss off about £100,000 in other ways, which in John McCain dollars would be about one and a half billion bucks, which, of course, a thoroughly modern Congress like ours could multiply in untold ways without really trying.)

Rest assured, anyone building a better battery for John McCain will get no better treatment than did John Harrison.  And 21st Century America is not 18th Century proto-Capitalist Britain.  As I said yesterday, anyone coming up with a better battery today is in for instant fame and a lot more than three hundred million dollars, without the government throwing around the dollars it steals from every man, woman, and child in the country, and anyone in it for the money would be an ass to limit himself to the government offering for what might very well be the invention of a generation (no pun intended).

Now, for the Ansari X Prize, which is as different from the Board of Longitude challenge and the McCain proposal, as day is from night.  It shouldn’t need to be laid out, but here it is:  The prize money isn’t coerced from anyone.  The rules to claim the prize are clearly defined.  All rights to developed technologies are retained by the developers:

6.2 Intellectual Property
The TEAM owns all rights in and to all of the TEAM’s Intellectual Property associated with the design, manufacture, and operation of CRAFT, secondary vehicles, and subsystems. Nothing contained herein shall be construed as granting any proprietary rights, by license or otherwise, to XPF with respect to such property.

The only claims the X Prize people make have to do with media rights to the X Prize story, and the like, and even there, are fairly generous.

So, I’m left wondering whether Jonathan Adler can advise whether the McCain proposal is going to follow the Board of Longitude model, or the X Prize model, and how he can justify supporting the proposal in either case.  If the former, the government is going to have to make its claims up front (unlike what happened with Harrison), and who does Adler suppose is going to do the hard work just to have it taken for a token amount?  If Adler thinks a prize for battery advancement is such a bloody good idea, why doesn’t he head on over to the X Prize page and click on the "PROPOSE AN X PRIZE" link, and propose it on his own?  Oh, that’s right, somebody already HAS, and they didn’t limit the proposal to battery technology, but to a complete automotive design, utilizing any technology available.  For all Adler knows, investing in battery technology is not the best way to go, and as just one of many possibilities is exactly the sort of "special-interest subsid[y]" that Adler claims McCain’s proposal is "A meaningful alternative to".  Can you un-addle that for me, Adler?

MikeSoja - June 24, 2008 -- 03:04 pm    Filed in: Stupid Government, The Press  
« The Biggest Moron in the World
Build the pot, and the cannibals will come »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud