The temptation was too much. There in the glow of the search engine spew was the headline, "The Three-Mile Island of coal", neatly encapsulated in a link to SOCIALISTWORKER.org. "That’s gotta be a laugh," I thought, and secured my seat pre-click. I was, however, quickly thrown for a loop when "Mike" "reported":
Within days, residents reported "vomiting for more than 12 hours after drinking the water"–which is a common symptom of arsenic or heavy metal poisoning.
"Wow," sez I to myself, "I must have missed some news," and so went searching. I found no recountings of mass vomitings in the incompetent Main Street Media, of course, but only the words of a certain anti-coal fanatic, who claimed on December 24th, just two days after the coal ash spill:
We met a man who had been vomiting for the past 12 hours after drinking a couple of pots of coffee made from the tainted water,” said Matt Landon of United Mountain Defense, a Knoxville TN based environmental organization. We advised him to go to the hospital.
In this version, also dated December 24th, Landon says that it was…
*** Yesterday we spoke with one man who had been vomiting for 12 hours after drinking a few pots of coffee made from the tainted water. We informed to go to the hospital and we could not find him again today. Today we met a lady whose dogs had been vomiting after drinking the un-boiled tainted water.
The claim was promulgated on Landon’s anti-coal group site, here, and subsequently picked up and repeated here, here, and further on down the line of usual suspects.
There is some reason to doubt Landon’s claim entirely, because, while the second December 24th entry above refers to "Yesterday", or December 23rd, the rest of the article pertains to Landon’s very first visit to the site of the coal ash spill, on the 24th. It doesn’t sound like Landon went to Kingston or Harriman on the 23rd. Therefore, Landon either spoke to someone on the phone on December 23rd, or heard the story from someone else (perhaps the "we" to which he continually tosses the exchange), or otherwise pulled the claim out of the air. (Landon, by the way, is half of the duo initially reported to have been "arrested and detained" by TVA police for the crime of taking pictures of the toxic heap, but now says: "I was not arrested just a few days ago; I was actually just detained for over an hour for taking photographs," which doesn’t particularly absolve the TVA police of anything, in my eyes.) In any event, to accept the bare gist of the coffee/vomiting story, we must believe that within a few hours of the giant spill someone in the immediate vicinity was stupid enough to go down to the river, scoop up some ash-filled muck with which to fill his coffee pot (at least twice, but as many as "a few" times), drink the resulting brew, followed by twelve hours of vomiting, to be saved only when the caring folks at UMD "advised him to go to the hospital." Either that, or we must believe that, in addition to the river and lake waters which were obviously immediately polluted by the untold gallons of coal ash dumped in them, the underground wells and aquifers in the area were also immediately rendered unsafe, but only with the invisible, odorless, tasteless particles from the spill, so that at least one person was lulled into believing his water unaffected by the calamity which had just taken place outside his walls. It doesn’t seem plausible to me.
What’s for sure is that Mike-the-SocialistWorker (top of post) is completely nuts, as there is no indication of a plural in the record, and no one as yet has even semi-officially cited any cases of arsenic poisoning associated with the spill.
Other instances of Mike-the-SocialistWorker’s loose association with reality can be seen in statements like, "To prevent these types of disasters in the future, we will need to […] establish public ownership and control over the TVA", his pitch seeming to land somewhere outside the ballpark of facts having to do with the current public ownership and control of the TVA. It is precisely that the TVA is publicly owned that is much of the problem.
But Mike-the-SocialistWorker’s title, "The Three-Mile Island of coal", is also fairly daft, even after dismissing his misspelling of the place (sludge is not radiation, and the country will continue to build coal plants despite the TVA’s incompetence), and yet it is fairly typical of the headlines I’ve been seeing for the last several weeks.
Here’s Landon again, playing the plague of biblical proportions card: "The Great Coal Ash Flood".
Then there is the calm and rational Dave Cooper, writing under the headline, "Disaster in Harriman is this country’s Chernobyl"…
Environmental Protection Agency data requested by The New York Times reveals that in just one year, TVA placed 45,000 pounds of arsenic in the Kingston impoundment. And, since the plant is over 50 years old, 1 million pounds of arsenic is a conservative estimate for the total release into the Emory River.
Cooper somehow misses the fact that the TVA posts its emissions data on a publicly viewable web page. And then he makes the commonly unclever mistake of presuming that the Kingston plant’s entire store of coal ash with all of its noxiousnesses included was immediately sucked into the surrounding environment never to be see again except in the genetic mutations of fauna and flora, when, in dreary fact, about half the pile collapsed, and a relatively small portion of that made it to the water. To be sure, the size of the original pile was, without question, immense, and a lot of damage was and is still to be done, but these attempts to blow the thing out of proportion seem counterproductive to me, especially inasmuch as direct criticism of the TVA is avoided in favor of attacking the stacks of coal that are the apparent, real enemies of the kooks and socialists.
The next headline in the parade of outsized calamaties that caught my eye was, "Holocaust Victims Attorney Files Class-Action Lawsuit Against TVA", but it turns out that the law firm really was founded by an attorney who chased down Nazi collaborators, back in the day.
And then we come to the Exxon Valdez, everyone’s favorite monumental environmental disaster and easy touchstone for smart sounding comparisions. Let ME say that I’d rather go play on the hundred acres of sludge in Kingston than swim around in two gallons of north shore crude, but maybe that’s just me.
Elsewise, here are the headlines…
Will Tennessee Coal Ash Spill Be the Exxon Valdez of Clean Coal?
Tennessee Sludge Spill: Government Disaster 30 Times Worse than Exxon-Valdez
Environmental Disaster in Tennessee Reported 40x Exxon Valdez Spill
Environmental Spill Disaster Devastates Tennessee; 48 Times the Size of Exxon Valdez
Nightmare before Christmas: Coal sludge spill 50X worse than Exxon Valdez
Here’s Landon again, upping the ante: "The volume of waste released was over 80 times larger than the Exxon Valdez spill."
But the champ of champs is (drum roll, please….. ) Barbara Boxer:
The committee’s chairwoman, Sen. Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., was more strident in her criticism of the Dec. 22 sludge flood at a coal ash-filled pond in Kingston, Tenn. — an event she characterized as "100 times greater than the amount of oil spilled during the Exxon Valdez" spill off the coast of Alaska in 1989.
Do I hear two hundred???!???
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||