KAYAK2U

August 7, 2009

Klein Boggle II

A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct “logical” and “reasonable” sides.

Q&A with Ezra Klein:

Re: Cash For Clunkers: Ezra, I don’t understand the Republican criticism (but when do I ever?) to this program, calling it a boondoggle because it already needs more money.

If my local store decides to boost sales with a special promotion and they clear the shelves of product, why is that a bad thing? Don’t you think their parent company would agree to give them more resources to keep the promotion going so they could sell more stuff?

I thought the Republicans understood capitalism.

Ezra Klein: It’s been confusing. There’s a legitimate criticism of cash for clunkers that it doesn’t do enough to force the purchase of high-mileage, environmentally friendly vehicles. But it’s hard to say that a bill that was meant to kickstart car sales is failing because it has kickstarted car sales.

Ezra’s acolytes are a dim bunch.  “Cash for Clunkers” is not “a boondoggle because it already needs more money.”  It’s a boondoggle because no matter how much money and resources are expended in its furtherance, it is a waste, a fraud, an economic travesty, useless, of no value, in fact, detrimental to any hoped for economic recovery.  In fact, “Cash for Clunkers” is worse than your ordinary boondoggle, which are usually mere excercises in waste and mismanagement.  With “Cash for Clunkers”, tax dollars are being used to purchase working automobiles at ridiculous premiums, and then those automobiles, which do have some value, are being unceremoniously destroyed.  Active value destruction.  With money forced from the citizenry, no less.

If my local store decides to boost sales with a …

[interjected circa 2015:] Local stores do not have the ability to boost sales by offering discounts backed by monies taken from non-customers, which is what the government did with Cash For Clunkers.

If your local store runs a promotion, its sales manager doesn’t come around to your house and put a gun to your head to solicit you for the difference between the regular and sales price, but that’s exactly what the government is doing to finance “Cash for Clunkers”.  Where the fuck do you think the three billion dollars for this joke of a program is coming from?

I thought the Republicans understood capitalism.

I got news for you, but “Cash for Clunkers” is not capitalism, which ought to be glaringly obvious, but, apparently, not so obvious that Klein would choose to so note.

Ezra Klein: It’s been confusing.

Yeah, I bet.

There’s a legitimate criticism of cash for clunkers that it doesn’t do enough to force the purchase of high-mileage, environmentally friendly vehicles.

Yeah, because if you’re going to dun working stiffs for three billion large, you want to be as big an asshole in directing people in your preferred direction as you possibly can.  Trouble is, there are numerous other truly legitimate objections to the stupid “Cash for Clunkers” program.  I even put some of them in earlier bloggings.

[I]t’s hard to say that a bill that was meant to kickstart car sales is failing because it has kickstarted car sales.

You think you’re eating a free lunch, Klein, but somebody is paying for the gristle in your mouth.  “Cash for Clunkers” is a failure because it begins with stolen productivity and ends with the destruction of real values in metal and plastic.  There are enough unintended consequences rattling around in the thing yet to come out to warrant a new passel of idiots to harangue the air for the government to DO something about them.

“It never ends, this shit…” (Beck link)

MikeSoja - August 7, 2009 -- 10:41 pm    Filed in: Capitalism, Commies  
« Klein Boggle
Turtles up »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud