That other shyster "economist", Brad DeLong, has joined the cavalcade of troofers, unearthing the conspiracy in Sarah Palin’s use of a famous Reagan quote. Here’s the title the nice, level-headed, "economist" Brad DeLong put on the thing:
McCain and Palin Reveal Their Plan to Destroy Medicare!!
Weeeee Ooooooooooooo.
Underneath the hysteria, he’s just as stupidly mistaken (or dishonest, take your pick) as Paul Krugman is.
Today’s Krugman mash:
Sarah Palin ended her debate performance last Thursday with a slightly garbled quote from Ronald Reagan about how, if we aren’t vigilant, we’ll end up “telling our children and our children’s children” about the days when America was free. It was a revealing choice.
You see, when Reagan said this he wasn’t warning about Soviet aggression. He was warning against legislation that would guarantee health care for older Americans — the program now known as Medicare.
Here’s what Palin said:
It was Ronald Reagan who said that freedom is always just one generation away from extinction. We don’t pass it to our children in the bloodstream; we have to fight for it and protect it, and then hand it to them so that they shall do the same, or we’re going to find ourselves spending our sunset years telling our children and our children’s children about a time in America, back in the day, when men and women were free.
Here’s Reagan’s exact quote, from a March 30, 1961 speech to the Phoenix Chamber of Commerce:
Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn’t pass it on to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same, or one day we will spend our sunset years telling our children what it was once like in the United States when men were free.
Here’s the line that Krugman pointed to from his blog (conveniently not cited in his larger column) where Reagan spoke about Medicare, as being the source of the quote Palin used (my own transcript from MP3 file of Reagan recording):
If you don’t, this program I promise you will pass just as surely as the sun will come up tomorrow, and behind it will come other federal programs that will invade every area of freedom as we have known it in this country, until one day, as Norman Thomas said, we will awake to find that we have socialism. And if you don’t do this and if I don’t do it, one of these days you and I are going to spend our sunset years telling our children, and our children’s children, what it once was like in America when men were free.
Do you think Krugman is lying, yet? Can you tell which of the quotes is more likely to be the source for Palin’s reference???
In his Times column, Krugman quotes only, “telling our children and our children’s children”. If one chops that slightly, taking “our children and our children’s children” over to the Reagan Library text search box, selecting "the exact phrase" and then "Search", one gets:
Search Results
Request: "“our children and our children’s children”"
50 document(s) retrieved
Reagan used that phrase in speech after speech, throughout his political career, including: "July 4, 1986 Address to the Nation", "Remarks During a Visit to the Goddard Space Flight Center", "Toast at a Dinner Honoring Premier Zhao Ziyang of China", etc., etc.
But Krugman wants you to believe that Sarah Palin used the Reagan quote because Republicans want to take away the rubes’s Medicare?
It’s simple: Krugman is using something less than the slimmest pretext, most people would call it a lie, to scare people going into the election. It’s what he does. It’s what the New York Times does. It’s part and parcel of the whole declining shebang. And it’s despicable.
Update: Krugman Watch is on it, too.
Krugman lied for the purpose of playing the McCain-Wants-To-Cancel-Your-MEDICARE card. I suppose I was somewhat naive about it, at first, but Krugman certainly knows his audience.
I’m fascinated (but not in a good way) with the downstream run, after Krugman blogged about the Reagan quote Palin used in the debate the other night. (I pulled Krugman’s post apart, here.)
Out of dozens of people who likewise blogged Krugman’s post, apparently I was the only one to question the provenance that Krugman provided for the quote. Krugman claimed the quote was taken from a recording put on vinyl as part of something called "Operation Coffeecup", said operation being the Sixties version of a 527 PAC, aimed at stopping the establishment of Medicare. Reagan did indeed lend his support to the effort, and lent his voice and words to the recording, but the full quote that Palin used did not come from that recording. The "Operation Coffeecup" recording contains but a piece of the full quote that Palin used. A YouTube of the recording is here.
Like many politicians, Reagan made a lot of speeches (even before he was a politician), and over the years he developed a lot of themes and phrases that he used over and over, throughout his speech-making career, and bits and pieces of the quote in question are repeated across the decades that Reagan was before the public.
The phrasing that comes closest to what Palin used is widely cited as being uttered by Reagon on March 30, 1961, in an address to the Phoenix Chamber of Commerce. There does not appear to be any full copy of that speech on the net. At least none that I can find.
What does it matter? I suppose it matters to me to see so many people just swallow something, even a trivial something, so uncritically.
Go to your favorite blog search and let it loose on "Krugman Reagan" and see all the fools now running around screaming that McCain-Palin want to take their Medicare away, all the fools commending Krugman on his good find, all the idiots shaking their empty heads as though there could not possibly be any reason in the world why anyone sane would oppose things like Medicare.
Here’s a fer-instance of one nutjob: "McCain/Palin intend to repeal Medicare to return us to freedom". You see, Krugman helped him decipher the super sickrit code words that Palin used.
The truth is, though, that all these idiots should be scared about whatever the context of the Phoenix Chamber of Commerce speech was, because that’s where the quote orginated.
Unless…
… it came from… here!
Freedom is something that cannot be passed on in the blood stream, or genetically. And it’s never more than one generation away from extinction. Every generation has to learn how to protect and defend it, or it’s gone and gone for a long, long time.
[…]
Will we, before it is too late, use the vitality and the magic of the marketplace to save this way of life, or will we one day face our children, and our children’s children when they ask us where we were and what we were doing on the day that freedom was lost?
That was from a speech Reagan gave at Hillsdale College on November 10, 1977, as one of the Ludwig Von Mises Memorial Lectures.
Krugman could just as easily have pinned the Palin quote there, but then he might not have been able to scare up the Medicare boogeyman for all his pinheaded followers to get gibberishy over.
And the further thing is, despite the fact that Reagan was completely right about socialism in general and Medicare in particular, the idea that McCain & Co. have any intention of taking one single centavo away from one Medicare grasping hand is ludicrous on the face of it.
No, in order to get rid of the drag on our economy and the imposition of our freedoms that Medicare is, we’re going to have to wait for the socialist behemoth to collapse of its own accord. Or for the government that makes it possible to collapse. And the way things are going, that just might not be too far off. I wonder how badly Krugman’s cavalcade of kooks will behave when it does. Not too brightly, I’d wager.
Now Krugman won’t approve my comments at his blog (small update at bottom). What am I gonna do?
Krugman thought he saw an opportunity to dump on Reagan and to pretend that one of the biggest socialist programs around (Medicare) isn’t socialist and isn’t growing by leaps and bounds and, contrary to Reagan’s and other’s warnings, isn’t directly and tangentally taking increasingly bigger bites out of freedom as it goes. Here’s the quote Krugman doesn’t like:
It was Ronald Reagan who said that freedom is always just one generation away from extinction. We don’t pass it to our children in the bloodstream; we have to fight for it and protect it, and then hand it to them so that they shall do the same, or we’re going to find ourselves spending our sunset years telling our children and our children’s children about a time in America, back in the day, when men and women were free.
And here’s how Krugman tries to deride it:
When did [Reagan] say this? It was on a recording he made for Operation Coffeecup — a campaign organized by the American Medical Association to block the passage of Medicare. Doctors’ wives were supposed to organize coffee klatches for patients, where they would play the Reagan recording, which declared that Medicare would lead us to totalitarianism.
You couldn’t make this stuff up.
Except that Krugman does make it up. The Operation Coffeecup link goes to a page titled, "Operation Coffeecup: Ronald Reagan’s Effort to Prevent the Enactment of Medicare", written in September 1994 by Larry DeWitt. The essay contains most of the text of the early sixties Reagan recording to which Krugman refers, including something vaguely similar to the Reagan quote above. Here ’tis:
[O]ne of these days, you and I are going to spend our sunset years telling our children, and our children’s children, what it once was like in America when men were free.
Yes, it’s close, but it’s only half the quote Krugman turns his nose up at, and more importantly, the Operation Coffeecup recording wasn’t the only place Reagan spoke similar lines. Within six feet of my computer I found:
"Freedom," Dutch declaimed, "is never more than one generation from extinction." — Edmund Morris, Dutch (Random House, 1999), p. 308
Morris caught Reagan saying those words on November 10, 1958 "in a ballroom on Wilshire Boulevard", at the California Fertilizer Association’s annual convention. In the fifties, Reagan reportedly made the same or similar speeches a thousand times across the country, to rollicking crowds everywhere.
And Reagan continued to use variations of those lines for the rest of his life. Wikiquote says he used them in an address at the Phoenix Chamber of Commerce in 1961, and again at his own inauguration as governor of California in 1967. Searching speeches at the archives of the Reagan library turns up numerous other instances and variations, all through the 1980s.
So the quote isn’t soley from some obscure album, as Krugman suggested, but that’s just a small part of Krugman’s perfidy. Krugman baldly states that "the Reagan recording […] declared that Medicare would lead us to totalitarianism." The author of the page to which Krugman links makes the same accusation, and uses the word "totalitarianism" twice on his own, but the recording Reagan made doesn’t use the word, or any other words that could be taken for euphemisms of it, except for "socialism" and its variants. An MP3 of the Reagan recording can be found at a link here, or go straight to the file, here (about 2.8 megs, 11 minutes of the Gipper’s mellifluous tones.)
Now, granted, Reagan feared creeping socialism with a passion, and rightly so, and one might easily argue that the fear of socialism stems from a recognition of the likelihood that it will lead to one form of totalitarianism or another, but in the recording to which Krugman refers Reagan does NOT "declare" what Krugman states he does.
Further, the whole purpose of Krugman’s horseplay with the truth is to have a laugh at Reagan’s expense while pretending that, against all the crazy fears of Reagan and others, Medicare never blossomed into anything a free people would need to concern themselves about. Ha ha. Hee hee.
Except that it has. In the Operation Coffeecup recording, Reagan says,
First you decide that the doctor can have so many patients. They are equally divided among the various doctors by the government. But then doctors aren’t equally divided geographically. So a doctor decides he wants to practice in one town and the government has to say to him, you can’t live in that town. They already have enough doctors. You have to go someplace else. And from here it’s only a short step to dictating where he will go. . . . All of us can see what happens once you establish the precedent that the government can determine a man’s working place and his working methods, determine his employment. From here it’s a short step to all the rest of socialism, to determining his pay. And pretty soon your son won’t decide, when he’s in school, where he will go or what he will do for a living. He will wait for the government to tell him where he will go to work and what he will do.
I suppose Krugman would have a good laugh at Reagan’s paranoia, yet here’s what Wikipedia says today:
Medicare funds the vast majority of residency training in the US. This tax-based financing covers resident salaries and benefits through payments called Direct Medical Education payments. Medicare also uses taxes for Indirect Medical Education, a subsidy paid to teaching hospitals in exchange for training resident physicians. Overall funding levels, however, have remained frozen over the last ten years, creating a bottleneck in the training of new physicians in the US. Meanwhile, the US population continues to grow, leading to greater demand for physicians. At the same time the cost of medical services continue rising rapidly and many geographic areas face physician shortages, both trends suggesting the supply of physicians remains too low. Medicare finds itself in the odd position of having assumed control of graduate medical education, currently facing major budget constraints, and as a result, freezing funding for graduate medical education, as well as for physician reimbursement rates. This halt in funding in turn exacerbates the exact problem Medicare sought to solve in the first place: improving the availability of medical care.
Reagan wasn’t that far off, was he? Also, consider that Medicare spending last year accounted for 16% of all federal spending, and that Medicare’s "little" brother, Medicaid, also growing by leaps and bounds at the federal level, is busting state budgets all across the country.
And then there IS the evidence of the creep in socialism that Reagan warned about. Massachusetts, two years ago, made it across the line of mandatory universal health care that Reagan predicted nearly fifty years ago. And with that state’s grab came the harder swing toward the arbitrary force that always lurks within the pigskin gloves of socialism. From yesterday:
Massachusetts officials announced new health care regulations Wednesday designed to ramp up pressure on companies that don’t help cover insurance costs for large portions of their workers.
Under Massachusetts’ landmark health care law, employers who did not enroll at least a quarter of their workers in an insurance plan or contribute a third of the premium costs faced a $295 annual fee per worker.
The fees only applied to businesses with 11 or more full-time workers.
Under the new regulations set to take effect in January, companies with more than 50 full-time employees will have to meet both tests.
The change is expected to generate $30 million annually, compared with $7.5 million under the old regulations.
Officials estimate that about 475 firms with 50 or more full-time workers would be liable under the new regulations.
The money will go to help support government-funded health care programs including Commonwealth Care, a subsidized health care plan created by the new law.
Sarah Iselin, commissioner of the state Division of Health Care Finance and Policy, said the new regulations would help ensure that all businesses are making a fair contribution to support the new insurance law.
"The long-term success of health care reform requires the continued shared commitment of consumers, employers, providers and government to achieve near-universal coverage in Massachusetts," Iselin said.
$30 million dollars a year, most of it from 475 firms, and none of it voluntary, may not amount to totalitarianism in some peoples’s books, but it is certainly getting closer.
And, I don’t know about you, but I think it’s a good bet that Krugman’s economic expertise is about on a par with how he handles a simple Reagan quote.
The next day: Sometime in the night, someone at Krugman’s blog inserted the first short comment I sent him yesterday noonish into the comment stream, but the longer "more accurate" citation/comment I sent a few minutes later didn’t make the cut. That’s his business, but this is mine.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||