KAYAK2U

January 28, 2008

Charlach Mackintosh is a Good Canadian

Charlach Mackintosh is "chief commissioner" of the Alberta Human Rights and Citizenship Commission, the group that, as she puts it, "invited" Ezra Levant to stop by and have a natter about those cartoons he published lo those many months ago.  Responding to the furor surrounding Levant’s "acceptance" of the HRC’s "invitation", Mackintosh writes in the Edmonton Journal (Holy Cow, it’s -22 degrees F there this morning!)… 

Individuals who have had a complaint made against them are invited to respond in person or in writing to the allegations. This opportunity is provided to ensure fairness in the process.

All invitations carry with them a presumption that they may be declined, and, indeed, Levant was free to have declined his, and under a government that truly respected the individual’s right to free speech (ignoring for a moment the contradiction in said government having created a speech watchdog in the first place), that would have been the end of it.  In Canada, though, declining the nice Human Rights Commission’s "invitation" isn’t the end of it, a fact that Charlach Mackintosh inadvertently (I’m sure) didn’t mention. 

Levant points to Alberta’s Human Rights, Citizenship And Multiculturalism Act sections 23 and 24, which delineate the enforcement powers of Mackintosh’s commission, in way of highlighting the potential threats he is under.

It must be said that the threats, even as things stand today, are only potential (ignoring, again, the fact that even potential threats from the state are impositions antithetical to free intercourse).  According to The Act above, the director of the commission may dismiss for sundry reasons any complaint that comes before him.  However, as Levant’s link to The Act shows, a refusal on Levant’s part to respond to the commission’s "invitations" empowers a judge to… 

make any order the judge considers necessary to enable the investigator to exercise the powers under section 23(1).

A person in Levant’s position has to assume that ignoring the commission will soon result in some less hospitable interactions.  (Of course, a person who chooses to respond to the commission as Levant has done might well assume the same thing.)  I’m not sure who the current "director" of the commission is, but both of the commission’s people (chief Mackintosh and investigative officer McGovern) whom I’ve seen comment on Levant’s travails seem fully imbued with the fraud and ignorance that they take as their mandate, and there is no evidence that the director is cut from any different cloth.  In other words, Mackintosh’s misdirection notwithstanding, Levant ignored the commission at his peril, and continues to suffer the commission at same.

Which takes us back to Mackintosh’s words above, where we see that, for her, it is Levant’s "opportunity" to respond that will "ensure fairness".  That’s on a par with Officer McGovern’s, "[Y]ou’re entitled to your opinions, that’s for sure", spoken to Levant as he sat before her in her capacity as an agent of the state investigating his opinions.  Mackintosh’s disconnect is that "fairness" is defined as following the rules, irrespective of the fraudulent nature of the rules themselves.  At some level, Mackintosh seems to think that as long as Levant is allowed to defend himself before commssion and country that the tenets of free speech are satisfied, even if the opinions she claims he "is entitled to freely express" are found in violation of some nebulous statute.

The bulk of Mackintosh’s statements consist of absolving herself of any fault in that she is just following the law.  Once someone makes a complaint, you see, well, it must be investigated.  Charlach Mackintosh is a good Canadian, after all.

Of course, the law is the law, and some despicable moron might wonder whether Ezra Levant is Morally Innocent, and ought not to have known better, especially in thumbing his nose at the HRC and republishing the cartoons of infamy on his website.  Charlach Mackintosh is not alone.

MikeSoja - January 28, 2008 -- 01:29 pm    Filed in: Freedom  
« Bigger feets…
FCK Me and The State of the Blog »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud