Paul Hsieh has a good op-ed in the Christian Science Monitor today:
[…]
Despite raising state taxes, the Massachusetts plan is kept afloat only by hundreds of millions of dollars of financial waivers and assistance from the federal government – i.e., by the taxpayers of the other 49 states. If the Massachusetts plan were adopted at the national level, it’s unlikely that China or Russia would bail out the United States.
Mr. Obama’s plan is based on the faulty premise that the government should guarantee a "right" to healthcare. But healthcare is not a "right." Rights are freedoms of action (such as the right to free speech), not automatic claims on goods and services that must be produced by another. There is no such thing as a right to a car – or a tonsillectomy.
Individuals do have the right to seek healthcare and health insurance in the free market from any willing providers. The president’s plan would violate this right, for example by forbidding individuals from purchasing low-cost "catastrophic" insurance that only covered unlikely-but-expensive accidents and illnesses.
Read der whole thang.
Mass. health insurers post losses
Increased use of benefits is among contributing factorsThe state’s four health insurers posted net losses for the second quarter, citing continuing pressure from the economic downturn.
It’s a good thing. When the private insurers are gone there will be no one to blame.
It turns out that the universal health care coverage snake oil that Mitt Romney sold to the rubes in Massachusetts doesn’t have any curative properties. In fact, the general populace might even be a little worse off than it used to be. Via Investors.com:
Massachusetts’ Health Reform Costs Too Much For Too Little
[…]
Public Citizen and Physicians for a National Health Program released a report this week calling the program flawed due to its cost, lack of access to care, and the remaining number of uninsured.
Dr. Sidney Wolfe, director of Public Citizen’s Health Research Group, said the report "shows that (Commonwealth Care) isn’t working."
Free-market experts have been making many of the same points for years.
But commies and other authoritarian types aren’t interested in "points." They want to pander to constituencies, to accrue power, to enrich themselves and their cohorts, all at other people’s expense. Government imposed collectivism never works, because it is, by its very essence, an attempt to rejigger the fundamentals of human nature, to force a necessarily limited set of rules onto disparate, non-homogeneous populations. The attempt skews incentives, rewards sloth and carelessness, punishes success, and is otherwise an always futile attempt to levitate the earth-bound laws of economics.
"I completely agree with their critique," said Greg Scandlen, president of Consumers for Health Care Choices at the Heartland Institute.
[…]
"The problem is you can’t fix the health care system with what President Obama has placed on the table, or with what we’ve done in Massachusetts, or what Baucus and Kennedy are talking about," said Dr. Steffie Woolhandler, a co-author of the report and co-founder of PNHP.
The report notes that "the reform has not reduced health costs in the state and . . . has proven far costlier than expected." State spending on the program jumped from about $630 million in fiscal year 2007 to nearly $1.1 billion in 2008. It’s expected to hit $1.3 billion this year.
Sharon Long, a principal research associate at the liberal Urban Institute and an expert on Commonwealth Care, claims that "on access to care, reform has made substantial progress. . . . But the elephant in the room is the cost, and they have not yet tackled that."
Of course, "cost" was one of the big reasons to institute the whole pile of shit in the first place. In early 2006:
Legislators say that by providing every Massachusetts resident with health insurance, the costs of health care are actually lowered.
Only a commie would be stupid enough to believe that crap.
But guess what! Despite the emerging Massachusetts failure…
Proposed reforms by both President Obama and Sen. Max Baucus, D-Mont., borrow heavily from the Massachusetts model, as does one being worked on by the staff of Sen. Ted Kennedy, D-Mass.
Though it doesn’t matter exactly what plan the idiots finally impose upon America, because "imposed" it will have to be, and all those for whom the imposition is the greatest will promptly begin to endeavor to relieve themselves of its onuses, and those who deem it their birthright to avail themselves of the forced contributions of the first group will grab and gobble for more and more, and only in poverty and in ruin the twain shall meet.
Massachusetts gets its Medicaid waiver:
Massachusetts reached an agreement with the federal government on a three-year extension of a Medicaid waiver needed to provide critical funding for the state’s landmark health care law, Gov. Deval Patrick announced Tuesday.
Patrick said the agreement secures billions of dollars more in spending authority for the state over the previous waiver and preserves existing eligibility and benefit levels already in place for the health care law.
The guaranteed federal funding also removes a large question mark in the state’s budget.
No prob, fellas. If you need any more money, just help yourself. ((hands raised in surrender))
Massachusetts is already looking at raising the co-pays, and not unsubstantialy, either, for its new insurance scheme. Tell me you didn’t know it was coming.
Among the proposed changes: Primary care visit co-payments for one of the subsidized plan options — Plan type III — would jump from $10 to $15 per visit, and emergency room co-payments would increase from $75 to $100 per visit. Prescription co-payments for Plan III would jump from $10 to $15 for generic drugs, $20 to $25 for preferred non-generic drugs, and from $40 to $50 for nonpreferred, more expensive brand name drugs.
Those are 50%, 33%, 50%, 25%, and 25% increases respectively. And those numbers weren’t particularly low to start with, were they? What on earth, you wonder, could be the reason for the state to want to impose these hefty hikes on the poor and downtrodden?
State officials said they want to ensure that the program, called Commonwealth Care, does not collapse under the weight of soaring costs or under a potential influx of residents whose employers drop coverage because the program offers a better deal for their workers.
"If we’re not only trying to insure the uninsured, but insure the previously insured, that’s going to blow the doors off," said Leslie Kirwan, the state’s top budget officer and chairwoman of the Commonwealth Health Insurance Connector Authority board that oversees Commonwealth Care.
The bots are walking a fine line there, because the proposed co-pay increases will fall largely on the people who can least afford it: all those previously uninsured schmoes that the whole system was ginned up for. Some, if not many of them will likely find themselves, as the state tends to raise its prices toward that old devil market level, back out on that old, cold, uninsured street again, just like before, except for then being in violation of the law mandating that they carry health insurance.
Of course, the fine line I mentioned is not really "fine". It is a swath, and it represents the spread between the price of lunch and the price of the proverbial free lunch. Someone ought to have told the Mass legislators, back in about high school, that never the twain can meet.
But there is good news, too, though darned if I can figure it out. Is it commie bot-speak, or am I really missing something here:
It was a key premise of the state’s landmark health care law – the more uninsured people who were enrolled in subsidized health care plans, the fewer uninsured people would show up at hospital emergency rooms for routine care.
Now a new study says that’s exactly what’s happening.
The report by the Massachusetts Hospital Association finds that the number of so-called "free care" visits to hospitals have declined by 28 percent over the past three years.
That mirrors a 28 percent increase in enrollment in subsidized health care programs, MassHealth and the new Commonwealth Care program, which was created by the law.
It seems to me that the article does NOT specifically say that emergency room visits are down, just that uninsured ER visits are down, exactly commensurate with the rise in the population of the newly insured. And that’s a triumph, why? Because the nurses now get to scan 28% more health cards? Or is it because the state now gets to pay for those 28% new patients, rather than having the costs passed on to the… state? From the same article, yeah:
The report also warned that while demand for free care is down, it is still significant and the state has to be prepared to continue helping reimburse hospitals that provide care to the uninsured.
So…….? That old javelin toss by P. J. O’Rourke about the cost of free health care would seem to have unerringly hit the bulls eye. People and businesses are all in turmoil, trying to factor new costs, and the state is up to its eyeballs in horrendous new spending. How will it end, oh, how will it end?
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||