KAYAK2U

March 16, 2009

Bastiat’s automobile

Economic shortsidedness is breaking out all around.  In Britain certain parties are clamoring for the same partiality that the German government has granted the like factions in that country.  The gist of it is that the respective governments will heavily subsidize the purchase of a new car, if one has a nine year old or older car to haul to the scrap yard.  Auto manufacturers are delighted, as are the scrap yard people, as are those in the market for new cars.

But, as Bastiat so elegantly and famously pointed out, there is the seen and the unseen.  That which is seen are the new cars parked around the council houses, and the increase in sales down at the big auto plants.  What is not seen is the distortion the scheme sets wriggling throughout the economy.  There is no such thing as an even partially free car.

The Germans are offering €2,500 per old car, while the Brits are thinking that £2,000 ought to do the trick.  Obviously, if one owns an older model that is worth more than those amounts, it makes no sense whatsoever to take the state up on its offer.  Even those whose cars are worth less than but close to the offered rebate amount will likely not be enticed if they weren’t already thinking about a new car, since the trade-in, etc., compared to the government’s offer is a near wash.  In fact, the scheme becomes gradually more enticing the closer the trade-in’s value is to zero.  Those with the junkiest cars achieve the greatest savings.  Additionally, I would not be surprised to learn that whatever used car market there is in Germany has been completely disrupted, for, by government fiat, any used car is now automatically worth €2,500.  Looking for that cheapo to get you to that new job and back?  Sorry.  It was already snapped up at €500 to trade in at the €2,500 rate for a new one.  Any Auto von Bismark used car dealer worth his name would have immediately seen the worth in pricing his goods appropriately.  And all those cars newly arrived at the scrap yards?  They’re no longer available at any price.  Perhaps you would be interested in something two-wheeled and motorless?  Very green, fights global warming, heil liberal fascism!

And what of the €2,500 and the £2,000 amounts taken from the earnest citizenry in the form of taxes to pay for these schemes?  The things that that money might have purchased also belong to that which is not seen.  Germany’s taxpayers are all the poorer for buying up junk cars at inflated prices.  Don’t forget to include the monies spent and debts incurred that might otherwise been distributed throughout the economy (or put toward debt retirement!) had it not been for the government’s perverse incentive.  How many littler purchases are being put off until later, or never made at all, so that cars can be bought now while the government monies are still available?

And, as the second link above points out, there are further knock on effects.  The perverse government-granted incentives encourage people to buy cars now, while the money lasts, cars that might otherwise have been purchased next year.  The auto companies are therefore ringing up next year’s business this year, which might seen like a good thing now, but come next year when nearly everyone that wanted a new car already has one, what then?  Factories need steady work, not to be opened and closed with the whims of the shortsighted political class.

Bollocks on all of it.

MikeSoja - March 16, 2009 -- 11:47 am    Filed in: Commies, Incompetents, Stupid Government  
« Instarot
Fog light »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud