KAYAK2U

August 12, 2009

Stephen Hawking and The Black Hole of Truth

Apparently Ezra Klein doesn’t read this blog.  Who knew?

(Thanks to Malone Vandam and Billy Beck for da links.  I do enjoy the avalanches.  There was at least one visitor, came in through Billy’s, from fed.gov who scooped a lot of pages.  Possibly others.  They’re always there, these days.  Santa Claus is making his lists and checking ’em twice.)

So, the progressive echo chamber was all into reverberating on the single unmodulated key that Klein played for them two days ago, a thing (the mindless echoing) that never ceases to amaze me.  There’s no reasoning with it, no poking it in the eye, no tripping it up, no making a dent.  It rolls on.

Me, I know I gave it a good whack, and if people stumble across it at some point, after wading through the endless seas of rote repetition, or even if they don’t, there it is.  The U.K.’s National Health Service was not prepared to accomodate Stephen Hawking’s needs back in 1985.

Today, following up on the Stephen Hawking story, Klein played anecdote parade with tweets from a Twitter … person? group?  calling itself welovetheNHS.  Makes you wonder if so many people can really be that stupid, going on and on about how it is all "free", and not the kind of "free" with quotes around it.  It never occurs to them that their lousy job market and their teensy cars (if they can afford one) and their teeny little flats with half-sized refrigerators are all partly due to the value sucked out of the performing end of their economy in service to that bloated disgrace called the NHS.  Not to belittle the suckings of every other socialist and/or welfare state agency.  It’s free, it’s free, it’s free is the sound of a million morons dancing under the watchful eye of the surveillance camera, not realizing at all the costs they paid.

And then, in the same entry, Klein waxed ecstatic, because Hugh Muir of the UK Guardian wrote that Stephen Hawking loves the NHS.  Muir writes:

We say [Hawking’s] life is far from worthless, as they do at Addenbrooke’s hospital, Cambridge, where Professor Hawking, who has motor neurone disease, was treated for chest problems in April. As indeed does he. "I wouldn’t be here today if it were not for the NHS," he told us. "I have received a large amount of high-quality treatment without which I would not have survived."

Klein said, of Muir, "[H]e called Hawking for his reaction," but Muir doesn’t claim that he called Hawking, or even when he collected the quote.  Not that it matters.  Hell, if I wanted to really go out on a limb I’d say that the quote attributed to Hawking doesn’t much sound like the man.  And, while his computer (a necessary ingredient in all his communications) is hooked to a phone system, I’d rather imagine that phoning him up to ask him what he thought of an Investor’s Business Daily editorial from two weeks ago isn’t easily done.  And yet, even if Klein knows more than Muir publicly states, and isn’t playing fabulist  to make the story sound better, and if Muir isn’t being cute, it doesn’t matter.

The NHS successfully treats millions of people a year, even, when necessary, Stephen Hawking.  They are a health service, after all.  But Stephen Hawking is a famous man, now, and his most recent visit to Addenbrooke’s hospital was not a particularly onerous burden for the public to bear.  He had some tests done and spent a day or so "in observation".  As I pointed out yesterday, twenty four years ago, before Hawking became a popular public figure, the NHS refused to provide him with the care that he and his family thought he deserved.  And at least one member of his family didn’t love the NHS because of it.  And, since 1985, Hawking has devoted significant effort and his own resources trying to help those, like himself, that the NHS leaves short.  Now, he may be entirely appreciative of the work that the NHS has done for him, and there’s nothing wrong with that, but if Hawking hadn’t turned out to be world famous Hawking, he’d probably be dead by now.

Furthermore, the argument Klein is trying to make with Muir’s quote from Hawking is specious.  It doesn’t matter how many people, including Hawking, love the NHS.  A lot of people loved slavery at one time, but that didn’t make that right.  And the fact that the NHS, or the Post Office, or Amtrak, do manage to stumble through most days and save someone’s life, or deliver a letter, or have a train show up on time, doesn’t mean that any of them aren’t unnecessary and immoral drains on their respective societies, and shouldn’t be abolished, with the monies extracted for their furtherances returned to its rightful owners.

MikeSoja - August 12, 2009 -- 11:10 pm    Filed in: Commies, Health care, Incompetents  
« Klein Boggle – The Inept Bully
Mid-month crazy »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud