Received another email from another Florida Department of Education official, advising me of exactly the same nonsense as yesterday.
Here's another clue for the twits: With a ball park average response rate of ten percent the last few years, anyone with the inclination to try to influence the survey results has a healthy ninety percent chance of being able to do so.
On the matter of the unsecured Exceptional Student Education survey (here, here, here), a person on the periphery has emailed:
You have to enter your child school's name, grade level , and date of birth, the data entered will be compared with the data the state has. They accept only the matched data. All other responses will be eliminated.
Of course, I considered the possibility of exactly that, deemed it unlikely, and while I have to give it further consideration because of the email, I have no way to ascertain the claim, and only more questions.
If the emailer is correct, then the survey really isn't anonymous, even though it was touted as being anonymous, yet perhaps people are being mislead in that respect.
Also, if the emailer is correct, then the survey is still ripe for abuse and fraud. Anyone with a list of disabled children's birthdays matched to the schools they attend, could skew the survey results quite easily, especially with the survey's historically abysmal number of survey takers. Even someone willing to work sequentially through all 365 days in the year would invariably have many of his entries accepted. On the flip side, the slightest error in Florida's database, or the slightest error in a parent's entry would supposedly invalidate a legitimate survey offering, with absolutely no indication, either way, to the user.
Additionally, if some nincompoop makes a run at the survey, and picks schools, grades, and birth dates of real students who haven't yet been matched with survey entries, then those entries are counted as valid, and when the legitimate parent comes along, his or her entry will be thrown away.
Further, I find it highly unlikely that the programming was done so stupidly, though it is a government endeavor, and therefore we should all probably be immeasurably thankful that it has been done as well as it has.
Obviously, if one were to insist on the methodology conveyed in the email, school/grade/birth date, then one should allow/forbid prospective survey takers after they've entered identifying parameters, but before they've taken the survey. Unless I've been extremely lucky (and selecting valid parameters may be easier than I think – with thousands of disabled kids per school district it's likely that several children share birthdays, every day of the year, even in the same grade), then everyone taking the survey, whether their entries end up being accepted or not, is thanked for taking the survey, and invited to take another survey pertaining to another aspect of the Florida government school system. There is no way to know if one's survey is one of those that "will be eliminated."
Of course, it may be that the scripts at www.esesurvey.com are not connected to the big Florida database where the data is allegedly "matched", but that then suggests a two step process of validating the data, which also seems ripe for abuse, fraud, or failure due to incompetence.
And with all that, there are numerous problems with Florida's ESE Survey methodology no matter which way the programming has been done.
Sweet Cheeks offers the ancillary observation relating to the validity of the survey results in light of Assistant Polk County School Board Superintendent Nancy Woolcock's recent offer (since rescinded) of free iPod Nanos to survey takers, and how those survey takers might more favorably view a school system that hands out such extravagant goodies, however incompetent and inexcellent its educational offerings. Read: bribes.
All in all, one giant, but typical, governmental clusterfuck.
Florida's Exceptional Student Education survey is still unsecured and open to fraud and abuse. No doubt earnest bureaucrats and activist teacher union members are busy filling out the forms repetitively, thereby guaranteeing a continuing flow of other people's money into their grasping hands.
Apropos of yesterdays link to Vandam's trend pegging, comes Matt Beauchamp's informal freedom of information foray into the particulars of Assistant Polk County School Board Superintendent Nancy Woolcock, the woman who so desperately wanted to give $350,000 worth of iPod Nanos to parents who filled out the aforementioned ANONYMOUS survey. Beauchamp reports that Gay Butler reports:
Mrs. Woolcock came to us in July 2007 and has an annual salary of $113,794.00. If I can be of any further help, please don’t hesitate to call or email.
Sincerely,
Gay Butler
Administrative Secretary
Superintendent's Office
Polk County School Board
Ph: (863) 534-0521 (51341)
Fax: (863) 519-8231
Beauchamp also reports:
By the way, Polk County has a per capita income of $18,302.
Making 621% of the average in Polk County, Woolcock is nevertheless happy to whistle past the fraud of that publicly accessible survey that's supposed to be limited to the parents of children with disabilities in Florida schools.
I'm still steeped in saving America from its felonious class, ie., the political slash bureaucratic establishment as represented this week by the Florida Department of Education, with a focus on Polk County, Florida, and its superintendent and sub-superintendent. Previous posts, here, here, here, and here.
The online Exceptional Student Education (ESE) Survey is still accessible to the marauding hordes (I've submitted a new rendition yet again), while it is supposed to only be available to parents with children suffering sundrily in Florida's school system.
Enticing people to participate in the survey was the raison d'etre behind the scheme to channel $350,000 worth of tax dollars in the form of iPods to parents of the aforementioned children who so participated. $350,000 is a fairly large amount of money to spread around just to get people to click twenty six times on their computer screens. But the payoff (a number never reported, of course) was a much bigger pile of the taxpayer's wealth. The Polk County school administrators were hoping for a windfall of millions of tax dollars if they could just qualify their schools under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) of 2004. One of the requirements of that act is that Polk County show a certain level of participation among the parents of students in the system having disabilities, and one of the ways of satisfying that requirement is to demonstrate a certain level of participation via a survey.
Here's Florida's 12th district Congressman Adam H. Putnam:
Giving an iPod in exchange for a few questions being answered certainly is extravagant in these tough times. These programs are important to disabled students and there is a survey requirement for the funds, but wouldn't doughnuts and coffee work?
Hmm, but apparently Assistant Polk County School Board Superintendent Nancy Woolcock and her boss, Polk County School District Superintendent Gail McKinzie, thought they needed to be sure.
And yet, their scheme was discovered, and all their plans ruined (no one has yet explained how Woolcock expected to match anonymous survey participants to their iPods). Or were they?
In the brouhaha over the announced iPod giveaway scheme, the internet address to the ESE Survey was reported a number of times. John Chambliss at The Ledger reported it here and here. Kara Phelps at NewsChief.com reported it here. And Tom Staik at The Polk County Democrat mentioned it here. All in conjunction with talking to Nancy Woolcock.
In other words, the publicity surrounding the iPod giveaway scheme gave much more publicity to the ESE Survey (the focus of the Polk County bureaucrat's endeavors) AND, then, you see, the survey form is wide open to anyone and everyone, so no longer do Woolcock and Crew have to worry about enticing squads of a small subsection of disinterested parents. Anyone, living in Florida or not, having disabled children or not, can take the survey and help Polk County (and any other county, too, for the survey is used state wide) attain the federal dollars to which they would otherwise not be entitled.
The whole thing is a fraud, and a large one. The entire education establishment in Florida is using a survey that is a fraud, and using that fraud of a survey to obtain millions and millions of tax dollars from Washington, D.C.
ps. Please forgive any sense I may give that the Florida government education establishment is entitled to any portion of money that has to be stolen from the earnest citizenry. Clearly, they are not entitled to any of it, but in the case under review, they are not even entitled to it under the dubious law.
Assistant Polk County School Board Superintendent Nancy Woolcock is determined to move those iPod Nanos. Even after the uproar her program caused the last two days, here she is:
Woolcock said it was still a good idea, and she hoped to get iPods for disabled students next year.
So, who is Woolcock's iPod connection? Exactly who is it on the other end of this blatant waste of tax dollars? Eh? Is anyone going to explore that end of it?
For those who couldn't or wouldn't make it to the end of my previous post pertaining to the attempted iPod giveaway (utilizing federal tax dollars) in Florida, here's more on the most troubling aspect of the issue.
First, from my safe redoubt in the hills of Tennessee, I have several times now filled out Florida's Exceptional Student Education Survey, the survey that becomes part of Florida's official education reporting documentation, and which is used to justify the state's acquisition of millions of federal tax dollars.
There is something decidedly wrong with me being able to do that. The survey is supposed to be limited to parents with students of sundry disabilities attending Florida schools, but apparently anyone in the world can fill out the forms, and thereby affect the amounts of federal tax dollars shipped off to the Sunshine State.
It's difficult to ferret information in the government rock pile, but here's a short history of Florida's ESE survey program:
Under the State Performance Plan, mandated by the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (2004), all states are now required to collect and report data on the “percent of parents with a child receiving special education services who report that schools facilitated parent involvement as a means of improving services and results for children with disabilities.”
The FDOE has a long history of gathering data from parents by means of large-scale surveys. Between 1999 and 2005, Florida’s monitoring system included a parent survey component, enabling parents to share their perceptions about services provided under IDEA.
[…]
In 2006, surveys were mailed to the entire population of parents of children receiving preschool services. For parents of students K-12, survey forms were mailed to all parents of students receiving special education services in districts with special education membership equal to or less than 4,000. In districts with special education membership greater than 4,000, surveys were sent to a random sample of 4,000 parents. A total of 177,901 surveys were sent out; of these, 18,725 (10.5%) were returned.
In 2007, the second year of implementation of data collection under the SPP, the same sampling plan was implemented. Additionally, parents of students K-12 were given the option of completing the survey online, using as a login an arbitrary individual ID number provided in the material they received by mail. Packets were mailed to 179,710 parents; a total of 16,812 (9.4%) were returned. Approximately 11% of parents of students K-12 who completed the survey did so online. In 2008, the opportunity to complete the survey online will be extended to include parents of preschool children. Additionally, a small number of districts will pilot “web-only” access to the survey.
To summarize, the survey was originally mailed directly to parents of children with disabilities. Subsequently, an online version of the survey was made available with a (presumably) secure login id sent to parents in the mail.
Now the program has been expanded, but in the face of an absolutely miserable response rate, and a desperate need to fulfill the terms of federal funding parameters, the login id component of the thing has been dropped. Anyone can access the survey, fill it out, and pump up the numbers and satisfaction quotient that will be reported to the federal government in return for those lovely tax dollars.
Why Florida's Polk County education bureaucrats Gail McKinzie and Nancy Woolcock thought they had to give away thousands of iPods to entice people into filling out the form is anyone's guess. All they have to do is assign an otherwise unoccupied education minion to fill out the forms day and night up until the July 1st deadline. Such a person might even be able to fill out more forms than there are disabled students in the county, which is exactly the sort of success that graft and malfeasance yearns to be proud of.
Seriously, though, there is something decidedly wrong with what's going on in Florida. Those forms need to be taken offline.
Yesterday, I blogged about the nitwits in Florida's Polk County government education establishment who thought it would be a good idea to give $350,000 (not their own money) worth of iPods to parents of students with disabilities who filled out an online survey. Public outrage quickly shut the scheme down, but there remain a number of troubling aspects, at least to my mind. (Some of the links below repeat, but are necessary for attribution.)
Early yesterday, Nancy Woolcock "attributed the original idea to a school committee". Later on, it turned out that "Nancy Woolcock, assistant superintendent of learning support, introduced the iPod giveaway idea at a School Board meeting Tuesday." Maybe the first quote can be chalked up to sloppy reporting, or maybe Woolcock is a dissembler. However, the school board wasted no time on the proposal:
District officials announced Tuesday that they will give silver iPods Nanos worth $150 to parents of children with disabilities who complete a 10-minute online survey.
And, somewhat surprisingly, "Woolcock had said she received a discount on the $150 price [of the iPod Nanos]." It seems Nancy went into the committee meeting with a full package already prepared. Has anyone asked the amount of the discount, or inquired as to any ancillary details that might have been part of the committment that Woolcock appears to have negotiated on her own? Particularly, who was supposed to have supplied the iPods in exchange for $350,000 of the fair citizenry's tax monies? And the committee? They required no persuasion, I guess. Or perhaps the individual members had already been working on the deal and the idea originated at some earlier time. If so, when, where, and by whom was it floated?
Now meet "Polk County School District Superintendent Gail McKinzie", who said:
[T]he district submitted a budget to the state for a grant it received. The budget, which was approved by the state, showed a listing for MP3 players but it did not specify the iPods would be given to parents.
The scheme goes back much further than Tuesday, but again, maybe there's a lot of sloppy reporting going on.
But there is more, much more, dissembling going on:
"The purpose behind the initiative has been to get the parents involved," said Nancy Woolcock, assistant superintendent of learning support.
She's lying, of course. Not even a moron of Woolcock's caliber thinks that giving away $350,000 worth of iPod Nanos in order to induce parents to fill out a multiple choice questionnaire has anything to do with getting "parents involved" in their children's education.
The sneaky little truth is that Woolcock & Crew were "investing" the $350 large in an attempt to snag a much bigger pile of other people's money under the auspices of the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. McKinzie, again:
As part of receiving funds from the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, the district must have a certain amount of parent participation, McKinzie said. The money cannot go to salaries.
"We have not met the requirements in previous years of having the level of participation that is required," McKinzie said.
Woolcock and her staff will meet next week about how they can get parents to fill out the online survey at www.esesurvey.com. The deadline to complete the survey is July 1. The survey must be taken online.
I have not been able to ascertain how much money the Polk County school board hoped to reap with their $350,000 "investment", but one hopes that it was a significant amount.
And that brings me to the most troubling aspect of this very troubling story: The online survey.
Woolcock said that in the coming days, the district plans to send fliers and e-mails to parents about the anonymous survey.
By March, parents who have filled out the survey should be able to pick up iPods at their children's schools, Woolcock said.
Say what???? Fill out a survey, ANONYMOUSLY, and then claim your iPod, how? Anonymously? That's rank freaking nonsense, and puts the lie to the entire ball of crap.
But, wait! It gets even worse. I just surfed to the survey web page, and took the survey myself. I filled out the entire thing, and got a "Thank you very much for your participation!" blurb. You don't have to be a parent of a student with disabilities in the Polk County schools to help them meet their quota entitling them to monies stolen from their fellow citizens. Anyone in the world can go fill out that survey and help Woolcock and McKinzie waste more tax dollars. The whole thing is one big fucking farce.

Federal tax dollar disbursement is being determined on the basis of the number of people who fill out a publicly available online survey? It's a national disgrace in a nation increasingly full of such disgraces.
Marketing genius in The Sunshine State:
The Polk County school district is giving away iPods to some parents.
The school district is using the device to reward parents of children with disabilities who fill out a 10-minute online survey. The district wants to know how well it's connecting with the parents and how to get parents involved in their children's education.
The district is spending about $350,000 in federal stimulus money for the iPods.
Is this a great country, or what?
UPDATE: The giveaway has been cancelled. But the nonsense is still palpable. The grave transgression, apparently, according to assistant superintendent Nancy Woolcock, is that the source of the funds for the iPod purchases was mis-attributed by the lousy press. The money for the iPods was to come from the Individuals with Disabilities Act, not federal "stimulus funds". The stimulus money has already been spent, on, amongst other things, "school psychologists and social workers." Badda bump. But really, someone has to deal with the fact:
According to the Florida Department of Education, 34 percent of third through fifth graders in Polk County are not reading on their grade level.
That's a lot of tender psyches who will no doubt have a hard time holding their heads up when they realize that they can't even meet the standards set by people like Nancy Woolcock.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||