What started out as a bad three page bailout plan:
By Monday, after an intense weekend of negotiations, the draft of the bailout legislation before Congress had swelled to 42 pages.
By Friday, after almost a week of marathon talks between Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson and key lawmakers in both parties, the working version was up to 102 pages.
It likely will grow even longer as negotiators continue to tweak the proposal this weekend, adding and subtracting key elements.
Rep. Barney Frank, D-Mass., the House Financial Services Committee’s chairman, was optimistic Friday that a final agreement could be reached by Sunday.
Hey, maybe I can get a line or two in there for me!
Or maybe, after this straw gets the camel bucking, we can look to see the bubble in collectivist ignorance burst.
September 28th update: The ‘‘Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008’’ is now 110 pages. Every one chock full of goodness, you just know it.
Smile. Smile. Smile.
With fear of economic collapse in all the news, Obama keeps on reading from his socialist crib sheet.
And McCain is too stupid to frame his (sometimes almost intelligent) instincts into effective anti-socialist soundbites, demonstrating (to me, at least) that most of what dribbles out of his mouth is purely contrived.
. . .
It may be time to buy a decent shotgun. I’ve been putting it off cuz I’m an optimistic type.
I can smell the shit when it hits the fan, however.
ps. And maybe that pistol I’ve been dreaming of.
pps. Purely defensive, of course. And I am optimistic that this gorgeous backwater will suffer less than other places, partly because it’s been suffering for time immemorial, already, with people fairly self-sufficient and proudly belligerent. Although some may mistakenly think the government should be doing more, they aren’t likely to want to take my things when their bellies shrink.
ppps. See how optimistic I am?
pppps. Cheers!
One thing is certain: The federal government hasn’t gone to such lengths to scare the population into trusting it since February 2003. That time, it concerned weapons of mass destruction, and it turned out to be much ado about nothing.
I’m down with the cliff thing, sort of, but only if we get to be lemmings instead of Robert Redford.
Or maybe something else.
It’s more like being herded off to an economic Siberia, only in America you get to watch the bastards on TeeVee, banging the gavel down on your life as they solemly swear that it’s all in everybody’s best interest, which, amazingly, probably 47% of people believe. (Or maybe it’s just 47% of the voting public, which isn’t quite as many, but enough, nevertheless.)
It’s America’s new rockpile, and the hammers are government issue.
…
(Gadzooks! I just realized it is Fall. How the hell did that happen?)
Have they closed Fannie and Freddie down, yet?
Have they shut down Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, yet????????????
They’ve banned short selling on several hundred stocks.
Short sellers have become scapegoats for the big declines in the share prices of weakened companies including Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. and American International Group Inc., though it is unclear whether they were the cause of the declines.
Gosh. Sounds like what passes for business as usual in the halls of government. A private entity that made decisions on the basis of unsubstantiated fingerpointing wouldn’t be in business long. One suspects that the govbots at the SEC lack even a fundamental understanding of markets in general, and of the stock market in particular.
It turns out, of course, that there are politicians creeping through the weeds at the edge of the swamp, and looky who they are (same link as above):
The SEC sped up its rule-making and on Wednesday it announced three trading rules that were aimed at curbing abusive short selling. Calls continued that afternoon with New York Sens. Charles Schumer and Hillary Clinton, who urged Mr. Cox to halt all short-selling for financial stock. They reasoned it was necessary to aid their Wall Street constituents.
I wonder how that works, eh? I mean, short selling isn’t as complicated as, say, cattle futures. I’m just surprised to see Hillary shilling for greedy corporate capitalists. Maybe her "constituents" are related to these people? Maybe Slick Willie & Co., too, have been caught holding. More likely, definitely. One is tempted to think that stopping short sales might give certain investors a few extra minutes to unwind unfavorable positions, but in today’s world-wide, electronic markets, people who might count themselves as Clinton’s "constituents" shouldn’t have much of a problem with that kind of thing, anyway. More likely, Hillary and Chuckie are showing their ignorance and incompetence viz a viz the market and its workings, and the brown nosers at the SEC (think the kind of people going through council home trash bins in England to snitch on their neighbors) jumped right to it.
Anyway, short selling is not a long term thing. People generally don’t sell and hold. It’s nerve wracking. The upside goes a long way up, and up is the downside of short sales. Additionally, in a falling market the entity loaning the shares that have been sold short will want to make the margin call, so that it can sell those shares outright. Relatedly, brokers and market makers can refuse to loan the shares that short sellers need, as one pension fund is already doing (first link above, again):
Calpers-California Public Employees’ Retirement System, the largest U.S. public pension fund, said it is no longer lending out shares of Goldman, Morgan Stanley or Wachovia.
In a falling market, or one perceived to be falling, that’s just sound business sense, and, ergo, another way that the market looks after itself without the SEC and Hillary Clinton sticking their stupid snoots in it.
In any event, killing short sales, even in just one sector of the market, kills one corner of market liquidity, and opens up hedge funds and even regular investors to volatility that they might ordinarily use short sales to hedge against. But, since people can still buy and sell, stocks will still tend toward some sane valuation. As market players, short sellers facilitate getting to that position. And when they’re wrong, they pay for it.
One of the many purported outrages of the week seems to be McCain saying that "the fundamentals of the economy are strong", or words to that effect. Supposedly educated people are calling it a "catastrophic" error by McCain. Every pundit worth a penny (and there are quite a few) weighed in in like vein, invariably pointing to the messes at Fannie, Freddie, Lehman, and AIG. Obama, Biden, and all their surrogates read the same lines. And McCain, chastised, hung his head and muttered something about workers.
Seems to me that Fannie, Freddie, Lehman, and AIG are NOT "economic fundamentals". Even the stock market isn’t a "fundamental". The stock market may be affected by fundamentals, but it can be affected by lots of things, such as revealed mismanagement at large economic institutions, or by hurricanes, wars, puerile acts of Congress, pontificating blowhards, etc.
No. Economic fundamentals are things like employment, interest rates, inflation, productivity, and the dollar. And those things are relatively strong. And despite nine or ten months (or six years, take yer pick) of Democrats wishing and praying and announcing that the country is in the midst of a recession, the economy still hasn’t fallen into one.
But no one cares about what is, anymore, or what words mean. It’s jibber jabber at a pace I’ve never seen before. It’s the wholesale shortage of the one commodity that no country calling itself free or civilized can do without: honesty.
Brett Arends, working the conveyor belt at Yahoo, comes up with, 10 Ways to Protect Your Finances From the Crisis.
Numero the last:
10. If you want to worry about anything, worry about your taxes. The worse this crisis gets, the more they will end up putting the taxpayer on the hook to prevent a meltdown. Taxes are going up sooner or later anyway, no matter who wins the election, because of our gigantic federal deficits. (If you think Lehman Brothers was bad, you should look at Uncle Sam). And you can forget about any talk of tax breaks. Oh, and if you want a break from worrying about taxes, worry about Treasury bonds. Deficits won’t do anything good for them.
Ray Evans in Australia’s Quadrant Magazine quotes Vaclav Klaus, President of the Czech Republic:
“As a politician who personally experienced communist central planning of all kinds of human activities, I feel obliged to bring back the already almost forgotten arguments used in the famous plan-versus-market debate in the 1930s in economic theory (between Mises and Hayek on the one side and Lange and Lerner on the other); the arguments we had been using for decades until the moment of the fall of communism. The innocence with which climate alarmists and their fellow travellers in politics and media now present and justify their ambitions to mastermind human society belongs to the same fatal conceit. To my great despair, this is not sufficiently challenged, neither in the field of social sciences, nor in the field of climatology. The social sciences, especially, are suspiciously silent.
“The climate alarmists believe in their own omnipotency; in knowing better than millions of rationally behaving men and women what is right or wrong. They believe in their own ability to assemble all relevant data into their Central Climate Change Regulatory Office equipped with huge supercomputers, and in the possibility of giving adequate instructions to hundreds of millions of individuals and institutions and in the non-existence of an incentive problem (and the resulting compliance or non-compliance of those who are supposed to follow these instructions).
“We have to restart the discussion about the very nature of government and about the relationship between the individual and society. Now it concerns the whole of mankind, not just the citizens of one particular country. To discuss this means to look at the canonically structured theoretical discussion about socialism (or communism), and to learn the uncompromising lesson from the inevitable collapse of communism eighteen years ago. It is not about climatology. It is about freedom.”
Evans goes on to hammer the "warmists" to the front door of their false religion with nail after solid nail.
You could read the whole thing if you like.
Via Coyote Blog, about people who are reduced to teaching Economics 101 to dummies, and the willful ignorance of politicians.
Oops. Another of those long lasting Compact Fluorescent Lightbulbs just blew. It lasted slightly longer than a conventional bulb, but of course, not quite long enough to have worked out to be cheaper than those good ol’ incandescents. Fortunately, it didn’t "blow" in the catastrophic way at least one of my CFLs has done, and I didn’t have to call a Hazmat team to change it. Of course, a couple years ago when that other one did blow, I didn’t know about the environmental hazard of the thing, but was more concerned with the flames shooting out of the top of the bulb, and counted my lucky stars that I was home and nearby when it happened. Otherwise, you know…
I am happy to inform that a perfectly symmetrical 75-Watt incandescent bulb is now in the socket where the CFL used to be.
Look, Ma, I gotta bigger carbon footprint!
DeLong posts the bulk of an anti-Washington Post union advertisement under the title Why Oh Why Can’t We Have a Better Press Corps?, and then, quite naturally for DeLong, forgets to give the other side of the story:
“The Post offered the union, over three years ago, a comprehensive contract proposal that included wage increases for all mail room employees and more secure retirement alternatives to a union pension plan that in recent years has been underfunded and has reduced members’ future benefits,” said Rima Calderon, The Post Co.’s senior director for communications.
“The union has chosen a public relations campaign rather than negotiations at the bargaining table to address the pension issue, which has prevented mail room employees from receiving wage increases and better retirement security,” Calderon added.
Phillips declined to say how much the union was spending on the campaign, but he said contributions were coming in from locals around the country. The CWA has about 750,000 members nationwide. According to a CWA news release, The Post reported a profit of $324.5 million in 2006 and “handed out millions in executive compensation. Despite this, our workers continue to receive nothing. No raises. No parity. No help on health care.”
Calderon said the $324.5 million represents profit for the entire Washington Post Co. The newspaper division, where the production employees work, was responsible for $63.4 million of that amount.
Production workers are primarily nighttime employees who bag and help sort newspapers into bundles and load them onto trucks for distribution. The CWA said its mail room workers at The Post have not had a pay increase since May 2002 and currently earn $12.71 to $26.15 per hour.
[…]
Operating income for the company’s newspaper division, primarily The Post, plummeted 50 percent during the third quarter of 2007, compared with the third quarter of 2006. The paper’s income has been ravaged by a sharp drop in real estate advertising and the continued defection of classified and employment advertising to the Internet.
update: link fixed
Balko gets it mostly right when he catches the wind whistling through John Edwards’s empty skull on the subject of crude oil prices, but down at the end I think he’s got something wrong:
But a guy like Edwards can’t trust the free market. So he’ll use government to keep gas artificially inexpensive (staving off market incentives to develop alternative fuels), while giving billions of taxpayer dollars to research and development boondoggles (also known as corporate welfare) to find replacements for gas.
I haven’t spent the last several months hanging on every word that comes out of Edwards’s mouth, but there’s absolutely nothing on his web site that could be interpreted as indicating that Edwards wants to try to actually hold oil prices artificially low. Dumping oil from the U.S. strategic reserve is at best a short term move, and one not guaranteed to move the price of oil much at all. (Nor, technically, would I call using the strategic reserves an “artificial” move. The reserves are a factor in the real market.) The reserves would at some point, presumably, have to be replenished, meaning a wash on the supply side, hence, largely irrelevant.
No, I don’t know of any candidate whining about the price of oil, or about big oil in general, who doesn’t have it in mind to use government interference to artificially raise the price of gas. I mean, unless Congress and the Prez vote to allow the opening up of the oil-rich U.S. lands that are currently off limits to drilling, resulting in a larger supply of oil to the market, or unless OPEC is persuaded to increase production, nothing within the power of the political class will lower prices. Putting caps on prices will just create shortages. Hitting big oil with increased or windfall taxes will wind up costing the consumer. Taking away any subsidies, ditto. Subsidizing competitive energy supply won’t amount to squat within a decade or two, and will only put further pressure on oil companies, most of whom are all ready deeply invested in seeking out their own brands of alternative energies. Factor in the waste in having someone as stupid as John Edwards or Nancy Pelosi try to select the sectors and specific companies on which to bestow the wonderful government subsidies, and we’re talking further dislocations, ala the rising price of corn.
Having the government directly pay for poor people’s gas and oil, will, of course, appeal to those people, and lower their costs, but is likely to drive up the overall cost of gas and oil, as people tend to use more of something they don’t have to pay for. Also, the money has to come from somewhere, and wherever that somewhere is, prices there will rise or someone will have less money to spend or invest.
No, despite all of Edwards prattling about the price of oil, nothing he has in mind will or can wind up reducing prices at the pump. His anti-global warming rhetoric alone will have everyone paying far more than they do now.
Last Saturday, Hillary Clinton, allegedly one of the smartest women around, came out with, “I predict to you, the oil-producing countries will drop the price of oil”. IF Hillary is elected, of course. And OPEC will do it, according to Hillary (as related by the New York Daily News), “When the world hears her commitment at her inauguration about ending American dependence on foreign fuel”.
She additionally “warned that folks shouldn’t be grateful now if oil countries cut prices from near $100 a barrel to $60 or $70”.
Got that? Hillary is going to mount a major national commitment (with other people’s money) to “alternative energy” that will scare (or otherwise manipulate) OPEC into lowering the world-wide price of oil, but that we shouldn’t be “grateful” to have that lower price, because OPEC will only be lowering the price to thwart Hillary’s “commitment” to “alternative energy” and that once that commitment is undermined they’ll raise the price again and “boil a frog”.
It’s almost like a Vast Right Wing Conspiracy, only kookier.
For one thing, OPEC, et al., is not going to alter its basic direction because of a “commitment” (no matter how forcefully declared) to embark on a quest for workable alternative energy. As the timeless interrogative goes: Commit to invent a new energy source in one hand and shit in the other and what have you got? Hillary’s “commitment” can do absolutely squat to alleviate one drop of world wide demand for oil, and it is precisely that demand that drives the current markets for the stuff. The only thing that can drop the price is for demand to ease, and demand can’t ease until long after Hillary’s “commitment” comes to fruition, if ever. The Greenies ought to get used to the idea: There will be demand for oil, oil will be pumped and shipped and burned and otherwise utilized, until every last drop of the stuff is gone and unrecoverable.
So, what’s Hillary really on about, then? Obviously, she wants oil at a hundred dollars a barrel, or higher. She doesn’t want people to enjoy lower priced oil. She needs the tension and crisis-like atmosphere of high oil prices to underline her fulminations and dedication to commit the country to the path she’ll, in her infinite wisdom, select for us.
It’s my contention that the first thing Hillary will do upon taking office is to jack up federal taxes at the pump, or impose some sort of profits tax on the oil companies, or both. Take a look at it. How else is she to finance her “commitment”? I mean, a national search for alternative energy is going to take lots of money, is it not? How much will the salutatory effects of a substantial (and artificial) rise in the price of gas subdue demand for oil on the American continent? It’s hard to say, but I’d guess that it wouldn’t be enough to drive a thirty or forty percent price cut amongst the bulk of the oil producing nations, though that’s what Hillary seems to believe.
What it would do is further burden an economy already bent under sundry governmental impositions, and for absolutely nothing. Creating artificial shortages of gas will not magically create the conditions for major energy supply breakthroughs. Taking money from oil companies and giving it to solar panel scientists or geothermal speculators is tantamount to throwing the money away. Those at the forefront of those endeavors are all ready drawing investments, where merited, from people personally interested in vetting the usefulness of the work. Committees of bureaucrats have no way of assessing the value of their “investments” because they have no real stake in the endeavor.
But none of that matters to one such as Hillary. As she said lo those many months ago, “”I want to take those [oil company] profits and put them into an alternative energy fund that will begin to fund alternative smart energy, alternatives that will actually begin to move us toward the direction of independence.”
But Hillary is nuts. For one thing, it is the oil companies themselves who are most interested, and all ready hardest at work, in developing so-called alternative energy sources. They all ready have the wherewithal, much of the expertise, and the ability to best utilize their own resources. Penalizing them and heaping more burdens on the all ready suffering taxpayer is exactly the wrong way to go about anything.
The commitment to impose false shortages upon the American oil market, and to try to fool the market with arbitrary investments, will wind up creating real shortages, and crippling the ability of the U.S. economy to play in the real world.
It is always a bad idea when governments intrude into markets, but it is especially ludicrous in a market as benign and common as the market in lightbulbs. There is, first and foremost, the regrettable fact of additional encroachment on personal freedom. The honest citizen is no longer to be allowed to purchase the bulbs that best suit his taste and budget, but instead must subsume his own judgement to that of the “collective” which knows and cares nothing about his own personal situation. Further, in the present case, it is even likely that there is no reason to be at all worried about the current levels of energy generation or consumption, and that all of the hand wringing and endless sanctimonious ponitifications on the “crises” at hand are no more than the blatherings of morons and charlatans. And for them we fritter away our freedoms?
In addition, government usurpation of the rights of citizens always brings with it unintended consequences. Here’s a specific one related to the lightbulb farce that hadn’t occurred to me, but Mike Masnick at Techdirt points out, eliminating one segment of a large market might have a not-so-subtle affect on overall business strategies…
Already, more and more people were moving to more efficient bulbs naturally, as they realized how much money they actually saved with them. For those who complained about the type of light given off by the fluorescents, that just gave more incentives for the makers of CFLs to make the light better match incandescent bulbs. The competition also gave more incentives to make CFLs cheaper and even more efficient, as well as coming up with ways to make the (already seriously overhyped) worries about mercury, less of an issue. However, if politicians take away the competition from incandescents, it suddenly gives the makers of CFLs a lot less incentive to come up with these kinds of innovations and breakthroughs.
The market is a two-way street, a negotiation between business and consumer. When the government steps in and disrupts that negotiation, we all lose.
… are about to clobber the people of Massachusetts. You would really think that people would know better than to try to force the market to go places that it doesn’t want to go on its own, but apparently it’s a lesson that needs to be learned over and over the hard way.
I’m talking about the mandatory health insurance laws that former Governor (and aspiring Presidential candidate) Mitt Romney helped jam into place just before he skedaddled out of town. It seems that the costs of compliance are not going unnoticed by the businesses targeted by the law.
To comply with the new state insurance law, a Burger King franchisee in Boston expanded coverage from just his salaried staff to all full-timers. To control his costs, he halved the share he pays. Only three of the 27 newly eligible employees took the insurance; others say they can’t afford it.
A large human service provider toughened eligibility for coverage in response to the new law, requiring employees to work 30 hours a week to qualify. That took away the option of work-based coverage for nearly 100 low-wage workers, but made them eligible for cheaper, state-subsidized insurance. It could reduce the company’s costs while increasing the state’s.
Another employer split his firm into separate corporations, each with fewer than 11 full-time employees, according to his insurance broker. That way he does not have to offer insurance, nor pay a fine.
Is anyone terribly surprised? Did anyone in the Massachusetts legislature seriously think that businesses wouldn’t do whatever they could to minimize the substantial new costs imposed on them?
But, of course, the pols are gearing up to let the honest citizenry know who’s boss…
When drafting the universal insurance law, “we purposely did not raise employer taxes” to pay for insurance, said Senator Richard T. Moore, cochairman of the Legislature’s Committee on Health Care Financing, who plans oversight hearings within a few months.
“We thought we were treating employers fairly, and I commend the overwhelming number of employers who are doing the right thing,” he said. “If some are not going to respond fairly, we’ll find ways to structure the law so the loopholes get closed.”
And when the honest business man, laboring under the state’s arbitrary notion of fairness, has no options and no money left, then what?
Sure, I suppose it’s nice that people and businesses can pick up and escape the People’s Republic of Massachusetts to neighboring states, but what’s going to happen when the entire country is bestowed with some version of Romney-care courtesy of any of the numerous front-running socialists in the current election marathon?
I know one thing: There’s no easy way to unwind the socialist tentacles once they’ve entwined themselves into the body politic, and every new grip made by the state in whatever the fashion of the day might be, is one step closer to mass upheavals and disruptions and convolutions. With every passing day I become more and more concerned that I’m going to see it in my lifetime.
It looks like the big fund that the banks were trying to set up in order to try to save some of their fat from the fire is now out of business. Back in October, when the thing was proposed, we wondered what the heck they were thinking. I would have blogged about it, if I’d been blogging then. Now…
Benn Steil, senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, a nonpartisan think tank, said the plan was based on the flawed notion that the fund would pay more for tainted securities than would the banks themselves. “I’m not surprised that this didn’t happen,” he said. “I never believed the proposal made much sense.”
No kidding, right? The banks are holding all kinds of mortgage-backed securities that are worth cents on the dollar, which they would desperately like someone to buy. So, they thought they’d create their own fund, put a bunch of their own money in it, and let the fund snap up those beautiful assets like popcorn. We saw it from the first: It’s just moving money from one pocket to another, and probably incurring new costs on the way.
Let’s just say that we’re no more sanguine about the competence of people than we ever were.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||