A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.
With DeathCare becoming the law of the land, and with that first leg of the new fascist/socialist stool firmly up his ass, Ezra Klein has turned his watery gaze toward that next great fascist/socialist challenge: The obesity epidemic. And if you think being forced to buy health insurance at ever rising prices while watching quality health care riding off over an ever receding horizon is painful, just wait until Klein's fat policy police come knocking.
Here's the girl himself visualizing it:
I think it's quite possible that a mix of surgeries and pharmaceuticals eventually becomes our society's answer to obesity.
What?
I commented under that post that I thought it likely the stupidest thing Klein has ever written, but really, stupid doesn't begin to cover it. It's depraved. The whole thing is depraved. It's ignorance unparalleled in the history of human kind, and that's saying a lot. Klein is talking about the mandated control of people's very physiques. It's insane.
Klein goes on:
The risk of these treatments will go down, their efficacy will go up and their cost will settle into a more affordable range — particularly compared with the cost of treating the complications of obesity.
I'm naming that the Josef Mengele Doctrine. But if we fuss too much at that, Klein has other options for us:
If we want to go at this without scalpels and pills, the changes will have to be dramatic: No more vending machines in schools and workplaces. No more food advertisements aimed at children. Serious investments in walkable communities. Significant taxes on junk food and sodas and even mega-portion meals at chain restaurants. Significant subsidies for healthier foods.
It's government control of the food supply, not with an eye toward increased or more efficient production, but with the intent of minding what the citizenry puts in its mouth.
Klein is fucking insane. And the scary thing: There are whole squads just like him.
Someone under another of Ezra Klein's disgraceful entries into the record just had to chortle:
msoja, so how does it feel to have exactly ZERO representation in congress?
That's the same thing it was about lo those many years ago, wasn't it? I only had a short answer:
I suppose it feels like it felt to Paine, Jefferson, Revere, Henry, etc.
The government they sought to institute was meant to protect the rights of everyone, not just those who could muster a political majority. We are now back to square one, as far as I'm concerned. Anything is now possible, and the road runs straight down hill.
That person is now "very entertain[ed]" at my disillusionment. Unbelievable.
A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.
In a fit of pique, midday, Ezra Klein lashed out at "the right" in general, and Mark Steyn at National Review (Steyn is always a worthwhile read) in particular, betraying Klein's own multicultural principles of inclusion and/or respect for diversity by calling those with whom he disagrees "toxic", "nuts", and "insane".
Klein's thrust was that authors like Steyn are fomenting discord over health care "reform" by telling lies about the true nature of the legislation. Klein averred that the proposed edict "maintains private insurers, private doctors, private hospitals, private medical device companies, private pharmaceutical manufacturers, private nurses, and doesn't even have anything to say about the insurance that medium and large employers provide", etc., despite the fact that the proposed legislation would add greatly to the already large governmentally gargantuan burden on private insurers, doctors, hospitals, medical device companies, and everyone else with any connection to health care, including patients and the citizenry at large.
But the truly stupid thing about Klein's post was the post he'd made an hour before, extolling the "huge progressive victory" (emphasis Klein's) should health care reform pass. He finishes that post with:
[T]he fact of it is that this bill represents an enormous leftward shift for American social policy. It is not, in my view, a sufficient leftward shift, but it is unmatched by anything that has passed into law in recent decades. Progressives have lost some very hard battles but are on the cusp of winning an incredibly important war. For all its imperfections, health-care reform itself is deeply, deeply progressive. And if you don't believe me, just ask the conservatives who have made opposing it their top priority.
Others jumped adroitly on Klein's two faced screeds, so I leave you to them. Protein Wisdom. National Review.
A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.
Amidst a sea of swill and billowing blather, Ezra Klein exudes the non sequitur:
I think I've built some credibility around my willingness to make pragmatic compromises and accept painful concessions when necessary.
Does the boy think he held his seat in the district against the marauding corporate infidels? Or what?
Or is he talking about the pain he feels after dropping trou for another of his demanding editors?
Who knows?
He certainly can't be talking about making "compromises" with the government. Klein does what the government tells him just like the majority of the hard working citizenry. If anything, Klein flops over on his back for those "painful concessions" with an alacrity that belies the stupidity of his statement.
Whatever, you know, but how stupid and disconnected from reality is he?
Elsewise, it's just the second funniest thing I read today, and thought I ought to share.
A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.
My newshounding has been lackadaisical of late, but I did manage to stop by the Post's Ezra Klein corner today, to find the dear girl still practicing the art of the big lie, to the usual acclaim of his dutifully credulous readers. Here 'tis (with Klein's link to the PDF study):
I get the sense that some Democrats in Congress could use a refresher on the stakes in health-care reform. According to a study conducted by researchers at Harvard Medical School, 45,000 people die a year because they lack health insurance.
He's told the "45,000 people die" lie several times. He's been repeatedly told that it is a lie, and he continues to tell it, anyway. I'm not aware that Klein even grants any sort of controversy with respect to the matter, which, one would think, an avowed health care policy expert ought to be able to take in stride, especially if he truly thinks he's on the right side of it.
But, of course, Klein is not on the right side of the erstwhile health care debate. As many have pointed out, the study that grants Klein and others their plausible denialability was baldly flawed in its methodologies.
Here are some of the critiques of the study, in no particular order…
David Dranove, a pro-reform academic type:
[T]he Harvard study uses a methodology that is inherently biased. (Note to the authors of the study: I did not say that you were inherently biased. I said that your methodology is biased. On the off chance that you see this blog and care to respond, let’s keep the discussion centered on methodology. I have had enough of your personal attacks.)
Now I have to get a bit technical. In regression and related analyses, a critical assumption is that the unobservable characteristics of the “control” and “experimental” groups are uncorrelated with the observables. Translation in this case – if the regression model does not include all possible factors that might predict mortality, and just one of these omitted factors is correlated with insurance status, then the reported coefficient on insurance status is biased. This is an onerous requirement for sure, but it must be met if bias is to be avoided. Without this full set of variables, and in the absence of a randomized experimental design, it is still possible to avoid bias by using advanced statistical techniques such as “instrumental variables” regression. But the Harvard study does not use this technique.
The implication is that their results are biased. We can even guess at the direction of the bias. They started with a few control variables and the estimated impact of being uninsured was much bigger than 44,000 lives lost. When they added additional control variables, the estimated impact fell. It is plausible to suppose that with additional controls, the estimated impact would shrink further, perhaps to the point of statistical insignificance. I don’t know that for sure. No one does.
David Hogberg at Investor's Business Daily:
Two of the authors, the husband and wife team of David Himmelstein and Steffie Woolhandler, are co-founders of the single-payer advocacy group Physicians for a National Health Plan. But even if they were completely disinterested researchers, the article cannot reliably link insurance status to mortality. The article itself says so:
Our study has several limitations. NHANES III assessed health insurance at a single point in time and did not validate self-reported insurance status. We were unable to measure the effect of gaining or losing coverage after the interview.
In other words, the researchers had no idea if respondents who were uninsured in 1993-1994 remained uninsured through the time that they died, or if they obtained insurance coverage during that time. (They also don’t know if respondents insured in 1993-1994 later lost insurance.)
Thus, it’s quite possible that the people who were uninsured in 1993-1994 and had died by 2000 may have had insurance and, presumably, greater access to health care sometime between 1993-1994 and their time of death. To put it gently, that’s a pretty serious flaw.
The authors follow that passage with this lame defense: “Point-in-time uninsurance is associated with subsequent uninsurance.” In other words, if you are uninsured at one point in time there is a reasonable likelihood that you will be insured later on.
To support that sentence, the authors cite a study in the journal Health Affairs titled “Health Insurance Coverage And Mortality Among The Near-Elderly.” This study examined insurance status of people aged 55-64 in 1992 and its effect on mortality through 2000. And this study did examine the insurance status of those uninsured in 1992 through subsequent surveys. But this is what the study found:
Among adults who were uninsured in 1992, the proportion of respondents who reported being publicly or privately insured rose progressively in the ensuing four surveys (46.6 percent, 58.4 percent, 66.1 percent, and 74.5 percent), as nearly half reached age sixty-five and became eligible for Medicare by 2000.
Thus, people who are uninsured at one point in time are more likely to be insured in subsequent years. It would be more accurate to say: “Point-in-time uninsurance is associated with a subsequent increase in insurance coverage.” Doing that, however, would have only widened the gaping hole in the research behind the “45,000” statistic.
Randall Hoven at American Thinker, in parallel with the folks at Harvard, concludes that voting Democrat causes cancer:
By applying the same logic in interpreting both studies, three times as many lives could be saved by no one voting Democrat as by providing universal health insurance.
Michelle Malkin caught the fever:
How did these political doctors come up with the 44,000 figure? They used data from a health survey conducted between 1988 and 1994. The questionnaires asked a sample of 9,000 participants whether they were insured and how they rated their own health. The federal Centers for Disease Control tracked the deaths of people in the sample group through the year 2000. Himmelstein, Woolhandler and company then crunched the numbers and attributed deaths to lack of health insurance for all the participants who initially self-reported that they had no insurance and then died for any reason over the 12-year tracking period.
At no time did the original researchers or the single-payer activists who piggy-backed off their data ever verify whether the supposed casualties of America's callous health care system had insurance or not. In fact, here is what the report actually says:
"Our study has several limitations," the authors concede. The survey data they used "assessed health insurance at a single point in time and did not validate self-reported insurance status. We were unable to measure the effect of gaining or losing coverage after the interview." Himmelstein et al. simply assumed that point-in-time uninsurance translates into perpetual uninsurance—and that any health calamities that result can and must be blamed on being uninsured.
Another caveat you won't see on Grayson's memorial to the dubious dead: The single-payer advocate-authors also conceded in their study limitations section that "earlier population-based surveys that did validate insurance status found that between 7 percent and 11 percent of those initially recorded as being uninsured were misclassified. If present, such misclassification might dilute the true effect of uninsurance in our sample."
Media Matters pretends to rebut Malkin, but completely ignore the study author's own admission of the study's "several limitations".
Someone at FactCheck.org was warily honest:
Now, on to the tough question: Is the 45,000 figure accurate? We can’t say for sure, but […]
… and…
There has been some criticism of this type of research and its ability to find a direct causal link. A 2003 commentary by Richard Kronick in Medical Care Research and Review questioned whether other factors beyond uninsurance would reduce the greater mortality for the uninsured. Kronick recreated the Franks study using more recent data and, after adjusting for various factors, also found a 25 percent greater risk of death for the uninsured. But he said: "It seems likely that if we were able to control for additional factors, such as health-related behaviors (smoking, alcohol consumption, obesity, and risk-taking behaviors more generally), wealth, or value placed on health or health care, the estimated effect of being uninsured would be reduced further. What is uncertain is whether the reduction would bring the estimated hazard ratio all the way down to 1.0 or whether an independent effect of being uninsured would remain." (Other studies, including the Franks study, did adjust for smoking, alcohol consumption, obesity and income.)
Another recent report, written by former Congressional Budget Office Director June O’Neill and her husband, economist Dave O’Neill, said "that lack of health insurance is not likely to be the major factor causing higher mortality rates among the uninsured. The uninsured — particularly the involuntarily uninsured — have multiple disadvantages that in themselves are associated with poor health." Those disadvantages include education level and income. The O’Neills’ study, published by the conservative Employment Policies Institute, separated those it deemed "voluntarily uninsured" (anyone earning 2.5 times the poverty level) from those considered to be "involuntarily uninsured." The study looked at data on persons aged 51 to 61 from the Health and Retirement Survey and determined the "involuntarily uninsured" had an 11 percent higher probability of dying; the number dropped to 3 percent when controlling for smoking as well as education and income. The “voluntarily uninsured” had a 2 percent to 3 percent greater probability of dying. EPI, the publisher of the study, supports business interests and has said that the “living wage campaign” is “an organized effort to force employees to inject a welfare mentality into the workplace.”
Carl at NoOilForPacificsts is not be left out and provides a multitude of links:
[T]he study's methodology obviously is flawed. The paper uses survey data gathered between 1988 and 1994 by the National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS). About 34,000 people were interviewed about various health-related characteristics, including whether they were insured. The authors then excluded those over 64 (virtually of of whom are covered by medicare) and children under 17. They also excluded non-elderly already covered by Medicare, Medicaid or VA health insurance, because "a substantial proportion of those individuals had poor health status as a prerequisite for coverage." The researchers also culled those with missing or incomplete interview data. The resulting relevant population was 9,004 surveyed individuals, of which about 84 percent were listed as insured while the remaining 16 percent were not. In a 2000 follow-up of the 9,004 individuals, 351 (or 3.1 %) had died. Then, for the most part, they assumed that mortality among the uninsured was caused by the lack of health insurance. This is nonsense, for three reasons:
First, demographics matter:
People with insurance tend to be healthier, wealthier, wiser and more gainfully employed than people without insurance.
So you can't blame their longer lives only on their insurance.
To be sure, the study acknowledges several other factors contributing to mortality, such as "gender, age, race/ethnicity, poverty income ratio, education, unemployment, smoking, regular alcohol use, [sub-standard] self-rated health, [and sub-standard] physician-rated health." But, because they found "no significant interactions" between the lack of insurance and those other variables, the authors downplay those factors.
Second, there's scant causal connection. The lack of health insurance isn't static–over 80 percent of the uninsured regain coverage within two years. And one can't assume deaths were due to any lack of health care–after all, bad health care also can be fatal. Yet the study presumes lack of health insurance is among the causes. As John Goodman, president of the National Center for Policy Analysis notes:
The subjects were interviewed only once and the study tries to link their insurance status at that time to mortality a decade later. Yet over the period, the authors have no idea whether subjects were insured or uninsured, what kind of medical care they received, or even cause of death.
And the study itself concedes that "between 7% and 11% of those initially recorded as being uninsured were misclassified," raising questions about the sample's accuracy.
Third, other research is to the contrary. For example, a study by UCSD prof Richard Kronick, Ph.D., found:
Adjusted for demographic, health status, and health behavior characteristics, the risk of subsequent mortality is no different for uninsured respondents than for those covered by employer-sponsored group insurance at baseline.
Further, a June 2009 report by Drs. June and David O’Neill of Baruch College found the differential mortality between insured and uninsured to be of questionable statistical significance, and in any event only about 3 percent when comparing the insured with the voluntarily uninsured. Overall, they conclude:
a lack of health insurance is not likely to be the major factor causing higher mortality rates among the uninsured. The uninsured–particularly the involuntarily uninsured–have multiple disadvantages that are associated with poor health.
Conclusion: I've always supported a tax-funded safety net for the poor, including for those who can't afford health insurance. But rejecting phony scare stories is crucial for assessing the scope of the actual problem and crafting the appropriate policy remedy.
And there you have it. It took me about five times longer to copy and paste it all than it took to Clusty it all up, so how come a guy whose business it is to know this stuff pretends it all doesn't exist?
The more I read Klein and get to know how he responds to the challenges put to him, the more I have to conclude that Ezra Klein is a Quisling and a liar. Look at his reaction to Grubergate (I only had time for a short comment there, but others made points, fazing Klein not a whit.)
How some people can live with themselves, I don't know.
A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.
I think Ezra Klein is cracking up. For example, yesterday:
[T]he Tea Parties have been, in large part, about how much everybody hates the banks.
Does anyone know what the hell he’s talking about?
Tea party protests are about banks????
I’m boggled.
A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.
Ezra Klein tries to split the political difference between force and force.
Klein:
[I]f you eventually developed a preexisting condition — asthma, say — would you rather a world in which insurers couldn’t discriminate against you or a world in which you could send in a form to the state of Missouri and ask if they had any room in their Big Pool o’ Sick people?
Me:
Imagining "worlds" is something children do. This world is what it is, and there won’t be any changing it. If Klein means "system" or "set of rules" or "laws", he should say so, but then, of course, his propaganda, buttressed as it is with various euphemisms and vagaries, would be all the more obvious and therefore less effectual.
I’m tempted, though, to fantasize a world where people who ask stupid questions are laughed into shame, instead of having their premises accepted as worthy of discussion (and then having them nattered over as though serious.) For instance, how does one go about "develop[ing] a preexisting condition"? One begins to suspect that Klein’s thinking is as sloppy as his writing.
Further, both of Klein’s "worlds" are based on government coercion, and therefore, the only answer a freedom-loving person can give is, "Neither". End of discussion.
As a wee lad I got into trouble because I couldn’t stay away from the big muddy hole at the end of the street where someone had dug the basement for a house. I do still distinctly remember that I took the liberty of stuffing my muddy snowsuit directly into the basement dryer in an attempt to circumvent the normal inspection process which would have quickly revealed my transgression. I didn’t get away with it. I wasn’t very old.
I’m still playing in the mud. At Ezra Klein’s:
–"rule of law"–
A friend recently pointed out that that phrase is essentially meaningless. Try to define it. Ask a lawyer, if you need to.
No, what has befallen this country is not a failure to adhere to some nebulous rule of law, but a failure of personal integrity. Politicians are always at the lick-spittle end of the cess pool, but they do unfortunately reflect to some degree the underlying electorate. Bad government comes from bad people voting factionally. That’s the fact of America, now.
Freedom, which I fear has slipped irretrievably away in the country that once exalted the concept, depends on intelligence and integrity and respect for the other fellow’s rights. There are now such significant numbers of people who haven’t a clue about those things that no amount of action in the political sphere can counter them.
You speak of good government, or making government work better, but government isn’t what makes a country. People are what make a country. And freedom is about self-government. We don’t have a failure of political government in the country, we have a failure of self-government. All the appeals to politicians, and all the politicians’ weaknesses in considering those appeals, are weaknesses of the individual, little personal acts of corruption, dishonesty, and failure. The only way to make a free and prosperous country is to live free oneself, and prosper oneself, as best as one can, and hold up one’s head knowing that one has made one’s best effort, and to encourage others to do likewise. All this other poaching of "rights" and stealing what others have produced is nothing but an utter disgrace in the light of what this country set out to be.
As to Klein, he’s as vapid and mindless as I’ve ever seen. I’m sure he believes his own nonsense, and the unerringness of his earnestness, and he would be funny, if he didn’t so abjectly reflect the nearly dominant state of political force in the country, because he’s really just collectivism’s little Valley Girl.
Billy Beck links to Vandam, and both link to Richard Epstein’s excellent video ripping what the government is trying to do with health care.
I have to be honest, I can’t normally suffer to sit and watch video essays. The pajamas tv efforts are almost completely wasted on me (can someone hit the tip jar over there so Glenn Reynolds can buy a new facial expression, please?) But Epstein is like a machine gun, hitting targets at a rapid clip. After thirty minutes, I was wanting him to go on, and on.
And the phrase he tossed, in the title above, is beautiful. It reminds me of that old favorite of mine, the Dunning-Kruger effect, or, to paraphrase Wikipedia, "the lack of metacognitive ability to recognise one’s own incompetence." I’ve already dropped it at Klein’s three ring circus of idiocy.
Listen to Epstein. He knows his stuff. Read Beck and Vandam, ditto.
What a couple o’ days stretching back a week or more. Log splitter work, today (Sweet Cheeks’s muscles have muscles), and trying to make the wood stove go, particulates a-swirl in the fall air. Expanded expanses.
And the internet comes in late, with me having to wade through Klein’s protracted delirium to find high ground from which to pontificate:
How many billion have been thrown at stupid LBJ’s ‘Great Society’, and what is there to show for it? Greater dependency upon The State and a greater demand for "sacrifice" from those who would be better off without any part of it. And Klein running around like an old housewife peering into everyone else’s laundry wondering how to write the perfect laundry policy to shove down everyone’s throat.
Washerwomen. Klein. Obama. Yeah. Thursday: Collectivist laundry day at the river. Bring your best endarkenment suit and we’ll pound it back to the iron age.
Ezra Klein is perverse in so many ways, but he sinks to new lows, today.
On the heels of Treasury Secretary Geithner’s decision to drop plans to force "banks and other financial services companies to offer ‘plain vanilla’ products, like 30-year fixed mortgages and low-interest, low-fee credit cards," Klein mutters around a bit (says it’s the "most depressing" thing he read all day), decrying the "tremendous power" of the banks in writing legislation, etc.
First they came for the "plain vanilla" products…
That’s a play on Martin Niemöller’s famous poem/quotation, of which there are many, but Klein has turned it completely upside down and backwards, trivializing and cheapening the poignant lesson drawn from one of humanity’s darkest periods. It is despicable beyond words.
It is the government that is coming for the banks, and Ezra Klein is there at the tracks, helping to herd the objects of his picayune ignorance and hatred into the cattle cars.
…
If that weren’t enough, now we turn to our old… nitwit, Dale Franks, at QandO.
My feed there had been misaligned for some time, but I got around to readjusting it the other day, and let the data stream.
You remember Steven Rhett? The issue was principles. Franks cited his alleged principles in a post I saw early this morning. It’s slowly ongoing.
Spitting at the butt ends of its ways:
That’s government for you. Eternally attempting to understand how one tells when something has worked, and never realizing that only *individuals*, freely making choices with their own assets, mark endeavors as successes or failures.
The government is like an investor throwing darts at a stock exchange list, and then trying to anticipate success by consulting an astrologer.
Me, in more comments at Ezra Klein’s.
Does Ezra Klein know about this?
“I have labeled my educational approach ‘HealthRock®,’” Dr. Seibel states. “It uses contemporary songs that I have written to convey lessons on how people can live healthier lives by making common sense lifestyle changes. In order to reach the widest possible range of demographic groups, the songs use a variety of musical genres, from gospel to pop.” This musical technique for health education, available in recordings and live performances at venues as varied as the Centers for Disease Control and elementary schools, has won wide recognition for its effectiveness, earning for Dr. Seibel the iParenting Media Award, the eHealthcare Leadership Award, and the Creative Child Magazine 2009 CD of the Year Award.
I’d say a billion or so would be optimal for this kind of clear innovation and example of selfless devotion to the values the country holds most dear.
Ezra Klein is playing house, today, serving tea to his coterie of expert dolls all dressed up and sitting around the cute little health care table. Klein plays gracious host and in his best play voice tells us that one doll’s credentials are "pretty impressive". I call the guy, "dishonest", in the comments.
In another post from Klein’s tea table, exgovgirl (in the comments) says that health care is not a market because she broke her arms twice and couldn’t afford the $75,000 to fix ’em. I retorted, in part (and rather ungrammatically, I daresay, in retrospect)…
You know, not too many years ago, your broken arms would have meant death to you. Now you get to threaten your neighbor’s life with impoverishment or incarceration if he refuses to take care of you. Advances in medicine!
… which apparently inflamed her passions to such an extent that she felt the need to wish me dead:
As much as it would pleasure me to see people like you rot on the side of the road if they were injured or ill, it’s way to messy to have that happen in an advanced, industrial society, so we just all need to chip in our share, and have our DEMOCRATICALLY ELECTED GOVERNMENT take on the responsibility of seeing that we don’t get screwed. Unless and until that happens, however, I certainly hope that you are one of the tens of thousands of people who die each year from lack of access to health care.
Oy. The thing is, I swear, I’d be of much better use alive in the gulag than dead. So, I’m optimistic.
Ooo, gotta go. Klein’s gonna make a cheeseburger out of Play-Doh, just like the government is gonna make a health care system from the policy papers of Harvard sucking chuckleheads.
I must admit, at first glance, I thought I saw potential. Ezra Klein linked Jonathan Chait who had just pooped out a critique of Ayn Rand and Objectivism, and it wasn’t promisin’ to be purty. I got all excited. I skimmed the first two pages of it and was wondering when I was going to get to the meat of it, when the phone rang with a neighbor on the other end wondering if I was up for a little chainsaw work. I was. We worked for over two hours in the dripping heat of the evening, carving up two large white oaks, loading them into a big dump truck, and bringin’ it all back to the hood.
After a shower, and back at the desk, I started up with Chait again where I’d left off, quickly wondering if the phrase of the day was going to be "straw man".
But that was just my first run through.
I started back at the beginning with a more careful eye and immediately ran into problems. The stupidest kind of problems.
First sentence: Chait doesn’t know what "florid" means. A fear of socialism is an "overheated" fear. And the current de rigueur nose-to-the-ceiling snide slide on death panels.
The second sentence gets downright swampy:
Amid this cacophony of rage and dread, there has emerged one anxiety that is an actual idea, and not a mere slogan or factual misapprehension.
Ignore the weak sop of the introductory phrase, and contemplate the notion of "an actual idea". Feel free to try "factual misapprehension".
Does Chait mean "thought" instead of "idea"? What differentiates an ordinary idea or thought from an actual one? Or does he mean "an idea of ostensible or possible merit"? Why doesn’t he say that, then?
I’ll be brief: A person trading in the sorts of locutions that Chait does shouldn’t try dissecting the philosophy of so much as Captain Kangaroo, never mind Ayn Rand. Chait is extolling farce from his first words. His is nonsense. All of it. From the emptiness of his suite of words, through the long draught of various salaciousnesses, into the straw men, false equivalences, and subtle and not-so-subtle dishonesties, the whole endeavor is a joke.
After Chait’s first two sentences one knows that one will have the spend the rest of one’s time with his piece attempting to unearth the most mundane stupidities, dishonesties, errors, and fallacies. It’s really not worth it.
ps. Brian Doherty at Reason takes the trouble.
Later: Will Wilkinson notes the same thing others have, that Chait’s critique of Rand has little to do with anything Rand herself said and a lot to do with Chait’s own ignorant biases, and then cites a few things that Rand did stand for.
My last comment at Ezra Klein’s blog got squashed into a moderation queue, and I don’t have much hope for it, so I’ll paste it here. I quote howard16, who is claiming that the freedom to vote whatever he wants is built into the Constitution and therefore legitimate, or, as he puts it, is part of his core values.
–"your first comment is remarkable: having conceded that the constitution allows all manner of things that you find reprehensible, now you simply want me to decide i no longer believe in my (and america’s) core values."–
The flip side of Freedom has always been responsibility, and that’s what you (and Ezra and most of the people in government) don’t have. You are free to punch your neighbor in the nose, but you really shouldn’t, all other things being normal. You are free to vote slavery back into the Constitution, but if you’re a responsible, ethical, moral person you won’t do that. But you’re free to vote for slavery, or free to vote your health care out of your neighbor’s pocket, but if that’s part of the "core values" of which you speak, then I think you’re a couple sandwiches and some potato salad shy of the proverbial picnic lunch. The core value of freedom is the responsibility and moral knowledge that just because one can doesn’t mean that one ought, and in cases where your alleged freedom meets the other fellow’s nose, that’s where true core values (and they’re not just American; they belong to every sentient individual) take over and respect for the other guy’s freedom and rights kicks in.
So, all I get out of your petulance about having the freedom to vote whatever the hell you want is the temper tantrum of an immoral child. You want some sort of socialist or fascist or communist or, at the very least, collectivist health care, and because you’ve got x amount of votes in the proper political bodies, that’s good enough for you. You can do it. You can tax rich people to pay for it. You can send the police to their house when they balk and confiscate their stuff to make them pay. It’s all legal. But it does NOT have anything to do with core American values. It’s thug values. And it’s cowardly thug values, to boot, because you don’t have the personal courage to go to your rich neighbor’s house and demand that he buy you a car or contribute to your pension or to pay for your mental health care.
Communists, socialists, fascists, nazis, they’re all just names. At heart they were and are all thugs, and their political systems were thugocracies.
America is swiftly becoming a thugocracy, and you’re cheering it on.
Why is health care not suited to the free market? I have no evidence that it isn’t. Your whining about shopping around is unimpressive. If you don’t like the bill they send you after the nearest doctor fixes your heart attack you can refuse to pay it. I say that if the government gets out of the health care business that the health business will boom. The "high barriers to entry" you mention are all government mandated. Part of the high costs of health care are the high costs of attaining medical educations and medical licenses, both things driven high by meddling government, followed by endless additional government meddling once one is in business. And it wasn’t always thus, but the… collectivists got their hooks in and it’s all just an unfolding disaster now.
And that was about the sum of your objections, that I see. Like I said, if you can’t hack exercising your own individual right to control your own health care situation, then join a co-op, but what’s with the insistence that the whole country has to adopt your health care vision?
Well, actually, I know the answer to that, too. Medicare is going broke. Medicaid is probably on the ropes, too. Politician’s careers are at stake. The only way to fix it, with today’s crew, is to rope more people into the system. More paying bodies. Until the next crisis, when the rest of everybody will be forced in. And then it’ll be the long slow wait for death by governmental asphyxiation. Anyone remember Mary Jo Kopechne?
So, like, how about you ALLOW me to exercise my inalienable rights to my freedom? I won’t ask you to pay for my liver when the boozing gets to me, and you can go join some commie co-op that won’t work out the way you figured it. Deal?
(And double whoops. This one never made it out of the hopper yesterday.)
Ezra Klein lets one slip in his latest weekly chat session:
Question:
How will the health care system handle the sudden and large influx of 35 to 40 million new regular customers (not just ER patients). Will we have enough physicians, enough hospitals to meet the demand?
Klein:
A few things. First, the new folks don’t come in all at once. They come in over 10 years. Second, most of these people are getting care right now, although somewhat less than they will be.
"[M]ost of these people are getting care right now."
How can that be?
I’ve been knocking around Ezra Klein’s place (well, his corner of his employer’s place) this eve, trying to break up the monotony of the comments, here and here. I keep thinking I could do better.
And all that reminds me to remind you that the hard working John J. Ray (M.A.; Ph.D.) at the nifty SOCIALIZED MEDICINE blog is still cranking ’em out, story after story, day after day, documenting the failings and disasters that are the socialist health care systems around the world. The U.K.’s NHS has featured prominently of late, and no wonder.
I know that it’s easy to catch one or two of the horror stories as they come out of these endarkened systems, and to somehow chalk them up to some sort of intermittent fluke, or one off anecdote, but there’s years and years of negligence, incompetence, and malfeasance documented at Ray’s place.
Read it. You’ll be appalled.
First up: On what planet does Ezra Klein think he lives? Amongst the clouds of wonk adolescence we find him wishing politicians the insight-generating wisdom of the latest in government supplied cost/benefit analysis:
If we change the process by which we pass laws, for instance, we might eventually arrive in a world in which we can actually pass good laws, rather than compromising them down to the point of maximum incoherence.
(Ignore the fact, for the moment, as Klein would have you do, that politicians are politicians, and unlikely to be otherwise even if Klein should summon the perfect chart for them to peruse.)
Republicans and Democrats, you see, only need better information to resolve the differences between them, which (in our enlightened times) have nothing to do with pitting individuals against collectivists (backed by the eager might of the government), but revolve instead around the best way for government to swing its fist.
In other words, Klein would like to find an easier way, a way that doesn’t involve having to pit freedom against incompetent intrusions of the state, a way that scientifically determines the best price to pay for the fucking prostitution of his ignorance up and down the exceedingly seedy boulevards of American society. Cost/benefit is nothing more than dickering about price for the service performed. Freedom be damned. You’re a number in a cost/benefit analysis, now, and it’s a government model being run on government computers, interpreted by agents of the state, and not only should no one question the algorithms, no one should ever have the chance to wonder whether people shouldn’t be running their own fucking lives without the Ezra Klein’s of the world playing ugly toothy grandma in their face.
And that’s Ezra Klein in his nutshell.
Next up, via a link from Klein’s little patch of incoherence over to that fetid farm of similar stuff at the Huffington Post, and then roundabout, we meet Sameer Dossani, who is exceedingly intent on telling the world that A is not A, because he wishes that A were not A, and therefore A is not A.
First, Dossani sets his premise with appeals to authority:
This country’s founders believed that every human being was endowed with certain inalienable rights — the rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. In the last century, the global community, led by the efforts of the United States and individuals like Eleanor Roosevelt, spelled those rights out. Article 25 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights states that "everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including… medical care…."
Health care is a human right. Like freedom from torture and ill treatment, equality before the law, and education, health care is something that all of us are entitled to by virtue of being human.
Note that somewhere between the founding and Article 25, the intangible was turned into the tangible. Now, not only do you have a right to your own life, you have a right to your life augmented with certain juicy perks courtesy of some unnamed schmoe. Somehow missed in the nobility of the declaration is the fact that the schmoe has seemingly lost the right to his own life, his own liberty, and the pursuit of his own happiness. Said schmoe is now on the hook providing "standard[s] of living", "well-being", education, and… "medical care" to those whose squeals can summon the Article 25 grease. What if the schmoe decides he doesn’t want to provide someone else’s education or medical care? Is he sent off for rehabilitation? Or just nickeled and dimed to death under threats of rather more complete impoverishment or incarceration? Kleins and Dossanis don’t care.
The moron Dossani goes on:
Health care is a public good, not a commodity and a healthy society benefits all of us.
I think Dossani is an idiot who thinks he’s a clever propagandist (though Lord Knows he didn’t get to be "Director of Amnesty International’s Demand Dignity Campaign" without having a few weak-minded people admire the living shit out of his earnest vapidity.) What he writes is almost like A = B, and B = C, therefore A = C, except that it’s closer to A = B, B != C, therefore A = C ain’t he a clever fellow. He wishes, therefore he invokes. It’s not a commodity! Heck no, it’s something else! It’s a public good. See? It’s important. Therefore it’s not a thing. It’s a right. You have a right to health care. Why, you can march down to your local General Practitioner’s and exercise that right, today, now, forever. It’s your right. You can steal from people when we all benefit. People who don’t want you to be healthy are mean and ignorant, and selfish, and you can take their money as recompense for their failings. You can force people to pay for your education, too, because their freedom to dispose of their assets as they see fit are trumped by your rights. Article 25 says so. And never mind the contradictions.
That’s how Sameer Dossani gets to pretend he’s important. Ginning rubes with castor oil made of gasoline.
And last, but only least, via Billy Beck, comes Glenn Reynolds of Instapundit, who, one would think, ought to know better, but he swings the same way time after time. I’ve said it before, he’s no better than Ezra Klein, and, as stupid as Sameer Dossani is, Reynolds is no better than that, either, for my money.
To hell in a hand basket.
A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.
Ezra Klein wonders, wonders, why another heavily subsidized (by whom? Can you guess?) industry consistently shows ever rising costs that outpace the Consumer Price Index:
Niraj Choksi runs the numbers and finds something interesting: Education costs have been rising even faster than medical costs:
[important looking chart goes here]
Per capita spending on health care is more than $7,000. It’s nowhere near as high in education, and so this is less of a problem. But it’s still interesting. More broadly, I’d like to know what experts think is driving the numbers. Is this hiding a relatively benign story, in which a lot more people are going to college, or graduate school, or even just choosing a private school? Is it just the cost of human labor rising quickly? Or is it more problematic? Or both?
Hey, Klein, you moron: It’s the subsidies. It’s the government SUBSIDIES. It’s the taking of hundreds of millions of dollars from productive and successful people and scattering them higgledy-piggledy across the educational land. It’s basic economics. Health care, education, housing, it makes no difference. You subsidize something, the price of that thing will tend to rise. You could look it up, even. Yes, I know, it’s hard for a tin-plated policy wonk (who never actually gets to watch the police go out and enforce his policy) to wrap his head around, but it is true nonetheless.
And it’s really sad.
Only a couple of Klein’s commenters even come close to answering the point in his call for "experts", demonstrating another side effect of two generations of massive subsidies for education: A completely watered down product; people with "educations" who are stone stupid.
Relatedly, in nosing around for the heck of it, I found the following argument against the subsidization of education, on a navy.mil page, interesting (though I don’t agree with every point made):
There are numerous reasons why governments may decide to sue [sic] subsidies as a policy tool. Somewhat cynically Houthakker (1972) has argued that a main reason has to do with political vote buying. From an economic perspective, the main purpose of subsidies is to reallocate resources, that is, to alter economic activity and behavior to achieve an outcome that is more desirable from what would occur otherwise. Hence arguments for subsidies are often based on some concept of efficiency or economic justice. But even when subsidies generate a more desirable outcome, it does not mean that the entire value of the subsidy is corrective in nature, or that the particular type of subsidy used for a given purpose is best among the available policy alternatives.
Economic arguments for using government subsidies generally fall into three broad categories:
1. Offsetting various market imperfections;
2. Exploiting economies of scale in production;
3. Meeting social policy objectives, including, for example protecting the poor,
4. Changing the distribution of income, and increasing or retaining employment.Oftentimes, however, those sectors receiving the largest subsidies do not clearly meet these criteria. Education subsidies in the United States are a prime example. In the early 1990s the government was spending nearly $300 billion on education or around 15% of all government spending, making it the third largest single type of government expenditure behind only national defense and social security. Meanwhile, government revenue collected from education was only around $30 billion. This $270 billion subsidy was roughly 5.5% of net national product. Clearly, the choice to subsidize education is an important one, and this choice seems to be widely accepted as a good decision. But the reasons why subsidizing education is a good choice are not so obvious.
Unlike a public good like national defense, markets can and do provide education. It is not clear why the government should subsidize this good rather than let markets work unimpeded. Several normative justifications for subsidizing education have been put forth. There are four main types: equity, paternalistic, borrowing constraint, and externality arguments. None of these is completely compelling, however. For example, few would argue, other things equal, against economic equality, especially equality of opportunity. This value judgment justifies helping the disadvantaged gain access to education. It does not, however, justify subsidizing the educational opportunities for all income classes.
Most economists find the second type of argument even less compelling. The various paternalistic arguments are based on the presumption that people do not fully recognize the benefits associated with education, and thus do not purchase enough education on their own. Therefore, those who are fortunate enough to fully recognize the benefits of education argue that the subsidy is necessary to induce the less enlightened to make better choices. There are two major problems with this argument, however. It is difficult to objectively justify why many people do not fully appreciate the benefits of education while there are some enlightened ones who do.
There is also a similar problem in objectively distinguishing the enlightened opinions from the unenlightened. The third justification argues that many students are constrained from borrowing against their potential future income to finance their education. This capital market imperfection (largely due to government-imposed constraints) may cause many students to acquire less than efficient amounts of education. This obstacle to opportunity may be viewed as inequitable as well. But if this borrowing constraint is the problem, then government-supported loans are the obvious solution. There is no reason to lower the private cost of education and redistribute income to all publicly educated students, as subsidies do.
The fourth justification has received the most attention by economists. If acquiring education produces spillover benefits, self-interested individuals will acquire less than socially efficient amounts of education. A subsidy internalizes the externality and encourages students to acquire more efficient amounts of education. A common view, however, is that although these external benefits probably do exist, it is unlikely their magnitude is large enough to warrant a subsidy as large as the one observed, particularly at the level of higher education. It seems improbable that the marginal external benefit is as substantial as the subsidy. If the above arguments are valid, one is apparently left with the disturbing conclusion that subsidizing education, particularly higher education, is mostly a redistribution that is inequitable by commonly accepted standards of equity.
It’s also wrong to steal from some people in order to enrich others.
Maybe it’s a Journolist thing. Maybe they should just get a room.
As I’ve documented before, Paul Krugman of the New York Times is not averse to playing loose with the truth. Like you didn’t know that. A few days ago, he couldn’t help but sneak Stephen Hawking into another of his paeans to collectivism. Klein started it. I debunked it five days before Krugman thought to keep the cute little lie alive.
I wouldn’t be either of those freaks for all the money in the world.
ps. Thanks to Jim May for the link a few days ago, attached to the excellent observation that (alá Bastiat) positing the non-existence of the U.K.’s National Health Service does not mean one has to posit barbarism or nothing in its stead.
Just before shutting down last night, I noticed a new editorial put up by Investor’s Business Daily speakin’ to the Stephen Hawking tempest in a twitter bowl.
(Speakin’ of which, if straight up Democracy is The Tyranny of the Majority, then Twitter groups like welovetheNHS are The Idiocy of the Masses. Just sayin’.)
Other than not finding and reading, "Stephen Hawking: A Life in Science", with its relevant passages that I quoted two days ago, the IBD guys don’t completely botch it this time. They could have done better, but it’s still a pretty good run at blasting the relative merit of the U.K.’s socialist National Health Service to smithereens.
And Ezra Klein is still a moron.
I gotta go weed whack, and pre-load the firepit.
NO HYDROCARBONS SHALL GO UNRELEASED THIS WEEKEND!
Apparently Ezra Klein doesn’t read this blog. Who knew?
(Thanks to Malone Vandam and Billy Beck for da links. I do enjoy the avalanches. There was at least one visitor, came in through Billy’s, from fed.gov who scooped a lot of pages. Possibly others. They’re always there, these days. Santa Claus is making his lists and checking ’em twice.)
So, the progressive echo chamber was all into reverberating on the single unmodulated key that Klein played for them two days ago, a thing (the mindless echoing) that never ceases to amaze me. There’s no reasoning with it, no poking it in the eye, no tripping it up, no making a dent. It rolls on.
Me, I know I gave it a good whack, and if people stumble across it at some point, after wading through the endless seas of rote repetition, or even if they don’t, there it is. The U.K.’s National Health Service was not prepared to accomodate Stephen Hawking’s needs back in 1985.
Today, following up on the Stephen Hawking story, Klein played anecdote parade with tweets from a Twitter … person? group? calling itself welovetheNHS. Makes you wonder if so many people can really be that stupid, going on and on about how it is all "free", and not the kind of "free" with quotes around it. It never occurs to them that their lousy job market and their teensy cars (if they can afford one) and their teeny little flats with half-sized refrigerators are all partly due to the value sucked out of the performing end of their economy in service to that bloated disgrace called the NHS. Not to belittle the suckings of every other socialist and/or welfare state agency. It’s free, it’s free, it’s free is the sound of a million morons dancing under the watchful eye of the surveillance camera, not realizing at all the costs they paid.
And then, in the same entry, Klein waxed ecstatic, because Hugh Muir of the UK Guardian wrote that Stephen Hawking loves the NHS. Muir writes:
We say [Hawking’s] life is far from worthless, as they do at Addenbrooke’s hospital, Cambridge, where Professor Hawking, who has motor neurone disease, was treated for chest problems in April. As indeed does he. "I wouldn’t be here today if it were not for the NHS," he told us. "I have received a large amount of high-quality treatment without which I would not have survived."
Klein said, of Muir, "[H]e called Hawking for his reaction," but Muir doesn’t claim that he called Hawking, or even when he collected the quote. Not that it matters. Hell, if I wanted to really go out on a limb I’d say that the quote attributed to Hawking doesn’t much sound like the man. And, while his computer (a necessary ingredient in all his communications) is hooked to a phone system, I’d rather imagine that phoning him up to ask him what he thought of an Investor’s Business Daily editorial from two weeks ago isn’t easily done. And yet, even if Klein knows more than Muir publicly states, and isn’t playing fabulist to make the story sound better, and if Muir isn’t being cute, it doesn’t matter.
The NHS successfully treats millions of people a year, even, when necessary, Stephen Hawking. They are a health service, after all. But Stephen Hawking is a famous man, now, and his most recent visit to Addenbrooke’s hospital was not a particularly onerous burden for the public to bear. He had some tests done and spent a day or so "in observation". As I pointed out yesterday, twenty four years ago, before Hawking became a popular public figure, the NHS refused to provide him with the care that he and his family thought he deserved. And at least one member of his family didn’t love the NHS because of it. And, since 1985, Hawking has devoted significant effort and his own resources trying to help those, like himself, that the NHS leaves short. Now, he may be entirely appreciative of the work that the NHS has done for him, and there’s nothing wrong with that, but if Hawking hadn’t turned out to be world famous Hawking, he’d probably be dead by now.
Furthermore, the argument Klein is trying to make with Muir’s quote from Hawking is specious. It doesn’t matter how many people, including Hawking, love the NHS. A lot of people loved slavery at one time, but that didn’t make that right. And the fact that the NHS, or the Post Office, or Amtrak, do manage to stumble through most days and save someone’s life, or deliver a letter, or have a train show up on time, doesn’t mean that any of them aren’t unnecessary and immoral drains on their respective societies, and shouldn’t be abolished, with the monies extracted for their furtherances returned to its rightful owners.
A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.
Ezra Klein was in high dudgeon yesterday, but inappropriately (and ignorantly) so. Klein’s wormy ire was directed at an editorial in Investor’s Business Daily, an anti-socialist health care editorial, an editorial, according to Klein, filled with "lies and distortions" to which one "could write some long response". Klein, instead, chose to attack the following single sentence in the IBD editorial:
People such as scientist Stephen Hawking wouldn’t have a chance in the U.K., where the National Health Service would say the life of this brilliant man, because of his physical handicaps, is essentially worthless.
Klein says that the IBD "simply lied", and he can prove it, because, as everyone ought to know, Stephen Hawking is a lifelong citizen and denizen of the U.K., and is still alive.
Klein’s post was picked up by a number of others, perhaps echoed through the little tin cup of Klein’s Journolist, and Badda Boom Badda Bing, the Investor’s Business Daily page now says…
Editor’s Note: This version corrects the original editorial which implied that physicist Stephen Hawking, a professor at the University of Cambridge, did not live in the UK.
… and the offending contentious sentence has been removed (though it’s still in the mp3 audio version of the piece that IBD offers.) (And, by the way, that correction sucks in that it does not admit of the true criticism the sentence elicited, even if, as we shall shortly see, that criticism was unwarranted.)
So, Stephen Hawking lives and breathes in the U.K., and he has the National Health Service to thank for it?
Hardly.
See, Ezra Klein, moron, forgot to investigate the principle thrust of the argument and instead aimed his tiny displeasure at the secondary clause. But, the record is unequivocal: England’s National Health Service did tell Hawking that it couldn’t accomodate his needs. It was only due to the steadfast devotion and hard work of his wife, and the generosity of friends and scientific groups around the world that Hawking didn’t end up in an institution where he surely would have died.
A commenter on Klein’s blog provided the first clue (complete with link), in Hawking’s own words:
I caught pneumonia in 1985. I had to have a tracheotomy operation. After this, I had to have 24 hour nursing care. This was made possible by grants from several foundations.
Hmm. Well, no mention of the NHS.
Interestingly, Michael White and John Gribbin have written a book about Stephen Hawking, which can be read online, or downloaded, here.
On page 96 we are told of the disillusion Hawkings’ father had with the NHS:
Since his diagnosis and early deterioration, Hawking’s symptoms had remained more or less constant, but in the latter half of the 1960s another rapid decline occurred. He had to take to using crutches rather than sticks in order to get around. At this point his father became disillusioned and impatient with the advice his son was receiving from the medical profession and decided to take over Stephen’s treatment. He carried out intensive research into ALS and prescribed a course of steroids and vitamins that Stephen continued to take until his father’s death in 1986.
On page 235 comes the real story:
After the tracheostomy, Stephen would need round-the-clock nursing. The best the National Health Service could offer was seven hours’ nursing help a week in the Hawkings’ home, plus two hours’ help with bathing. They would have to pay for private nursing. The advance from the book would not last long, and there was absolutely no certainty about its eventual success. To Jane there seemed little long-term hope. How were they to survive if he could never work again? There were few possibilities. She would willingly have left her own career and devoted herself full-time to looking after her husband, but she was not a qualified nurse, and in any case, who would then provide for the family? The alternative was the dreaded thought of Stephen in a nursing home, unable to work, slipping into gradual decline and eventual death. “There were days when I felt sometimes I could not go on because I didn’t know how to cope,” Jane has said of that period.
It was obvious they would have to find financial support from somewhere. Jane wrote letter after letter to charitable organizations around the world and called upon the help of family friends in approaching institutions that might be interested in assisting them. Help arrived from an American foundation aware of Hawking’s work and international reputation, which agreed to pay £50,000 a year toward the costs of nursing. Shortly afterward several other charitable organizations on both sides of the Atlantic followed suit with smaller donations. Jane feels bitter about the whole affair. She resents the fact that, after paying a lifetime of contributions to the National Health Service, they were offered such meager help when the need arose. She is very aware that if her husband had been an unknown physics teacher he would now be living out his final days in a residential home. “Think of the waste of talent,” she has said of the situation.
Jane Hawking bitter at the NHS? Whatever for, Klein? Whatever for?
On page 310 we hear of Hawking’s efforts to raise money for others whose ailments are deemed too costly for NHS concern:
[Hawking] also firmly believes that the technology now available to him through the money he has earned as an author should be made available to other seriously disabled people via the NHS and claims that reliance upon charity (and in his case good fortune) is “simply not good enough.” To help the plight of others who have been paralyzed either through accidents or diseases such as ALS, Hawking has spearheaded several campaigns to generate funds.
That is what socialised fucking medicine is all about. When the chips are down, if you can’t fend for yourself, you’re dead. If you think the free market is the same thing, you’re wrong. You’re worse off with socialized medicine because it fails you after you’ve spent your entire healthy life "donating" to it. Socialism continuously drains the very resources individuals could use to provide for themselves. Education, health care, it’s the same. If you want to give your kids a decent education, you have to pay the fucking taxes to support the public schools, and then you still have to pay for that private education. Those well off in the U.K. have to pay the horrendous taxes for the "free" health care, and then they have to go and pay for private care, too. The poor slobs who can’t afford to pay twice wind up crushed in the maw.
And Ezra Klein is an ignorant twit and should admit that Stephen Hawking, and those like him, are routinely denied substantive care by the socialists in the UK. And then Klein should apologize to the Investor’s Business Daily and asked them to recorrect their correction.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||