KAYAK2U

January 26, 2008

The Perspective of a Tool

The great debate about the newly proposed Fiscal Stimulus Package reveals a lot about the interests of those who choose to speak on the matter.  On the one hand, we have the purely partisan types like Paul Krugman, who want to argue whether Person A or Person B would be the better recipient of the government’s new-found largesse:

Unfortunately, the plan — which essentially consists of nothing but tax cuts and gives most of those tax cuts to people in fairly good financial shape — looks like a lemon.

[…]

This ensures that the bulk of the money would go to people who are doing O.K. financially — which misses the whole point.

[…]

On the other hand, money delivered to people who aren’t in good financial shape — who are short on cash and living check to check — does double duty: it alleviates hardship and also pumps up consumer spending.

[…]

But the Bush administration has apparently succeeded in killing all of these ideas, in favor of a plan that mainly gives money to those least likely to spend it.

Etc.,  etc., etc.  Krugman likes the idea of government giving money to people, but only to certain people.

On the other hand are those who seem to have a larger perspective, and question the wisdom of doling out dough in the name of stimulus to anyone:

"Stimulus" is slang for a sordid economic nostrum administered on the advice of bankers and academics, many of them carrying the title of "Dr.". But don’t mistake these "Doctors" for devotees of the Hippocratic Oath. "Stimulus" or economic crank, like any other economic panacea, is a fake cure that gives its victims a temporary but false sense of well-being, even as it sets about causing long term damage to users and the economic community at large. The opium of the economists know as "stimulus" acts directly on bread winners and investors by misdirecting them into production plans and consumption levels which cannot be successfully coordinated or sustained across time. As a consequence, the "high" of this political drug lasts for only a few months, often followed by a depressing "crash" period, which cannot be avoided without further and ever increasing quantities of "stimulus". The drug received its proper name "crank" because it was most often smuggled into policy debates by monetary cranks, the most famous of whom was John Maynard Keynes.

and… 

In fact, the $100 billion is simply extra spending; it is a giant one-time welfare program. To pay for it, the government will borrow an added $100 billion, which will impose $100 billion of higher taxes on future generations.

and… 

We all know by now that the way out of a recession is through the building of capital goods, not through the temporary fattening up of American retailers and Chinese manufacturers. 

Second, government can finance its largesse only by either raising taxes — if for political reasons not now, then in future years — or by borrowing even more. Already today, total public debt amounts to over $9 trillion, or two thirds of annual GDP. About 44 percent of it is owed to foreign entities. It will have to be paid back — whether through years of lower consumption, or domestic inflation, or a reduction in the external value of the dollar. 

Even someone at the Washington Post gets it… 

To pay Peter, you must tax Paul (or at least promise to tax Paul in the future, when your debts come due). Peter spends more, but Paul spends less. 

Now maybe you can time things so Peter goes on a spending spree today but Paul doesn’t tighten his belt until next month. (Then again, maybe you can’t: Paul’s no fool, and he’s likely to start cutting back as soon as he sees higher taxes on the horizon.) But even if you manage to pull this trick off, sooner or later you must tax Paul. So today’s fiscal stimulus comes at the expense of tomorrow’s fiscal drag. 

Moreover, even if you do somehow manage to increase spending, that doesn’t mean you’ll put Americans to work. More likely, you’ll put Asians to work producing goods for the U.S. market. 

Notice the difference?  The partisan tool wants to argue for his faction.  Krugman never questions whether stimulus per se is a good idea.  All he wants to do is flash the wad of money in front of his constituency.  Krugman is a political, partisan tool.  But we knew that.

Of course, Krugman fails even within his limited partisan view.  From his Times article again:

People who have good incomes, good credit and secure employment make spending decisions based on their long-term earning power rather than the size of their latest paycheck. Give such people a few hundred extra dollars, and they’ll just put it in the bank.

See the very last thing there?  I’ve seen other people say the same thing, and have always chalked it up to them not making the effort or taking the time to think it through, but a smart guy like Krugman, allegedly trained to a high level in Economics, ought to know better.

Does he think that the money people put in banks just sits there?  Does the money people put in their IRAs just sit there?  Does the money used to purchase stocks and bonds just sit in a corporate warehouse somewhere?  Of course not.  Putting money in a bank or investing it puts the money into the hands of professional spenders.  The only way money doesn’t get spent is if it is stuffed in a cookie jar or mattress.  And Krugman ought to know that, but apparently he doesn’t, or doesn’t want to say it because he’s a tool of the progressive, socialist, elitist politicians.

Of course, whether those who are on the receiving end of this latest round of government handouts "spend" the money or not is irrelevant to the fact that a government stimulus package is a fraud and farce from its inception.

MikeSoja - January 26, 2008 -- 11:29 am    Filed in: Political Gibberish  
« Casting Stones
Hippocratic Oath Isn’t Worth as Much as It Used to Be »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud