KAYAK2U

August 26, 2009

Klein Boggle – A blonde walks into a confusing situation…

A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.

Ezra Klein wonders, wonders, why another heavily subsidized (by whom?  Can you guess?) industry consistently shows ever rising costs that outpace the Consumer Price Index:

Niraj Choksi runs the numbers and finds something interesting: Education costs have been rising even faster than medical costs:

[important looking chart goes here]

Per capita spending on health care is more than $7,000. It’s nowhere near as high in education, and so this is less of a problem. But it’s still interesting. More broadly, I’d like to know what experts think is driving the numbers. Is this hiding a relatively benign story, in which a lot more people are going to college, or graduate school, or even just choosing a private school? Is it just the cost of human labor rising quickly? Or is it more problematic? Or both?

Hey, Klein, you moron:  It’s the subsidies.  It’s the government SUBSIDIES.  It’s the taking of hundreds of millions of dollars from productive and successful people and scattering them higgledy-piggledy across the educational land.  It’s basic economics.  Health care, education, housing, it makes no difference.  You subsidize something, the price of that thing will tend to rise.  You could look it up, even.  Yes, I know, it’s hard for a tin-plated policy wonk (who never actually gets to watch the police go out and enforce his policy) to wrap his head around, but it is true nonetheless.

And it’s really sad.

Only a couple of Klein’s commenters even come close to answering the point in his call for "experts", demonstrating another side effect of two generations of massive subsidies for education:  A completely watered down product; people with "educations" who are stone stupid.

Relatedly, in nosing around for the heck of it, I found the following argument against the subsidization of education, on a navy.mil page, interesting (though I don’t agree with every point made):

There are numerous reasons why governments may decide to sue [sic] subsidies as a policy tool. Somewhat cynically Houthakker (1972) has argued that a main reason has to do with political vote buying. From an economic perspective, the main purpose of subsidies is to reallocate resources, that is, to alter economic activity and behavior to achieve an outcome that is more desirable from what would occur otherwise.  Hence arguments for subsidies are often based on some concept of efficiency or economic justice. But even when subsidies generate a more desirable outcome, it does not mean that the entire value of the subsidy is corrective in nature, or that the particular type of subsidy used for a given purpose is best among the available policy alternatives.

Economic arguments for using government subsidies generally fall into three broad categories:

1.      Offsetting various market imperfections;
2.      Exploiting economies of scale in production;
3.      Meeting social policy objectives, including, for example protecting the poor,
4.      Changing the distribution of income, and increasing or retaining employment.

Oftentimes, however, those sectors receiving the largest subsidies do not clearly meet these criteria.  Education subsidies in the United States are a prime example.  In the early 1990s the government was spending nearly $300 billion on education or around 15% of all government spending, making it the third largest single type of government expenditure behind only national defense and social security.  Meanwhile, government revenue collected from education was only around $30 billion. This $270 billion subsidy was roughly 5.5% of net national product.  Clearly, the choice to subsidize education is an important one, and this choice seems to be widely accepted as a good decision. But the reasons why subsidizing education is a good choice are not so obvious.

Unlike a public good like national defense, markets can and do provide education. It is not clear why the government should subsidize this good rather than let markets work unimpeded. Several normative justifications for subsidizing education have been put forth.  There are four main types: equity, paternalistic, borrowing constraint, and externality arguments. None of these is completely compelling, however. For example, few would argue, other things equal, against economic equality, especially equality of opportunity. This value judgment justifies helping the disadvantaged gain access to education.  It does not, however, justify subsidizing the educational opportunities for all income classes.

Most economists find the second type of argument even less compelling. The various paternalistic arguments are based on the presumption that people do not fully recognize the benefits associated with education, and thus do not purchase enough education on their own. Therefore, those who are fortunate enough to fully recognize the benefits of education argue that the subsidy is necessary to induce the less enlightened to make better choices. There are two major problems with this argument, however. It is difficult to objectively justify why many people do not fully appreciate the benefits of education while there are some enlightened ones who do.

There is also a similar problem in objectively distinguishing the enlightened opinions from the unenlightened. The third justification argues that many students are constrained from borrowing against their potential future income to finance their education. This capital market imperfection (largely due to government-imposed constraints) may cause many students to acquire less than efficient amounts of education. This obstacle to opportunity may be viewed as inequitable as well. But if this borrowing constraint is the problem, then government-supported loans are the obvious solution. There is no reason to lower the private cost of education and redistribute income to all publicly educated students, as subsidies do.

The fourth justification has received the most attention by economists. If acquiring education produces spillover benefits, self-interested individuals will acquire less than socially efficient amounts of education. A subsidy internalizes the externality and encourages students to acquire more efficient amounts of education. A common view, however, is that although these external benefits probably do exist, it is unlikely their magnitude is large enough to warrant a subsidy as large as the one observed, particularly at the level of higher education. It seems improbable that the marginal external benefit is as substantial as the subsidy. If the above arguments are valid, one is apparently left with the disturbing conclusion that subsidizing education, particularly higher education, is mostly a redistribution that is inequitable by commonly accepted standards of equity.

It’s also wrong to steal from some people in order to enrich others.

MikeSoja - August 26, 2009 -- 12:46 am    Filed in: Commies, Education, Health care, Morons  
« They own you
I’m afraid to look »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud