"We are determined to meet division and confusion with understanding and compassion – and also with truth," Holder said
Holder should have put "truth" first. Without truth, there can be no undertanding or compassion.
The Zimmerman case has been marked by a false understanding and a false compassion built on the falsehood that Trayvon Martin's actions played no role in his untimely demise.
Holder, et. al., are plainly not interested in addressing that side of the equation. They are seeking with all their hearts further persecution of George Zimmerman.
De la Rionda, who would have cross-examined Zimmerman had he taken the stand, said he would have been interested to see how the former neighborhood watch captain answered several of his questions:
“Why did you assume because [Trayvon] Martin was wearing a hoodie, he was committing a crime? Why did you assume that because he was walking he was doing something improper? Why didn’t you identify yourself? Why did you assume he didn’t belong in the neighborhood?”
De la Rionda’s expectations with those questions is on a par with the ridiculous way the entire trial was conducted. It’s just more of the same histrionics tethered to unprofessional appreciation for the law.
Zimmerman said that Martin looked “suspicious”, not that “he was committing a crime”, so De la Rionda’s question is dishonest.
Zimmerman mentioned more than Martin’s “walking”, that he was “on drugs or something”, “staring”, “looking at all the houses”, so De la Rionda’s second question is dishonest.
Why Zimmerman didn’t identify himself? He probably didn’t want to confront Martin. Zimmerman was apprehensive even when Martin approached or went by his truck.
And the fourth question: Zimmerman didn’t recognize Martin as belonging in his gated community.
Simple, common sense answers that say nothing about what was to transpire later.
The four Jacksonville, Fla., prosecutors — de la Rionda, Angela Corey, John Guy and Rich Mantei — said they respect the jury’s decision but believe Zimmerman got away with murder.
That’s farcical. The jury said Zimmerman didn’t murder Martin, so how can those clowns claim a murder occurred, that they “respect” the verdict, while denying its legitimacy? And they’re in charge of serving Justice in Florida day in and day out?
The four, who said they thought they were going to win the case until the verdict was read […]
The only wild card in the whole deal was the jury, but outside that bit of unpredictability, no one outside the corrupt, biased media and a few true believers thought the state had come close to making its case. The evidence from the first just wasn’t there, and despite stupid Corey’s promises that more evidence would be revealed, it never was.
That “The four” believed their own bullshit right up until the end is reason enough to ruin any sort of legitimacy that they cling to.
“I think [Zimmerman] had the gun out earlier … but we didn’t have the eyewitnesses,” de la Rionda said.
If you didn’t have witnesses, you fucking moron, why do you think it? You’re not paid to imagine things. You’re paid to play your part in ascertaining the facts and presenting them to a jury. If you don’t have the facts to fit your theory, you shouldn’t waste the court’s, and everybody else’s, time.
They believe Zimmerman pointed his gun at Martin not too long after they confronted each other and that the teen was screaming for help.
These idiots think they’re in an episode of “Law and Order” where the last piece of evidence falls into place just before the camera fades to the Vagisil commercial.
On what basis do they “believe” such nonsense? Because they conjured up a psychological profile in their heads representing nothing more than their own dim psychological predispositions? How does Martin go from screaming for help with a gun pointed at him to being on top of Zimmerman, having enough time to break Zimmerman’s nose, bruise his face, and bash his skull, all while the gun is presumably waving around, and not make some substantive grab for the gun thereby leaving his DNA on the thing? The whole supposition is preposterous, and yet the state’s professionals are glued to it.
As they attempted to convince jurors during the trial, they pointed out that the screams stopped immediately when the gunshot was fired.
“It’s common sense. No one stops screaming for help unless they are certain they killed him,” Corey said. “He had said he thought he missed.”
More nonsense from Corey. The firing of the gun marked a significant point in the altercation. It would have been very natural for Zimmerman to have stopped screaming at that point to see what effect the shot had on the situation.
And Corey leaves out one little qualification to Zimmerman’s “missed”. As Zimmerman told police, “After I shot him he sat up. I didn’t think I hit him because he sat up and he said ‘Oh, you got me. You got it.’ I thought he was just saying: ‘I know you have a gun now, I heard it, I’m giving up’.” Zimmerman “thought he missed” because the nature of the altercation changed, and stopped his screaming for help with the punctuation of the firing of his weapon, and because he was no longer being pummeled. It fits much more naturally with the known facts, than the imagined scenario put forth by the incompetent state agents.
The attorneys say Zimmerman’s team exaggerated his injuries and that rain made the pictures of his bloodied head seem worse than they were.
The extent of Zimmerman’s injuries are immaterial to the claim of self-defense. That the state’s clowns are still harping on such adds to the compendium of their overall negligence of their duties.
“To call something an overcharge is to say there was no evidence for the charge,” Mantei said. “There was clearly intentional pulling of the trigger and motive. The question was it justifiable.”
You didn’t have the “motive” you thought you had, Mantei, except somewhere in your incompetent imagination. You ignored the motive of self-defense, despite all the evidence pointing to it.
Corey says they decided not to bring the case up to a grand jury because they wanted to put forward all the evidence.
Yet Corey filed a fraudulent charging document, and her office was negligent in withholding evidence from the defense.
De la Rionda said, “We try cases to win. Hope we bring justice to the table.”
You’ve got it backwards, asshole. You’re supposed to try cases in the name of justice, and not just hope that it fits somewhere on the table.
“I’ve been doing this for 30 years,” said de la Rionda, who has now only lost two murder cases in his career. “We respect our colleagues. I guess they don’t.”
There is nothing respectable about you.
Rem Rieder of USA Today, in a piece titled, Column: Media got Zimmerman story wrong from start:
If [Zimmerman] had stayed in his vehicle as he was told to do by the police, Trayvon Martin would be alive today.
The "Media" is still getting it wrong, even in a piece about getting it wrong.
Once again, the police didn't tell Zimmerman to stay in his vehicle. It was fifteen seconds after Zimmerman got out his truck to run after Martin that the police dispatcher said, "Okay, we don't need you to do that." The dispatcher never said "Don't do that".
Additionally, it was testified to in court that dispatchers do not give orders. It's not their job. Zimmerman was well within his rights to disregard the dispatcher's advice.
And USA Today, and a whole host of other authors and publications should get some remedial reporter training.
Shitweasel Eliot Spitzer opens his yap.
Two words: Mann Act.
Josh Israel at Think Progress cooks up a big one:
While the U.S. Department of Justice did indicate that it would conduct a review of the case to determine whether there were an federal civil rights laws violated on March 20, the Florida state attorney sent the state case to a grand jury on the same day. Only three days later did the president weigh in, calling only for a full investigation and noting that if he had a son, “he’d look like Trayvon.” The federal investigation has been on hold while the state trial played out.
While the Florida jury ultimately found that the prosecution had not proven the case beyond all reasonable doubts, the grand jury in the case also did find that there was “probable cause.”
It is true that on March 20, 2012, Florida state attorney Norm Wolfinger prepared to send the Martin/Zimmerman case to a grand jury, but it never got there. (AND, contra Israel, the feds announced their investigation on March 19th, the day before the grand jury announcment.)
On March 22, 2012, Wolfinger recused himself from the case and Governor Scott appointed stupid Angela Corey to lead things. On April 9th, Corey announced she would not send the case to the grand jury. And to the grand jury the case did not go.
So, what the fuck is Josh Israel writing about?
Obama said, "If I had a son, he'd look like Trayvon", one day after Wolfinger recused himself and Corey was appointed to take over, more than two weeks before Corey took the grand jury out of the equation, and announced her intention to charge Zimmerman.
Think Progress never has been a reputable news source.
The grinning despot speaks:
Corey said she, along with the prosecution, believed that Trayvon was behind the screams that were heard on the 911 call.
"Screams stop the moment the shot is fired," Corey said.
Corey called it a "common sense" piece of evidence.
Zimmerman wouldn't have stopped screaming after the assault was ended?
Peter Gelzinis at the Boston Herald gurgitates:
In what was supposed to be the emotional fulcrum of this trial, Sybrina Fulton took the stand, listened to that scream echo throughout the courtroom, and calmly insisted that the voice belonged to her son. Clearly, a mother’s certainty did not prevail with this jury of other mothers.
I guess Gladys Zimmerman just isn't black enough.
Other hilarity:
Don West, the bald-headed, goateed defense counselor
As opposed to Bernie de la Rionda, not referred to as the bald-headed, mustachioed prosecutor.
Was it about the right to reach for a gun, even if you have nothing more than an uneasy feeling about a kid wearing a hoodie?
Yeah, that uneasy feeling at the back of your skull.
Shameful.
There was even a call for President Obama to address the nation from the Oval Office to promise action to quell projected violence.
There is no upside for Obama in this. His son was just rendered a thug.
Emily Bazelon at Slate ignores her inner ability to integrate facts and throws herself over to emotion:
It feels wrong, this verdict of not guilty for George Zimmerman. It feels wrong to say that Zimmerman is guilty of no crime. If he hadn’t approached 17-year-old Trayvon Martin, if he hadn’t pulled his gun, Martin would be alive.
It's not a crime to approach people, and there's no evidence that Zimmerman so much as "approached" Martin. All anybody knows is that Zimmerman followed Martin, which is not the same as approaching.
And Zimmerman didn't willy nilly pull his gun and shoot Martin. There was the matter of the mashed nose, the concrete, and the approximately forty seconds of screaming for help, before the gun came out.
And then, bizarre:
Here’s the problem: To convict Zimmerman of murder, the six women of the jury had to find that he killed Martin out of ill will, hatred, or spite, or with a depraved mind. The law didn’t account Zimmerman’s fear or feeling of being physically threatened.
But the physical evidence suggested that in the heat of the moment, Zimmerman could have felt both of those things
Esscuse me? One's self defense is rendered unjustified because one is afraid "of being physically threatened"? If one isn't afraid of being threatened, then, what? Zimmerman ought not to have reacted to having the various sides of his head mashed?
And how lame and passive is Bazelon's "feeling of being physically threatened"? Zimmerman possibly misinterpreted Martin's outreach to his nose and skull?
Good grief.
University of Colorado at Boulder professor Paul Campos is all bent out of shape:
Suppose Trayvon Martin had been a 230-pound 30-year-old black man, with a loaded gun in his jacket. Suppose Zimmerman had been a 150-pound 17-year-old white kid, who was doing nothing more threatening than walking back from a convenience store to his father’s condo.
What's the point of drawing a parallel, using completely distorted facts to do it? Zimmerman wasn't 230 pounds or 30 years old. He was 28 at the time of the shooting, stood 5 foot 8 inches and weighed 185 pounds. Martin was 17 years old (the only thing Campos has right), stood 5 foot 11 inches and weighed 158 pounds. Martin was taller, and leaner, though approximately 27 pounds lighter. Apparently Campos thinks those stats don't quite paint the sort of picture he'd like to paint, so he has to lie about them.
Suppose Martin had stalked Zimmerman in his car, until Zimmerman became afraid and tried to elude him.
The "stalked" is more embellishment. Zimmerman attempted to follow Martin. Though the fact was never established, Zimmerman's initial 911 call, and Jeantel's testimony, both seem to indicate the Martin did elude Zimmerman. Martin certainly had enough time to make it home between the time Zimmerman reported Martin ran and the time Zimmerman's call with police dispatch ended, unless Martin didn't, for one reason or another, head for home. There is even enough unaccounted time between the various calls to speculate that Zimmerman and Martin played some kind of cat and mouse game, that ended up, again, by Zimmerman's statements and the testimony of Jeantel, with Martin accosting Zimmerman, but none of that has much bearing on what then transpired. It's not illegal to follow someone suspected of being up to no good. It is illegal to punch someone in the nose just because you don't like their interest in you.
But of course this is America, which means that the scary figure in this story is the skinny unarmed teenager, because in America pretty much any black male over the age of 12 in this sort of situation is going to be presumed to be the ”aggressor,” the “thug” – in short,” the real criminal,” until he’s proved innocent, which he won’t be, even if he’s now a dead, still unarmed teenager.
Campos's "presumed" is nullified by the facts of Zimmerman's injuries. Had there been no injuries, presumptions would have ruled the day. The prosecution had plenty of opportunity to try to prove that Zimmerman was a violent aggressor, but there just wasn't enough there to be there.
Because this is America, pointing out that a black boy can be shot with impunity by a more or less white man because many white Americans are terrified by black boys and men is called “playing the race card.” The race card is what the people who benefit politically from the fact that many white Americans are terrified by black boys and men call any reference to the fact that race continues to play an overwhelmingly important, and overwhelmingly invidious, role in American culture in general. And in the criminal justice system in particular.
That's beautiful: Zimmerman was "a more or less white man". Campos is a professor of law at the University of Colorado, Boulder. No, Campos, "playing the race card" is the taking of a tragic, but open and shut case of self defense, and imbuing it with all sorts of racial aspects with distorted facts and inflammatory racialist rhetoric.
Trayvon Martin was stalked by George Zimmerman because he was black. Trayvon Martin is dead because he was black. George Zimmerman was acquitted of killing Trayvon Martin because the boy Zimmerman killed was black.
If you deny these things, you are either a liar or an idiot, or possibly both.
No one can say that Zimmerman didn't initially notice Martin because he was black. As even the immaculate Jesse Jackson once said, "There is nothing more painful to me at this stage in my life than to walk down the street and hear footsteps… then turn around and see somebody white and feel relieved." Given the history of break ins in Zimmerman's community it's not likely to think that Zimmerman was keeping an eye on things with a completely blank mind. A completely blank mind is not the usual way humans do things. Martin, himself, formed opinions about the "creepy ass cracka" and "nigga" who was following him, according to Jeantel. Any alleged racial animus is immaterial, though, depending on who initiated the violence, and the preponderance of evidence indicates that Martin did. That there is some racial lens that supercedes the particular facts of what transpired, countering the available established evidence, is a noxious by product of political correctness codified in the public mind, if not the corrupt judicial apparatus, and certainly in the main stream press as represented by Salon.
And Martin isn't dead because he was black. He is dead because Zimmerman came to the fraught conclusion that Martin was administering him grievous bodily harm, possibly with intent to kill, testified to by Zimmerman's very real injuries. Zimmerman didn't care whether his head was being bashed by a black guy.
To avow that Zimmerman was found Not Guilty because Martin "was black", is to assert that common law itself, the right to self defense, is predicated on some sort of prejudicial lie. Campos's slimy premise is that a judicial reliance on the particular facts of a matter are immaterial, if "a more or less white man" is thrown into a situation with a black man. When that happens, the rules of evidence, and even the rule of law, should be thrown out, according to Campos. Giant white guy kills skinny black guy, that's all you need to know. Campos would SCREAM if that sort of judicial test were applied in the reverse, though that's the entire thrust of his argument, beginning with his initial supposition that distorts the heights, weights, and ages of the protagonists.
I can come to no other conclusion than that Campos is a liar and an idiot, and also a race baiting asshole punk.
The Daily Beast insults its readers with stupid lies:
“These assholes, they always get away,” Zimmerman told a police dispatcher after spotting Martin—before he disregarded the dispatcher’s instructions and got out of his car […]
By all accounts, Zimmerman was well out of his truck, huffing and puffing along, when the dispatcher advised, but did not instruct, him:
At 2:10 of the audio recording, the vehicle door can be heard to open and at 2:14 it closes. By this time Martin has passed from near the clubhouse toward the area between the 13 and 28 buildings. Zimmerman begins to chase and you can hear the rustle of his clothing and his breathing at 2:19. The dispatcher ask if he is chasing Martin and Zimmerman acknowledges that he is. At 2:26 the dispatcher says:
"OK, we don't need you to do that."
Zimmerman says "OK" and the rustling ends at 2:42.
At this late date, how can a place like The Daily Beast screw that up so badly? With malice?
Jelani Cobb at The New Yorker shucks and jives with a sophisticated bias:
The N.R.A.’s success in passing proactive self-defense laws like Florida’s Stand Your Ground is tied to a decades-long concern with crime that is only marginally tethered to the threat it actually poses.
Zimmerman's defense isn't predicated on "Florida's Stand Your Ground" law. Such laws are, however, precisely "tethered" to particular circumstances, irrespective of overall crime stats. One doesn't get to invoke Stand Your Ground for failure to pay child support, for instance.
A nation doesn’t generate the largest prison population in the world by making assessments based solely on reason instead of emotion.
That statement, directly following the one previously quoted is dishonest in linking U.S. incarceration rates to the sort of crime that self defense laws address. The driver of obscene incarceration rates is not violent crime.
Last winter, George Zimmerman saw a hoodie-clad black male cutting through a subdivision in the rain, and registered him as a threat. There are many white people who do not think of themselves as racist who can imagine themselves drawing the same conclusion. From this perspective, blandishments about Trayvon Martin’s right to move through that neighborhood unmolested are only so much political correctness. And as a result, Zimmerman becomes a sympathetic figure
But that isn't the whole story. Zimmerman isn't "a sympathetic figure" because he behaved as numerous Neighborhood Watch people do every day, but that in doing so he wound up assaulted, with a beaten face and bloody skull.
That Zimmerman now reportedly wears a disguise and body armor in public completes his sacrificial mythology.
It also speaks to the very public threats of extra-judicial justice that have been made against him.
[F]ifty-six per cent of the public believes that the rate of crimes committed with guns has gone up over the past twenty years, when in fact the firearm homicide rate dropped by forty-nine per cent from 1993 to 2010, and the rate of non-fatal violent crimes that involved a gun fell by seventy-two per cent. Thus the assumption among his defenders that Zimmerman was, at worst, wrong for all the right reasons.
Overall crime rates have nothing at all to do with the fact that Zimmeran was on his back, screaming for help, fearing for the disposition of his life at the hands of Trayvon Martin.
We live in an era in which the protocol for addressing even the most severely bigoted behavior very often includes a conditional apology to the offender—a declaration that he has made a terrible error, but is, of course, in no way racist—and, eventually, an outpouring of support for the fallible transgressor, victim of the media and the “race-hustlers.” We grade racism on the severest of curves, and virtually no one qualifies. This apparent contradiction—the prevalence of racist attitudes, the disavowal of actual racism—is key to understanding the way Zimmerman has been received. His actions are understandable, even reasonable, because it doesn’t take a racist to believe black males equal danger
Again, whether "black males equal danger" is irrelevant when someone is one top of you raining down blows.
To bridge the gap between those assumptions and the objective fact of Martin as an unarmed teen on a snack run, it’s been necessary for Zimmerman’s defenders—legal and otherwise—to assassinate a dead teen-ager’s character, to turn him from a slight seventeen-year-old into a rapper in his thirties with facial tattoos.
Martin's "character" was not allowed into court evidence.
The link Cobb provides is to a sideshow that I, closely following the case since it impinged the national conciousness more than a year ago, never saw until two days ago when someone else cast the same aspersion. No one in his right mind would believe that picture was of Trayvon Martin. No one serious ever asserted that it was. The picture may have actually been sent around, but anyone can send any kind of idiocy around. That Cobb affords it any kind of legitimacy in his criticism redounds to Cobb's lack of character, and his dishonesty.
Traces of weed, a few vile tweets, and a suspension from school don’t usually get you menace-to-society status, but for some Zimmerman diehards, it’s close enough to round up.
That, and Zimmermans flattened nose.
An increasingly loud din originating in the conspiratorial right wing, but by no means confined to it, has begun warning of impending race riots should Zimmerman be acquitted.
The "din" is "originating" from Twitter feeds and Facebook statuses of those avowing violent action depending on the results of the trial. It has nothing to do with some alleged "conspiratorial right wing".
That the defense seemingly deployed every known synonym for “weak” in describing their client only makes him resonate even more with people already fearful of crime and worried about angry black mobs taking to the streets.
The mobs have announced their intentions.
In fairness, Broward County sheriffs have proactively begun meeting with community leaders and clergy to plan post-verdict strategies for keeping the peace.
Now why would they need to do that?
For the moment, Zimmerman exists in a sort of racial penumbra. He’ll retain that status for as long as he’s thought of as a Charles Bronson figure for people who are or believe themselves besieged by crime, people who know well the resentments that come in tandem with fear.
Again, Zimmerman's circumstances have nothing to do with any "racial penumbra", but come down to whether or not Trayvon Martin initiated the violence that George Zimmerman felt put him in mortal danger.
Whatever the troubling rationales for Zimmerman’s behavior, they’ll remain subsumed by the drama in the courtroom and the inevitable tide of recrimination in the wake of the verdict, whatever it is.
There are no "troubling rationales for Zimmerman's behavior". He was keeping an eye on his neighborhood, something millions of people do everyday, even without being involved in a Neighborhood Watch program. Zimmerman's notoriety stems solely from the fact that the object of his concern turned and violently assaulted him, which left him little leeway for any sort of rationale other than self-preservation.
Each side will take up their defensive positions, but, no matter what happens, we’ll still find ourselves witness to an undeclared war on crime and our own fears, one led by private citizens and in which a seventeen-year-old became collateral damage.
What noxious bullshit. There is no "undeclared war on crime". The war on crime is fully declared. People's fears about crime are fully justified, even if the stats show a drop in recent years. Crime is still crime, and it's still rampant. And it's an issue that "private citizens" have a very invested interest in, since they are its victims. And Trayvon Martin isn't "collateral damage". He is, or was, the agent of damage. Witness Zimmerman's head.
I thought I'd seen a fair bit of stupid in the comments at Ezra Klein's grab bag of socialist delights, but today reached new depths.
It started with one commenter saying, "Call me cruel, or mean-spirited but I still don't understand why people think health care is a right. Food and shelter are not rights and they are absolutely critical for life."
Right he is.
And thence began the stupid, with commenter wolfemi1 as sole master of the art:
I submit that they are. If they are not, they should be.
The "they are"/"they are not" confusion is typical of woof.
He then proceeds to develop his theory:
After all, "life" is one of the rights, so how can that right be valid without a right to food and shelter? We provide those to people being punished for crimes, so we do think of them as rights anyway, don't we?
and:
All of the other rights guaranteed in the Constitution are contingent on being alive.
I threw in:
The right to life is a proscription against being deprived of one's life by another person or by government action. It is not a guarantee to the state of existence, which is preposterous on its face.
wolfemi1 came back:
I never claimed it was a guarantee to the state of existence, but keep in mind that through inaction the government can do things that it's not specifically prohibited from.
For example, it could simply stop feeding prisoners. This would be allowed under the "not being deprived of one's life by another person or government action", but it would in effect be killing people. Think laws of robotics: you're not allowed to kill anyone, and you're not allowed to allow them to die due to inaction.
Since we have decided that food is a basic right of prisoners, why should we not make that decision for the larger population who hasn't been convicted of a crime?
At that point, unable to contain my derision, with my comments being deleted, I gave up.
My head still hurts contemplating the utter inanity of it, but I'll soldier on.
What the idiot woof doesn't fathom is that when it comes to prisoners, the state, as part of the judicial process, temporarily (in some cases, permanently) restricts the ability of convicts to exercise their liberty, and their pursuit of happiness. Except in rare cases, the right to life is left intact. But because a prisoner's freedom to look after himself is denied, the state takes over that responsibility, providing food, shelter, health care, and a modicum of safety. It is required to do so. To "simply stop feeding prisoners" would be beyond cruel and unusual punishment; it would be a death sentence, ie., beyond the bounds of justice.
To state it another way, prisoners, by being imprisoned, do not acquire a right to food per se. Instead, the state takes on the obligation of servicing the one large right that prisoners retain, their right to life. Once prisoners are discharged, the state's obligations in such regards is ended.
Also note the implications of woof's corollary, "[W]hy should we not make that decision for the larger population who hasn't been convicted of a crime?" Well, it is precisely because they are not prisoners, but are afforded the freedom, and with that, the responsibility, to look after their own interests. Even if people choose to abdicate that responsibility, the rest of the citizenry excercising its own freedom is under no obligation to step in and pick up the slack. Insofar as the state may force them to, anyway, it is they, then, who are made akin to woof's prisoners, a portion of their liberty conscripted in service to the state's sense of justice. And that is not in keeping with the principles underlying the founding of the country.
Back in prison, most inmates are required to work, earning from 12 cents to $1.15 an hour (according to the Federal Bureau of Prisons) and they don't get to keep all of that. One might like to see food stamp recipients afforded the same sort of regime.
There. I need a drink.
ps. Apparently Klein's comment auto-moderater doesn't like the word, "Moochelle". Go figure.
Down in Angela Corey land:
Police in Broward County fear that Twitter could be used to organize flash mob violence if George Zimmerman is acquitted, with authorities planning to flood the social network with anti-riot messages.
Oh, that ought to work.
If I were a business down Florida way, I'd be trying to hire me a George Zimmerman or two.
Of course, Georgie may get the noose, in which case there will be celebratory riots, and the wise asset holder will likewise be prepared.
In any event, buy stock in Revs. Sharpton and Jackson. They are the future.
Jones, at CNN, grounds and pounds the dominant white male judicial heirarchy, without any sense of irony respecting the parallels to the Martin/Zimmerman case she's covering:
Said Crump then: "The jury will have to hear all of the evidence. We think this is a simple case. No. 1: Zimmerman was a grown man with a gun. No. 2: Trayvon was a child with no blood on his hands. Literally."
[…]
"You have a young black kid, walking with a sweatshirt on and some guy, who wants to be a cop, assumes he's a criminal and shoots him dead."
[…]
This is a murder case. One person is dead, and the other person is a murderer.
[…]
We should […] remind America that when an unarmed child is confronted and gunned down in the street by a grown man who's trained to kill, that's murder. End of story.
That argument (each of those statements is the same argument) is exactly the same assault on reason that Trayvon Martin exercised in a more physical way on "creepy ass cracka" George Zimmerman. Martin assaulted the "white" guy who had the temerity to concern himself with crime in his neighborhood, while Jones assaults the judicial system that deigns to concern itself with the particulars of what transpired between Martin and Zimmerman. Both assaults are bereft of reason. Both assaults are grown of racial animus. Both assaults are predicated on an appeal to force; in Martin's case, an immediate, unjustified application of force in response to being observed; in Jones's case, an equally emotional, unjustified, lashing out at the system that seeks to minutely observe the issue.
And while Martin had no appreciation for the passion play his violence was about to engender, Jones ought to know better. Martin undoubtedly hoped to gain some street cred with his assault on Zimmerman, and undoubtedly Jones hopes likewise with her assault on the judicial system, but as "an award-winning editor, reporter, writer and producer" she should appreciate that her argument is as dead as Trayvon Martin is dead.
The following, for instance, offered as argument by Jones:
"This case is a perfect storm," says Xavier Donaldson, a defense attorney and former prosecutor in New York. "You have to look at the nature of the case and the racial, political and social economics of the defendant and accused. You have a young black kid, walking with a sweatshirt on and some guy, who wants to be a cop, assumes he's a criminal and shoots him dead." Zimmerman has pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder.
"Zimmerman had an image in his community as a good guy, who wanted to protect people. So he — and not Martin, the victim — has gotten the benefit of presumption of innocence. Normally, in murder cases that doesn't happen. People generally believe that if you've been arrested and charged that you must have done something wrong, but those lines are blurred here," says Donaldson.
Who, in this country, would hire a defense attorney who proceeds from the allegedly popular belief that "if you've been arrested and charged that you must have done something wrong"? Donaldson is doing nothing less than grounding and pounding common law.
Why has Trayvon Martin not been granted the presumption of innocence? Because he is not on trial. Had he lived, he might very well have been charged with assault, and then afforded his day in court to stand against the proofs against him. His innocence would have been assumed until the rendering of a verdict.
Why is George Zimmerman afforded the presumption of innocence? Because he is on trial, accused of murder. As in all other cases, the state has to prove its allegations beyond a reasonable doubt. Innocence is assumed until the preponderance of facts outweigh the presumption. That's how it works. That's the best method humans have come up with to sort these kinds of matters out.
Trayvon Martin sought to exact his sense of justice by assaulting George Zimmerman for the affront of being singled out and observed, which isn't a crime at all.
Roxanne Jones pursues her sense of justice by assaulting common law jurisprudence for the affront of its very standards, which are the basis of justice.
Martin and Jones are both thugs.
Why Zimmerman’s Motion for Acquittal Should Have Been Granted
Alvarez, at the Times:
From the very beginning, there was no more powerful theme in the fatal shooting of Trayvon Martin than the issue of race.
Color me provincial, but I thought the most "powerful theme" of the Zimmerman case was the body of known facts adhering to the events of February 26, 2012. The "issue of race" was, and is, an orchestrated sideshow put on by the media to work its agenda of various noxious subplots, one of which is selling sensationalism for profit.
But in the courtroom where George Zimmerman is on trial for second-degree murder, race lingers awkwardly on the sidelines, scarcely mentioned but impossible to ignore.
And the Times is here to make sure you don't ignore it, even though it has no bearing on the facts of the case.
For African-Americans here and across the country, the killing of Mr. Martin, 17, black and unarmed, was resonant with a back story steeped in layers of American history and the abiding conviction that justice serves only some of the people.
The Martin/Zimmerman story can be spun (meaning: dishonestly told) to resemble other stories where justice was not served.
Had Mr. Martin shot and killed Mr. Zimmerman under similar circumstances, black leaders say, the case would have barreled down a different path: Mr. Martin would have been quickly arrested by the Sanford Police Department and charged in the killing, without the benefit of the doubt.
Even if true, it has no bearing on the merits of the case against Zimmerman. Injustices in other cases are deplorable, but each such incident has to be adjudicated on its own merits.
And the assertion is dubious, at best. Trevor Dooley, a black Floridian asserting a stand-your-ground defense was NOT immediately charged with the killing of David James (a creepy ass cracka). Here. Here. Here. He WAS subsequently charged, and convicted, but is currently out on appeal. It should be noted that there were numerous witnesses in the Dooley case, unlike with Zimmerman, though from the little I've read the various accounts are muddled.
The Times continues:
Instead, there was no arrest for six weeks. And only after sharp criticism from civil rights leaders and demonstrations here and elsewhere did the Florida governor transfer the case to a special prosecutor from another county.
Political intrusions into judicial matters via pressure from various factions are always suspect, but in the Zimmerman case, the appointment of a special prosecutor does not amount to a breach of justice, per se. When the special prosecutor is Angela Corey, unfortunately, justice is a secondary consideration.
The Times, again:
“For members of the African-American community, it’s a here-we-go-again moment,” said JeffriAnne Wilder, an assistant professor of sociology at the University of North Florida. “We want to get away from these things, but this did not happen in a vacuum. It happened against the backdrop of all the other things that have happened before.”
No. The only "backdrop" the Zimmerman shooting "happened against" was the few minutes Zimmerman and Martin were in each other's presence. Even the arguments over Zimmerman's concerns with previous break ins, or Martin's seeming flirtations with thug culture, are largely immaterial to what transpired between those two individuals on that rainy night. The motives of the protagonists are negated by the happenstance nature of their encounter.
Yet inside a Seminole County courtroom, with the prosecution’s case against Mr. Zimmerman now over, race only occasionally punctuated the proceedings. The judge made it clear that statements about race would be sharply limited and the term “racial profiling” not allowed. What is more, overtly bringing up race might not have helped the prosecution.
“There is no question that race is the 800-pound gorilla in this trial,” said Ed Shohat, a Miami lawyer who is also a member of the Miami-Dade County Community Relations Board. “But if you overplay that card either way, you lose with the jury. You have to let the jury come to its own conclusion.”
Which is all bullshit, because there is little evidence that Zimmerman was or is a racist. There is evidence that Martin held a racist animus that Zimmerman did not. The Times doesn't mention that George Zimmerman once protested treatment of homeless black man by police.
The Times continues:
For supporters of the Martin family, Mr. Martin’s death was part of a more complex tale of profiling and injustice. But this perception has run up against the protocols of a criminal trial and Florida’s expansive self-defense laws. These laws, critics say, give too much leeway to people who say they acted violently because they felt threatened.
The right to self-defense is a bedrock of our free nation. And, in the wake of the Zimmerman case, the Florida stand-your-ground law (not even used in Zimmerman's defense) was reviewed and left unchanged by recommendation of the reviewing body. The larger body of self-defense doctrine is not remotely in question.
Defense lawyers argue that Mr. Zimmerman, 29, a neighborhood watch volunteer in his gated community in Sanford, was attacked by a visiting Mr. Martin and, fearing for his life, shot him.
There are virtually no ascertainable facts to challenge that assertion.
Prosecutors counter that Mr. Zimmerman, whose mother is Peruvian, set out to confront Mr. Martin and initiated the fight that ended in Mr. Martin’s death.
There is no evidence that Zimmerman "initiated the fight". Period.
The charge is second-degree murder, inflicting death with spite, hatred or ill will. But no one in the courtroom is saying outright that race or racial hatred entered into the shooting.
Because the facts don't support the supposition. If the facts supported the supposition, such facts would be presented.
“It’s like we are watching two different trials,” said the Rev. Al Jackson, a pastor in Richmond Heights, a predominantly black community in Miami-Dade County, expressing frustration over the case and how it is unfolding at trial. “The law doesn’t care how this started, but we do. You are punishing this boy for defending himself, even though it wasn’t his fault.”
Defending himself against what, Rev? Being followed? Being followed justifies a violent response?
Even so, race made an entrance on the first day of the trial. John Guy, a prosecutor, said in opening statements that Mr. Zimmerman had “profiled” Mr. Martin and pursued him because he was suspicious of the black teenager who looked as though “he was up to no good,” as Mr. Zimmerman told the police dispatcher in a call that night. He cited Mr. Zimmerman’s apparent frustration in that call, quoting him making derogatory references to potential burglars who always seemed to “get away.”
Burglars, whether they get away or not, deserve "derogatory references". There's nothing heinous about it.
Race came up again when the jury heard four other phone calls to the police by Mr. Zimmerman reporting suspicious people in the neighborhood, all of them black. The fact that Mr. Zimmerman was studying criminal justice in college and seemed eager for a career in law or law enforcement rounded out the prosecution’s portrait of a would-be vigilante.
The less sensationalist claim, in light of his endeavors within the traditional framework of law enforcement certification, is that Zimmerman was disposed NOT towards vigilantism, but towards professionalism.
Race arose again, in topsy-turvy manner, when Rachel Jeantel, 19, a young black woman who was speaking to Mr. Martin on the phone shortly before he was shot, took the stand. Mr. Martin told her during that call, Ms. Jeantel said, that Mr. Zimmerman was following him; he called him a “creepy-ass cracker.” The defense team quickly jumped on the words, suggesting to the jury that Mr. Martin had profiled Mr. Zimmerman.
Turn about is fair play, I suppose, goes to Martin's state of mind, and stands, if one is hung up on racial issues, as the most overtly racist item in the proceedings. Though I believe Jeantel also said that Martin called Zimmerman "nigga", too, but that was in a friendly sort of way.
In the cocoon of the courthouse, even Mr. Martin’s bullet-scarred hooded sweatshirt, positioned for jurors in a clear plastic frame, appeared less a poignant symbol for the thousands who marched in his name than a lamentable but necessary piece of evidence.
Emotional tripe, non sequitur, etc. It doesn't matter how many marched. The hoodie is a piece of evidence. It's only "lamentable" if its significance as a piece of evidence goes unrecognized.
Still, black pastors, sociologists and community leaders said in interviews that they feared that Mr. Martin’s death would be a story of justice denied, an all-too common insult that to them places Trayvon Martin’s name next to those of Rodney King, Amadou Diallo and other black men who were abused, beaten or killed by police officers.
Zimmerman wasn't a police officer. His case has nothing in common with the King and Diallo cases.
