KAYAK2U

August 8, 2009

Klein Boggle

A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.

In which Klein takes liberties with the truth.

On the 5th, Ezra Klein cited what he termed a "good editorial" in The Boston Globe concerning the Massachusetts health care fiasco.  Klein quoted, in part:

[The Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation] report this spring put the cost to the state taxpayer at about $88 million a year, less than four-tenths of 1 percent of the state budget of $27 billion.

Klein, allegedly an expert on health care matters (though I suspect he’s more an expert on left-wing political strategies than he is knowledgeable about any real world practical matter) swallows the number uncritically (or counts on his readers swallowing it uncritically), even though it’s as bogus as a number can be.  The anonymous op-ed writer, too, has either made a stupid mistake, or is just plain lying, and anyone familiar with the health care cost numbers coming out of Massachusetts should have seen it.

Here’s the relevant passage from the Mass. Taxpayers Foundation report (PDF) that The Globe and Klein have so badly mangled:

Based on actual and projected spending data for the first four years of health care reform, the Foundation concludes that state budget spending on health reform has grown from a base of $1.041 billion in fiscal 2006 to a projected $1.748 billion in fiscal 2010.  That is an increase of $707 million, half of which is supported by federal reimbursements.  The $353 million state share translates into an average yearly increase of only $88 million.

That’s a yearly INCREASE of $88 million, not total cost.  Are The Globe and Klein incompetent?  Or are they just common liars?  One never knows with these clowns, but squint your eyes, read the passage, and see if you can make the same mistake.

Hell, The Globe op-ed mentions in passing the lawsuit against the state by Boston Medical Center, a lawsuit being brought because the Center is facing a $100 million loss this year which it chalks up to the increased costs of RomneyCare, and neither The Globe nor Klein wonder how one hospital could lose more than the state’s entire health care budget?

Michael F. Cannon at Cato-at-liberty.org read the same Boston Globe editorial and was appalled: 

1.  According to the Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation, $88 million is not the annual cost of the law, but the average year-to-year increase in state spending due to the law.  It’s a marginal-cost estimate, not a total-cost estimate.

2.  The foundation used (uncertain) future spending cuts to make the average annual increase in spending appear smaller.  In 2009, the total cost to the state government, according to the foundation, will be $408 million, nearly five times what the Globe claims.

3.  That $408 million is just the cost to the state government.  According to the foundation’s estimates, the state government’s share amounts to just 20 percent of the law’s total cost of $2.1 billion in 2009. The remaining 80 percent is borne by the federal government (20 percent) and private individuals and employers complying with the law’s individual and employer mandates (60 percent).  Since Massachusetts taxpayers also pay federal taxes and must comply with the law’s mandates, state taxpayers pay much more than $88 million to comply with the law.  In fact, the total cost of the law is about 24 times what the Globe says it is.

Oops.  Mistakes were made.  Lies were told.  Just another day in Collectivist Land.

After citing the spurious (but "good") editorial, Klein made some of his own comments respecting "the Massachusetts effort":

It has been a success.

Like "Cars for Clunkers", anytime you have people piling in to take advantage of that "free" government money, the program is a "success" of social engineering.  Of course, under RomneyCare, some of the "success" comes from the state threating impoverishment or incarceration to those who don’t qualify for the "free" care, if they don’t "volunteer" to play along and pay to make it all happen.

It has radically cut the number of uninsured residents.

Don’t you absolutely love that smarm?  The counter is that "it" has radically raised the number of insured residents that the state (ie., the taxpayer) has to treat for "free".

It has come in at about the cost predicted. It has proved popular.

Let’s turn those mind boggling comments over to the Treasurer of the State of Massachusetts, Tim Cahill, who spoke on CNBC a little over a week ago, as reported by the Washington Post, Ezra Klein’s own employer.  The points Cahill made: 

— The program has so far cost 30 percent more than anticipated.

— It already has a $9 billion shortfall projected over the next two years.

— Costs have risen 41 percent since the program’s inception, well outpacing the rise in healthcare costs nationwide, which stands at 18 percent.

— We thought this program would mean fewer people would go to hospitals, which is the highest cost any insurance plan has to pay. In fact, fewer people are not going to hospitals.

— A Harvard study shows 60 percent of state residents are unhappy with the plan. The most unhappy? Those whom it should be helping the most — those making $25,000 to $50,000 per year.

— To cut costs, the program is now having to kick out legal immigrants.

Remember, Klein is supposed to know this stuff.  But the boy goes on: 

And it has given Massachusetts the courage to contemplate much more aggressive cost control than anything that’s being consider at the national level, or in another state.

Courage?  Like you get from a couple of long draughts on a bottle of Thunderbird?  Courage?  More like the quaking fear of bankruptcy and political failure.

Are you boggled, yet?

MikeSoja - August 8, 2009 -- 01:51 pm    Filed in: Commies, Dishonesty  
« Be a good spot for a FREE country
Catboat! »
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud