Tom Kilgore, chief despot at the Tennessee Valley Authority, saddles his captive constituency with the costs of his and his government established monopoly’s incompetence, malfeasance, and dereliction:
The head of TVA said Thursday that electricity users will have to pay nearly $3 billion to clean up and revamp the way coal ash is handled following the Kingston spill, the country’s worst ash spill ever.
[…]
[N]ine months after the Dec. 22 spill at the Kingston plant, Kilgore said he isn’t ready to dismiss any employees over the incident.
These people are beyond the law, because they are the law. It’s another fucking government disgrace.
Not quite four months after the Kingston Tennessee coal ash disaster, the Tennessee Valley Authority is pleading special dispensation:
The Tennessee Valley Authority filed motions Friday in U.S. District Court in Knoxville seeking the dismissal of all seven lawsuits brought by residents claiming damages from the Dec. 22 spill of coal-ash sludge at the Kingston Fossil Plant.
TVA claims its actions maintaining a coal-ash retention pond are covered under the discretionary function doctrine, which, with exceptions, prevents a federal government entity from being sued for planning and carrying out policy.
You can’t sue them. They’re the government! It’s a regular TVA defense in suits brought against it, as I noted in an earlier post quoting a TVA filing:
On April 3, 2006, TVA moved to dismiss the suit on grounds that the case is not suitable for judicial resolution because of separation of powers principles, including the fact that these matters are based on policy decisions left to TVA’s discretion in its capacity as a government agency and thus are not subject to tort liability (the “discretionary function doctrine”), as well as the Supremacy Clause.
It’s one of the wonders of Fascism.
Better learn to love it, I say.
Via: Sweet Cheeks
ps. There are about ninety five angles on this that I’m not touching, but it still all boils down the immorality of locking responsibility up behind the veneer of government officialdom.
Also, I posted about the lawsuits that the TVA is moving to dismiss here.
The temptation was too much. There in the glow of the search engine spew was the headline, "The Three-Mile Island of coal", neatly encapsulated in a link to SOCIALISTWORKER.org. "That’s gotta be a laugh," I thought, and secured my seat pre-click. I was, however, quickly thrown for a loop when "Mike" "reported":
Within days, residents reported "vomiting for more than 12 hours after drinking the water"–which is a common symptom of arsenic or heavy metal poisoning.
"Wow," sez I to myself, "I must have missed some news," and so went searching. I found no recountings of mass vomitings in the incompetent Main Street Media, of course, but only the words of a certain anti-coal fanatic, who claimed on December 24th, just two days after the coal ash spill:
We met a man who had been vomiting for the past 12 hours after drinking a couple of pots of coffee made from the tainted water,” said Matt Landon of United Mountain Defense, a Knoxville TN based environmental organization. We advised him to go to the hospital.
In this version, also dated December 24th, Landon says that it was…
*** Yesterday we spoke with one man who had been vomiting for 12 hours after drinking a few pots of coffee made from the tainted water. We informed to go to the hospital and we could not find him again today. Today we met a lady whose dogs had been vomiting after drinking the un-boiled tainted water.
The claim was promulgated on Landon’s anti-coal group site, here, and subsequently picked up and repeated here, here, and further on down the line of usual suspects.
There is some reason to doubt Landon’s claim entirely, because, while the second December 24th entry above refers to "Yesterday", or December 23rd, the rest of the article pertains to Landon’s very first visit to the site of the coal ash spill, on the 24th. It doesn’t sound like Landon went to Kingston or Harriman on the 23rd. Therefore, Landon either spoke to someone on the phone on December 23rd, or heard the story from someone else (perhaps the "we" to which he continually tosses the exchange), or otherwise pulled the claim out of the air. (Landon, by the way, is half of the duo initially reported to have been "arrested and detained" by TVA police for the crime of taking pictures of the toxic heap, but now says: "I was not arrested just a few days ago; I was actually just detained for over an hour for taking photographs," which doesn’t particularly absolve the TVA police of anything, in my eyes.) In any event, to accept the bare gist of the coffee/vomiting story, we must believe that within a few hours of the giant spill someone in the immediate vicinity was stupid enough to go down to the river, scoop up some ash-filled muck with which to fill his coffee pot (at least twice, but as many as "a few" times), drink the resulting brew, followed by twelve hours of vomiting, to be saved only when the caring folks at UMD "advised him to go to the hospital." Either that, or we must believe that, in addition to the river and lake waters which were obviously immediately polluted by the untold gallons of coal ash dumped in them, the underground wells and aquifers in the area were also immediately rendered unsafe, but only with the invisible, odorless, tasteless particles from the spill, so that at least one person was lulled into believing his water unaffected by the calamity which had just taken place outside his walls. It doesn’t seem plausible to me.
What’s for sure is that Mike-the-SocialistWorker (top of post) is completely nuts, as there is no indication of a plural in the record, and no one as yet has even semi-officially cited any cases of arsenic poisoning associated with the spill.
Other instances of Mike-the-SocialistWorker’s loose association with reality can be seen in statements like, "To prevent these types of disasters in the future, we will need to […] establish public ownership and control over the TVA", his pitch seeming to land somewhere outside the ballpark of facts having to do with the current public ownership and control of the TVA. It is precisely that the TVA is publicly owned that is much of the problem.
But Mike-the-SocialistWorker’s title, "The Three-Mile Island of coal", is also fairly daft, even after dismissing his misspelling of the place (sludge is not radiation, and the country will continue to build coal plants despite the TVA’s incompetence), and yet it is fairly typical of the headlines I’ve been seeing for the last several weeks.
Here’s Landon again, playing the plague of biblical proportions card: "The Great Coal Ash Flood".
Then there is the calm and rational Dave Cooper, writing under the headline, "Disaster in Harriman is this country’s Chernobyl"…
Environmental Protection Agency data requested by The New York Times reveals that in just one year, TVA placed 45,000 pounds of arsenic in the Kingston impoundment. And, since the plant is over 50 years old, 1 million pounds of arsenic is a conservative estimate for the total release into the Emory River.
Cooper somehow misses the fact that the TVA posts its emissions data on a publicly viewable web page. And then he makes the commonly unclever mistake of presuming that the Kingston plant’s entire store of coal ash with all of its noxiousnesses included was immediately sucked into the surrounding environment never to be see again except in the genetic mutations of fauna and flora, when, in dreary fact, about half the pile collapsed, and a relatively small portion of that made it to the water. To be sure, the size of the original pile was, without question, immense, and a lot of damage was and is still to be done, but these attempts to blow the thing out of proportion seem counterproductive to me, especially inasmuch as direct criticism of the TVA is avoided in favor of attacking the stacks of coal that are the apparent, real enemies of the kooks and socialists.
The next headline in the parade of outsized calamaties that caught my eye was, "Holocaust Victims Attorney Files Class-Action Lawsuit Against TVA", but it turns out that the law firm really was founded by an attorney who chased down Nazi collaborators, back in the day.
And then we come to the Exxon Valdez, everyone’s favorite monumental environmental disaster and easy touchstone for smart sounding comparisions. Let ME say that I’d rather go play on the hundred acres of sludge in Kingston than swim around in two gallons of north shore crude, but maybe that’s just me.
Elsewise, here are the headlines…
Will Tennessee Coal Ash Spill Be the Exxon Valdez of Clean Coal?
Tennessee Sludge Spill: Government Disaster 30 Times Worse than Exxon-Valdez
Environmental Disaster in Tennessee Reported 40x Exxon Valdez Spill
Environmental Spill Disaster Devastates Tennessee; 48 Times the Size of Exxon Valdez
Nightmare before Christmas: Coal sludge spill 50X worse than Exxon Valdez
Here’s Landon again, upping the ante: "The volume of waste released was over 80 times larger than the Exxon Valdez spill."
But the champ of champs is (drum roll, please….. ) Barbara Boxer:
The committee’s chairwoman, Sen. Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., was more strident in her criticism of the Dec. 22 sludge flood at a coal ash-filled pond in Kingston, Tenn. — an event she characterized as "100 times greater than the amount of oil spilled during the Exxon Valdez" spill off the coast of Alaska in 1989.
Do I hear two hundred???!???
It should be obvious that responsibility for the recent catastrophe at the Kingston Steam Plant is to be laid soley at the feet of the Tennessee Valley Authority, owners and operators of said plant.
The coal ash spill isn’t the fault of Tennesseans who use electricity. Customers have no ownership rights or responsibilities, especially when they are denied a choice of supplier. The TVA is a federally mandated monopoly.
The billion gallons of sludge across the land isn’t the fault of the coal industry, any more than murder is the fault of Remington Arms Co., or traffic fatalities are the fault of Ford, or that graffiti is the fault of spray paint manufacturers.
The contaminated water making its way through the heart of the eastern half of the country isn’t even the fault of state and federal legislators and regulators. Nope. Even if there were some half-sensical justification (there isn’t) for raising another platoon of regulators, it still wouldn’t be their responsibility to prevent disasters like the one at the mouth of the Emory River. It isn’t the fault of the USDA when E. coli crops up. It isn’t the fault of the FCC when someone bares a breast on Superbowl TeeVee. If someone wanted to hire a person or agency to prevent or insure against various calamities, then one might be able to assign responsibility and extract compensation if said person or agency failed to fulfill their contract and said calamity came to pass, but state and federal regulators are under no such onus (which is particularly why they are ineffective to the point of worthlessness.)
No, the only people responsible for the coal ash spill are the people who owned and operated the site, who failed to maintain their dike in which they were storing their fly ash which is a by-product of their business. They are the sole responsible party. Unfortunately, the situation at the Emory River is clouded by the fact that the TVA isn’t owned by anyone, because it is ostensibly owned by everyone. The fingerpointing can go on quite a ways when there are 300 million others to pass the buck to, but that doesn’t change the fact that there are only a relatively few people whose responsibility it is to run the TVA.
And yet, a large number of people just don’t get it, or are otherwise lost in their own personal agendas. For instance, some eleven days ago, two kayakers and a canoeist paddled up the Emory River to the big spill to have a look around, and to take pictures and water samples. They made a little (YouTube) video of what they saw and did. It’s generally boring, but at the 6:50 mark we are given:
But at about that time, we were interrupted. A nice little TVA officer [in his nice little TVA speed boat -ed] issued us a warning citation for criminal tresspass. He told us if we ever came back to the river he would prosecute us, even though we never set foot on dry land, and never touched any private property. We remained in our boats on navigable public waters of the United States at all times.
Elsewhere, they tell that part of the story slightly differently:
Wathen said the groups have been denied access to public roads and escorted out of a waterway by private TVA security police who claimed they were given federal authority through the Patriot act.
These are, Watham said, “gestopo tactics intended to scare people away from the truth.”
Along with Donna Lisenby and Sandra Diaz, Watham skirted police lines and took samples. “Cops (were) yelling from both sides,” he said. “The cops in cars could not get to us for the water. The cops in the boat could not reach us for the mud and debris in the river, and the helicopter couldn’t land in the muck to pick us up either.”
Personally, I don’t care if they had to cold cock a TVA goon in order to get to the river, but in the same interview, what do you suppose Wathan’s take on what he saw that day was? Here ’tis:
“Folks, it is time to change the way we do business with coal burning,” Wathen said.
There he is, standing within sight of a disaster caused by TVA negligence, been ticketed and escorted out of places he had a right to be by TVA goons, had absolute drivel about "the Patriot Act" thrown at him by the same TVA goons, and yet, for him and others, it’s all about the coal burning, man.
Jesus.
And there’s those "private" TVA police again. And I don’t doubt they were making noises about the Patriot Act. Who’s going to call them on it, eh? They’ve been running things in these parts for quite some time, and they don’t have to stand for some weaselly schnook trying to stick a nose in their business.
More evidence of the abuse the TVA throws around can be found at the link I gave yesterday to the TVA’s 2007 SEC filing. Down in the bowels of the "Legal Proceedings" section, one finds this gem:
On April 3, 2006, TVA moved to dismiss the suit on grounds that the case is not suitable for judicial resolution because of separation of powers principles, including the fact that these matters are based on policy decisions left to TVA’s discretion in its capacity as a government agency and thus are not subject to tort liability (the “discretionary function doctrine”), as well as the Supremacy Clause.
Anyone want to claim that maintaining shoddy dikes next to rivers isn’t a "policy decision left to TVA’s discretion"? Good luck
In the case cited, the court ended up denying the TVA’s motion (though the SEC filing doesn’t say for what reason), but it isn’t the only case listed where the TVA tried to use its position as a federally chartered institution to protect itself from those with claims against it. Such is nothing less than raw despotism hiding behind the privilege of political power. It’s a license to be negligent and irresponsible, and it’s part and parcel of all government entities. I don’t know why the little canoeists and kayakers can’t understand that.
Erin Brockovich is on her way to the TVA ash spill with a team of seasoned ambulance chasers hiding in her petticoats, to help the po' folks of mid-central Eastern Tennessee further impoverish themselves as payment for their alleged transgressions against nature and society. Ms Brockovich and crew will join a burgeoning throng of issue-interest litigants…
The suing organizations include the Sierra Club, Appalachian Center for the Economy and Environment, Earthjustice and Public Justice. Their notice expands on a similar action last week by Knoxville-based Southern Alliance for Clean Energy.
… all a-flutter over the chance to put the squeeze on the nation's largest energy turnip. If I thought any of 'em or all of 'em had a chance of putting the TVA out of business, I'd be cheering them on. But it's not going to happen. Yes, the TVA is sunk in up over its stinking, stupid eyeballs in debt ('07 report of some kind here). Yes, its debt notes are technically, as they say, "not backed by the full faith and credit of the United States". But the TVA is one of the bigger showpieces of socialist makework, and, it also doesn't take much effort to recollect at least two other Government Sponsored Enterprises whose liabilities also were not legally or ethically attachable to the wages of the erstwhile free citizenry, but whose liabilities were suddenly so intertwined. Whether the entire TVA region's rate paying droids are on the hook for the clean up, penalities, and exhorbitant lawyer's fees, or whether Mr U.S. taxpayer has to quit farting around and sacrifice a little more to make the nation whole again, one thing is certain: No one at the TVA is going to go to jail, and maybe even no one will lose a day's work. Life at the TVA will continue to be golden.
When a private company screws up, someone is held accountable. People stop buying its products. Shareholders fire the CEO. The company goes bankrupt. But when a government-run company has a similar problem, no one takes the blame.
Officials at TVA don't have to answer to shareholders or voters. Government-run companies, like the TVA, are interested in one thing: maintaining their own existence. As long as they keep their jobs, they couldn't care less about the quality — or dangers — of their product.
We are learning an important lesson about the differences between what happens when a private company and a public one impact the community negatively. Exxon had to pay over a half- billion dollars to fix the mess it caused, and rightfully so. Troublingly, taxpayers will be forced to pay to clean up the TVA's debacle.
The failure in Kingston isn't just a failure of walls and dams. It is the failure of socialist-style government conglomerates like TVA to be accountable to consumers.
It is time to tell our local, state and federal officials that if they think we are going to give the government even more control — control over our money, homes, businesses and families — they must be insane.
Well said, Mr Mitchell.
And what about this guy? From Wikipedia, no less:
One such considered above criticism, sacred as motherhood, is TVA. This program started as a flood control project; the Tennessee Valley was periodically ravaged by destructive floods. The Army Engineers set out to solve this problem. They said that it was possible that once in 500 years there could be a total capacity flood that would inundate some 600,000 acres (2,400 km²). Well, the engineers fixed that. They made a permanent lake which inundated a million acres (4,000 km²). This solved the problem of floods, but the annual interest on the TVA debt is five times as great as the annual flood damage they sought to correct. Of course, you will point out that TVA gets electric power from the impounded waters, and this is true, but today 85 percent of TVA's electricity is generated in coal burning steam plants. Now perhaps you'll charge that I'm overlooking the navigable waterway that was created, providing cheap barge traffic, but the bulk of the freight barged on that waterway is coal being shipped to the TVA steam plants, and the cost of maintaining that channel each year would pay for shipping all of the coal by rail, and there would be money left over.
Ronald Reagan, 1964. [Ed note, Oct 26, 2012. The quote from Wikipedia is gone, the speech as cited, apparently, not being given when it was claimed to have been given. Still, the quote appears to be genuine (except for the "km²" factoids) and shows up here, here, and here. The provenance is still all screwed up.]
All those years the TVA has been utter disaster after utter disaster, and they're still here. That's government for ya. That's the crime of socialism.
Just when I thought it couldn’t get any more ridiculous:
David Cooper and Matt Landon who were detained by the TVA police planned to take water samples but were just taking photographs of the spill at the time of their arrest. TVA has not responded to requests for more information on the incident.
How do you like it? A fucking utility with its own police force. Arresting people for taking pictures. Goddamned morons.
The whole lot of ’em should be taken out and stuck upside down in the sludge they let loose. And all the screamers screaming about dirty coal might as well be stuck in there with ’em, as far as I care.
Get rid of the TVA. Get rid of the whole incompetent, thug-run shooting match. Dump it in the river with the rest of the crap, but get rid of it.
Mrs Sweet Cheeks and I decided to motor off for a burger and a beer at the joint where we first landed in this neck of the woods some seventeen months ago, and also to have a gawk at the environmental disaster unfolding (courtesy of the Tennessee Valley Authority) just north of the I-40 bridge over the Clinch River at Kingston, Tennessee.
Access to the steam plant (the source of the coal ash that broke free of its TVA-engineered containment) from state route 70 was being monitored by a cop with his lit up SUV standing guard, but that way in is pretty much a dead end, now, anyway. We cruised through Kingston and puttered around some back roads until we got as close as we could, across the Emory River from the giant ash spill.
Lots of other folks were out trying to get a view, too, and we ended up nattering with an older feller who used to work for the TVA folks (the TVA is the big employer in these parts), and who claimed to have fished the section of water we were looking at, many a time. He was having a hard time recognizing the place, and was pretty pessimistic about the fallout to fish and the like. It’s pretty sad, because one of the better fishing spots (well known in general, not from conversations tonight) in the area was right as close as one could get to the steam plant, and it looks like that whole area is going to die dead, for at least a while.
While the stuff that washed into the Emory River and downstream, the so-called fly ash, is inert in some ways, it does have ingredients and properties that aren’t entirely compatible with yer common unacclimated river ecosystem. The reason the ash was in the big pile next to the steam plant in the first place is because various parties deemed it was too dangerous to be left spewing out of the tall and stately smokestacks looming so majestically over the landscape. And now all that shit that the government tried to save us from has slumped directly into the very LARGE river system that winds its way through much of Tennessee, the north of Alabama, a corner of Mississippi (before it gets hit from tother side), a lot of Kentucky, and then says hello to the Ohio River at Paducah, Kentucky, not too far from where the whole shebang meets the Mississippi River.
The good news is that the so-called fly ash is inert in some ways, and that the Tennessee River ecosystem is nearly comatose anyway. Any heavy metals in the crap are going to settle along the main channel of the Clinch and Tennessee Rivers, which are already loaded up with very similar shit from decades of human activity at the fringes. Nevertheless, the TVA’s malfeasance is singular in the scope of its transgression. This spill is a major impediment to any recovery that the river system might have been enjoying. The TVA’s negligence is a major setback for the entire area. And the TVA, itself, won’t suffer a jot for it.
We’re not sure how it’s going to play here on the margins of Watts Bar Lake. Right now, the TVA has the lake pumped up to near summer pool so they can get their barges and dredges up to the spill site, and, we figure, to minimize the flow of pollution south. But it occured to Sweet Cheeks that they might soon otherwise decide to let all the water out of the local system, so that bulldozers and steamshovels can be driven directly into the sludge heaps, and also to minimize the flow of allegedly toxic ash down stream (though we are perhaps slightly naive for thinking the incompetents at TVA really give a shit.) If they did decide to take the "low" road, I think they’d have to shut off the big generators down at the dam, and maybe curtail the big HEAT at the nuke there, too, so I’m on the side of keeping the lake HIGH all winter. Maybe we could get the sailboat out of storage, ya know?
Despite the calamity, the new missus and myself ended up at The Brewery, in Kingston. It is a magnificent bar. We found the place when we laid up at the nearby Knight’s Inn on our way kayaking through Tennessee in July of ’07. We’ve been back many times. The bar itself is tiny. And there’s no indication that there is any beer brewing going on there. And they don’t have a website! But they do have the biggest fricking cheeseburger East of the Pacific Ocean, and it’s always perfectly cooked. Onion rings to die for. Ashtrays on the tables. Cheap beer. Excellent service. And a regular crowd that is very friendly and not devoid of entertainment value. It was Merry Christmas to everybody, all around.
Yes.
For once we’re almost with Greenpeace. They’re calling for a criminal investigation of the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) for their negligence in maintaining the earthen barrier that collapsed two nights ago, sending nearly two million cubic yards of coal ash downhill into the Emory River. An inspection but two months ago showed no major problems with the system, and the TVA is now blaming "the weather". Apparently, the TVA isn’t competent to account for a couple extra inches of rain in a month.
The Knoxville News has multiple stories on the unfolding disaster, and the nascent cleanup. The best pictures, so far, are in this (apparently TVA-provided) PDF.
It is quite a large, local disaster. While no one was injured, a dozen homes were flooded or swept away, and countless other properties were affected. The Emory River has been rendered "impassable", and tons of ash and mud are now flowing into the Clinch River, and then, four and a half miles later, into the Tennessee River and Watts Bar Lake. From our vantage point (we can’t see nuthin’) twenty seven miles below the scene, it looks like the TVA has put the plug in the Watts Bar Dam in order to slow the flow of the ash and other muck into and through the system. The lake here is coming up to just under summer pool.
Along with the foulness dumped in the Emory and Clinch, blooms of raving idiots are dumping themselves into the media river. For instance (first link above), there’s…
"This holiday disaster shows that there really isn’t such a thing as a clean coal plant," said Chandra Taylor, a staff attorney for the [Southern Environmental Law Center].
… as though the failure of dikes is the natural consequence of certain politically incorrect energy production methods.
But the bigger problem is this: Aside from the damage done to property and environment, guess who is essentially on the hook for the cost of it? That’s right, the wholly owned subsidiary of the Tennessee Valley Authority: We the people. Once more, incompetence blossoms unbidden, and the costs are charged to those whose rights were suspended in order to facilitate said incompetence. The fine for cutting a tree in one’s back yard (all land around Watts Bar Lake, for instance, up to the 745 ft. level — which equals the top of the dam — is owned by the TVA) is about $10,000. But, of course, the TVA isn’t about to charge itself for all the trees it just destroyed. And no one at the TVA is going to be liable for any of the costs of the cleanup or repairs, despite blatherings from groups like Greenpeace. No, if someone were to cast some semblance of justice onto this mess, it would be toward attempting to dissolve the bloated, incompetent TVA, and return its ill-gotten assets to the private sector, where people could be held accountable for their part in like disasters. Instead, the people are forced to pay for the stupidity and negligence that paved the way for the disaster, and then they’re forced to pay for new stupidities, negligences, and ongoing incompetences in the mash of rectifying it all.
It’s time to dissolve the abomination that is the TVA.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||