KAYAK2U

July 27, 2010

Proclamations

[This one's been in the hopper for a number of days and may not represent the most up to date pessimism that it could – ed]

And so it was legislated in the year of our LORD two thousand and ten that henceforth man should eat his cake, and yet still have it.  And there was great rejoicing across the land… 

Apparently, our dear Legislators and our dear El Presidenté don't understand how the simplest things work.

I'm talking the brand spanking new financial regulation law, signed and sealed.

Someone left the cake out in the rain… 

Parts of the bond market are shutting down this week as ratings agencies try to figure out how they'll be affected by a last-minute provision in the finance bill, the WSJ reports.

But there's a can of government lipstick that can be troweled over the pock marks temporarily… 

The Securities and Exchange Commission will allow asset-backed bond issuers to omit credit ratings from filings for six months to help them comply with new rules that are part of the most sweeping financial overhaul since the 1930s.

Whew.  The unintended consequences to that stratagem (unintended consequences compounded) ought to be simply astounding.  (As I said at the propagandist Ezra Klein's the other day, "It's a cascade of unintended consequences from here on out. You ain't seen nuthin', yet.")

So, what happened?  The government tried to suspend gravity by fiat, that's what.  In FinReg, the government proclaimed that henceforth the ratings issued by the government anointed, sanctioned, and empowered ratings agencies would be incontrovertibly true and unassailable under penalty of law.

Someone forgot to tell Pelosi, Reid, Obama and crew that *ratings*, whether they issue from Consumer Reports, Bob the Bookie, Michelin, Siskel & Ebert, The Motley Fool, or Standard and Poors, are nothing more than educated (one hopes) guesses at the suitability of a product for a general audience.  The new law would seem to express the idea that relative risk in markets can be calculated (somehow) in such a way as to remove substantially all risk from given transactions.  That's like holding Consumer Reports liable for the performance of each individual coffee maker purchased at their recommendation.  Moody's sez IBM is triple A?  Two weeks later Intel announces "The Discovery of the Epoch" and puts IBM out of business, sue Moody's.  Fitch sez the city of San Bernardino's bonds are rated triple C minus (I have no idea) and then San Bernardino doesn't default and pays its ridiculously high interest rates to everyone who believed, sue Fitch because they cheated *you*, who never bought less than BBB, out of a beautiful pure play.

Or, look at it this way:  What's the difference between one bond rated at AAA and one rated at AA+?  How about a bond rated at AAA and another at BBB?  If AAA means that the company underwriting the bond "will not default" on said bond, does BBB mean that the company underwriting that bond *will* default?  If it doesn't, then what's the difference between AAA and BBB?  If both ratings are merely guesses, or opinions about relative risk, how can one be held to account for them?  In ObamaLand, if the BBB issuer doesn't default on the BBB bond, shouldn't the rating agency have rated the thing as AAA?  And be liable for such lack of foresight?

Or, look at it THIS way:  If ratings agencies can pick winners and losers so much more accurately than anyone else, why aren't they richer than anyone else and selling their expertise on the open market?  And further, what is it about threatening them with criminal sanctions that'll make 'em perform even better?

And once you've answered those questions, can you muster even the slightest optimism that the financial system isn't on the governmentally fostered fast track to ruin?

MikeSoja - July 27, 2010 -- 11:48 pm    Filed in: Commies, Economy, Morons  
« Gormenghast
Your right to a government tow… »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud