Alvarez, at the Times:
From the very beginning, there was no more powerful theme in the fatal shooting of Trayvon Martin than the issue of race.
Color me provincial, but I thought the most "powerful theme" of the Zimmerman case was the body of known facts adhering to the events of February 26, 2012. The "issue of race" was, and is, an orchestrated sideshow put on by the media to work its agenda of various noxious subplots, one of which is selling sensationalism for profit.
But in the courtroom where George Zimmerman is on trial for second-degree murder, race lingers awkwardly on the sidelines, scarcely mentioned but impossible to ignore.
And the Times is here to make sure you don't ignore it, even though it has no bearing on the facts of the case.
For African-Americans here and across the country, the killing of Mr. Martin, 17, black and unarmed, was resonant with a back story steeped in layers of American history and the abiding conviction that justice serves only some of the people.
The Martin/Zimmerman story can be spun (meaning: dishonestly told) to resemble other stories where justice was not served.
Had Mr. Martin shot and killed Mr. Zimmerman under similar circumstances, black leaders say, the case would have barreled down a different path: Mr. Martin would have been quickly arrested by the Sanford Police Department and charged in the killing, without the benefit of the doubt.
Even if true, it has no bearing on the merits of the case against Zimmerman. Injustices in other cases are deplorable, but each such incident has to be adjudicated on its own merits.
And the assertion is dubious, at best. Trevor Dooley, a black Floridian asserting a stand-your-ground defense was NOT immediately charged with the killing of David James (a creepy ass cracka). Here. Here. Here. He WAS subsequently charged, and convicted, but is currently out on appeal. It should be noted that there were numerous witnesses in the Dooley case, unlike with Zimmerman, though from the little I've read the various accounts are muddled.
The Times continues:
Instead, there was no arrest for six weeks. And only after sharp criticism from civil rights leaders and demonstrations here and elsewhere did the Florida governor transfer the case to a special prosecutor from another county.
Political intrusions into judicial matters via pressure from various factions are always suspect, but in the Zimmerman case, the appointment of a special prosecutor does not amount to a breach of justice, per se. When the special prosecutor is Angela Corey, unfortunately, justice is a secondary consideration.
The Times, again:
“For members of the African-American community, it’s a here-we-go-again moment,” said JeffriAnne Wilder, an assistant professor of sociology at the University of North Florida. “We want to get away from these things, but this did not happen in a vacuum. It happened against the backdrop of all the other things that have happened before.”
No. The only "backdrop" the Zimmerman shooting "happened against" was the few minutes Zimmerman and Martin were in each other's presence. Even the arguments over Zimmerman's concerns with previous break ins, or Martin's seeming flirtations with thug culture, are largely immaterial to what transpired between those two individuals on that rainy night. The motives of the protagonists are negated by the happenstance nature of their encounter.
Yet inside a Seminole County courtroom, with the prosecution’s case against Mr. Zimmerman now over, race only occasionally punctuated the proceedings. The judge made it clear that statements about race would be sharply limited and the term “racial profiling” not allowed. What is more, overtly bringing up race might not have helped the prosecution.
“There is no question that race is the 800-pound gorilla in this trial,” said Ed Shohat, a Miami lawyer who is also a member of the Miami-Dade County Community Relations Board. “But if you overplay that card either way, you lose with the jury. You have to let the jury come to its own conclusion.”
Which is all bullshit, because there is little evidence that Zimmerman was or is a racist. There is evidence that Martin held a racist animus that Zimmerman did not. The Times doesn't mention that George Zimmerman once protested treatment of homeless black man by police.
The Times continues:
For supporters of the Martin family, Mr. Martin’s death was part of a more complex tale of profiling and injustice. But this perception has run up against the protocols of a criminal trial and Florida’s expansive self-defense laws. These laws, critics say, give too much leeway to people who say they acted violently because they felt threatened.
The right to self-defense is a bedrock of our free nation. And, in the wake of the Zimmerman case, the Florida stand-your-ground law (not even used in Zimmerman's defense) was reviewed and left unchanged by recommendation of the reviewing body. The larger body of self-defense doctrine is not remotely in question.
Defense lawyers argue that Mr. Zimmerman, 29, a neighborhood watch volunteer in his gated community in Sanford, was attacked by a visiting Mr. Martin and, fearing for his life, shot him.
There are virtually no ascertainable facts to challenge that assertion.
Prosecutors counter that Mr. Zimmerman, whose mother is Peruvian, set out to confront Mr. Martin and initiated the fight that ended in Mr. Martin’s death.
There is no evidence that Zimmerman "initiated the fight". Period.
The charge is second-degree murder, inflicting death with spite, hatred or ill will. But no one in the courtroom is saying outright that race or racial hatred entered into the shooting.
Because the facts don't support the supposition. If the facts supported the supposition, such facts would be presented.
“It’s like we are watching two different trials,” said the Rev. Al Jackson, a pastor in Richmond Heights, a predominantly black community in Miami-Dade County, expressing frustration over the case and how it is unfolding at trial. “The law doesn’t care how this started, but we do. You are punishing this boy for defending himself, even though it wasn’t his fault.”
Defending himself against what, Rev? Being followed? Being followed justifies a violent response?
Even so, race made an entrance on the first day of the trial. John Guy, a prosecutor, said in opening statements that Mr. Zimmerman had “profiled” Mr. Martin and pursued him because he was suspicious of the black teenager who looked as though “he was up to no good,” as Mr. Zimmerman told the police dispatcher in a call that night. He cited Mr. Zimmerman’s apparent frustration in that call, quoting him making derogatory references to potential burglars who always seemed to “get away.”
Burglars, whether they get away or not, deserve "derogatory references". There's nothing heinous about it.
Race came up again when the jury heard four other phone calls to the police by Mr. Zimmerman reporting suspicious people in the neighborhood, all of them black. The fact that Mr. Zimmerman was studying criminal justice in college and seemed eager for a career in law or law enforcement rounded out the prosecution’s portrait of a would-be vigilante.
The less sensationalist claim, in light of his endeavors within the traditional framework of law enforcement certification, is that Zimmerman was disposed NOT towards vigilantism, but towards professionalism.
Race arose again, in topsy-turvy manner, when Rachel Jeantel, 19, a young black woman who was speaking to Mr. Martin on the phone shortly before he was shot, took the stand. Mr. Martin told her during that call, Ms. Jeantel said, that Mr. Zimmerman was following him; he called him a “creepy-ass cracker.” The defense team quickly jumped on the words, suggesting to the jury that Mr. Martin had profiled Mr. Zimmerman.
Turn about is fair play, I suppose, goes to Martin's state of mind, and stands, if one is hung up on racial issues, as the most overtly racist item in the proceedings. Though I believe Jeantel also said that Martin called Zimmerman "nigga", too, but that was in a friendly sort of way.
In the cocoon of the courthouse, even Mr. Martin’s bullet-scarred hooded sweatshirt, positioned for jurors in a clear plastic frame, appeared less a poignant symbol for the thousands who marched in his name than a lamentable but necessary piece of evidence.
Emotional tripe, non sequitur, etc. It doesn't matter how many marched. The hoodie is a piece of evidence. It's only "lamentable" if its significance as a piece of evidence goes unrecognized.
Still, black pastors, sociologists and community leaders said in interviews that they feared that Mr. Martin’s death would be a story of justice denied, an all-too common insult that to them places Trayvon Martin’s name next to those of Rodney King, Amadou Diallo and other black men who were abused, beaten or killed by police officers.
Zimmerman wasn't a police officer. His case has nothing in common with the King and Diallo cases.
“Profiling, stereotyping, the disparity in treatment of African-Americans when it comes to criminal matters, how imbalanced it all is in the eyes of African-Americans,” said the Rev. Lowman Oliver, the pastor at St. Paul Missionary Baptist Church in Sanford. “That’s why so many eyes are on this case. It’s nationwide and international.”
Maybe.
The makeup of the jury, six women, none black, is occasionally noted. Race also framed Ms. Jeantel’s turn on the witness stand, which drew heckling online from white and black observers who mocked her demeanor. In testimony over two days, Ms. Jeantel, a high school senior and Mr. Martin’s friend, was clearly uneasy in the spotlight, at times impatient and often hard to hear or understand.
Jeantel's problem wasn't her demeanor. It was her inability to establish any sort of veracity.
“She was mammyfied,” said Ms. Wilder, the sociology professor, expressing disappointment over the reaction. “She has this riveting testimony, then she became, overnight, the teenage mammy: for not being smart and using these racial slurs and not being the best witness. A lot of people in the African-American community came out against her.”
Jeantel's testimony was not "riveting", unless one counts the spectacle of it. She was confused, and confusing.
In the past two weeks, defense lawyers have methodically chipped away at the prosecution’s case, legal analysts said, raising the possibility of an acquittal. The law in Florida allows for the use of force if someone fears great bodily harm, and prosecutors must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Mr. Zimmerman did not act in self-defense.
Yeah.
The twists and turns of the case — its weaknesses and legal complications — were not a factor for many supporters of the Martin family, until recently.
“We thought this was an open-and-shut case,” said Mr. Jackson, the pastor in Richmond Heights.
You didn't pay attention to the facts of the matter, did you, pastor? Maybe you should do that ahead of the spectacle, next time.
Mr. Oliver, the Sanford pastor, said he remained optimistic. “You can feel a little sense that anger is re-emerging,” he said.
And that has what to do with anything pertaining to the alleged crime?
The possibility of an acquittal has prompted community leaders, ministers and law enforcement officials in Miami and Sanford to begin preparing. This week in Miami, they will hold a meeting in Miami Gardens, where Mr. Martin lived, to talk about the complexity of the legal case and what has happened in the courtroom so far. They are also reaching out to young people in schools and parks and through Web sites, urging them to remain calm.
“It is important that we still maintain peace, even though decisions are not made to our liking,” Mr. Jackson said. “That is our message, and that is what we are preaching.”
Even the suggestion that trouble may follow an acquittal is fraught with racial overtones, particularly since much of the preparation is focused on the black community.
While the New York Times is busy priming the "black community" to express the outrage that the New York Times would like to see expressed.
But in cities like Miami, which have experienced racial unrest, the ministers and activists said it was a reasonable concern. It is better to be prepared, they say, than caught off guard.
“Everybody wants to know the pulse of the community,” Mr. Jackson said. “It’s not an insult to ask whether we feel there will be unrest.”
Is it an insult to suggest that if you didn't want unrest you wouldn't have inflamed the racial passions of your fellows in trumping up a case against George Zimmerman?
As the trial begins its third and perhaps final week, there is widespread agreement that one fact rises above all others: post-racial America, as some hoped it would be after a black man was elected president, is still a work in progress.
"If I had a son, he'd look like Trayvon". Obama threw down his racialist marker, right there.
“We are going to have to have a dialogue in this nation about racial matters,” Mr. Oliver said.
Except it won't be an honest one, at least at the New York Times.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||