That I got mentioned in an Investor’s Business Daily update of the Stephen Hawking NHS story. (Also copied at Investors.com.)
It still may be too early for me to barter my principles for a little cash and a chance to see my phiz on a box of Cheerios, but I’m that much closer to the time when.
Despite earlier mistreatment (yes, believe it or not, I’m working it with all the mundane alacrity I can muster) at the hands of the U.K.’s National Health System, it appears that Stephen Hawking believes that all that socialism requires for success is a number of popular and famous individuals to advocate for their special privileges. Or so the agéd article dribbling into my newsreader would have the world believe:
Professor Stephen Hawking has called on Gordon Brown to release cash withheld from a Gloucestershire college.
Last month Cheltenham’s National Star College was told a grant of more than £5m from the Learning and Skills Council (LSC) was being withdrawn.
The money was to improve capacity and facilities for students with complex physical disabilities.
Professor Hawking has asked the prime minister to find funding to "enable this invaluable project to go forward".
The great theoretical physicist would like the prime minister to "find funding" somewhere, as though those spendy pounds were some narrow bandwidth energy signature that appropriately-government-sponsored sensitive instruments could pluck out of the background noise of all creation and plug into the great altruistic equation.
Or the great black hole of taxation could just suck harder.
Stephen doesn’t care. It’s all theoretical to him.
ps. By the way, I’m entirely willing to entertain the claim that Stephen Hawking is not a socialist. The fervor of collectivist incompetence associated with him of late may instead be emanating from those around him; for instance, his daughter, who co-authored the letter of the story above, and who, perhaps, speaks for him when U.K. Guardian gossip columnists need a quick quote to serve their impartialities:
When Obama’s in trouble we intervene. That’s just the way it is.
Maybe it’s a Journolist thing. Maybe they should just get a room.
As I’ve documented before, Paul Krugman of the New York Times is not averse to playing loose with the truth. Like you didn’t know that. A few days ago, he couldn’t help but sneak Stephen Hawking into another of his paeans to collectivism. Klein started it. I debunked it five days before Krugman thought to keep the cute little lie alive.
I wouldn’t be either of those freaks for all the money in the world.
ps. Thanks to Jim May for the link a few days ago, attached to the excellent observation that (alá Bastiat) positing the non-existence of the U.K.’s National Health Service does not mean one has to posit barbarism or nothing in its stead.
Just before shutting down last night, I noticed a new editorial put up by Investor’s Business Daily speakin’ to the Stephen Hawking tempest in a twitter bowl.
(Speakin’ of which, if straight up Democracy is The Tyranny of the Majority, then Twitter groups like welovetheNHS are The Idiocy of the Masses. Just sayin’.)
Other than not finding and reading, "Stephen Hawking: A Life in Science", with its relevant passages that I quoted two days ago, the IBD guys don’t completely botch it this time. They could have done better, but it’s still a pretty good run at blasting the relative merit of the U.K.’s socialist National Health Service to smithereens.
And Ezra Klein is still a moron.
I gotta go weed whack, and pre-load the firepit.
NO HYDROCARBONS SHALL GO UNRELEASED THIS WEEKEND!
Apparently Ezra Klein doesn’t read this blog. Who knew?
(Thanks to Malone Vandam and Billy Beck for da links. I do enjoy the avalanches. There was at least one visitor, came in through Billy’s, from fed.gov who scooped a lot of pages. Possibly others. They’re always there, these days. Santa Claus is making his lists and checking ’em twice.)
So, the progressive echo chamber was all into reverberating on the single unmodulated key that Klein played for them two days ago, a thing (the mindless echoing) that never ceases to amaze me. There’s no reasoning with it, no poking it in the eye, no tripping it up, no making a dent. It rolls on.
Me, I know I gave it a good whack, and if people stumble across it at some point, after wading through the endless seas of rote repetition, or even if they don’t, there it is. The U.K.’s National Health Service was not prepared to accomodate Stephen Hawking’s needs back in 1985.
Today, following up on the Stephen Hawking story, Klein played anecdote parade with tweets from a Twitter … person? group? calling itself welovetheNHS. Makes you wonder if so many people can really be that stupid, going on and on about how it is all "free", and not the kind of "free" with quotes around it. It never occurs to them that their lousy job market and their teensy cars (if they can afford one) and their teeny little flats with half-sized refrigerators are all partly due to the value sucked out of the performing end of their economy in service to that bloated disgrace called the NHS. Not to belittle the suckings of every other socialist and/or welfare state agency. It’s free, it’s free, it’s free is the sound of a million morons dancing under the watchful eye of the surveillance camera, not realizing at all the costs they paid.
And then, in the same entry, Klein waxed ecstatic, because Hugh Muir of the UK Guardian wrote that Stephen Hawking loves the NHS. Muir writes:
We say [Hawking’s] life is far from worthless, as they do at Addenbrooke’s hospital, Cambridge, where Professor Hawking, who has motor neurone disease, was treated for chest problems in April. As indeed does he. "I wouldn’t be here today if it were not for the NHS," he told us. "I have received a large amount of high-quality treatment without which I would not have survived."
Klein said, of Muir, "[H]e called Hawking for his reaction," but Muir doesn’t claim that he called Hawking, or even when he collected the quote. Not that it matters. Hell, if I wanted to really go out on a limb I’d say that the quote attributed to Hawking doesn’t much sound like the man. And, while his computer (a necessary ingredient in all his communications) is hooked to a phone system, I’d rather imagine that phoning him up to ask him what he thought of an Investor’s Business Daily editorial from two weeks ago isn’t easily done. And yet, even if Klein knows more than Muir publicly states, and isn’t playing fabulist to make the story sound better, and if Muir isn’t being cute, it doesn’t matter.
The NHS successfully treats millions of people a year, even, when necessary, Stephen Hawking. They are a health service, after all. But Stephen Hawking is a famous man, now, and his most recent visit to Addenbrooke’s hospital was not a particularly onerous burden for the public to bear. He had some tests done and spent a day or so "in observation". As I pointed out yesterday, twenty four years ago, before Hawking became a popular public figure, the NHS refused to provide him with the care that he and his family thought he deserved. And at least one member of his family didn’t love the NHS because of it. And, since 1985, Hawking has devoted significant effort and his own resources trying to help those, like himself, that the NHS leaves short. Now, he may be entirely appreciative of the work that the NHS has done for him, and there’s nothing wrong with that, but if Hawking hadn’t turned out to be world famous Hawking, he’d probably be dead by now.
Furthermore, the argument Klein is trying to make with Muir’s quote from Hawking is specious. It doesn’t matter how many people, including Hawking, love the NHS. A lot of people loved slavery at one time, but that didn’t make that right. And the fact that the NHS, or the Post Office, or Amtrak, do manage to stumble through most days and save someone’s life, or deliver a letter, or have a train show up on time, doesn’t mean that any of them aren’t unnecessary and immoral drains on their respective societies, and shouldn’t be abolished, with the monies extracted for their furtherances returned to its rightful owners.
A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.
Ezra Klein was in high dudgeon yesterday, but inappropriately (and ignorantly) so. Klein’s wormy ire was directed at an editorial in Investor’s Business Daily, an anti-socialist health care editorial, an editorial, according to Klein, filled with "lies and distortions" to which one "could write some long response". Klein, instead, chose to attack the following single sentence in the IBD editorial:
People such as scientist Stephen Hawking wouldn’t have a chance in the U.K., where the National Health Service would say the life of this brilliant man, because of his physical handicaps, is essentially worthless.
Klein says that the IBD "simply lied", and he can prove it, because, as everyone ought to know, Stephen Hawking is a lifelong citizen and denizen of the U.K., and is still alive.
Klein’s post was picked up by a number of others, perhaps echoed through the little tin cup of Klein’s Journolist, and Badda Boom Badda Bing, the Investor’s Business Daily page now says…
Editor’s Note: This version corrects the original editorial which implied that physicist Stephen Hawking, a professor at the University of Cambridge, did not live in the UK.
… and the offending contentious sentence has been removed (though it’s still in the mp3 audio version of the piece that IBD offers.) (And, by the way, that correction sucks in that it does not admit of the true criticism the sentence elicited, even if, as we shall shortly see, that criticism was unwarranted.)
So, Stephen Hawking lives and breathes in the U.K., and he has the National Health Service to thank for it?
Hardly.
See, Ezra Klein, moron, forgot to investigate the principle thrust of the argument and instead aimed his tiny displeasure at the secondary clause. But, the record is unequivocal: England’s National Health Service did tell Hawking that it couldn’t accomodate his needs. It was only due to the steadfast devotion and hard work of his wife, and the generosity of friends and scientific groups around the world that Hawking didn’t end up in an institution where he surely would have died.
A commenter on Klein’s blog provided the first clue (complete with link), in Hawking’s own words:
I caught pneumonia in 1985. I had to have a tracheotomy operation. After this, I had to have 24 hour nursing care. This was made possible by grants from several foundations.
Hmm. Well, no mention of the NHS.
Interestingly, Michael White and John Gribbin have written a book about Stephen Hawking, which can be read online, or downloaded, here.
On page 96 we are told of the disillusion Hawkings’ father had with the NHS:
Since his diagnosis and early deterioration, Hawking’s symptoms had remained more or less constant, but in the latter half of the 1960s another rapid decline occurred. He had to take to using crutches rather than sticks in order to get around. At this point his father became disillusioned and impatient with the advice his son was receiving from the medical profession and decided to take over Stephen’s treatment. He carried out intensive research into ALS and prescribed a course of steroids and vitamins that Stephen continued to take until his father’s death in 1986.
On page 235 comes the real story:
After the tracheostomy, Stephen would need round-the-clock nursing. The best the National Health Service could offer was seven hours’ nursing help a week in the Hawkings’ home, plus two hours’ help with bathing. They would have to pay for private nursing. The advance from the book would not last long, and there was absolutely no certainty about its eventual success. To Jane there seemed little long-term hope. How were they to survive if he could never work again? There were few possibilities. She would willingly have left her own career and devoted herself full-time to looking after her husband, but she was not a qualified nurse, and in any case, who would then provide for the family? The alternative was the dreaded thought of Stephen in a nursing home, unable to work, slipping into gradual decline and eventual death. “There were days when I felt sometimes I could not go on because I didn’t know how to cope,” Jane has said of that period.
It was obvious they would have to find financial support from somewhere. Jane wrote letter after letter to charitable organizations around the world and called upon the help of family friends in approaching institutions that might be interested in assisting them. Help arrived from an American foundation aware of Hawking’s work and international reputation, which agreed to pay £50,000 a year toward the costs of nursing. Shortly afterward several other charitable organizations on both sides of the Atlantic followed suit with smaller donations. Jane feels bitter about the whole affair. She resents the fact that, after paying a lifetime of contributions to the National Health Service, they were offered such meager help when the need arose. She is very aware that if her husband had been an unknown physics teacher he would now be living out his final days in a residential home. “Think of the waste of talent,” she has said of the situation.
Jane Hawking bitter at the NHS? Whatever for, Klein? Whatever for?
On page 310 we hear of Hawking’s efforts to raise money for others whose ailments are deemed too costly for NHS concern:
[Hawking] also firmly believes that the technology now available to him through the money he has earned as an author should be made available to other seriously disabled people via the NHS and claims that reliance upon charity (and in his case good fortune) is “simply not good enough.” To help the plight of others who have been paralyzed either through accidents or diseases such as ALS, Hawking has spearheaded several campaigns to generate funds.
That is what socialised fucking medicine is all about. When the chips are down, if you can’t fend for yourself, you’re dead. If you think the free market is the same thing, you’re wrong. You’re worse off with socialized medicine because it fails you after you’ve spent your entire healthy life "donating" to it. Socialism continuously drains the very resources individuals could use to provide for themselves. Education, health care, it’s the same. If you want to give your kids a decent education, you have to pay the fucking taxes to support the public schools, and then you still have to pay for that private education. Those well off in the U.K. have to pay the horrendous taxes for the "free" health care, and then they have to go and pay for private care, too. The poor slobs who can’t afford to pay twice wind up crushed in the maw.
And Ezra Klein is an ignorant twit and should admit that Stephen Hawking, and those like him, are routinely denied substantive care by the socialists in the UK. And then Klein should apologize to the Investor’s Business Daily and asked them to recorrect their correction.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||