KAYAK2U

January 24, 2011

Harvest moonbat

I'm always drawn to stories about WalMart, both the WalMart-is-fabulous and the WalMart-is-evil types.  The following is the latter.

Elizabeth McVay Greene, self-assessed "Food and ag entrepreneur", plows some mutilated logic into the henbane of self-promotion.

She's talking about WalMart's recent plan to lower prices on fresh fruits and vegetables in its many stores, and how that's bad.

As the perceived value of fruits and vegetables increases, your willingness to pay for them increases. If you're willing to pay more, the price the farmer gets increases. As the price to the farmer goes up, his incentive to grow that food for you also goes up. When he grows more, supply of fresh food in the market increases and, all else being equal, lowers the market price of that food. Basic needs, flavors, and headlines all influence demand for fresh food, and as you see more value, you probably eat more fresh food and push the market price upward (again, all else being equal).

Wal-Mart is trying to artificially diminish the perceived value of fruits and vegetables. By lowering consumers' expectations about what they should have to pay to eat fresh food, Wal-Mart fools the market and gives farmers no reason to continue growing fruit and vegetable crops. By dropping prices on fruits and vegetables, Wal-Mart isn't making more fruits and vegetables accessible to people who think they can't afford to eat well; it's making it less appealing for farmers to grow specialty crops. If Wal-Mart's approach takes hold, we will see fewer farmers choosing to grow non-commodity crops, and instead of more people being able to eat fresh foods, fewer of us will (even those of us who can afford to pay full price for it). Wal-Mart has chosen the wrong point to press on to serve demand for fresh food and get people to eat better.

[ed. note:  I was going to go through line by line, but it got tedious, so I'm cutting to the chase.]

The first cited paragraph serves best to muddle the meanings of "value" and "price", but outside that, the text amounts to a bobbleheaded nod to a subset of the laws of supply and demand.  Lefties have to pretend that they're trying to work sound theory into their ramblings.

It's in the second paragraph where the roadrunner steps out past the edge of the cliff, and stands there blinking in the sun… 

Wal-Mart is trying to artificially diminish the perceived value of fruits and vegetables.

Taken on its own, that statement is just plain ridiculous, but is probably just a case of Greene again using the word "value" inappropriately, instead of a phrase like, "commonly accepted price".  In Greene's next sentence… 

By lowering consumers' expectations about what they should have to pay to eat fresh food, Wal-Mart fools the market and gives farmers no reason to continue growing fruit and vegetable crops.

… the phrase "expectations about what they should have to pay" would seem to map back to the word "value", though perhaps that's giving more credit than is due.  But all that is prologue to a real ripper of a conclusion.  How on Earth is WalMart "fool[ing] the market"?  Cheap apples will suddenly be what peasants eat, and beneath the contempt of the middle class?  People won't want oranges because they've gone down in price instead of up?  Those organic carrots won't look so delicious to Mrs Average when they're actually reasonably priced?  What the heck?!? 

WalMart is trying to stimulate demand, trying to sell more heads of lettuce, more onions.  Retailers routinely lower prices to stimulate demand.  It's how retail businesses work.  It's how WalMart has become the world's biggest grocery.  Give them some freaking credit.

And if WalMart sells more cucumbers, as they surely will, then farmers will make more money, even if they get a smaller slice of the pie per cuke.  And they'll grow more.  And if WalMart somehow does not sell more veggies, which is ridiculous, then they won't have achieved their aim of putting more vegetables on people's plates, and someone will have egg on his face because the plan will have failed, and WalMart will go back to doing things the old way, because there's no reason to sell fewer vegetables at a lower price if people will buy more at a higher price.

Greene is absolutely bonkers.  And I mean that in the nicest, most civil way.

ps.  For those who haven't read it, here's the WalMart Pickle Story.  I love that story.

MikeSoja - January 24, 2011 -- 09:52 pm    Filed in: Capitalism, Failure  
« More mundane threats
Google Bombs »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud