Tom Kilgore, chief despot at the Tennessee Valley Authority, saddles his captive constituency with the costs of his and his government established monopoly’s incompetence, malfeasance, and dereliction:
The head of TVA said Thursday that electricity users will have to pay nearly $3 billion to clean up and revamp the way coal ash is handled following the Kingston spill, the country’s worst ash spill ever.
[…]
[N]ine months after the Dec. 22 spill at the Kingston plant, Kilgore said he isn’t ready to dismiss any employees over the incident.
These people are beyond the law, because they are the law. It’s another fucking government disgrace.
Not quite four months after the Kingston Tennessee coal ash disaster, the Tennessee Valley Authority is pleading special dispensation:
The Tennessee Valley Authority filed motions Friday in U.S. District Court in Knoxville seeking the dismissal of all seven lawsuits brought by residents claiming damages from the Dec. 22 spill of coal-ash sludge at the Kingston Fossil Plant.
TVA claims its actions maintaining a coal-ash retention pond are covered under the discretionary function doctrine, which, with exceptions, prevents a federal government entity from being sued for planning and carrying out policy.
You can’t sue them. They’re the government! It’s a regular TVA defense in suits brought against it, as I noted in an earlier post quoting a TVA filing:
On April 3, 2006, TVA moved to dismiss the suit on grounds that the case is not suitable for judicial resolution because of separation of powers principles, including the fact that these matters are based on policy decisions left to TVA’s discretion in its capacity as a government agency and thus are not subject to tort liability (the “discretionary function doctrine”), as well as the Supremacy Clause.
It’s one of the wonders of Fascism.
Better learn to love it, I say.
Via: Sweet Cheeks
ps. There are about ninety five angles on this that I’m not touching, but it still all boils down the immorality of locking responsibility up behind the veneer of government officialdom.
Also, I posted about the lawsuits that the TVA is moving to dismiss here.
Another week goes by, another load of toxic sludge rolls out of the TVA ash heap.
First, the interesting factoids:
The ASU scientists estimate that the ash layer covering the bed of the Emory River is 12 feet deep closest to the spill site. The ash is two inches deep 3.5 miles downstream and about a quarter inch deep 6.5 miles downstream at the Tennessee River’s Watts Bar Reservoir.
By the time it gets to New Orleans, it won’t be nuthin’! Granted, that’s a quarter inch of not naturally concentrated crap in Watts Bar Lake that wasn’t there before, but it’s very much less harsh crap than the stuff that Watts Bar Lake has been slooooooooooowly recovering from the last three decades or so. As I understand it, there used to be a little river of Cesium down the middle bottom of the waterway, courtesy of The Manhattan Project and other like endeavors. Maybe some Strontium, too. Possibly some PCBs. Most of it thanks to earnest endeavors by your friendly folks at the local FedGov, i.e., not by private industry, but by the same cranks who are "responsible" for the latest pile of garbage.
Before leaving the link above, consider this malarky:
Meanwhile, the push to better regulate coal combustion ash as hazardous waste appears to be picking up momentum. Congressman Nick Rahall (D-W.V.) has introduced legislation to set minimum design and stability standards for coal ash storage facilities like the one that collapsed in Tennessee.
The socialists are big on trying to control what other people do with their stuff, but I’ve got a better idea: How about letting the free market of accountability work its magic? The problem with the TVA isn’t that there are too few regulations with which it must comply, but that the incompetent thugs who run the place have nothing at risk when their shit blows all up and down the valley. The only fear CEO Tom Kilgore has is that he might have to wallow in the toxic sludge of ordinary people’s public concerns more than twice a year. He’s working the nation’s biggest monopoly, man, and if the ankle biters are getting a little too expensive to feed, all he has to do is jack the price to those who have no choice but to pay. Instead, he should be scrambling to undo the recent disaster while fending off the horde of competitors who would naturally be trying to capitalize on his incompetence, were they permitted to do so. In order to survive malfeasance like that which occurred near here a month ago, TVA should have fired those on whose watch the spill occurred, and begun selling assets to raise the money needed to fix it all. They will do none of it, of course, because the U.S. government has bestowed upon them the privilege of doing what they damn well please, and what they damn well please doesn’t involve punishing themselves for their own transgressions.
Which brings me to this helpful recommendation by another Tennessee governmental monopoly:
A warning for people living in Rhea and Meigs Counties who may rely on their food from rivers north of them. Don’t eat some of the fish.
The people living in horror at the Kingston Three Mile Island Krakatoa Valdez Chernobyl ash spill will no doubt pale at hearing that the fish are themselves poison now, but the fact is, the fish in the entire system have long been larded up with the benefits of government expenditure, and the warnings are standard issue. See Wikipedia, if you don’t believe me.
The state of Tennessee advises against eating fish caught in certain areas of the lake due to PCB contamination.
That "certain areas" means "in the water". There’s every other bad thing you ever heard of in the water here, too. With complications:
Environmentalists worry about digging up the bottom of Watts Bar Lake, a Tennessee River reservoir downstream. Mercury and radioactive cesium from World War II nuclear-bomb building work at Oak Ridge are in Watts Bar’s sediments and officials decided in the 1990s it was better to leave the deposits undisturbed.
Tell me that accountable, private enterprise could have done more damage to eastern Tennessee than socialism’s buffoons have done.
To see us out, here’s one more buffoon, Shea R. Tuberty, a local biology perfessor:
“Aerial photography has provided for my estimates that more than 1.1 billion gallons of sludge along with 1,035 tons of toxic metals were released into the river.”
Reading the newspaper could have told him the same thing, but it would still be wrong. A billion gallons of sludge broke the dike. If Shea R. Tuberty were to have an honest look at his "Aerial photography" he might see that most of those gallons are still sitting in plain sight, just off the river. Once again, that doesn’t excuse the malfeasance of the idiots at the TVA, who should be forced to pay, and pay large, for all the damage that they have done.
But good luck with that, because intransigent socialism precludes it, and the new indians in Wash, D.C. are more about intransigent socialism than anyone heretofore. Please do stand by for the imminent call for more sacrifice on your part to help clean up the latest socialist/government mess.
Update: Added that last link, overlooked before.
Everything.
10,000 words on the subject from Richard Munson, in 2001.
It’s a comprehensive indictment, and a must read for anyone wanting a partially blazed trail into the morass.
Later: The link is borked. I noticed it September 7, 2009. Munson is the former director of the Northeast-Midwest Institute, where that story was hosted, and I’ve written to them to see what’s what. It seems that all of Munson’s stuff is gone from there, along with Munson himself. Of course, Munson didn’t just completely disappear, but is now a vice president of a private company, and I also wrote him there to see if someone somewhere can put a copy of his report back online. Because, like I said above, it’s an excellent indictment of the TVA. I’ll host the thing myself if he gives permission.
In the meantime, here’s an excerpt:
TVA officials and their supporters hold that FDR’s giant experiment cleared the rivers, replenished the soil, rebuilt the forests, delivered cheap electricity, and brought new life and hope to the depressed Tennessee Valley. David Lilienthal’s Democracy on the March and the TVA staff’s TVA: The First Twenty Years boast of enormous progress resulting from TVA. No doubt the agency’s payroll — which averaged 13,000 workers in its early years — boosted the region’s economy, but the long-term benefits of TVA’s investments are less clear. According to William Chandler, author of The Myth of TVA and a researcher with Battelle National Laboratory, those investments performed poorly when compared to development in adjacent regions. Chandler, for instance, concluded:
Per-capita income growth in surrounding, non-TVA areas equaled or exceeded that in the TVA region, despite they’re being equal at the beginning of the TVA experiment.
Manufacturing employment grew more slowly in the TVA area than in surrounding non-TVA areas.
Rural electrification progressed more slowly in the Tennessee Valley region than in comparable surrounding areas.
The installation of piped running water in households and the utilization of home electric appliances proceeded less rapidly than in non-TVA states.
In its defense of appropriations for TVA’s non-power programs, the Clinton administration repeats the myth that "TVA is a tremendous success," citing statistics that per-capita income increased ten-fold in the TVA service territory, well above the national average. Yet such statistics are misleading, in large part because the Tennessee Valley started from such a low base in the 1930s that any gain looks substantial in percentage terms. When comparing instead the growth in per-capita income between Tennessee, where TVA supplies virtually all the power, to neighboring states that also suffered economic hardship in the 1930s, TVA’s "success" is less clear. In fact, per-capita income increased more substantially in non-TVA Georgia, Kentucky, and Virginia than it did in Tennessee.
TVA customers for many years certainly benefitted from electricity rates that were about half the national average. Such benefits, however, were made possible by substantial (if unwitting) subsidies from taxpayers across the country and by TVA’s failure to pay for cleaning up its own pollution.
A second coal ash pond has ruptured at a TVA plant, this time at its Widows Creek plant in northeastern Alabama.
“I had heard that that’s the case,” confirmed Barbara Martocci, TVA spokesman who was at the Kingston plant in Tennessee. She had no more information yet.
Remember, it’s not the TVA’s fault. It was Ronnie Rayguns.
For once we’re almost with Greenpeace. They’re calling for a criminal investigation of the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) for their negligence in maintaining the earthen barrier that collapsed two nights ago, sending nearly two million cubic yards of coal ash downhill into the Emory River. An inspection but two months ago showed no major problems with the system, and the TVA is now blaming "the weather". Apparently, the TVA isn’t competent to account for a couple extra inches of rain in a month.
The Knoxville News has multiple stories on the unfolding disaster, and the nascent cleanup. The best pictures, so far, are in this (apparently TVA-provided) PDF.
It is quite a large, local disaster. While no one was injured, a dozen homes were flooded or swept away, and countless other properties were affected. The Emory River has been rendered "impassable", and tons of ash and mud are now flowing into the Clinch River, and then, four and a half miles later, into the Tennessee River and Watts Bar Lake. From our vantage point (we can’t see nuthin’) twenty seven miles below the scene, it looks like the TVA has put the plug in the Watts Bar Dam in order to slow the flow of the ash and other muck into and through the system. The lake here is coming up to just under summer pool.
Along with the foulness dumped in the Emory and Clinch, blooms of raving idiots are dumping themselves into the media river. For instance (first link above), there’s…
"This holiday disaster shows that there really isn’t such a thing as a clean coal plant," said Chandra Taylor, a staff attorney for the [Southern Environmental Law Center].
… as though the failure of dikes is the natural consequence of certain politically incorrect energy production methods.
But the bigger problem is this: Aside from the damage done to property and environment, guess who is essentially on the hook for the cost of it? That’s right, the wholly owned subsidiary of the Tennessee Valley Authority: We the people. Once more, incompetence blossoms unbidden, and the costs are charged to those whose rights were suspended in order to facilitate said incompetence. The fine for cutting a tree in one’s back yard (all land around Watts Bar Lake, for instance, up to the 745 ft. level — which equals the top of the dam — is owned by the TVA) is about $10,000. But, of course, the TVA isn’t about to charge itself for all the trees it just destroyed. And no one at the TVA is going to be liable for any of the costs of the cleanup or repairs, despite blatherings from groups like Greenpeace. No, if someone were to cast some semblance of justice onto this mess, it would be toward attempting to dissolve the bloated, incompetent TVA, and return its ill-gotten assets to the private sector, where people could be held accountable for their part in like disasters. Instead, the people are forced to pay for the stupidity and negligence that paved the way for the disaster, and then they’re forced to pay for new stupidities, negligences, and ongoing incompetences in the mash of rectifying it all.
It’s time to dissolve the abomination that is the TVA.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||