KAYAK2U

November 30, 2010

Rule of law

In law of apparent relative long standing, if one wishes to sell certain types of bonds, one must include in the offering documents certain specified ratings as issued by such places as Moody's, Standard & Poor's, and Fitch's.  However, until earlier this year, the ratings were merely for reference, and carried no legal weight and were always rendered with copious caveats.  One could not, upon losing one's shirt in buying bonds, fetch one's prospectus out of the pile, reference the pristine rating, and sue the pants off Fitch, say, for not being sufficiently rigorous in its reading of the pre-entrails.  Ratings are little more than guesses, after all, opinions as to an unknowable future performance based on a limited, albeit arguably informed, snapshot of facts known at present.

In the middle of the year, Congress and the Prez implemented a new law that held ratings agencies to legal standards similar to those to which accountants are held.  But accountants attest to facts pertaining to assets and debts and cash flow and the like at a certain point in the past, all of which are perfectly definable and absolutely ascertainable within generally acceptable and agreed upon accounting norms, while the job of ratings agencies is to prophesy on the likelihood that a financial instrument will perform in a certain way over a period of time in the future, during which time any number of factors and circumstances can change in large and small ways, defying anyone's ability to unerringly anticipate.  

But the brilliant folks up at FedGov passed and implemented the law, anyway, declaiming that ratings agencies were henceforth to be held liable for their sundry prognostications.  No one knows what the Democrats and Obama were thinking, or if they were thinking at all, because the law passed and was signed pretty much without anyone, even the alleged authors, knowing what was in it.  We live in a great country.

So, the ratings agencies, smelling hordes of lawyers at the outer gates, forthwith began refusing to allow their ratings to be incorporated into the official legal documents required to sell bonds in the marketplace.  The ratings agencies aren't stupid, after all, just not infallible in predicting the future.

Therefore no one could sell bonds.  No one could buy bonds.

So, the Securities and Exchange Commission belched out an exemption to the law requiring agency ratings in the offering documents.  Those no longer including the required ratings in their prospecti would not be recommended for prosecution.

The first exemption was for six months, during which time no one managed to rescind any of the applicable confounding laws, or find other ways to compel people to act against their own interests, so the exemption has now been extended indefinitely.

And there it is:  One law (passed somewhat hastily but according to official procedure) so stupid that unelected bureaucrats have had to override an earlier law in order to keep the economy from further collapse.  We truly have become a banana republic.

As the spectacle continues to unfold, I wonder:  Who is the moron (or group of morons) with access to legislative committees who really thinks that making it illegal to make a bad guess about the future will somehow increase the number of correct guesses about the future?  I really do wonder that.

By the way, the notion that bonds should only be bought or sold if some of the paperwork includes officially sanctioned ratings (and certain bonds can only be bought or sold in certain categories if they are rated in certain ways) is more legislative gobbledegook that achieves absolutely nothing in terms of giving people good honest information about products they may be interesting in purchasing, and, in fact, is but one more bit of distortion the meddling government has injected into the markets, the result of which has been in all the news, for several years.

The government cannot legislate financial safety by passing laws that say "A ratings shall not fail ever", "B ratings shall not fail before next Thursday", etc.

It's ludicrous.  The country has become ludicrous.

Good night.

MikeSoja - November 30, 2010 -- 12:55 am    Filed in: Commies, Corruption  
« Breaking News
The beatings will continue… »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud