KAYAK2U

September 3, 2013

The verbosity of propaganda

It took at least three people to write the new hash on drug shortages for the New York Times, titled, How a Cabal Keeps Generics Scarce.

The "Cabal", of course, is an ostensible artifact of the private sector, and even though the writers end the piece pining for "free-market competition", it's a weak sop offered to counter a picayune aspect of the entire debacle.

Here's the paragraph fisk:

Paragraph 1:  There are ongoing shortages of generic drugs, which ought to be preventable.

Paragraph 2:  There are shortages in lots of drugs.

Paragraph 3:  A recent law (which I made mock of, lo) to tackle the shortages doesn't work, and it's the fault of "giant purchasing organizations" who have "undermined the laws of supply and demand".  Just the bald claim, no supporting evidence.

Paragraphs 4, 5, & 6:  Anecdotes about drug shortages.

Paragraphs 7 & 8:  Blatant rope-a-dope.  An anecdote about a drug shortage that ostensibly led  to the fungal meningitis outbreak last year, with the main blame laid at alleged negligence at the "now bankrupt New England Compounding Center".  For the Times's writers, the important part is that NECC had a "sister company" that had "supply contracts" with some of the aforementioned "giant purchasing organizations".  Just the bald innuendo, no supporting evidence of relevance.  As far as I know, there is no relevance.  NECC was negligent all by its ownself.

Paragraph 9:  The F.D.A. is floundering.

Paragraph 10:  "[T]he purchasing organizations have squeezed manufacturers’ operating margins to razor-thin levels" such that quality control has suffered to the extent that the F.D.A. has had to shut sundry places down.  How could the "purchasing organizations" have done such a thing?  See Paragraph 11.  By the way, no evidence is offered in support of the contention.

Paragraph 11:  "This perverse system was created in 1987 when Congress enacted the Medicare anti-kickback 'safe harbor,' which exempted these buying organizations from criminal prosecution for accepting vendor kickbacks."

The Times alleges that a 26 year old "vendor kickbacks" law is responsible for the current drug shortages.  The government could end the shortages caused by kickbacks, except for "the industry's lobby".

Paragraph 12:  "[R]epealing the anti-kickback" law will restore "free-market competition".

That's it.  It took three people to write that empty, anecdote laden, innuendo heavy mash pointing to an obscure corner of government intrusion into the drug markets, without an iota of substantive evidence to back any of it up.

So does Times roll on.

MikeSoja - September 3, 2013 -- 12:59 am    Filed in: Health care, Propaganda, Shortages  
« Klein Boggle — Roofies
We Own the West Coast »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud