KAYAK2U

February 21, 2008

Simon Glik is Free…

Glik is the guy arrested in Boston on wiretapping charges (as mentioned here) for using his cell phone to record video of two cops manhandling a teen in one of the many skirmishes in the War on Drugs.  Despite the shitty attitude of the cops, and the best efforts of the prosecutors to further that attitude, the judge had the good sense to toss the thing out.  The Phoenix (which isn’t in Arizona) makes some good noises about the ambiguity (if not utter nonsense) of the current laws in states like Massachusetts:

Even so, neither the Hyde opinion nor Summerville’s decision is likely to stop police in the future from arresting citizens who record their misconduct. 

The explicit statement in Hyde, that the law prohibits only secret recordings, creates a perverse incentive for cops to exaggerate or lie about whether a citizen was surreptitiously recording them in order to obtain a conviction in future cases. The small size of cell-phone cameras makes it easy for a cop to claim that at least part of the recording was done before the police noticed. And if it comes down to an officer’s word against the citizen’s, who do you think wins?

Citizens who want to document police misconduct need more protection than the statute, the Hyde opinion, and Summerville’s Glik ruling provide. As long as state law prohibits secret recordings of police activity, there can be little effective deterrent to police abuse. Without evidence, citizens cannot credibly pursue complaints. Under Massachusetts’s Hyde standard, as Chief Justice Margaret Marshall pointed out in her vigorous dissent in that case, the Rodney King video taper (or a reporter in the same position) would have committed a crime by recording that infamous example of police brutality on a Los Angeles street. 

When cops take off their badges and go home at the end of the day, they should, of course, expect they won’t be harassed by tape-recorder-wielding citizen advocates. But they should not expect privacy in their official speech and actions while on the clock. What the state does is the public’s business. In a democracy, we citizens are the owners, not the servants, and especially not the designated victims. 

The legislature should address this flaw in our wiretapping statute, since the Supreme Judicial Court majority has failed to do so. Good governance and public officials’ integrity are only helped by letting citizens record their interactions with public officials — secretly or openly. Accordingly, one solution to the bad precedent created by Hyde would be to recognize in a reconfigured wiretap law that public officials and employees, and especially police officers, have no privacy right in what they say and do while exercising the authority of office or law. 

Since we’re living in a surveillance society — evinced by municipal street-corner video cameras and the federal government’s warrantless wiretapping program — we citizens should at least be able to turn the tables and surveil those who are watching and listening to, and sometimes abusing, us. It’s still a free society, right?

MikeSoja - February 21, 2008 -- 09:14 pm    Filed in: Freedom, The Police  
« More corrugated tin blows off Fourth Estate roof…
Ryan Frederick denied bond… »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud