KAYAK2U

July 11, 2013

The Right to Life

I thought I'd seen a fair bit of stupid in the comments at Ezra Klein's grab bag of socialist delights, but today reached new depths.

It started with one commenter saying, "Call me cruel, or mean-spirited but I still don't understand why people think health care is a right. Food and shelter are not rights and they are absolutely critical for life."

Right he is.

And thence began the stupid, with commenter wolfemi1 as sole master of the art:

I submit that they are. If they are not, they should be.

The "they are"/"they are not" confusion is typical of woof.

He then proceeds to develop his theory:

After all, "life" is one of the rights, so how can that right be valid without a right to food and shelter? We provide those to people being punished for crimes, so we do think of them as rights anyway, don't we?

and:

All of the other rights guaranteed in the Constitution are contingent on being alive.

I threw in:

The right to life is a proscription against being deprived of one's life by another person or by government action. It is not a guarantee to the state of existence, which is preposterous on its face.

wolfemi1 came back:

I never claimed it was a guarantee to the state of existence, but keep in mind that through inaction the government can do things that it's not specifically prohibited from.

For example, it could simply stop feeding prisoners. This would be allowed under the "not being deprived of one's life by another person or government action", but it would in effect be killing people. Think laws of robotics: you're not allowed to kill anyone, and you're not allowed to allow them to die due to inaction.

Since we have decided that food is a basic right of prisoners, why should we not make that decision for the larger population who hasn't been convicted of a crime?

At that point, unable to contain my derision, with my comments being deleted, I gave up.

My head still hurts contemplating the utter inanity of it, but I'll soldier on.

What the idiot woof doesn't fathom is that when it comes to prisoners, the state, as part of the judicial process, temporarily (in some cases, permanently) restricts the ability of convicts to exercise their liberty, and their pursuit of happiness.  Except in rare cases, the right to life is left intact.  But because a prisoner's freedom to look after himself is denied, the state takes over that responsibility, providing food, shelter, health care, and a modicum of safety.  It is required to do so.  To "simply stop feeding prisoners" would be beyond cruel and unusual punishment; it would be a death sentence, ie., beyond the bounds of justice.

To state it another way, prisoners, by being imprisoned, do not acquire a right to food per se.  Instead, the state takes on the obligation of servicing the one large right that prisoners retain, their right to life.  Once prisoners are discharged, the state's obligations in such regards is ended.

Also note the implications of woof's corollary, "[W]hy should we not make that decision for the larger population who hasn't been convicted of a crime?"  Well, it is precisely because they are not prisoners, but are afforded the freedom, and with that, the responsibility, to look after their own interests.  Even if people choose to abdicate that responsibility, the rest of the citizenry excercising its own freedom is under no obligation to step in and pick up the slack.  Insofar as the state may force them to, anyway, it is they, then, who are made akin to woof's prisoners, a portion of their liberty conscripted in service to the state's sense of justice.  And that is not in keeping with the principles underlying the founding of the country.

Back in prison, most inmates are required to work, earning from 12 cents to $1.15 an hour (according to the Federal Bureau of Prisons) and they don't get to keep all of that.  One might like to see food stamp recipients afforded the same sort of regime.

There.  I need a drink.

ps.  Apparently Klein's comment auto-moderater doesn't like the word, "Moochelle".  Go figure.

MikeSoja - July 11, 2013 -- 10:41 pm    Filed in: Morons, The Wreckage  
« Tweet the thugs away
Race baiting at The New Yorker »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud