The impertinence of thinking one knows what’s best for other people continues to spread. Science.blog offers up without comment a press release from the Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology (FASEB) which references a big blah blah blah survey it conducted of people who were asked (for instance) who they’d like to get scientific information from. Surprisingly, few people wanted to be taught science by school board members. Yeah, I know, a big shocker there.
The part that caught my attention and that perfectly highlights the idiocy of trying to turn scientists into advocates was in the blurb from the Editor-in-Chief of the FASEB Journal:
“In an age when people have benefited so greatly from science and reason, it is ironic that some still reject the tools that have afforded them the privilege to reject them,” says Gerald Weissmann, MD, Editor-in-Chief of The FASEB Journal.
Is he calling freedom (or choice) a “privilege”? And how are science and reason “the tools” that have “afforded” us this “privilege”? It sort of sounds like Weissmann is parroting the old saw about Freedom of Speech being about tolerating speech promoting intolerance of free speech, but I don’t think he subjected his little ditty to sufficient rigorous scientific exploration. Or peer review.
I suppose that one could say that we owe the establishment of the U.S., and to some large degree the freedoms of Western culture in general, to the Enlightenment (built on the then new disciplines of Science and Reason) that closed the old Dark Ages, but I hardly think that that is what Weissmann means. After all, his entire thrust is against teaching as science the alleged twin invidiousnesses of Creationism and Intelligent Design, in favor of our old friend Evolution, when the latter was still quite a ways from being invented back when all the talk was about the unalienable rights of man. In other words, the freedom enshrined in the formation of this country had nothing to do with the modern “tools” (or the allusions to them) that Weissman hopes to use in flogging our education system into something satisfying his values. If anything, the slow realizations of the human condition that culminated in the American experiment grew up out of the various fervors that Weissmann, et. al., would now have us consign to the proverbial dustbin of history. And without good cause, I might add.
The Theory of Mathematics, or the Theory of Evolution, never granted anyone an ounce of greater freedom. And while one could say that sciences like Metallurgy have contributed to the freedom and wealth of everyone on the planet, one should also point out that no one is “reject[ing]” such endeavors.
So, I really don’t know what Weissmann is talking about, and I doubt that he does either. I suppose it is another case of Galloping Euphemasia, wherein he is caught up in the delusions of his time and can’t quite help himself (even though he has all the proper “tools” to do so right at hand.)
What science and reason ought to teach us about public education is that “the public” ought to be gotten out of it. (In even the short time this blog has existed I’ve all ready made a small post on the matter and further HIGHLY recommend a close read of The Theory of Education in the United States.) The BEST thing that scientists can do is immerse themselves in their science, and not endeavor to go blundering about in public policy and advocacy, unless those are the particular things that occupy their explorations, and even then their reports are as suspect as those spewing from any other discipline. If there ever is any substantive value to what scientists produce, and there certainly is, then people will line up for it, as very many of them all ready do. But joining around in a side of the political struggle that seeks to mold or control those who are perceived to be in ideological error, and using as one’s main article of persuasion the unbridled force of the state, has nothing to do with any scientific discipline or tool that I know about.
It’s my contention, of course, that science would very likely be the beneficiary of a fully privatized education establishment. In the current predominantly socialized school system, science is being forced aside to make room for all sorts of frivolous and popular endeavors that rational individuals might well choose to dispense with were they not shackled to the one-size-fits-all public system.
Even believers in an all powerful almighty might still recognize the value of exploring the full range of human knowledge. It would be nice if they had the freedom to make the choices that have value to them, and right now, despite “the tools” of “science and reason”, most of them don’t.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||