Teachers demoralized over attacks on profession
Things are going swimmingly in the government school system:
The Department of Education estimates the percentage of schools not meeting yearly targets for their students' proficiency in in math and reading could jump from 37 to 82 percent as states raise standards in attempts to satisfy the law's mandates.
The 2002 law requires states to set targets aimed at having all students proficient in math and reading by 2014, a standard now viewed as wildly unrealistic.
"now viewed"??? The "targets" were ALWAYS "wildly unrealistic."
All of it is a big fucking joke:
"The reality is coming home that you can't essentially demonstrate very little progress for ten years and then expect all of your progress to occur in the last two or three years," Whitehurst said.
He said some states believed improvement would accelerate as students advanced, creating a "snowball effect," while others put off the heavy lifting to avoid the consequences.
Fire 'em all. Fire everybody. Shut the whole miserable stupid worthless conglomeration DOWN.
On the other hand, Homeland Security will have no shortage of sluggish malcontents to fill its staffing needs for at least a generation.
Here's a guy putting computers in front of kids, and then leaving them alone:
I've been saying for some time that one could abolish the government school system (give everyone's money back), rescind the laws stipulating that every child must go to school, etc., and the nation's literacy and competency in math will expand. In Wisconsin, only 34% of 8th graders read proficiently. And this…
In Alabama, only 18 percent of eighth graders are proficient in math.
In Mississippi, only 14 percent of eighth graders are proficient in math.
In New Jersey, only 40 percent of eighth graders are proficient in math.
In Connecticut, only 35 percent of eighth graders are proficient in math.
In New York, only 30 percent of eighth graders are proficient in math.
In Arizona, only 26 percent of eighth graders are proficient in math.
In California, only 24 percent of eighth graders are proficient in math.
Could one do worse if one were purposely trying not to teach math?
Get the government out of education, before it's too late (if it isn't, already.)
Via: TED vid via Protein Wisdom.
Wisconsin Education Association Council President Mary Bell:
Our goal is not to close schools, but to instead to remain vigilant in our efforts to be heard.
She's one of the education elite.
Wisconsin state Sen. Bob Jauch, D-Poplar:
The story around the world is the rush to democracy. The story in Wisconsin is the end of the democratic process.
Nobody in his right mind ought to deal with these people as though were anything other than morons.
Nationally, approximately 15 percent of students entering college are already on a prescribed psychotropic medication (for anxiety, attention deficit disorder, depression or some other condition), according to a 2009 survey conducted by Penn State University's Center for the Study of Collegiate Mental Health. Art school students are part of that same trend. Between 10 and 15 percent of the students entering the School of the Art Institute of Chicago are on one or another medication, and a quarter of the students entering the counseling centers of RISD and the Maryland Institute are taking some psychotropic. Those numbers may rise as students deal with the stress of college life.
I think the country is just about ready to collectively shit its pants.
ps. Art Carden at Mises parses it a bit more finely than I do.
More on the Evanston Township, Illinois school saga (earlier blog here). The high points:
Your kid is an honor student at ETHS? Heck, everyone is an honors student at ETHS.
And…
School administrators in Evanston insist the change is aimed at making the curriculum more demanding, even as they make it less demanding for some students. Thanks to the abolition of this elite course, we are told, "high-achieving students" will profit from "experiencing multiple perspectives and diversity in their classes to gain cultural capital."
They won't learn English beyond about a fourth grade level, but that cultural capital can go straight into the bank.
In Evanston Township, Illinois, they're busy forging the chains of the future out of weakest links:
After weeks of debate that touched on academics, race and politics, Evanston Township High School District 202 approved a dramatic plan Monday night that eliminates a combined honors English and history course for the highest-achieving incoming freshmen — usually white students.
It's a program with national potential, especially in today's political climate. If school districts can sabotage the educations of our best, brightest, and hardest working, early enough, the country will be spared the spectacle and ignominy of "the rich". And maybe even the merely wealthy.
The unanimous school board vote paves the way for freshmen of all races, socioeconomic and achievement backgrounds next fall to take the same freshman humanities course next fall. Proponents of the move see it as a way to diversify advanced courses and circumvent the traditional process of tracking students into courses by test scores that often places minorities in lower-level classes.
It was unanimous. And all students next fall will be consigned to "lower-level classes" next fall. It's genius! In fact, the Chicago Tribune has already embraced the mandate!
The board approved the plan despite opposition from hundreds of parents who signed a petition urging officials to at least delay the proposal while it can be studied further.
Are these people crazy?!? On what basis do they hope that inveigling morons to study their own stupidity will lead to enlightenment?
Among other concerns, parents felt top-performing students could be bored or held back in classes that cater to the abilities of a wide range of students. The class scheduled for elimination is designed for freshmen who outscore about 95 percent of peers nationally on eighth-grade tests.
Bored or held back? They're going to be stunted, wounded, maimed, damaged, warped, deprived, bereft, debilitated, hobbled, and infected with the anti-social rot that grows in places where people are forced to be where they don't want to be.
Now, those students will be melded with all incoming freshmen able to read at the ninth-grade level, which the high school defines as scoring at or about the 40th percentile on the achievement test given to eighth-graders. All freshmen in the class will have the opportunity to earn honors credit, depending on their grades on assignments.
Sweet. 5th percentile achievers will be forced to sit with 40th percentile malcontents, and they better like it, or the malcontents will make 'em.
The district wants to apply the same approach to freshman biology in 2012-13.
After which, Biology will no longer deserve a capital "B", which the Trib has already anticipated, in its half-assed reporting style.
The disgrace unfolding in Evanston Township illustrates exactly why government should not have anything to do with education. There is no reason that students who show little to no interest in learning should be forced to participate in a pretense, where their reluctance and recalcitrance serves only to distract and hinder those who, contrary-like, want to acquire an education. Further, the one size fits all character of government schools, coupled with the forced taxation that finances them, eliminates free choice for most families (they can't afford both the taxes and the private tuition to escape the government morass), and stifles the very diversity, experimentation, and entrepreneurial activity so obviously vital to education in a fast changing world.
But it's a great country, isn't it?
Via: Protein Wisdom.
The Underground Grammarian, that is. I keep a link to Richard Mitchell to the left, there. His work is always worth dipping into.
Like this:
There be three things, yea four, for which Earth is troubled, for which she tosses in her sleep: the officious governor who requires of the governed what he does not require of himself; the prideful benefactor who grandly dispenses what is not his own; the convinced improver of the world who easily detects the deficiency of virtue in almost everybody else; and in the incurious teacher who ignorantly sows in his students seeds that he wouldn’t like to see sprouting in his own garden. All are tyrants.
And they all hang out in the school business, not infrequently cohabiting in the same body.
Many evils are countenanced in the labyrinths of government schools, and, indeed, are promoted and perpetuated there. Mitchell saw it all.
The following elicited a veritable grunt (resembling an exhortation of mirth) out of me:
American educationism is actually a religious cult deriving its theory and practice from numerous small articles of belief. Here are two of them:
¶ Study, learning, and practice, except in certain extra-curricular activities, are difficult and unpleasant.
¶ Children are sick, and the proper business of schooling is their cure.
These doctrines are propagated by recitation and role-modeling in the teacher-training academies, but, truly, without much need. Of the first, most teacher-trainees are already convinced, for it corresponds exactly to their own experience as students. Of the second, they are delighted to be convinced, for it lends the glamour of healership to a calling into which they were forced by their SAT scores.
“Those who can, do. Those who can’t, teach.” It’s always been true, and all the resolutions and decrees and appreciations and benefits packages can’t change that silly little thing. Teaching is a matter of very basic, simple functions that almost anyone can be trained to perform. There are exceptional teachers, of course, but they are no more in abundance than are exceptional people anywhere, and the barrier to exceptionalism in the education trades is exceedingly low high.
At least Basket Weaving 101 taught a skill:
Most of Johnson's students are female. A few are recovering from eating disorders; their cheeks are hollow and their scrawny arms droop like slack rubber bands. About a quarter of the class is slightly overweight.
All of them have worried about weight at some point in their lives. Some have shown her photos of their former selves: pictures of nearly unrecognizable obese teens. Others merely packed on the freshman 15. Two months into the semester, her few male students have begun to feel comfortable talking about their weight, recounting taunts from childhood and revealing their fears about size. The girls still hesitate to speak up—it always takes them longer to feel secure, Johnson says.
That's concerning an allegedly scholastic course taught at George Washington University.
One doesn't get an education these days. One gets therapy.
And then, later, one exhibits what the experts call an eating disorder after one finds out what a fucking moron one has been one's entire life.
Via: Protein Wisdom.
Al Gore's whore (whether he banged her or not, she's still his whore), Laurie David, spun a book off the movie she whored for Gore, the book being the "Down-to-Earth Guide to Global Warming". That book is the object of my title, there.
The book has at least one glaring error in it, that has allowed some pretend-responsible types in some school district to declare that they are suspending use of the book until said glaring error is rectified in some future edition. Note that the folks at Omaha.com can't be bothered to describe in any detail whatsoever what the glaring error is. Likewise, know that if there are any other errors (which there are), they won't be describing those, either.
What the fuck is such a book doing in any school, anyway, is my question. It's PLAINLY propaganda. It doesn't help kids learn math. It doesn't help kids learn to read. It's like Soviet bullshit propaganda from fifty years ago, dressed up with modern computer typography and graphics. And is global warming propaganda now part of the national curriculum? Or are sales of such pieces of trash to the federal education establishment one of the perks for being whore for an ex-vice president of the federal conglomerate?
The only cheerful part of this crap is reading one or two of the reviews of the book at Amazon.com:
That Ms. David, a non-scientist, has opted to perpetuate this rather glaring error suggests one of two things – either that she really is a vapid celebrity of little brain or that she perhaps has some other reason for inducing nightmares in children than the good of Planet Earth. It could be, perhaps, that she would like for us to forget about her jet-setting narcissistic lifestyle and her own huge carbon footprint – and also her opposition to renewable energy projects when they impede her view from Martha's Vineyard.
… sandwiched in amongst the true believer morons.
Why is this crap in U.S. schools? Because the schools are government schools, and government schools are in the business of pushing collectivist, big government propaganda.
The story of the "Cry Wolf" project might have legs. Maybe. For at least one professor, anyway.
Both links via Instapundit.
BigJournalism has a follow up to yesterday's breaking piece, mostly rambling around the edges of it…
These so-called scholars have freely admitted, in their own words, that they intend to “undermine the credibility and arguments” of those who happen to hold opposing viewpoints to theirs. No unbiased research methodology, no respect for the opinions of others, no intellectual honesty. Just pure propaganda, put to the service of their ideology. That’s not scholarship: it’s naked advocacy.
And BigJournalism has another, more pointed look at some of the legalities…
It looks like Professor Dreier drove an academic Mack truck right through Occidental’s wall between academic endeavors and politics. He sent the “Cry Wolf” memo using his Occidental email account, and presumably used the College’s servers as well. He identifies himself as an Occidental College professor in the memo – in fact, he ensures that everyone knows that he is the renowned “E.P. Clapp Distinguished Professor of Politics, Director of the Urban & Environmental Policy Program, Occidental College.” His email is directed to “Colleagues” – presumably other college professors and similarly situated social parasites. He solicits “faculty and graduate students” specifically. This memo is start to finish a product of Occidental College – which may find itself solely responsible for its content.
Of course, this thing doesn't touch most of Academe, where the collectivists have long played their incestuous games, but any crack of light on it can only be good.
I thought it was an old story, but it's got today's date on it.
Anyone who's ever spent any time arguing with lefties knows that about 98% of the battle is cutting through all the wrong things they think they know or understand. It's an uphill slog, always.
Daniel B. Klein at the Wall Street Journal has a look at a Zogby survey that seeks to answer the question of no small consequence: "Who is better informed about the policy choices facing the country—liberals, conservatives or libertarians?"
Yep, you guessed it. The people more likely to want to put the government boot on the neck of their fellows, and keep it there, are as uneducated about real world matters as you always thought they were.
And they have the attention spans of gnats, but that's just personal observation.
Via: Protein Wisdom. And read this one there, too.
Patrick Courrielche at BigJournalism.com peeks under the blanket of propaganda being woven at American universities:
This is what our higher education system has become – a publicly funded amplifier of progressive ideology.
Read the whole, horrible thing.
And Gomorrah. That's what Harvard and Yale are the modern intellectual equivalents of. With Princeton their cross-eyed mutant teenager.
Meyer (no offense, man, it's only a generalization) links Bernstein:
The president went to Harvard, and barely defeated a primary opponent who went to Yale. His predecessor went to Yale and Harvard, and defeated opponents who went to Yale and Harvard, and Harvard, respectively. The previous two presidents also went to Yale, with Bush I defeating another Harvard grad for the presidency. And once Elena Kagan gets confirmed, every Supreme Court Justice will have attended Harvard or Yale law schools.
When you virtually exclude all but two of the nation's 160 law schools as sources for justices, it not only reduces the number of outstanding candidates but guarantees a certain insularity in training and influences on the court. This bias is not only elitist but decidedly anti-intellectual.
At Mises.org they focus on Kagan:
S. M. Oliva linkes Nate Oman, describing what's missing in certain, modern, "elite" educations:
Kagan has spent her entire career either in government or else in academia studying the processes of government regulation. She shows little academic or professional interest in business. This is important because while public regulation makes up the bulk of the Court’s docket, private businesses are overwhelmingly the target of that regulation. Everything in Kagan’s career, however, suggests that she is intellectually geared to look at the regulatory process from the government’s point of view. For example, in law school I had an advanced seminar on administrative law from Kagan. It was an interesting class, mainly focused on the competition between bureaucrats and political appointees. In our discussions businesses were always conceptualized as either passive objects of regulation or pernicious rent-seekers. Absent was a vision of private businesses as agents pursuing economic goals orthogonal to political considerations. We were certainly not invited to think about the regulatory process from the point of view of a private business for whom political and regulatory agendas represent a dead-weight cost.
Barack Obama and the new age of “diversity” has given us two left wing Ivy League females — identically unmarried and childless — not simply from the same city and same state, and not simply from the same undergraduate college, but from the very same undergraduate degree program .
The Nate Oman link most nearly supports my contention: The worth of Harvard and Yale educations is severely overinflated, and has been for two or three decades.
As the government insinuates itself more and more into the economy and the private lives of the citizenry, advancement and achievement will depend less and less on the merits of one's efforts and more and more on one's political pull. Another example of the creeping rise of the nomenklatura:
While many Chicago parents took formal routes to land their children in the best schools, the well-connected also sought help through a shadowy appeals system created in recent years under former schools chief Arne Duncan.
Whispers have long swirled that some children get spots in the city’s premier schools based on whom their parents know. But a list maintained over several years in Duncan’s office and obtained by the Tribune lends further evidence to those charges. Duncan is now secretary of education under President Barack Obama.
If you read the rest of it, note the underlying rot at the root of the favor seeking behavior: The government schools themselves. There are very good reasons that people want out of the vast majority of them, but, of course, they can't be permitted that freedom. People like Arne Duncan and Barack Obama won't allow it.
Via: Warren Meyer, who notes, "Arne Duncan Really Does Favor School Choice". Just not for the average citizen who can't further Duncan's career.
We find that, in the areas studied, public schools are spending 93 percent more than the estimated median private school.
… while achieving less.
It's another collectivist success!
There are lots of laffs to be had at the expense of the Texas State Board of Education, but the joke is just as much on the jokers who can't seem to see that when you've set up the cannibal pot, you're going to have endless squabbles about what goes into it, and over time the squabbles will become increasingly picayune. And neither side is beyond reproach. When your schools are run by the government, you're going to get politicized educations, period. Plain and simple. And you're not going to get good education, whatever you might think that entails; you're going to get a lowest common denominator education, and probably at the low end of lowest common denominator at that. Take a look around.
Get the government out of the business of education, leave the stupid, nauseating politics behind, and watch individuals exercising their freedom choose exemplary educations for their children the same way they use the free market for all their other exemplary products and services. Instead of worrying about what is being taught to everyone else's kid, all you have to do is worry about your own. It's easy, IF you can manage to mind your own business.
Received another email from another Florida Department of Education official, advising me of exactly the same nonsense as yesterday.
Here's another clue for the twits: With a ball park average response rate of ten percent the last few years, anyone with the inclination to try to influence the survey results has a healthy ninety percent chance of being able to do so.
On the matter of the unsecured Exceptional Student Education survey (here, here, here), a person on the periphery has emailed:
You have to enter your child school's name, grade level , and date of birth, the data entered will be compared with the data the state has. They accept only the matched data. All other responses will be eliminated.
Of course, I considered the possibility of exactly that, deemed it unlikely, and while I have to give it further consideration because of the email, I have no way to ascertain the claim, and only more questions.
If the emailer is correct, then the survey really isn't anonymous, even though it was touted as being anonymous, yet perhaps people are being mislead in that respect.
Also, if the emailer is correct, then the survey is still ripe for abuse and fraud. Anyone with a list of disabled children's birthdays matched to the schools they attend, could skew the survey results quite easily, especially with the survey's historically abysmal number of survey takers. Even someone willing to work sequentially through all 365 days in the year would invariably have many of his entries accepted. On the flip side, the slightest error in Florida's database, or the slightest error in a parent's entry would supposedly invalidate a legitimate survey offering, with absolutely no indication, either way, to the user.
Additionally, if some nincompoop makes a run at the survey, and picks schools, grades, and birth dates of real students who haven't yet been matched with survey entries, then those entries are counted as valid, and when the legitimate parent comes along, his or her entry will be thrown away.
Further, I find it highly unlikely that the programming was done so stupidly, though it is a government endeavor, and therefore we should all probably be immeasurably thankful that it has been done as well as it has.
Obviously, if one were to insist on the methodology conveyed in the email, school/grade/birth date, then one should allow/forbid prospective survey takers after they've entered identifying parameters, but before they've taken the survey. Unless I've been extremely lucky (and selecting valid parameters may be easier than I think – with thousands of disabled kids per school district it's likely that several children share birthdays, every day of the year, even in the same grade), then everyone taking the survey, whether their entries end up being accepted or not, is thanked for taking the survey, and invited to take another survey pertaining to another aspect of the Florida government school system. There is no way to know if one's survey is one of those that "will be eliminated."
Of course, it may be that the scripts at www.esesurvey.com are not connected to the big Florida database where the data is allegedly "matched", but that then suggests a two step process of validating the data, which also seems ripe for abuse, fraud, or failure due to incompetence.
And with all that, there are numerous problems with Florida's ESE Survey methodology no matter which way the programming has been done.
Sweet Cheeks offers the ancillary observation relating to the validity of the survey results in light of Assistant Polk County School Board Superintendent Nancy Woolcock's recent offer (since rescinded) of free iPod Nanos to survey takers, and how those survey takers might more favorably view a school system that hands out such extravagant goodies, however incompetent and inexcellent its educational offerings. Read: bribes.
All in all, one giant, but typical, governmental clusterfuck.
Yep. Fire the teachers. That story helped broaden my usual morning smile.
That Rhode Island school is by all accounts one of the least shiny examples of a very tarnished system. Things like…
Test scores remain a problem at Central Falls High School as only 3 percent of 11th graders are proficient in math in 2008 and 7 percent in 2009.
… make you wonder if they couldn't do better just letting the kids run wild. And the money spent on achieving that level of abysmal? Hoo boy.
As I've noted before, Rhode Island is a tiny cesspit of collectivism. I don't think one school superintendent with steel in her spine stands a chance, but bless her little heart, anyway.
I'm still steeped in saving America from its felonious class, ie., the political slash bureaucratic establishment as represented this week by the Florida Department of Education, with a focus on Polk County, Florida, and its superintendent and sub-superintendent. Previous posts, here, here, here, and here.
The online Exceptional Student Education (ESE) Survey is still accessible to the marauding hordes (I've submitted a new rendition yet again), while it is supposed to only be available to parents with children suffering sundrily in Florida's school system.
Enticing people to participate in the survey was the raison d'etre behind the scheme to channel $350,000 worth of tax dollars in the form of iPods to parents of the aforementioned children who so participated. $350,000 is a fairly large amount of money to spread around just to get people to click twenty six times on their computer screens. But the payoff (a number never reported, of course) was a much bigger pile of the taxpayer's wealth. The Polk County school administrators were hoping for a windfall of millions of tax dollars if they could just qualify their schools under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) of 2004. One of the requirements of that act is that Polk County show a certain level of participation among the parents of students in the system having disabilities, and one of the ways of satisfying that requirement is to demonstrate a certain level of participation via a survey.
Here's Florida's 12th district Congressman Adam H. Putnam:
Giving an iPod in exchange for a few questions being answered certainly is extravagant in these tough times. These programs are important to disabled students and there is a survey requirement for the funds, but wouldn't doughnuts and coffee work?
Hmm, but apparently Assistant Polk County School Board Superintendent Nancy Woolcock and her boss, Polk County School District Superintendent Gail McKinzie, thought they needed to be sure.
And yet, their scheme was discovered, and all their plans ruined (no one has yet explained how Woolcock expected to match anonymous survey participants to their iPods). Or were they?
In the brouhaha over the announced iPod giveaway scheme, the internet address to the ESE Survey was reported a number of times. John Chambliss at The Ledger reported it here and here. Kara Phelps at NewsChief.com reported it here. And Tom Staik at The Polk County Democrat mentioned it here. All in conjunction with talking to Nancy Woolcock.
In other words, the publicity surrounding the iPod giveaway scheme gave much more publicity to the ESE Survey (the focus of the Polk County bureaucrat's endeavors) AND, then, you see, the survey form is wide open to anyone and everyone, so no longer do Woolcock and Crew have to worry about enticing squads of a small subsection of disinterested parents. Anyone, living in Florida or not, having disabled children or not, can take the survey and help Polk County (and any other county, too, for the survey is used state wide) attain the federal dollars to which they would otherwise not be entitled.
The whole thing is a fraud, and a large one. The entire education establishment in Florida is using a survey that is a fraud, and using that fraud of a survey to obtain millions and millions of tax dollars from Washington, D.C.
ps. Please forgive any sense I may give that the Florida government education establishment is entitled to any portion of money that has to be stolen from the earnest citizenry. Clearly, they are not entitled to any of it, but in the case under review, they are not even entitled to it under the dubious law.
For those who couldn't or wouldn't make it to the end of my previous post pertaining to the attempted iPod giveaway (utilizing federal tax dollars) in Florida, here's more on the most troubling aspect of the issue.
First, from my safe redoubt in the hills of Tennessee, I have several times now filled out Florida's Exceptional Student Education Survey, the survey that becomes part of Florida's official education reporting documentation, and which is used to justify the state's acquisition of millions of federal tax dollars.
There is something decidedly wrong with me being able to do that. The survey is supposed to be limited to parents with students of sundry disabilities attending Florida schools, but apparently anyone in the world can fill out the forms, and thereby affect the amounts of federal tax dollars shipped off to the Sunshine State.
It's difficult to ferret information in the government rock pile, but here's a short history of Florida's ESE survey program:
Under the State Performance Plan, mandated by the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (2004), all states are now required to collect and report data on the “percent of parents with a child receiving special education services who report that schools facilitated parent involvement as a means of improving services and results for children with disabilities.”
The FDOE has a long history of gathering data from parents by means of large-scale surveys. Between 1999 and 2005, Florida’s monitoring system included a parent survey component, enabling parents to share their perceptions about services provided under IDEA.
[…]
In 2006, surveys were mailed to the entire population of parents of children receiving preschool services. For parents of students K-12, survey forms were mailed to all parents of students receiving special education services in districts with special education membership equal to or less than 4,000. In districts with special education membership greater than 4,000, surveys were sent to a random sample of 4,000 parents. A total of 177,901 surveys were sent out; of these, 18,725 (10.5%) were returned.
In 2007, the second year of implementation of data collection under the SPP, the same sampling plan was implemented. Additionally, parents of students K-12 were given the option of completing the survey online, using as a login an arbitrary individual ID number provided in the material they received by mail. Packets were mailed to 179,710 parents; a total of 16,812 (9.4%) were returned. Approximately 11% of parents of students K-12 who completed the survey did so online. In 2008, the opportunity to complete the survey online will be extended to include parents of preschool children. Additionally, a small number of districts will pilot “web-only” access to the survey.
To summarize, the survey was originally mailed directly to parents of children with disabilities. Subsequently, an online version of the survey was made available with a (presumably) secure login id sent to parents in the mail.
Now the program has been expanded, but in the face of an absolutely miserable response rate, and a desperate need to fulfill the terms of federal funding parameters, the login id component of the thing has been dropped. Anyone can access the survey, fill it out, and pump up the numbers and satisfaction quotient that will be reported to the federal government in return for those lovely tax dollars.
Why Florida's Polk County education bureaucrats Gail McKinzie and Nancy Woolcock thought they had to give away thousands of iPods to entice people into filling out the form is anyone's guess. All they have to do is assign an otherwise unoccupied education minion to fill out the forms day and night up until the July 1st deadline. Such a person might even be able to fill out more forms than there are disabled students in the county, which is exactly the sort of success that graft and malfeasance yearns to be proud of.
Seriously, though, there is something decidedly wrong with what's going on in Florida. Those forms need to be taken offline.
Yesterday, I blogged about the nitwits in Florida's Polk County government education establishment who thought it would be a good idea to give $350,000 (not their own money) worth of iPods to parents of students with disabilities who filled out an online survey. Public outrage quickly shut the scheme down, but there remain a number of troubling aspects, at least to my mind. (Some of the links below repeat, but are necessary for attribution.)
Early yesterday, Nancy Woolcock "attributed the original idea to a school committee". Later on, it turned out that "Nancy Woolcock, assistant superintendent of learning support, introduced the iPod giveaway idea at a School Board meeting Tuesday." Maybe the first quote can be chalked up to sloppy reporting, or maybe Woolcock is a dissembler. However, the school board wasted no time on the proposal:
District officials announced Tuesday that they will give silver iPods Nanos worth $150 to parents of children with disabilities who complete a 10-minute online survey.
And, somewhat surprisingly, "Woolcock had said she received a discount on the $150 price [of the iPod Nanos]." It seems Nancy went into the committee meeting with a full package already prepared. Has anyone asked the amount of the discount, or inquired as to any ancillary details that might have been part of the committment that Woolcock appears to have negotiated on her own? Particularly, who was supposed to have supplied the iPods in exchange for $350,000 of the fair citizenry's tax monies? And the committee? They required no persuasion, I guess. Or perhaps the individual members had already been working on the deal and the idea originated at some earlier time. If so, when, where, and by whom was it floated?
Now meet "Polk County School District Superintendent Gail McKinzie", who said:
[T]he district submitted a budget to the state for a grant it received. The budget, which was approved by the state, showed a listing for MP3 players but it did not specify the iPods would be given to parents.
The scheme goes back much further than Tuesday, but again, maybe there's a lot of sloppy reporting going on.
But there is more, much more, dissembling going on:
"The purpose behind the initiative has been to get the parents involved," said Nancy Woolcock, assistant superintendent of learning support.
She's lying, of course. Not even a moron of Woolcock's caliber thinks that giving away $350,000 worth of iPod Nanos in order to induce parents to fill out a multiple choice questionnaire has anything to do with getting "parents involved" in their children's education.
The sneaky little truth is that Woolcock & Crew were "investing" the $350 large in an attempt to snag a much bigger pile of other people's money under the auspices of the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. McKinzie, again:
As part of receiving funds from the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, the district must have a certain amount of parent participation, McKinzie said. The money cannot go to salaries.
"We have not met the requirements in previous years of having the level of participation that is required," McKinzie said.
Woolcock and her staff will meet next week about how they can get parents to fill out the online survey at www.esesurvey.com. The deadline to complete the survey is July 1. The survey must be taken online.
I have not been able to ascertain how much money the Polk County school board hoped to reap with their $350,000 "investment", but one hopes that it was a significant amount.
And that brings me to the most troubling aspect of this very troubling story: The online survey.
Woolcock said that in the coming days, the district plans to send fliers and e-mails to parents about the anonymous survey.
By March, parents who have filled out the survey should be able to pick up iPods at their children's schools, Woolcock said.
Say what???? Fill out a survey, ANONYMOUSLY, and then claim your iPod, how? Anonymously? That's rank freaking nonsense, and puts the lie to the entire ball of crap.
But, wait! It gets even worse. I just surfed to the survey web page, and took the survey myself. I filled out the entire thing, and got a "Thank you very much for your participation!" blurb. You don't have to be a parent of a student with disabilities in the Polk County schools to help them meet their quota entitling them to monies stolen from their fellow citizens. Anyone in the world can go fill out that survey and help Woolcock and McKinzie waste more tax dollars. The whole thing is one big fucking farce.

Federal tax dollar disbursement is being determined on the basis of the number of people who fill out a publicly available online survey? It's a national disgrace in a nation increasingly full of such disgraces.
Marketing genius in The Sunshine State:
The Polk County school district is giving away iPods to some parents.
The school district is using the device to reward parents of children with disabilities who fill out a 10-minute online survey. The district wants to know how well it's connecting with the parents and how to get parents involved in their children's education.
The district is spending about $350,000 in federal stimulus money for the iPods.
Is this a great country, or what?
UPDATE: The giveaway has been cancelled. But the nonsense is still palpable. The grave transgression, apparently, according to assistant superintendent Nancy Woolcock, is that the source of the funds for the iPod purchases was mis-attributed by the lousy press. The money for the iPods was to come from the Individuals with Disabilities Act, not federal "stimulus funds". The stimulus money has already been spent, on, amongst other things, "school psychologists and social workers." Badda bump. But really, someone has to deal with the fact:
According to the Florida Department of Education, 34 percent of third through fifth graders in Polk County are not reading on their grade level.
That's a lot of tender psyches who will no doubt have a hard time holding their heads up when they realize that they can't even meet the standards set by people like Nancy Woolcock.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||