Krugman lied for the purpose of playing the McCain-Wants-To-Cancel-Your-MEDICARE card. I suppose I was somewhat naive about it, at first, but Krugman certainly knows his audience.
I’m fascinated (but not in a good way) with the downstream run, after Krugman blogged about the Reagan quote Palin used in the debate the other night. (I pulled Krugman’s post apart, here.)
Out of dozens of people who likewise blogged Krugman’s post, apparently I was the only one to question the provenance that Krugman provided for the quote. Krugman claimed the quote was taken from a recording put on vinyl as part of something called "Operation Coffeecup", said operation being the Sixties version of a 527 PAC, aimed at stopping the establishment of Medicare. Reagan did indeed lend his support to the effort, and lent his voice and words to the recording, but the full quote that Palin used did not come from that recording. The "Operation Coffeecup" recording contains but a piece of the full quote that Palin used. A YouTube of the recording is here.
Like many politicians, Reagan made a lot of speeches (even before he was a politician), and over the years he developed a lot of themes and phrases that he used over and over, throughout his speech-making career, and bits and pieces of the quote in question are repeated across the decades that Reagan was before the public.
The phrasing that comes closest to what Palin used is widely cited as being uttered by Reagon on March 30, 1961, in an address to the Phoenix Chamber of Commerce. There does not appear to be any full copy of that speech on the net. At least none that I can find.
What does it matter? I suppose it matters to me to see so many people just swallow something, even a trivial something, so uncritically.
Go to your favorite blog search and let it loose on "Krugman Reagan" and see all the fools now running around screaming that McCain-Palin want to take their Medicare away, all the fools commending Krugman on his good find, all the idiots shaking their empty heads as though there could not possibly be any reason in the world why anyone sane would oppose things like Medicare.
Here’s a fer-instance of one nutjob: "McCain/Palin intend to repeal Medicare to return us to freedom". You see, Krugman helped him decipher the super sickrit code words that Palin used.
The truth is, though, that all these idiots should be scared about whatever the context of the Phoenix Chamber of Commerce speech was, because that’s where the quote orginated.
Unless…
… it came from… here!
Freedom is something that cannot be passed on in the blood stream, or genetically. And it’s never more than one generation away from extinction. Every generation has to learn how to protect and defend it, or it’s gone and gone for a long, long time.
[…]
Will we, before it is too late, use the vitality and the magic of the marketplace to save this way of life, or will we one day face our children, and our children’s children when they ask us where we were and what we were doing on the day that freedom was lost?
That was from a speech Reagan gave at Hillsdale College on November 10, 1977, as one of the Ludwig Von Mises Memorial Lectures.
Krugman could just as easily have pinned the Palin quote there, but then he might not have been able to scare up the Medicare boogeyman for all his pinheaded followers to get gibberishy over.
And the further thing is, despite the fact that Reagan was completely right about socialism in general and Medicare in particular, the idea that McCain & Co. have any intention of taking one single centavo away from one Medicare grasping hand is ludicrous on the face of it.
No, in order to get rid of the drag on our economy and the imposition of our freedoms that Medicare is, we’re going to have to wait for the socialist behemoth to collapse of its own accord. Or for the government that makes it possible to collapse. And the way things are going, that just might not be too far off. I wonder how badly Krugman’s cavalcade of kooks will behave when it does. Not too brightly, I’d wager.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||