KAYAK2U

January 8, 2009

Thugs, despots, and blaming the wrong people

It should be obvious that responsibility for the recent catastrophe at the Kingston Steam Plant is to be laid soley at the feet of the Tennessee Valley Authority, owners and operators of said plant.  

The coal ash spill isn’t the fault of Tennesseans who use electricity.  Customers have no ownership rights or responsibilities, especially when they are denied a choice of supplier.  The TVA is a federally mandated monopoly.

The billion gallons of sludge across the land isn’t the fault of the coal industry, any more than murder is the fault of Remington Arms Co., or traffic fatalities are the fault of Ford, or that graffiti is the fault of spray paint manufacturers.

The contaminated water making its way through the heart of the eastern half of the country isn’t even the fault of state and federal legislators and regulators.  Nope.  Even if there were some half-sensical justification (there isn’t) for raising another platoon of regulators, it still wouldn’t be their responsibility to prevent disasters like the one at the mouth of the Emory River.  It isn’t the fault of the USDA when E. coli crops up.  It isn’t the fault of the FCC when someone bares a breast on Superbowl TeeVee.  If someone wanted to hire a person or agency to prevent or insure against various calamities, then one might be able to assign responsibility and extract compensation if said person or agency failed to fulfill their contract and said calamity came to pass, but state and federal regulators are under no such onus (which is particularly why they are ineffective to the point of worthlessness.)

No, the only people responsible for the coal ash spill are the people who owned and operated the site, who failed to maintain their dike in which they were storing their fly ash which is a by-product of their business.  They are the sole responsible party.  Unfortunately, the situation at the Emory River is clouded by the fact that the TVA isn’t owned by anyone, because it is ostensibly owned by everyone.  The fingerpointing can go on quite a ways when there are 300 million others to pass the buck to, but that doesn’t change the fact that there are only a relatively few people whose responsibility it is to run the TVA.

And yet, a large number of people just don’t get it, or are otherwise lost in their own personal agendas.  For instance, some eleven days ago, two kayakers and a canoeist paddled up the Emory River to the big spill to have a look around, and to take pictures and water samples.  They made a little (YouTube) video of what they saw and did.  It’s generally boring, but at the 6:50 mark we are given:

But at about that time, we were interrupted.  A nice little TVA officer [in his nice little TVA speed boat -ed] issued us a warning citation for criminal tresspass.  He told us if we ever came back to the river he would prosecute us, even though we never set foot on dry land, and never touched any private property.  We remained in our boats on navigable public waters of the United States at all times.

Elsewhere, they tell that part of the story slightly differently: 

Wathen said the groups have been denied access to public roads and escorted out of a waterway by private TVA security police who claimed they were given federal authority through the Patriot act.  

These are, Watham said, “gestopo tactics intended to scare people away from the truth.” 

Along with Donna Lisenby and Sandra Diaz, Watham skirted police lines and took samples. “Cops (were) yelling from both sides,” he said.  “The cops in cars could not get to us for the water. The cops in the boat could not reach us for the mud and debris in the river, and the helicopter couldn’t land in the muck to pick us up either.”

Personally, I don’t care if they had to cold cock a TVA goon in order to get to the river, but in the same interview, what do you suppose Wathan’s take on what he saw that day was?  Here ’tis:

“Folks, it is time to change the way we do business with coal burning,” Wathen said.

There he is, standing within sight of a disaster caused by TVA negligence, been ticketed and escorted out of places he had a right to be by TVA goons, had absolute drivel about "the Patriot Act" thrown at him by the same TVA goons, and yet, for him and others, it’s all about the coal burning, man.

Jesus.

And there’s those "private" TVA police again.  And I don’t doubt they were making noises about the Patriot Act.  Who’s going to call them on it, eh?  They’ve been running things in these parts for quite some time, and they don’t have to stand for some weaselly schnook trying to stick a nose in their business.

More evidence of the abuse the TVA throws around can be found at the link I gave yesterday to the TVA’s 2007 SEC filing.  Down in the bowels of the "Legal Proceedings" section, one finds this gem:

On April 3, 2006, TVA moved to dismiss the suit on grounds that the case is not suitable for judicial resolution because of separation of powers principles, including the fact that these matters are based on policy decisions left to TVA’s discretion in its capacity as a government agency and thus are not subject to tort liability (the “discretionary function doctrine”), as well as the Supremacy Clause.

Anyone want to claim that maintaining shoddy dikes next to rivers isn’t a "policy decision left to TVA’s discretion"?  Good luck

In the case cited, the court ended up denying the TVA’s motion (though the SEC filing doesn’t say for what reason), but it isn’t the only case listed where the TVA tried to use its position as a federally chartered institution to protect itself from those with claims against it.  Such is nothing less than raw despotism hiding behind the privilege of political power.  It’s a license to be negligent and irresponsible, and it’s part and parcel of all government entities.  I don’t know why the little canoeists and kayakers can’t understand that.

MikeSoja - January 8, 2009 -- 10:15 pm    Filed in: Stupid Government, TVA  
« Oh, joy
“[E]verything but freedom” »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud