KAYAK2U

April 5, 2013

Not seeing the government for the regulations…

… or something.

Every once in a while Denninger spazzes out.  In this case, he does so referencing an Ezra Klein & Co. post without, apparently, reading the full post or the follow up discussion that do nothing to buttress his beef.  Not that Klein & Co. are authoritative in the slightest, which they aren't, but that if they had any inclination to blame the free market on the situation at hand, they'd have done so verbosility like.

Denninger:

1. All these oncologists pay the same, average price? There's no variation in price and no market for these drugs? You can't choose to get them somewhere else — like, for instance, in Mexico or Canada?

2. Further, all these oncologists cannot charge anything other than this same, average price that each of them paid?

Really? Honestly? That's the real situation?

Prove it.

Because if you do prove it, then you're proving that there is a cartel that is fixing prices and restraining trade.

Well, as to 2., it's NOT a matter of what oncologists choose to charge for the drugs they administer, it's what the government Medicare establishment stipulates it will reimburse for the acquisition of those drugs.  Oncologists can attempt to charge whatever they like, but they will only be paid the set fee, which is 6% above of the average price.  And I'm guessing that the "average price" isn't derived from widely disparate low and high prices.  The drugs under consideration are specialized formulations, applicable to limited conditions.  They aren't big money makers for the pharmaceutical companies, though they aren't promoted as loss leaders, either.  And that's their business.

As to Denninger's 1., I'll go out on a limb and say, No, they cannot officially shop for drugs from Mexican and Canadian purveyors, just as average U.S. citizens are not permitted to purchase drugs from outside the purview of the FDA.  Yes, there is a booming gray market in pharmaceuticals, even at the hospital level, but prices are not, unsurprisingly, lower than on the open market.  In fact, unsurprisingly, they are much higher.

Further, even absent conclusive refutations to Denninger's 1. and 2., it is a leap to assume that oncologists have conspired in some "cartel" to fix prices and restrain trade WITHOUT THE EXPLICIT BLESSING OF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT.  And since we're talking oncology in conjunction with Medicare, the supposition of a rogue free market conspiracy is particularly ludicrous.  One may posit with great certainty a private/government cartel, but such is "legal", and Denninger's proposed remedies are off the table, not that such penalties shouldn't be extended to the government facilitators, but Denninger doesn't mention them.

All in all, Denninger's take seems strange to me.

MikeSoja - April 5, 2013 -- 03:39 am    Filed in: Health care, The Wreckage  
« What is Justice?
Best shopping excursion ever »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud