Everything.
10,000 words on the subject from Richard Munson, in 2001.
It’s a comprehensive indictment, and a must read for anyone wanting a partially blazed trail into the morass.
Later: The link is borked. I noticed it September 7, 2009. Munson is the former director of the Northeast-Midwest Institute, where that story was hosted, and I’ve written to them to see what’s what. It seems that all of Munson’s stuff is gone from there, along with Munson himself. Of course, Munson didn’t just completely disappear, but is now a vice president of a private company, and I also wrote him there to see if someone somewhere can put a copy of his report back online. Because, like I said above, it’s an excellent indictment of the TVA. I’ll host the thing myself if he gives permission.
In the meantime, here’s an excerpt:
TVA officials and their supporters hold that FDR’s giant experiment cleared the rivers, replenished the soil, rebuilt the forests, delivered cheap electricity, and brought new life and hope to the depressed Tennessee Valley. David Lilienthal’s Democracy on the March and the TVA staff’s TVA: The First Twenty Years boast of enormous progress resulting from TVA. No doubt the agency’s payroll — which averaged 13,000 workers in its early years — boosted the region’s economy, but the long-term benefits of TVA’s investments are less clear. According to William Chandler, author of The Myth of TVA and a researcher with Battelle National Laboratory, those investments performed poorly when compared to development in adjacent regions. Chandler, for instance, concluded:
Per-capita income growth in surrounding, non-TVA areas equaled or exceeded that in the TVA region, despite they’re being equal at the beginning of the TVA experiment.
Manufacturing employment grew more slowly in the TVA area than in surrounding non-TVA areas.
Rural electrification progressed more slowly in the Tennessee Valley region than in comparable surrounding areas.
The installation of piped running water in households and the utilization of home electric appliances proceeded less rapidly than in non-TVA states.
In its defense of appropriations for TVA’s non-power programs, the Clinton administration repeats the myth that "TVA is a tremendous success," citing statistics that per-capita income increased ten-fold in the TVA service territory, well above the national average. Yet such statistics are misleading, in large part because the Tennessee Valley started from such a low base in the 1930s that any gain looks substantial in percentage terms. When comparing instead the growth in per-capita income between Tennessee, where TVA supplies virtually all the power, to neighboring states that also suffered economic hardship in the 1930s, TVA’s "success" is less clear. In fact, per-capita income increased more substantially in non-TVA Georgia, Kentucky, and Virginia than it did in Tennessee.
TVA customers for many years certainly benefitted from electricity rates that were about half the national average. Such benefits, however, were made possible by substantial (if unwitting) subsidies from taxpayers across the country and by TVA’s failure to pay for cleaning up its own pollution.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||