“Profiling, stereotyping, the disparity in treatment of African-Americans when it comes to criminal matters, how imbalanced it all is in the eyes of African-Americans,” said the Rev. Lowman Oliver, the pastor at St. Paul Missionary Baptist Church in Sanford. “That’s why so many eyes are on this case. It’s nationwide and international.”
Maybe.
The makeup of the jury, six women, none black, is occasionally noted. Race also framed Ms. Jeantel’s turn on the witness stand, which drew heckling online from white and black observers who mocked her demeanor. In testimony over two days, Ms. Jeantel, a high school senior and Mr. Martin’s friend, was clearly uneasy in the spotlight, at times impatient and often hard to hear or understand.
Jeantel's problem wasn't her demeanor. It was her inability to establish any sort of veracity.
“She was mammyfied,” said Ms. Wilder, the sociology professor, expressing disappointment over the reaction. “She has this riveting testimony, then she became, overnight, the teenage mammy: for not being smart and using these racial slurs and not being the best witness. A lot of people in the African-American community came out against her.”
Jeantel's testimony was not "riveting", unless one counts the spectacle of it. She was confused, and confusing.
In the past two weeks, defense lawyers have methodically chipped away at the prosecution’s case, legal analysts said, raising the possibility of an acquittal. The law in Florida allows for the use of force if someone fears great bodily harm, and prosecutors must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Mr. Zimmerman did not act in self-defense.
Yeah.
The twists and turns of the case — its weaknesses and legal complications — were not a factor for many supporters of the Martin family, until recently.
“We thought this was an open-and-shut case,” said Mr. Jackson, the pastor in Richmond Heights.
You didn't pay attention to the facts of the matter, did you, pastor? Maybe you should do that ahead of the spectacle, next time.
Mr. Oliver, the Sanford pastor, said he remained optimistic. “You can feel a little sense that anger is re-emerging,” he said.
And that has what to do with anything pertaining to the alleged crime?
The possibility of an acquittal has prompted community leaders, ministers and law enforcement officials in Miami and Sanford to begin preparing. This week in Miami, they will hold a meeting in Miami Gardens, where Mr. Martin lived, to talk about the complexity of the legal case and what has happened in the courtroom so far. They are also reaching out to young people in schools and parks and through Web sites, urging them to remain calm.
“It is important that we still maintain peace, even though decisions are not made to our liking,” Mr. Jackson said. “That is our message, and that is what we are preaching.”
Even the suggestion that trouble may follow an acquittal is fraught with racial overtones, particularly since much of the preparation is focused on the black community.
While the New York Times is busy priming the "black community" to express the outrage that the New York Times would like to see expressed.
But in cities like Miami, which have experienced racial unrest, the ministers and activists said it was a reasonable concern. It is better to be prepared, they say, than caught off guard.
“Everybody wants to know the pulse of the community,” Mr. Jackson said. “It’s not an insult to ask whether we feel there will be unrest.”
Is it an insult to suggest that if you didn't want unrest you wouldn't have inflamed the racial passions of your fellows in trumping up a case against George Zimmerman?
As the trial begins its third and perhaps final week, there is widespread agreement that one fact rises above all others: post-racial America, as some hoped it would be after a black man was elected president, is still a work in progress.
"If I had a son, he'd look like Trayvon". Obama threw down his racialist marker, right there.
“We are going to have to have a dialogue in this nation about racial matters,” Mr. Oliver said.
Except it won't be an honest one, at least at the New York Times.
I show it has rained for the last sixteen days, with something over five inches of the stuff in just the last few. The creek is up, to say the least, but man is everything growing.
In the interest of closing tabs…
The deputy director of the Tennessee Division of Water Resources, who admonished water quality complainants that their complaints could be considered "an act of terrorism" is now the former deputy director of the Division of Water Resources. He was demoted "to a lower-ranking position" where his professionalism will be less of an embarrassment to his agency.
—
In Henderson, Nevada, the police are upstanding believers in Truth, Justice, and the New American Way:
"Defendant Officer David Cawthorn outlined the defendants' plan in his official report: 'It was determined to move to 367 Evening Side and attempt to contact Mitchell. If Mitchell answered the door he would be asked to leave. If he refused to leave he would be arrested for Obstructing a Police Officer. If Mitchell refused to answer the door, force entry would be made and Mitchell would be arrested.'"
The stalwart officers successfully carried out their plan, along with committing subsequent atrocities, and two years on have not been punished in the slightest. But, hey, same sex marriage.
—
In the wake of the terrible tragedy at Yarnell, a mixed bag of suggested "reforms" that do nothing so well as highlight the problem.
—
More Executive Branch Kabuki re ObamaCare: An invitation to fraud.
—
Another emotional screed that studiously ignores the possibility that Trayvon Martin might have been the initiator of force against George Zimmeran with the intent to maim or kill him. I guess Zimmerman smashed his nose into Martin's fist and then fell back hitting his own head several times on the sidewalk.
—
And the rain just keeps on coming.
I ran across "The American Revolution was flop" at one of The Nation sites, but it apparently was reprinted from the lovely Washington Post (now slowly slipping behind a paywall.)
The thing is despicable in all its particulars. The premise is that the rhetorical promises of "advancing life, liberty,and the pursuit of happiness" have not been delivered, with a paragraph or so for each particular meant to substantiate the conclusion stated in the title.
For "life and liberty", the sole argument offered is that "in British-controlled Canada, the abolition of slavery began almost 20 years before the War of 1812", refering, without stating it, to the 1793 Act Against Slavery, which "freed no slaves". By contrast, most northern U.S. states had abolished slavery by 1804. Also unmentioned in the piece is that slavery in Canada was largely practiced by aboriginal tribes raiding their aboriginal neighbors, with black slaves imported from the U.S. or elsewhere a distinct minority, with overall numbers in any case miniscule compared to the U.S. Canada wasn't suited for plantations, and most black slaves were held as domestic servants.
Continuing with "liberty" the low author cites the U.S. incarceration rate, currently the highest per capita in the world. That factoid certainly is outrageous, and a blot on the nation, but it ignores the fact that it wasn't always so. In fact, U.S. incarceration rates shot up from the 1970s with the misquided advent of the War on Drugs, nicely matching the not-exactly uncoincidental growth of the U.S. government into all areas of what were once private endeavors, leading inexorably to the current state of affairs with multiple bureaucracies incarcerating people for such things as selling unpasteurized milk to willing buyers, wearing t-shirts with NRA logos, pointing fingers like a gun, and filming the police. Such things, including the criminality of smoking or growing marijuana, et. al., are not the remnants of a failed embrace of freedom, but are the distinct large artifacts of the erosion of that freedom.
The author's last and longest winded jab is at the "pursuit of happiness", citing "51st in life expectancy at birth", and a couple of studies allegedly quantifying "life satisfaction", as though happiness in any true sense is quantifiable. Perhaps happiness for some people is enjoying themselves into an early grave. I probably qualify for that, and I'm still here. It's my life, and I have a fair amount of fun. The studies, of course, even without looking, are larded with arbitrary government-centric measures of what constitutes the worthwhile life. Health insurance. Mandated vacations. Pre- and post-natal care on the collective's dime, or somesuch. And the author doesn't seem to be able to cite any "loss" in happiness over the year, just a "half century without gains".
Maybe the human condition and our appreciation of it is somewhat of a constant.
In which case, all the fol-de-rol busybodying about how to make things better for everyone else is just so much wasted effort, and best aggressively pushed back in people's noses.
And the Washington Post is a continued disgrace, along with others who reprinted the thing.
Duh headline: State Department bureau spent $630,000 on Facebook 'likes'.
Without a doubt, most government "likes" come from government employees.
Do the pathology.
Go find government YouTube videos and look at the views. Not a lot of "gone viral" examples, are there? Bullshit isn't a big draw? Imagine.
Otherwise, there are no hit counters on government sites for a very good reason.
Guess the reason.
It's all a very expensive charade.
Some intrepid reporter somewhere should look into it.
Alexandra Robbins tappity taps out 7,300 words that amount to absolutely nothing other than to make clear that drug shortages are growing in the U.S. The piece is big on highlighting the problem with anecdote upon anecdote, but like so many similar pieces, doesn't come within a country mile of fingering the cause.
No mention of federally imposed quotas on drug manufacturers. No mention of federally imposed price controls. No mention of the role of Medicare in undermining a once competitive pharmaceutical industry.
Robbins does take a few weak swipes at the FDA, but every solution to do something about the shortages ends as a call for more FDA involvement in things, the very prescription that has contributed to the ongoing crisis.
7,300 words of nothing useful, and all the ignorance and wasted effort is encapsulated in these few words: "How could this be allowed to happen?"
That short question establishes beyond doubt the writer's complete ignorance about how businesses and markets operate, and the effects of government interference in same. The shortages haven't been "allowed to happen". They've been mandated. They've been forced to happen. Shortages are the inevitable outcome of government imposed quotas, price controls, and the relentless pressure from the nation's biggest drug buyer to lower costs to the point of lost capacity and unsustainability. Shortages are the result of an industry NOT being "allowed" to freely meet the demands of the market. It is the insidious short-sighted inclination of idiots like Robbins, convinced of a superiority of intellect based on little more than the awesomeness of their ability to be empathetic (as if that can so much as buy a cup of coffee), on such little basis convinced that they must "get something done", without having the slightest appreciation for what it takes to run something as large as a drug plant, that sends them running to the government to start throwing monkey wrenches into the works.
It's just disgraceful. It really is.
I started to write last night, but quickly boggled at the numerous absurdities re Jeantel's testifying in the Zimmerman trial, and the follow on media disgrace. I was trying to sort out the four court videos at Legal Insurrection (scroll down past the others, if you wish) from Wednesday's session, unable to put my finger on it.
The press is dutifully thrashing itself debating Jeantel's "credibility", or, as the NY Times put it "her powerful account".
But the debate is nonsense.
The issue of Jeantel's credibility doesn't come down to the various versions of the stories she's told. It doesn't come down to her sad illiteracy. It's not about whether she's unafraid to float a lie or two, or the subsequently introspected, pathetic justifications with which she admits to doing so. It's not her trite, boring attitude. It's not completely about her inability to fathom simple declarative sentences or to understand simple questions, or her inability to answer those questions with anything approaching relevance. It's not about her being unable to adjust to being told to speak more clearly and loudly. It's not about her disinterest in what happened to Trayvon Martin after she purportedly heard the sounds of a fight and the phone went dead. It's not down to her teenage shallowness. It's not about her mundane racism.
It's all of it together.
Almost any person would be hard pressed to remember every particular detail of a night such as the one under scrutiny. The more time that passes, studies show, practice shows, unsurprisingly, the less accurately do people recall. So under what presumptions is someone like Jeantel afforded so much as the time of day? She starts from a huge, personal disadvantage, and then has been buffeted by the likes of Crump, et. al., Martin's parents, her own peeps (can I say that here?), the media, and even the ostensibly earnest yet persistently obnoxious defense team.
Yet, are we obligated to grant her some sort of respect for the fact that she actually may be able to recall some portions of a some conversations accurately? Do we assay her testimony like some clever phrenologists groping over the bumps of her various pathologies certain that we can, in our own proud minds, find the semblance of truth in a life and death matter?
I don't see how it's possible.
The best history/roundup I've seen.
The people of Maury County, Tennessee, have reportedly been complaining for months that there is something wrong with their water. A meeting of the various parties was organized by a state representative, and a chill descended upon the room:
A Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation deputy director warned a group of Maury County residents that unfounded complaints about water quality could be considered an “act of terrorism.”
“We take water quality very seriously. Very, very seriously,” said Sherwin Smith, deputy director of TDEC’s Division of Water Resources, according to audio recorded by attendees. “But you need to make sure that when you make water quality complaints you have a basis, because federally, if there’s no water quality issues, that can be considered under Homeland Security an act of terrorism.”
“Can you say that again, please?” an audience member can be heard asking on the audio.
Smith went on in the recording to repeat the claim almost verbatim.
Sherwin Smith has really caught the spirit of the times, I'd say. His forward thinking on behalf of the state's vested interests mark him as an up and comer with prospects for a solid future in nationwide peon control.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||