First up: On what planet does Ezra Klein think he lives? Amongst the clouds of wonk adolescence we find him wishing politicians the insight-generating wisdom of the latest in government supplied cost/benefit analysis:
If we change the process by which we pass laws, for instance, we might eventually arrive in a world in which we can actually pass good laws, rather than compromising them down to the point of maximum incoherence.
(Ignore the fact, for the moment, as Klein would have you do, that politicians are politicians, and unlikely to be otherwise even if Klein should summon the perfect chart for them to peruse.)
Republicans and Democrats, you see, only need better information to resolve the differences between them, which (in our enlightened times) have nothing to do with pitting individuals against collectivists (backed by the eager might of the government), but revolve instead around the best way for government to swing its fist.
In other words, Klein would like to find an easier way, a way that doesn’t involve having to pit freedom against incompetent intrusions of the state, a way that scientifically determines the best price to pay for the fucking prostitution of his ignorance up and down the exceedingly seedy boulevards of American society. Cost/benefit is nothing more than dickering about price for the service performed. Freedom be damned. You’re a number in a cost/benefit analysis, now, and it’s a government model being run on government computers, interpreted by agents of the state, and not only should no one question the algorithms, no one should ever have the chance to wonder whether people shouldn’t be running their own fucking lives without the Ezra Klein’s of the world playing ugly toothy grandma in their face.
And that’s Ezra Klein in his nutshell.
Next up, via a link from Klein’s little patch of incoherence over to that fetid farm of similar stuff at the Huffington Post, and then roundabout, we meet Sameer Dossani, who is exceedingly intent on telling the world that A is not A, because he wishes that A were not A, and therefore A is not A.
First, Dossani sets his premise with appeals to authority:
This country’s founders believed that every human being was endowed with certain inalienable rights — the rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. In the last century, the global community, led by the efforts of the United States and individuals like Eleanor Roosevelt, spelled those rights out. Article 25 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights states that "everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including… medical care…."
Health care is a human right. Like freedom from torture and ill treatment, equality before the law, and education, health care is something that all of us are entitled to by virtue of being human.
Note that somewhere between the founding and Article 25, the intangible was turned into the tangible. Now, not only do you have a right to your own life, you have a right to your life augmented with certain juicy perks courtesy of some unnamed schmoe. Somehow missed in the nobility of the declaration is the fact that the schmoe has seemingly lost the right to his own life, his own liberty, and the pursuit of his own happiness. Said schmoe is now on the hook providing "standard[s] of living", "well-being", education, and… "medical care" to those whose squeals can summon the Article 25 grease. What if the schmoe decides he doesn’t want to provide someone else’s education or medical care? Is he sent off for rehabilitation? Or just nickeled and dimed to death under threats of rather more complete impoverishment or incarceration? Kleins and Dossanis don’t care.
The moron Dossani goes on:
Health care is a public good, not a commodity and a healthy society benefits all of us.
I think Dossani is an idiot who thinks he’s a clever propagandist (though Lord Knows he didn’t get to be "Director of Amnesty International’s Demand Dignity Campaign" without having a few weak-minded people admire the living shit out of his earnest vapidity.) What he writes is almost like A = B, and B = C, therefore A = C, except that it’s closer to A = B, B != C, therefore A = C ain’t he a clever fellow. He wishes, therefore he invokes. It’s not a commodity! Heck no, it’s something else! It’s a public good. See? It’s important. Therefore it’s not a thing. It’s a right. You have a right to health care. Why, you can march down to your local General Practitioner’s and exercise that right, today, now, forever. It’s your right. You can steal from people when we all benefit. People who don’t want you to be healthy are mean and ignorant, and selfish, and you can take their money as recompense for their failings. You can force people to pay for your education, too, because their freedom to dispose of their assets as they see fit are trumped by your rights. Article 25 says so. And never mind the contradictions.
That’s how Sameer Dossani gets to pretend he’s important. Ginning rubes with castor oil made of gasoline.
And last, but only least, via Billy Beck, comes Glenn Reynolds of Instapundit, who, one would think, ought to know better, but he swings the same way time after time. I’ve said it before, he’s no better than Ezra Klein, and, as stupid as Sameer Dossani is, Reynolds is no better than that, either, for my money.
To hell in a hand basket.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||