Bastiat would have kicked fat Bradford DeLong’s ass around the town square at will.
DeLong wants to figure the cost/benefit of "Cash for Clunkers", but can only address that which sits obviously before his little pig eyes: The difference in the gas mileages of the Clunker vs. The New Car (and even there, as his first commenter makes clear, DeLong can’t even get the math right). What DeLong can’t see, or refuses to see, are all the things that aren’t obvious without turning one’s brain over to look for them. DeLong, ostensibly a professor at a well-known university, can’t see his way out of the simple Broken-window Fallacy (see Bastiat, above).
The unseen:
There’s the billion (so far) dollars stolen from the productivity of the country that would have been spent freely elsewhere, negating DeLong’s "boosts spending (somewhat)" argument. What the idiot should have said is, "boosts spending on cars (somewhat) over the course of the week I’ve been paying attention to the Cash for Clunkers story, but maybe spending lagged before the end of July with people putting off their purchases in order to grab the loot being handed out by the government, and maybe sales will tank after the Cash for Clunkers cash runs out. I have no idea if overall spending in the economy is up, down, or sideways, because people may have put off other purchases to take advantage of the ‘good’ car deal."
Also, when one considers that a certain number of "clunkers" would have been traded in anyway without any fake incentives ("free" money that happened to have been stolen via taxes), the apparent increase in car sales is marginal, at best. Edmunds.com notes that 50,000 extra clunkers traded in works out to about $20,000 tax dollars per clunker. About typical for government work, I’d say.
The billion dollars (so far) is a billion dollars PLUS some not insignificant amount. The government doesn’t have the billion. It’s going to borrow it. There will be interest to pay on the debt. The taxpayer will end up paying that interest.
Any increase in new cars sales will be matched by an increase in consumer debt. That can’t be a good thing in the Obama recession.
The used car market is going to take a hit. Over the short term all used cars in private hands are automatically worth at least $3500. Why sell that car to the kid down the street for $800 when the government will steal five times that amount from your neighbors and make you an offer you can barely refuse. Honesty? Ethics? Please, if health care is a right, so is twenty percent off the price of that gleaming new piece of steel. The kid down the street is young; he can walk.
Over the long term, the nation’s used car lots are going to be short about 250,000 cars. Maybe a million cars short, if Chuckie Schumer gets his way. Obviously, prices for used cars are going to be heading up, escpecially in a down economy when more people are going to be looking for something that doesn’t carry that new car premium. That’s going to be bad for consumers, but dealers will lose out, too, since, at least over the short term, they aren’t taking in any new used cars. They’re taking in "clunkers", that have to be rendered useless and scrapped. That means less overall inventory to have on offer for those prospective used-car buyers, meaning fewer overall sales. That’s also fewer total cars for their mechanics (standing around by the big bay doors) to be working on. Adios to at least some used-car mechanics.
The idiot DeLong mumbles that the clunker cars "would have been junked anyway", but apparently doesn’t understand that the clunkers in the government program aren’t just being junked, they’re having their engines, the most valuable component to any car, completely destroyed first. So, not only does Cash for Clunkers play havoc with the used car market, it also fucks royally with the downstream markets, which are extensive, and support a great many people while providing value to a great many more.
And then, of course, the one thing that fat buffoon Brad DeLong will never see as he pretends to survey the economic horizons, is the loss of freedom that always accompanies these billion dollar government handouts. The money comes out of the very lives of real working people. All taxpayers are now saddled (under threat of impoverishment or incarceration) with another billion dollar plus bill, with the likelihood of three or four times that amount if our dear political elite get their way. These people are fucking with real lives, and idiot buffoons like Brad DeLong want to try to justify it with half a minute of calculator work that isn’t even correct.
And those are just the most obvious "unseen" factors. There are undoubtedly many more. Will more people die in lighter ("more efficient") cars? Get the calculator out, Brad. If it’s less than "x" amount, it’ll be okay, right? As long as it’s in our collective interest, I mean.
If "Genius is one percent inspiration, ninety-nine percent perspiration," then buffoon "economist" Brad DeLong is a whopping one percent down the road to genius. He’s inspired, that’s for sure, but he hasn’t a clue as to how to proceed. Here’s an entire blog post from the renowned perfessor at Berkeley:
How Are We Going to Manage to Do All This
The Obama administration is going to be rebuilding and reconstructing five major sectors of the American t. It has no choice–there is no other option. It has to remake:
Autos
Housing finance
High finance
Energy
And the big one—health care
On what principles and through what procedures is this extraordinary exercise in structural economic reform policy going to be accomplished? I get how to do the macroeconomics of Obama administration economic policy. I don’t get how to do the structural side…
Just write the policy, Brad. Leave the rest to the military.
A perceptive chap peruses "economist" Brad DeLong’s blog entry deriding Ludwig von Mises, and observes:
The most intelligent part of this blog is that which was quoted of von Mises. The author [of the blog] fails to explain exactly why von Mises’ points are invalid, implicitly assuming that his "economists" of choice are correct without justification. I place quotations around the word "economists" because the advocation of printing money for "price stabilisation" makes absolutely no economical sense and is demonstrably poor theory when inflation is taken into consideration (i.e. the fact that real prices remained almost the same for the 100 years prior to being taken off the gold standard). Funny, that thing we call history. Never did so many banks (when taken as a ratio of the total) fail in that century versus the one post gold standard.
The buffoon DeLong takes several more succinct wallops before he closes down the comments, without uttering a peep in his own defense.
Via: Von Mises
Morning Update: Buffoon "economist" Brad DeLong, overnight, deleted many of the comments critical of his unsubstantiated claims, including the one I quoted above, without answering any of them. Delong is all vanity, you see, and no substance. I predict he’ll find work in the Obama administration.
Here’s Brad, admitting his own wrongheadedness:
The Wrong Financial Crisis
J. Bradford DeLong
Professor of Economics, U.C. Berkeley
Research Associate, NBER
delong@econ.berkeley.edu
October 8, 2008We—all of us from Nouriel Roubini to Lawrence Summers to John Taylor to Tim Geithner (except perhaps Ben Bernanke, who really did seem to believe in a long-run global savings glut)—were expecting a very different financial crisis. We were expecting the Balance of Financial Terror between Asia and America to collapse and produce chaos. We were expecting a free fall in the dollar’s value that would push and be pushed by large-scale capital flight from America that would [blah blah blah]
And here’s Brad praying that taxpayer money is going to keep him corporeal through the coming lean times:
I Am Optimally Hedged. I Have a Defined-Benefit Pension Here at Cal
So I keep telling myself
I dunno, Brad. You look like you eat a lot of potatoes. Do you know how to grow potatoes? How are you going to trade an expertise you don’t have for that which you cannot produce?
Anyone see what’s wrong with DeLong’s suggestion?
Buy low, sell high after all.
Just saying…
Anyone?
For one thing, it would be against the law, and while I hold no truck with the law in most ways, a law which constrains government to tend its stolen monies with the utmost prudence is probably one of the better laws to have.
Further, there is NO "Social Security Trust Fund Balance". There is only a pile of IOUs, in a file cabinet in Parkersburg, West Virginia, enumerating the sums that the government has taken from the alleged fund and spent elsewhere. Technically, the IOUs are non-negotiable (as in non-marketable), special series Treasury bonds, backed solely by whatever faith and credit future Congresses can muster. As such, the IOUs are U.S. government debt, and the approximately two trillion dollar entry in the books in the Public Debt file cabinet is part of the widely cited total U.S. public debt figure.
Theoretically, the government could attempt to sell the Social Security debt on the open market, just like it does all its other debt, but Congress would have to change the laws to allow it. Theoretically, also, Congress could change the laws to allow the Treasury to take the Social Security tax receipts and buy equities with them, instead of special series, non-negotiable Treasury bonds, but then the equities wouldn’t be backed by the flagging faith and credit of the U.S. government, and, more importantly, the money then couldn’t be spent by the government in all the ways that unbridled profligacy enjoys (which is probably the way Social Security should have been set up, if there were ever some legitimate reason to set it up in the first place, which there wasn’t.)
Of course, nitwits like Brad DeLong have raised the question before. In 1999, Greenspan was forced to cough up testimony before a House subcommittee of the Commerce Committee on the very matter. In amongst paragraphs of important-sounding blatherings can be found:
If social security trust funds are shifted from U.S. Treasury securities to private debt and equity instruments, holders of those securities in the private sector must be induced to exchange them, on net, for U.S. Treasuries. Private pension and insurance funds, among other holders of equities, presumably would swap equities for Treasuries. It seems likely that a rise in the interest rate paid on Treasuries, and perhaps an increase in equity prices and a reduction in the expected future return on equity, would be necessary in order to induce private investors to reallocate their portfolios from equities to U.S. Treasury securities. If this is indeed the case, then the net increment to the government of investing the trust fund in equities on an ongoing basis presumably would be less than the historical rates of return suggest. That said, exactly what changes in bond and stock prices would result from this type of large-scale swap of U.S. Treasuries for equities is extremely difficult to predict.
But analyzing the macroeconomic effects of the portfolio reallocation is much less complicated. The transfer of social security assets from U.S. Treasuries to equities would not, in itself, have any effect on national saving. Thus, the underlying economic assets in the economy would be unchanged, as would the total income generated by those assets. Any increase in returns realized by social security must be offset by a reduction in returns earned on private portfolios, which represent, to a large extent, funds held for retirement. Investing social security assets in equities is, then, largely a zero-sum game.
[…]
[I]nvesting the social security trust funds in equities does little or nothing to improve the overall ability of the U.S. economy to meet the retirement needs of the next century. Given this lack of evident benefit, it is unclear to me why we should take on the risk of interference, which, probably short of a Constitutional amendment, cannot be eliminated. Even if concerns about politically driven investment were not to materialize, what would have been gained by such a huge shuffling of funds?
Further, were all the hoops adroitly jumped through, and some Paulson protégé given the task of trading the Fed’s two trillion dollar position, should we then look to incompetent boob Brad DeLong to signal when to get out of the market?
… or:
Hey, Brad, you ignorant commie, how about you let me manage my own retirement funds and if I fuck up I don’t ask you to bail me out? Or do I have to be yoked to the broken-wheeled wagon of your stupidity forever? Or is me being saddled with the likes of your incompetence part of the great social contract? Do you know?
More on the Social Security Trust Fund here, and this:
These [Trust Fund] balances are available to finance future benefit payments and other Trust Fund expenditures – but only in a bookkeeping sense…. They do not consist of real economic assets that can be drawn down in the future to fund benefits. Instead, they are claims on the Treasury that, when redeemed, will have to be financed by raising taxes, borrowing from the public, or reducing benefits or other expenditures.
That other shyster "economist", Brad DeLong, has joined the cavalcade of troofers, unearthing the conspiracy in Sarah Palin’s use of a famous Reagan quote. Here’s the title the nice, level-headed, "economist" Brad DeLong put on the thing:
McCain and Palin Reveal Their Plan to Destroy Medicare!!
Weeeee Ooooooooooooo.
Underneath the hysteria, he’s just as stupidly mistaken (or dishonest, take your pick) as Paul Krugman is.
Poor "economist" Brad DeLong. Today’s vote didn’t go the way he wanted:
Bring Congress Back into Session After the Election…
…and go for the Swedish plan: nationalize the insolvent large financial institutions: dare Bush to veto that after the election.
Vote Count:
Democrats: 141 Yea, 94 Nay
Republican: 66 Yea, 132 Nay.
This Republican Party needs to be burned, razed to the ground, and the furrows sown with salt…
Don’t worry, Brad. It was that close. Nancy and Barney will be back with more and will eventually succeed, and, with your exemplary work as party spokesworm, and with a little help from the centralized worker’s party ruling class, you just might find yourself with the power you obviously crave, power to affect real people in real numbers instead of just the few who stray across your path, power to control a real financial institution or two, and most importantly, the power to punish your political enemies, to raze them "to the ground".
Do they believe their own little lies?
Paul Krugman: "[T]axpayers may end up making money in the end."
Brad DeLong: "Nationalization has the best chance of avoiding large losses and possibly even making money for the taxpayer."
Larry Summers: "The Chrysler bail-out, President Bill Clinton’s emergency loans to Mexico, and the Depression-era support programmes for housing and financial sectors all ultimately made profits for taxpayers."
Anyone remember getting a check from the government on any of those deals?
Anyone think he’ll be getting more than a hearty "Fuck You" out of this new one?
Nope. Any money taken in anywhere in any of this latest government clusterfuck will immediately be swallowed up by the slavering beast amid bellowings for more, more, and more.
It is impossible to finesse a correction the size of the current one, with all of its attendant complexities, with money that no one has. If defies belief, but Summers, at the link above, says now is the time to the government to make its push for greater involvement in healthcare, energy, education, and infrastructure.
God help us.
What to say about an economist (or any man, for that matter) who routinely stoops to taking cheap shots at those with whom he disagrees? One suspects that the cheapness most likely creeps throughout that man’s life and work.
Newsweek put its considerable resources into finding out how many vehicles the McCains and Obamas own, and DeLong can’t contain himself, barely managing to type out a decipherable thought: John McCain the Eiitist [sic]. Nice work, Brad.
Of course, DeLong’s cheap shot, like all cheap shots, lacks substance. That’s what "cheap" means. It’s also childish, as though DeLong believes that a thing will become the names that he calls it, solely by dint of his doing so.
The Newsweek story is that the McCains own some thirteen cars, and the Obamas but one small hybrid. I wouldn’t deign to trouble DeLong (he’s played the lying twit in email before) to trace the logic leading to his characterization. And, besides, I have my own take on it.
By any definition of the word elite, McCain and Obama both fit the bill. The Senate is routinely referred to as one of the most exclusive clubs on the planet. Both men are wealthy. Both men head their respective political parties, no mean feat in itself (though one wishes they might instead find honest work.) Both men travel the globe in style and luxury. But one of them owns thirteen vehicles (including three glorified golf carts) and the other owns one.
I would suggest to buffoonish Brad DeLong that the man more likely to have someone else drive him around is the true elite.
I would also point out that snooping through people’s garages is but one more type of buffoonery, eagerly taken up in this case by Newsweek, ABC News, and the salivating Brad DeLong. It’s the kind of thing Chavez encourages in his socialist showcase; the kind of thing that was routine in the old Soviet Union.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||