KAYAK2U

March 6, 2009

Heated illogic

In these times of tumult, strife, and rampant incompetence, one never quite knows exactly where to point the ignominious finger of blame.  It’s troublesome.

Is it the ubiquitously rotten state of reportage, or the hubris fevered megalomania of the frustrated despot, or simply just a nebulous ineffable misty morning something missing from the otherwise exemplary public educations of all involved.

I say, "Yes."

First up is a post by Keith Johnson on a Wall Street Journal blog titled, A Heated Exchange: Al Gore Confronts His Critic(s), purporting to highlight Gore’s (non-)response to Bjorn Lomborg, a socialist who criticizes Gore’s blather from a social priority perspective.  Directly under the headline is an embedded video, but all that’s in it is Gore’s well practiced hand gestures and a T. Boone Pickens moment where the two mutually respect and admire each other.  Nothing heated about it, unless watching corpulence admire itself gets your heart pumping.

Further down the post, where Lomborg does appear, Johnson writes: 

[W]ould you be willing to have a debate with me on that point?” asked the polo-shirt wearing Dane.

“I want to be polite to you,” Mr. Gore responded. But, no. “The scientific community has gone through this chapter and verse. We have long since passed the time when we should pretend this is a ‘on the one hand, on the other hand’ issue,” he said. “It’s not a matter of theory or conjecture, for goodness sake,” he added. 

As an example, he pointed to a new addition to the budget for the island nation of the Maldives: “Funds to buy a new nation.”

So, can we trust the reporting of Johnson?  That exchange isn’t in the associated video.  How do we know the words as written reflect Gore’s answer as it was given?  Because, you see, it doesn’t matter one whit if the "island nation of the Maldives" voted to jump off a cliff in celebration of Gore’s birthday as to the "matter of theory or conjecture" about the validity of global warming science.  If enough people raise their hands to the question, "Who believes the moon is made of green cheese?" are we suddenly to assume that yes, yes it is?  Nonsense.

So, who is the moron here?  Is it Gore?  Johnson?  Both?

I say, "Yes."

Can we posit that if Gore and Johnson are blithering idiots in one respect that they might also be blithering idiots in others?  Not definitely, but we can certainly begin to suspect it.

Elsewhere, the ever-increasing contingents of whackos are all over the oh-so-cleverly punctuated Eco:nomics summit with Gore, determined to save us all with their earnest vapidities.  Here’s David Roberts, who could be one of those Wal-Mart price-gouging smiley faces, if Wal-Mart weren’t so indisputably evil: 

The question is always, do the nebulous distant benefits justify the immediate economic costs? 

This mindset informed virtually all the questions the moderators asked (with the exception of Jeffrey Ball, who’s very sharp). With every business or policy proposal, it was, what about the cost? Will people pay the cost? Can we afford the cost during a recession? The one-track-mindedness reached comic proportions a few times. Right after Lomborg, architect William McDonough came out, told a few stories of saving companies millions of dollars, then built his way in a poetic reverie on buildings that could be like trees, fecund and regenerative. WSJ’s Kimberly Strassel paused, and then, I kid you not: "But what about the cost?"

Jaybus. I mean, A, how about having more than one thought, and B, he just told you he saved these companies millions of dollars. S-A-V-E-D. That like … un-cost.

Jaybus.  Jaybus, even.  I bet Roberts is one of those morons whose Visa card is perpetually charged to the limit with all the purchases he made where he S-A-V-E-D himself untold amounts heeding the advice embedded in those tried and true advertising messages which are the favorites of furniture, appliance, and tech stores.  Save, save, SAVE!  If only you buy today!  Untold Savings!  Yay.

Or maybe Roberts believes that having his house environmentally tuned with flourescent bulbs, for instance, has S-A-V-E-D him a bundle.  But one wonders if Roberts threw away perfectly good incandescent bulbs to make way for the flourescents, and subsequently shouldn’t he throw away his older flourescents for the new, improved models, and then, shouldn’t he throw all of them away for a nice expensive (but totally environmentally friendly) house full of L.E.D. lights.  And if (on and on) some smart ass develops something that beats L.E.D.s for efficiency, shouldn’t they be installed post haste if not sooner?  The trouble being, you see, is that the avowed savings come on the back end of the life cycle, and the rapid pace of technological advancement (at least Before Obama) continually seduces one toward interrupting that cycle, mitigating or eliminating the hoped for savings.

And shouldn’t all of that be up to him, Roberts, anyway?  Light bulbs are small ticket items, and so seem trivial to argue over, but what if Gore came around to Roberts’ house and said, "You could really save with a new hot water heater, and that furnace has to go, and some heat reflective windows would be very nice, and some more insulation (just tear out the walls and ceilings, and then put them back!), maybe an earthen berm around the perimeter, some solar cells on the roof, an auxillary wind farm for when the sun isn’t shining, and they’re making some nice composting toilets these days think of what you could S-A-V-E Jaybus!!!!"?  And it’s true, installing all that stuff will lead to big, big savings on Roberts’ energy bill.  Big savings.  So, like, why not be S-A-V-E-D Jaybus!  ?

And further, if the god damned savings are so real, why not be content to allow (I’m begging for "allowance" in an ostensibly free country, that’s what it’s come to.) your neighbors and compatriots the freedom to manage their own assets and redeem their own savings in a manner entirely suited to their own needs and abilities?  Could it be that the petty despot in you is so convinced that you know what’s right for mankind that you don’t give a fig about trampling the rights (and bank accounts) of your fellow men, many of whom are at least as intelligent and caring as you, but hold a different opinion from the one propelled by your earnest despotism?  Again, it’s enough to make me suspect it.

MikeSoja - March 6, 2009 -- 10:19 am    Filed in: Global warming, Incompetents  
« Freeman brambles, Geithner shambles
Modern politics in two sentences »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud