KAYAK2U

August 6, 2009

Why Oh Why Can’t Berkeley Hire Competent Economists?

Bastiat would have kicked fat Bradford DeLong’s ass around the town square at will.

DeLong wants to figure the cost/benefit of "Cash for Clunkers", but can only address that which sits obviously before his little pig eyes:  The difference in the gas mileages of the Clunker vs. The New Car (and even there, as his first commenter makes clear, DeLong can’t even get the math right).  What DeLong can’t see, or refuses to see, are all the things that aren’t obvious without turning one’s brain over to look for them.  DeLong, ostensibly a professor at a well-known university, can’t see his way out of the simple Broken-window Fallacy (see Bastiat, above).

The unseen:

There’s the billion (so far) dollars stolen from the productivity of the country that would have been spent freely elsewhere, negating DeLong’s "boosts spending (somewhat)" argument.  What the idiot should have said is, "boosts spending on cars (somewhat) over the course of the week I’ve been paying attention to the Cash for Clunkers story, but maybe spending lagged before the end of July with people putting off their purchases in order to grab the loot being handed out by the government, and maybe sales will tank after the Cash for Clunkers cash runs out.  I have no idea if overall spending in the economy is up, down, or sideways, because people may have put off other purchases to take advantage of the ‘good’ car deal."  

Also, when one considers that a certain number of "clunkers" would have been traded in anyway without any fake incentives ("free" money that happened to have been stolen via taxes), the apparent increase in car sales is marginal, at best.  Edmunds.com notes that 50,000 extra clunkers traded in works out to about $20,000 tax dollars per clunker.  About typical for government work, I’d say.

The billion dollars (so far) is a billion dollars PLUS some not insignificant amount.  The government doesn’t have the billion.  It’s going to borrow it.  There will be interest to pay on the debt.  The taxpayer will end up paying that interest.

Any increase in new cars sales will be matched by an increase in consumer debt.  That can’t be a good thing in the Obama recession.

The used car market is going to take a hit.  Over the short term all used cars in private hands are automatically worth at least $3500.  Why sell that car to the kid down the street for $800 when the government will steal five times that amount from your neighbors and make you an offer you can barely refuse.  Honesty?  Ethics?  Please, if health care is a right, so is twenty percent off the price of that gleaming new piece of steel.  The kid down the street is young;  he can walk.

Over the long term, the nation’s used car lots are going to be short about 250,000 cars.  Maybe a million cars short, if Chuckie Schumer gets his way.  Obviously, prices for used cars are going to be heading up, escpecially in a down economy when more people are going to be looking for something that doesn’t carry that new car premium.  That’s going to be bad for consumers, but dealers will lose out, too, since, at least over the short term, they aren’t taking in any new used cars.  They’re taking in "clunkers", that have to be rendered useless and scrapped.  That means less overall inventory to have on offer for those prospective used-car buyers, meaning fewer overall sales.  That’s also fewer total cars for their mechanics (standing around by the big bay doors) to be working on.  Adios to at least some used-car mechanics.

The idiot DeLong mumbles that the clunker cars "would have been junked anyway", but apparently doesn’t understand that the clunkers in the government program aren’t just being junked, they’re having their engines, the most valuable component to any car, completely destroyed first.  So, not only does Cash for Clunkers play havoc with the used car market, it also fucks royally with the downstream markets, which are extensive, and support a great many people while providing value to a great many more.

And then, of course, the one thing that fat buffoon Brad DeLong will never see as he pretends to survey the economic horizons, is the loss of freedom that always accompanies these billion dollar government handouts.  The money comes out of the very lives of real working people.  All taxpayers are now saddled (under threat of impoverishment or incarceration) with another billion dollar plus bill, with the likelihood of three or four times that amount if our dear political elite get their way.  These people are fucking with real lives, and idiot buffoons like Brad DeLong want to try to justify it with half a minute of calculator work that isn’t even correct.

And those are just the most obvious "unseen" factors.  There are undoubtedly many more.  Will more people die in lighter ("more efficient") cars?  Get the calculator out, Brad.  If it’s less than "x" amount, it’ll be okay, right?  As long as it’s in our collective interest, I mean.

MikeSoja - August 6, 2009 -- 01:29 am    Filed in: Morons  
« The Great Destruction
“The Hawaiian Good Luck Sign” »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud