KAYAK2U

July 25, 2013

Let’s discriminate

Maquire argues with Ta-Nehisi Coates who attacks the value of profiling:

If I were to tell you that I only employ Asian-Americans to do my taxes because “Asian-Americans do better on the Math SAT,” you would not simply question my sensitivity, but my mental faculties. That is because you would understand that in making an individual decision, employing an ancestral class of millions is not very intelligent. Moreover, were I to tell you I wanted my son to marry a Jewish woman because “Jews are really successful,” you would understand that statement for the stupidity which it is.

It would not be acceptable for me to make such suggestions (to say nothing of policy) in an enlightened society — not simply because they are “impolite” but because they betray a rote, incurious and addled intellect. There is no difference between my argument above and the notion that black boys should be avoided because they are overrepresented in the violent crime stats. But one of the effects of racism is its tendency to justify stupidity.

Maquire picks it apart in his own way, but here’s another…

If one were required to choose a tax preparer solely on the basis of “Math SAT” scores, it would be natural to select those with the highest scores, balanced against what one could afford, of course.  Coates wants to have it both ways, setting the criteria, while simultaneously noting that the criteria is ludicrous, which of course it is, because he has gone out of his way to so contrive it.

Likewise, were sons directed to choose wives based on the limited criteria of wives being potentially “really successful”, then sons might well opt blindly for Jewish wives based on Coates’s assertion that “Jews are really successful”.  I did.  But then, I’m Jewish, too.  Hey!  (Actually, both Sweet Cheeks’s and my lineage are more rumored than established fact, but we indulge in it, anyway, between games of “Beat Out That Rhythm on a Drum“).

The point being, Coates is pushing examples of “stupidity” that don’t admit the same constraints that adhere to George Zimmerman’s encounter with Trayvon Martin.  Zimmerman’s criteria was limited to the history of crime in his neighborhood, a person he didn’t recognize in that gated neighborhood, and an evaluation that the person was “on drugs or something”, “staring”, “looking at all the houses”, and “suspicious”.  Whether the evaluation as related was honest or not, can’t be known, but it is plausible, without any reference to Martin’s race.  In fact, Zimmerman offered most of his observations before he confirmed Martin’s race to the dispatcher.  One might quibble over whether or not Zimmerman was being coy with the dispatcher, but such speculation cannot be satisfied.

Coates’s final sentence in the quote above is certainly true, but his piece doesn’t establish that Zimmerman’s alleged “stupidity” amounts to racism.

MikeSoja - July 25, 2013 -- 03:54 am    Filed in: The Wreckage  
« Winning!
Honk if you have a horn »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud