KAYAK2U

August 7, 2009

Klein Boggle

A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.

Recently, Ezra Klein and Megan McArdle had a little back and forth about whether "health care reform" (the banal euphemism for the mighty grab by the government) might inhibit or stifle innovation and new discoveries in the private sector, and whether it might matter.

To begin, Klein, with his usual appeal to authority, trotted out one Dr. Jerry Avorn, who proceeded to emit one non sequitur after another, interspersed with unsupported contentions of various flavors.  To her credit, McArdle whacks Avorn around pretty well, a nice forward smash being, "This makes about as much sense as saying that Dr. Jerry Avorn cannot be that smart because his brain only weighs about three pounds."  Follow the links, read, and you’ll see that’s she right.

Unamazingly, Klein came back with new volumes of nonsense, leading to new appeals to authority under the names of Gruber and Finkelstein.  Asked whether "universal health care would retard medical technology innovation", Gruber said "No.  In fact, there is direct evidence to the opposite," and then passed the baton to Finkelstein, who said, "My prior belief would be the opposite."  Klein seems to assign importance to the fact that Finkelstein and Gruber each used the word "opposite".  I wonder what she meant by "prior".  It begs the question:  What is her current belief?  And, of course, we mustn’t wonder why she only has her "belief[s]", instead of say, a couple of nuggets of factoids that one could go out and verify.

There’s more nonsense in there, all on Klein’s side, to be sure ("If we want innovation and scientific discovery," [Avorn] said, "we should fund innovation and scientific discovery."  Ah, but of course!  If we want to fly to the ends of the galaxy, we should simply fly to the ends of the galaxy!  How utterly CLEVER!), but the whole reason I’ve bumped along this far is because of something posted by Dale Amon at Samizdata earlier today that might have some bearing on Klein’s preposterous contention that governments are perfectly acceptable alternatives (over that nasty private sector) in the drive for "innovation and scientific discovery".

Amon linked an article in New Scientist, and quoted:

In fact, the evidence shows otherwise. In 2003, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development published The Sources of Economic Growth in OECD Countries, reporting on a comprehensive regression analysis of the factors that might explain the different growth rates of the world’s 21 leading economies between 1971 and 1998. This indicated that only privately funded R&D led to economic growth, and that publicly funded R&D did not. Worse, the public funding of R&D crowded out private funding, and thus slowed economic growth.

A link in the article takes one to the 248 page PDF report:  The Sources of Economic Growth in OECD Countries.

Klein, I’m sure, could read that report and cherry pick quotes to buttress his feeble position, but there is much to support the New Scientist’s characterization.

And let us not forget, the most important reason for wanting to leave R&D, innovation, and the pursuit of scientific discovery in private hands is that that is what adherence to the concept of FREEDOM enjoins us to do.  It matters not a jot to me that the current hordes of meddling busy bodies wanting to write policy for the coming authoritarianism think they’re the world’s smartest people, or that they might actually back a winner on occasion.  Forcing people to do one’s bidding, no matter how noble that bidding might be, is wrong.  The fact that doing the wrong thing also very often leads to failure and ignominious waste, is just icing on the argument’s cake.

MikeSoja - August 7, 2009 -- 09:38 pm    Filed in: Commies, Freedom, Incompetents  
« How much perversity can one country take?
Klein Boggle II »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud