Humana Inc. thought it was free to conduct its own business in its own way. It was wrong.
But, that’s what you get when you crawl into bed with the fucking State.
What’s up with that, Paul, is that you’re getting exactly the kind of bonehead-Left dictatorship you voted for; you got suckered by the old Hopeychange bait and switch, and ignorance of the nature of the game is no fucking excuse. You elect a green-weenie socialist, and green-weenie socialism is what you end up living with. It’s just too bad that less gullible people have to suffer for your obtuseness along with you. Wake up and learn something, you dolt. I have exactly as much sympathy for your position here as I had for the dipshit tourists I used to see getting fleeced by the three-card-monte players when I walked around midtown Manhattan: none whatever.
Bravo!
Three seconds later: Sweet Cheeks is upset, and, as usual, she’s got a point. The paragraph above would be much better if it were non-denominational, so to speak. The socialism might have crept slightly different directions under Mssrs Boosh and (hypothetically) McCain, but the rot’s the same.
And that isn’t to say that Hendrix wouldn’t have posted a similar thing had the last election gone differently.
Carrying on.
ps. The foregoing may or may not fall within the constraints of Vandam’s Conjecture.
I must admit, at first glance, I thought I saw potential. Ezra Klein linked Jonathan Chait who had just pooped out a critique of Ayn Rand and Objectivism, and it wasn’t promisin’ to be purty. I got all excited. I skimmed the first two pages of it and was wondering when I was going to get to the meat of it, when the phone rang with a neighbor on the other end wondering if I was up for a little chainsaw work. I was. We worked for over two hours in the dripping heat of the evening, carving up two large white oaks, loading them into a big dump truck, and bringin’ it all back to the hood.
After a shower, and back at the desk, I started up with Chait again where I’d left off, quickly wondering if the phrase of the day was going to be "straw man".
But that was just my first run through.
I started back at the beginning with a more careful eye and immediately ran into problems. The stupidest kind of problems.
First sentence: Chait doesn’t know what "florid" means. A fear of socialism is an "overheated" fear. And the current de rigueur nose-to-the-ceiling snide slide on death panels.
The second sentence gets downright swampy:
Amid this cacophony of rage and dread, there has emerged one anxiety that is an actual idea, and not a mere slogan or factual misapprehension.
Ignore the weak sop of the introductory phrase, and contemplate the notion of "an actual idea". Feel free to try "factual misapprehension".
Does Chait mean "thought" instead of "idea"? What differentiates an ordinary idea or thought from an actual one? Or does he mean "an idea of ostensible or possible merit"? Why doesn’t he say that, then?
I’ll be brief: A person trading in the sorts of locutions that Chait does shouldn’t try dissecting the philosophy of so much as Captain Kangaroo, never mind Ayn Rand. Chait is extolling farce from his first words. His is nonsense. All of it. From the emptiness of his suite of words, through the long draught of various salaciousnesses, into the straw men, false equivalences, and subtle and not-so-subtle dishonesties, the whole endeavor is a joke.
After Chait’s first two sentences one knows that one will have the spend the rest of one’s time with his piece attempting to unearth the most mundane stupidities, dishonesties, errors, and fallacies. It’s really not worth it.
ps. Brian Doherty at Reason takes the trouble.
Later: Will Wilkinson notes the same thing others have, that Chait’s critique of Rand has little to do with anything Rand herself said and a lot to do with Chait’s own ignorant biases, and then cites a few things that Rand did stand for.
Here’s the big gorilla I didn’t see sitting in the health care "system" reform corner before: The nurse’s unions.
Just as teacher’s unions have little or nothing to do with fostering quality education (all while being promoted as "for the children"), so now are we about to be treated to the spectacle of the rise of a monolithic nurse’s union, with all the similar fol-de-rol, misdirection, and cheap lies about the true nature of it. It’s for the patients, dontcha know:
“Let it be known this was a unanimous vote by the House of Delegates,” CNA/NNOC Co-President Deborah Burger, said in the CNA’s Sept. 10 statement about the California union’s endorsement of the merger. “This is truly a historic moment and I hope it sends chills down the backs of those employers who would want to keep us down.”
[…]
The new group’s goals include strengthening the ability of “direct care” nurses to protect and improve patient care conditions, improve nursing standards, win union representation in an “RN union” for all unrepresented RNs, pass state and national legislation to protect patients including national RN-to-patient safe staffing ratios, and to work for guaranteed health care for all, according to CNA.
Longtime CNA/NNOC Executive Director Rose Ann DeMoro said a national union could be “the most incredible, powerful, unshakable force in the history of nursing and health care.”
Politics in your bedpan, and woe betide those who cross the powerful new constituency.
Relatedly, though not at all surprisingly, Marxist Adjutant General and Fellow Traveler Fearless Leader Biggie Obama came down four-square on the side of the United Steelworkers, slapping a hefty tariff on tires imported from China. American consumers, as usual, and importers (and last though not entirely least: those hardworking chinese tire makers) wind up making all the sacrifice on behalf of Biggie O’s preferred political pals.
Marguerite Trossevin, who represents a coalition of U.S. tire companies that import Chinese tires, said the tariff decision is "very disappointing." She predicted price increases for U.S. consumers and losses for U.S. tire importers.
"For the U.S. tire distributors and consumers, there’s going to be a heavy burden to bear," she said. "It sends the message that special interests will get protection if they ask for it — regardless of what that means for broader trade policy."
[…]
The tariff’s detractors said higher tire prices could lead some consumers to wait longer before replacing tires, creating a safety risk. Moreover, they said, the tariff won’t result in more jobs. Tires will simply come in from other low-cost countries, they say, and U.S. manufacturers, keep making their cheaper tires in China.
"U.S. tire manufacturers years ago decided to move production of low end tires off-shore," said David Spooner, a lawyer representing the Chinese tire industry. "Frankly, a temporary tariff is not going to get them to change their business plan."
In today’s climate of endarkenment, relocating out of the U.S. makes rather sound business sense.
The RomneyCare Express is still eating up expensive pavement in the late great state of Massachusetts, and now they’ve got new worries:
Current health care outcomes and spending trends oblige us to put all of our energies into creating an affordable, high-quality, cost-effective and fair health care system for all Americans. It’s troubling when provisions are added that are at odds with these goals.
It’s the eternal cannibal’s lament. Weep with me for a moment, won’t you?
One such provision being considered by Congress would change the formula for distributing Medicare funds nationally and could wipe out any hope for real reform in many states, including Massachusetts.
If adopted, this proposal would force a radical redistribution of health care funding away from Massachusetts, California, New York, Rhode Island, Texas and nine other states. The money would be shifted to other states. The effects could be devastating, not only for quality of health care and the advancement of research in these states, but also for jobs and the economy. Massachusetts alone could lose more than $1.1 billion in Medicare funding annually.
[…]
Medicare accounts for nearly 40 percent of the average hospital’s total patient revenue. This one provision could slash 11 percent of the entire Medicare funding Massachusetts receives each year – and that threatens health care in the Bay State.
Boo hoo HOOOOO!
That works out to about $10 billion a year for Medicare, just in Massachusetts. Remember that the next time you see Ezra Klein trying to paint the amount of money being spent on RomneyCare as being minimal.
Which reminds me: Those billions in Medicare subsidies that Massachusetts receives from the nation’s taxpayers have been increasing at a remarkable rate, out of sight of most of the accounts to be found in these days of Obama. Last year:
Gov. Deval Patrick announced in Boston that the state and the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services had negotiated the extension of a waiver that enables federal financial support for the state’s subsidized coverage plan. The agreement will allow the state to spend up to $21.2 billion on the program over the next three years, an increase of $4.3 billion over the initial three-year period.
If RomneyCare were to go nationwide, who then would pick up the tab, eh? It’s a frickin’ disaster in one tiny state, and yet, and yet….
There’s a lotta stoopit people out there.
There’s only one item on the menu, and all the ingredients used, and the methods of preparation practiced, are all arrived at via majority vote by a committee of morons who know nothing about food. It’s always soup, and it’s always bland with a hint of rancid. And there’s always much squabbling leading up to the next vote of the committee.
Or, as the Cato guy sez:
When government controls education, wrenching political and social conflict is inevitable. Americans are very diverse – ideologically, ethnically, morally, religiously – but they all have to support a single system of government schools. As a result, they are constantly forced to fight to have their values and desires respected, and the losers inevitably have their liberty infringed. In this case, reasonable people who want their children to hear the President must fight it out with equally reasonable people who do not want their children to watch the speech in school. It’s a situation completely at odds with a free society, but as we have seen not just with the current conflict, but seemingly endless battles over history textbooks, the teaching of human origins, sex education, and on and on, it is inevitable when government runs the schools. Which is why the most important lesson to be learned from this presidential-address donnybrook is that Americans need educational freedom. We need universal school choice or crippling conflicts like this will keep on coming, liberty will continue to be compromised, and our society will be ripped farther and farther apart.
I’m not sure what the author means by "universal school choice", as it sounds eerily similar to the school choice that government-sponsored vouchers are supposed to facilitate, and to my way of thinking, even that much government involvement is pretty stupid.
How do you report the culmination of "weeks of controversy" when you failed to report any of the controversy for all those weeks?
Like the New York Times does. Gingerly. Very gingerly.
And with as few specifics as possible.
Kaus cites Noah Silverman (facebook):
Readers of the print edition will never have heard of the presidential appointee so controversial the President had to dump him. Is this a milestone in the decline of the NYT?
Think of it as pre-airbrushing?
Synopsis at Power Line.
I should probably bookmark Capitalism Magazine and visit them as part of some sort of routine, because whenever I do stumble across one of their articles I like it, mostly.
In continuing to buzz hell at the commenters at Ezra Klein’s blog, a dim recollection regarding HMOs struck me, and sure enough, the health care option that everyone loves to hate wasn’t a free market experiment, but another goddamned excursion into idiocy by the federal poltroons:
From their beginnings, HMOs were designed–by Democrats and Republicans–to eliminate individual health insurance. The result is a vast network of health care collectives (HMOs, PPOs, Point-of-Service plans) created by government that are destined to do harm to individuals.
The individual was first discouraged from buying insurance in 1942 when employee health premiums were made tax deductible to employers–not to individuals. Congress created Medicare in 1965, making individual insurance for those over 65 obsolete. Subsidized, unrestricted health care for seniors lead to an unprecedented frenzy of spending by patients and doctors.
Costs went up, introducing an economic obstacle to individual health insurance. As costs rose, those on the New Left, including then freshman Sen. Ted Kennedy, argued that government ought to pay for everyone’s health care and promoted the idea of a health maintenance organization, a term coined by a left-wing college professor.
President Nixon appeased the left and proposed the HMO Act, which Congress passed in 1973. The law created new, supposedly cheaper health coverage with millions of dollars to HMOs, which, until then, constituted a small portion of the market. Kaiser Permanente was the only major HMO in the country by 1969 and most of its members were compelled to join through unions.
Combined with Medicare, the HMO Act eventually eliminated the market for affordable individual health insurance.
The new managed care plans mushroomed with federal subsidies. Employers perceived managed care as less expensive than individual insurance and stopped offering a choice of plans, making insurance more expensive for the individual. The government had effectively instituted HMOs, at the insistence of the left and the capitulation of conservatives and pragmatic businessmen.
Short and sweet, and about as good a summation as I’ve seen anywhere. And the commies are still at it, still trying to brew gold from their own rotten feces.
The end of the CapMag article, written in 1999, is interesting, for another reason. It demonstrates the ridiculousness of putting even the least faith in your best public servants (though I could have told you back then that Hastert was a worthless disgrace of a man.)
"When I started to gain on that Cadillac."
What a song. Now it’s the General Motors Zombie Watch with Government Motors blowing hot gas all over everybody’s highway:
There is no way GM can catch ToMoCo’s four-wheeled planet cooler. Even if GM can get the Volt to work, they can’t sell it for anything like the Prius’ $22,000 price tag. Unless . . . Unless . . . they do it anyway, and Government Motors takes the hit.
Of course, a “hit” is not a good thing for a company that wants to offer shares to the general public. So . . . how about we subsidize the shit out of the car so that it appears as if the car is somewhat profitable-ish? Or, at the very least, take the costs off GM’s books?
That process is under way. The federal government has already cash-injected the battery makers developing the Volt’s power supply, to the tune of $100 million plus. Your elected representatives are going to use your taxes to subsidize the plant making the car [see: DOE loans above]. And the car itself (via a $7,500 tax credit). Not to mention signing over $62 billion to a company that can’t even set a timeline for the Volt’s potential profitability.
Before a hundred or so hand-built Volts hit Chevy showrooms, the feds will re-up the battery research grants and find some other eco-friendly way of “helping” the halo car that the Presidential Task Force on Automobiles rejected as delusional, pre-nationalization.
Cheery stuff, no? The New GM is being run in the best "Cash for Clunkers" tradition, I say, except with extra super secret political accounting techniques not seen since "the Gorky Automobile Plant was awarded the Order or [sic] Lenin for achievements in setting up mass production of new trucks and cars for the national economy", as early as… uh, 1971.
Hmm, I’m getting an image of my friendly GM dealer’s sales lot, and out of the showroom door comes Honest Joe Biden to fix me up with my new ride.
At Powerline, on the Van Jones watch: "Jeremiah Wright behind a White House desk".
My last comment at Ezra Klein’s blog got squashed into a moderation queue, and I don’t have much hope for it, so I’ll paste it here. I quote howard16, who is claiming that the freedom to vote whatever he wants is built into the Constitution and therefore legitimate, or, as he puts it, is part of his core values.
–"your first comment is remarkable: having conceded that the constitution allows all manner of things that you find reprehensible, now you simply want me to decide i no longer believe in my (and america’s) core values."–
The flip side of Freedom has always been responsibility, and that’s what you (and Ezra and most of the people in government) don’t have. You are free to punch your neighbor in the nose, but you really shouldn’t, all other things being normal. You are free to vote slavery back into the Constitution, but if you’re a responsible, ethical, moral person you won’t do that. But you’re free to vote for slavery, or free to vote your health care out of your neighbor’s pocket, but if that’s part of the "core values" of which you speak, then I think you’re a couple sandwiches and some potato salad shy of the proverbial picnic lunch. The core value of freedom is the responsibility and moral knowledge that just because one can doesn’t mean that one ought, and in cases where your alleged freedom meets the other fellow’s nose, that’s where true core values (and they’re not just American; they belong to every sentient individual) take over and respect for the other guy’s freedom and rights kicks in.
So, all I get out of your petulance about having the freedom to vote whatever the hell you want is the temper tantrum of an immoral child. You want some sort of socialist or fascist or communist or, at the very least, collectivist health care, and because you’ve got x amount of votes in the proper political bodies, that’s good enough for you. You can do it. You can tax rich people to pay for it. You can send the police to their house when they balk and confiscate their stuff to make them pay. It’s all legal. But it does NOT have anything to do with core American values. It’s thug values. And it’s cowardly thug values, to boot, because you don’t have the personal courage to go to your rich neighbor’s house and demand that he buy you a car or contribute to your pension or to pay for your mental health care.
Communists, socialists, fascists, nazis, they’re all just names. At heart they were and are all thugs, and their political systems were thugocracies.
America is swiftly becoming a thugocracy, and you’re cheering it on.
Why is health care not suited to the free market? I have no evidence that it isn’t. Your whining about shopping around is unimpressive. If you don’t like the bill they send you after the nearest doctor fixes your heart attack you can refuse to pay it. I say that if the government gets out of the health care business that the health business will boom. The "high barriers to entry" you mention are all government mandated. Part of the high costs of health care are the high costs of attaining medical educations and medical licenses, both things driven high by meddling government, followed by endless additional government meddling once one is in business. And it wasn’t always thus, but the… collectivists got their hooks in and it’s all just an unfolding disaster now.
And that was about the sum of your objections, that I see. Like I said, if you can’t hack exercising your own individual right to control your own health care situation, then join a co-op, but what’s with the insistence that the whole country has to adopt your health care vision?
Well, actually, I know the answer to that, too. Medicare is going broke. Medicaid is probably on the ropes, too. Politician’s careers are at stake. The only way to fix it, with today’s crew, is to rope more people into the system. More paying bodies. Until the next crisis, when the rest of everybody will be forced in. And then it’ll be the long slow wait for death by governmental asphyxiation. Anyone remember Mary Jo Kopechne?
So, like, how about you ALLOW me to exercise my inalienable rights to my freedom? I won’t ask you to pay for my liver when the boozing gets to me, and you can go join some commie co-op that won’t work out the way you figured it. Deal?
(And double whoops. This one never made it out of the hopper yesterday.)
Ezra Klein lets one slip in his latest weekly chat session:
Question:
How will the health care system handle the sudden and large influx of 35 to 40 million new regular customers (not just ER patients). Will we have enough physicians, enough hospitals to meet the demand?
Klein:
A few things. First, the new folks don’t come in all at once. They come in over 10 years. Second, most of these people are getting care right now, although somewhat less than they will be.
"[M]ost of these people are getting care right now."
How can that be?
I’ve been knocking around Ezra Klein’s place (well, his corner of his employer’s place) this eve, trying to break up the monotony of the comments, here and here. I keep thinking I could do better.
And all that reminds me to remind you that the hard working John J. Ray (M.A.; Ph.D.) at the nifty SOCIALIZED MEDICINE blog is still cranking ’em out, story after story, day after day, documenting the failings and disasters that are the socialist health care systems around the world. The U.K.’s NHS has featured prominently of late, and no wonder.
I know that it’s easy to catch one or two of the horror stories as they come out of these endarkened systems, and to somehow chalk them up to some sort of intermittent fluke, or one off anecdote, but there’s years and years of negligence, incompetence, and malfeasance documented at Ray’s place.
Read it. You’ll be appalled.
John Kerry is poised to undermine it all. Go, John, go!
“This is the moment, this is the time, and I do understand that the cause endures, and the work goes on,’’ he told the audience of more than 2,000, invoking Kennedy’s famous words. “And I pledge to you, with every bone in my body and every ounce of thinking that I can find, we are going to apply ourselves to this task and we are going to get it done.’’
Every ounce! His foes rejoice!
The Tennessee Department of Transportation has "competitively" awarded more than half a million dollars out of the pockets of hard working Tennesseans for the design of a floating walkway that is to be dumped in the muddy water south of Knoxville.

With Tennessee’s unemployment rate approaching eleven percent, it’s good to know that city planners, professional grant seekers, and assorted government contracters are still unperturbed at spending every dime and nickel they can rake off the top of all the free market transactions they can get their hooks into.
Nice to see the Feds showing their "generosity" in said regards, too.
Powerline has a video by Jan Helfeld as Helfeld interviews Rep. Pete Stark, (D) California.
The video is appalling from start to finish (Stark is an utter disgrace on all counts), and ends with Stark saying, "You get the fuck out of here or I’ll throw you out the window."
Prop Stark up against Charlie Rangel…
"I recognize that all of you have an obligation to ask questions knowing that there’s none of you smart enough to frame it in such a way that I’m going to respond."
… contemplate the various implications for intelligence and honesty in public officialdom, and know that those two clowns are just the tip of the iceberg.
There is no good way out of this.
First up: On what planet does Ezra Klein think he lives? Amongst the clouds of wonk adolescence we find him wishing politicians the insight-generating wisdom of the latest in government supplied cost/benefit analysis:
If we change the process by which we pass laws, for instance, we might eventually arrive in a world in which we can actually pass good laws, rather than compromising them down to the point of maximum incoherence.
(Ignore the fact, for the moment, as Klein would have you do, that politicians are politicians, and unlikely to be otherwise even if Klein should summon the perfect chart for them to peruse.)
Republicans and Democrats, you see, only need better information to resolve the differences between them, which (in our enlightened times) have nothing to do with pitting individuals against collectivists (backed by the eager might of the government), but revolve instead around the best way for government to swing its fist.
In other words, Klein would like to find an easier way, a way that doesn’t involve having to pit freedom against incompetent intrusions of the state, a way that scientifically determines the best price to pay for the fucking prostitution of his ignorance up and down the exceedingly seedy boulevards of American society. Cost/benefit is nothing more than dickering about price for the service performed. Freedom be damned. You’re a number in a cost/benefit analysis, now, and it’s a government model being run on government computers, interpreted by agents of the state, and not only should no one question the algorithms, no one should ever have the chance to wonder whether people shouldn’t be running their own fucking lives without the Ezra Klein’s of the world playing ugly toothy grandma in their face.
And that’s Ezra Klein in his nutshell.
Next up, via a link from Klein’s little patch of incoherence over to that fetid farm of similar stuff at the Huffington Post, and then roundabout, we meet Sameer Dossani, who is exceedingly intent on telling the world that A is not A, because he wishes that A were not A, and therefore A is not A.
First, Dossani sets his premise with appeals to authority:
This country’s founders believed that every human being was endowed with certain inalienable rights — the rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. In the last century, the global community, led by the efforts of the United States and individuals like Eleanor Roosevelt, spelled those rights out. Article 25 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights states that "everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including… medical care…."
Health care is a human right. Like freedom from torture and ill treatment, equality before the law, and education, health care is something that all of us are entitled to by virtue of being human.
Note that somewhere between the founding and Article 25, the intangible was turned into the tangible. Now, not only do you have a right to your own life, you have a right to your life augmented with certain juicy perks courtesy of some unnamed schmoe. Somehow missed in the nobility of the declaration is the fact that the schmoe has seemingly lost the right to his own life, his own liberty, and the pursuit of his own happiness. Said schmoe is now on the hook providing "standard[s] of living", "well-being", education, and… "medical care" to those whose squeals can summon the Article 25 grease. What if the schmoe decides he doesn’t want to provide someone else’s education or medical care? Is he sent off for rehabilitation? Or just nickeled and dimed to death under threats of rather more complete impoverishment or incarceration? Kleins and Dossanis don’t care.
The moron Dossani goes on:
Health care is a public good, not a commodity and a healthy society benefits all of us.
I think Dossani is an idiot who thinks he’s a clever propagandist (though Lord Knows he didn’t get to be "Director of Amnesty International’s Demand Dignity Campaign" without having a few weak-minded people admire the living shit out of his earnest vapidity.) What he writes is almost like A = B, and B = C, therefore A = C, except that it’s closer to A = B, B != C, therefore A = C ain’t he a clever fellow. He wishes, therefore he invokes. It’s not a commodity! Heck no, it’s something else! It’s a public good. See? It’s important. Therefore it’s not a thing. It’s a right. You have a right to health care. Why, you can march down to your local General Practitioner’s and exercise that right, today, now, forever. It’s your right. You can steal from people when we all benefit. People who don’t want you to be healthy are mean and ignorant, and selfish, and you can take their money as recompense for their failings. You can force people to pay for your education, too, because their freedom to dispose of their assets as they see fit are trumped by your rights. Article 25 says so. And never mind the contradictions.
That’s how Sameer Dossani gets to pretend he’s important. Ginning rubes with castor oil made of gasoline.
And last, but only least, via Billy Beck, comes Glenn Reynolds of Instapundit, who, one would think, ought to know better, but he swings the same way time after time. I’ve said it before, he’s no better than Ezra Klein, and, as stupid as Sameer Dossani is, Reynolds is no better than that, either, for my money.
To hell in a hand basket.
The only surprise is that anyone is surprised. Cash for Clunkers rolls on:
"I wonder how long they’d wait if I owed them $3.2 million."
That’s Dave Billion, contemplating honor among thieves. Maybe Dave shouldn’t have been so eager to do "business" with people whose basic presumption is that what’s yours is theirs. I hope he’s not too surprised when he finds out his options for recourse are severely limited.
And who’s to be angry at whom when the drivers of the new Cash for Clunkers welfare fleet read the fine print on their April 15th sales chit?
The now scrapped government incentive will be less than what buyers expected, since they might end up paying taxes on the amount of the rebate even twice in some states: first, when they pay sales taxes on the price of the vehicle, and second, if the rebate is considered income, the they will have to pay state income taxes on the amount of the rebate as well.
Success!
Well, of course you do, old moron… I mean, comrade!
Two stories, both heartwarming beyond ken. One from the old country, and one from the land of lost dreams (lost American dreams, the lost dreams of freedom, individual initiative and responsibility, self-reliance, and the can-do spirit, the American dream that Bill Clinton has been waiting forty years to "recreate" with Socialist health care! Oops, that make three stories.)
First, back in the former USSR, Stalin’s grandkid is suing someone over some unkind mention of his soulless progenitor. The title quote is from the kid’s lawyer. I doubt if Stalin would be proud. I mean, why sue someone when you could blow fuck out of his business, or have the bastard killed? If you believe in Stalin, get with the program already.
Second, practically in downtown New York, people who know the difference between what Stalin delivered and what the American dream promised wonder how it all went wrong where it surely shouldn’t have. I steal the entire thing:
Wednesday night a few Russian women were ticketed $250 a piece for swimming past 6 p.m. at Brighton Beach. The Parks security allegedly threatened to jail them and check up on their immigration statuses. While the Parks Dept. told us that "New York State law does not allow you to swim at your own risk," the swimmers (and eyewitnesses) say that the lifeguards never alerted them that the beach was closing, and simply clocked out without getting anyone out of the water.
One of the women fined, Irina Kovaneva, told us her side of the story, which you can read below.
We came to the U.S. to escape the Communism regime, the regime when every step is watched and controlled by the government. What I am facing with this incident is a liberal fascism, when government interferes in your personal life and tells you what you should do, how, and when. You feel like you are not responsible for your life any more. Somebody else is. Where is freedom?"
Continue reading after the jump, where Kovaneva brings up a good point about paying lifeguards to stay on duty an extra hour or two during the summer.
"I am adult I know what I am doing. I happened to finish my workday early, so there was a chance for me to swim a little bit in the ocean on the hot August day. I do not have that many chances. I work, I can’t swim from 10 to 6, I only can swim after work. So I went to enjoy swimming. Instead I got yelled at, harassed and abused as many other people every day there. I wonder why instead of paying these extremely rude Parks Securities to go along the beach on the hot summer days yelling and abusing people, the city does not pay the lifeguards to stay until 7 or 8 on duty and let working people swim in the warm water and enjoy the long summer days. Does not it make sense?
How rude and abusive these people are—is another story. They do not treat you as a human being, they treat you like you are a low level something. And they are getting paid with taxpayers’ money, with my money to abuse me and many others like me. Again instead of paying them why not pay lifeguards?
The man who called himself sergeant refused to talk to me and explain anything. He stated he does not have to. Another one refused to give me his name. He rudely yelled at me with a furious face. At the moment when I came out of water he requested the ID from me and threatened to take me to jail for not having one. Do you know anybody who swims with his ID?
In response to your article the Parks Department is referring to New York State law, I would love to see it. I asked the one who issued me summons about it and he refused to give me the information. Regarding the signs on the boardwalk, I never noticed them.
Yes, it is very upsetting. But how it does not happen again? It happens every day during the summer there. You feel like you are in prison or in the mental hospital, not in New York—New York! It is upsetting, but more then upsetting it is super ridiculous! What is going on, people?
Hey! "What is going on, people?"
The Russian swimmer story came via SondraK.
A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.
Ezra Klein wonders, wonders, why another heavily subsidized (by whom? Can you guess?) industry consistently shows ever rising costs that outpace the Consumer Price Index:
Niraj Choksi runs the numbers and finds something interesting: Education costs have been rising even faster than medical costs:
[important looking chart goes here]
Per capita spending on health care is more than $7,000. It’s nowhere near as high in education, and so this is less of a problem. But it’s still interesting. More broadly, I’d like to know what experts think is driving the numbers. Is this hiding a relatively benign story, in which a lot more people are going to college, or graduate school, or even just choosing a private school? Is it just the cost of human labor rising quickly? Or is it more problematic? Or both?
Hey, Klein, you moron: It’s the subsidies. It’s the government SUBSIDIES. It’s the taking of hundreds of millions of dollars from productive and successful people and scattering them higgledy-piggledy across the educational land. It’s basic economics. Health care, education, housing, it makes no difference. You subsidize something, the price of that thing will tend to rise. You could look it up, even. Yes, I know, it’s hard for a tin-plated policy wonk (who never actually gets to watch the police go out and enforce his policy) to wrap his head around, but it is true nonetheless.
And it’s really sad.
Only a couple of Klein’s commenters even come close to answering the point in his call for "experts", demonstrating another side effect of two generations of massive subsidies for education: A completely watered down product; people with "educations" who are stone stupid.
Relatedly, in nosing around for the heck of it, I found the following argument against the subsidization of education, on a navy.mil page, interesting (though I don’t agree with every point made):
There are numerous reasons why governments may decide to sue [sic] subsidies as a policy tool. Somewhat cynically Houthakker (1972) has argued that a main reason has to do with political vote buying. From an economic perspective, the main purpose of subsidies is to reallocate resources, that is, to alter economic activity and behavior to achieve an outcome that is more desirable from what would occur otherwise. Hence arguments for subsidies are often based on some concept of efficiency or economic justice. But even when subsidies generate a more desirable outcome, it does not mean that the entire value of the subsidy is corrective in nature, or that the particular type of subsidy used for a given purpose is best among the available policy alternatives.
Economic arguments for using government subsidies generally fall into three broad categories:
1. Offsetting various market imperfections;
2. Exploiting economies of scale in production;
3. Meeting social policy objectives, including, for example protecting the poor,
4. Changing the distribution of income, and increasing or retaining employment.Oftentimes, however, those sectors receiving the largest subsidies do not clearly meet these criteria. Education subsidies in the United States are a prime example. In the early 1990s the government was spending nearly $300 billion on education or around 15% of all government spending, making it the third largest single type of government expenditure behind only national defense and social security. Meanwhile, government revenue collected from education was only around $30 billion. This $270 billion subsidy was roughly 5.5% of net national product. Clearly, the choice to subsidize education is an important one, and this choice seems to be widely accepted as a good decision. But the reasons why subsidizing education is a good choice are not so obvious.
Unlike a public good like national defense, markets can and do provide education. It is not clear why the government should subsidize this good rather than let markets work unimpeded. Several normative justifications for subsidizing education have been put forth. There are four main types: equity, paternalistic, borrowing constraint, and externality arguments. None of these is completely compelling, however. For example, few would argue, other things equal, against economic equality, especially equality of opportunity. This value judgment justifies helping the disadvantaged gain access to education. It does not, however, justify subsidizing the educational opportunities for all income classes.
Most economists find the second type of argument even less compelling. The various paternalistic arguments are based on the presumption that people do not fully recognize the benefits associated with education, and thus do not purchase enough education on their own. Therefore, those who are fortunate enough to fully recognize the benefits of education argue that the subsidy is necessary to induce the less enlightened to make better choices. There are two major problems with this argument, however. It is difficult to objectively justify why many people do not fully appreciate the benefits of education while there are some enlightened ones who do.
There is also a similar problem in objectively distinguishing the enlightened opinions from the unenlightened. The third justification argues that many students are constrained from borrowing against their potential future income to finance their education. This capital market imperfection (largely due to government-imposed constraints) may cause many students to acquire less than efficient amounts of education. This obstacle to opportunity may be viewed as inequitable as well. But if this borrowing constraint is the problem, then government-supported loans are the obvious solution. There is no reason to lower the private cost of education and redistribute income to all publicly educated students, as subsidies do.
The fourth justification has received the most attention by economists. If acquiring education produces spillover benefits, self-interested individuals will acquire less than socially efficient amounts of education. A subsidy internalizes the externality and encourages students to acquire more efficient amounts of education. A common view, however, is that although these external benefits probably do exist, it is unlikely their magnitude is large enough to warrant a subsidy as large as the one observed, particularly at the level of higher education. It seems improbable that the marginal external benefit is as substantial as the subsidy. If the above arguments are valid, one is apparently left with the disturbing conclusion that subsidizing education, particularly higher education, is mostly a redistribution that is inequitable by commonly accepted standards of equity.
It’s also wrong to steal from some people in order to enrich others.
More stuff you couldn’t make up:
THE HAGUE, Netherlands — Thirteen-year-old Laura Dekker wants to become the youngest person to sail solo around the world, and her parents think that’s a great idea.
But the Dutch Council for Child Protection is so concerned about the dangers of the marathon voyage it has asked a court to grant it temporary custody of Laura so it can do what her parents refuse to: Halt the trip.
Think: It took generations of professional busybodying to get to this point, and there’s no going back the easy way. These people are just too fucking stupid, and too goddamned sure of themselves.
But you’ve got to love young Dekker, who says, "I want simply to learn about the world and to live freely." Good luck with that.
Here’s Michael D. Tanner’s entire blog entry earlier, at Cato:
The Boston Globe reports that Massachusetts now has the highest insurance premiums in the nation. The average family premium for plans offered by employers in Massachusetts was $13,788 in 2008, 40 percent higher than in 2003. Over the same period, premiums nationwide rose an average of 33 percent. And, according to the Commonwealth Fund, an annual family premium in Massachusetts is expected to hit $26,730 by 2020. Meanwhile CNN hails Romneycare as the model for the nation…
The numbers are impressive, to say the least, though not in a good way. Forty percent and thirty three percent; do any of the idiots pushing any of the hybrid Romenycares out there wonder exactly what is causing numbers like that? And how much whistling around pretending not to see anything do they have to do in order to turn themselves to talking about something else?
I’ve got news for them: There’s only one thing in the world that provokes that kind of multi-year rise, and it’s interference by an external entity (government, in this case) in what ought to be a free market. Period. You just don’t get that shit any other way. The whole so-called health care crisis is nothing more than stupid people not realizing what the government is doing to the health care market.
The insurance market is an utter joke because of government regulations and mandates. A very large portion of the practical health care apparatus is likewise hobbled (made more expensive) by regulations from every side. And then a thousand subsidies, from Medicare and Medicaid to the Massachusetts miracle mandate, to all the smaller and more picayune programs for every special interest group with an outraged mother at its head, all clamoring for those free dollars out of their neighbors’ pockets; and hell, what does anyone EXPECT?
No matter WHAT Obamacare turns out to be, it’s going to be more expensive.
And then, slightly later, it’s going to become very much more incompetent, riddled with fraud, and dangerous to people’s lives.
Robert Higgs at von Mises traces the rise of the welfare state, aided and abetted by crooked, weak, and/or dim politicians the entire way (look no farther than "Republican National Committee chairman, Michael Steele" for an up-to-the-minute example of the weak-minded, unprincipled fool type.)
As an added bonus, also at Mises, read Yuri N. Maltsev’s gloss on the world’s first "’cradle-to-grave’ healthcare" attempt:
Not surprisingly, government bureaucrats and Communist Party officials, as early as 1921 (three years after Lenin’s socialization of medicine), realized that the egalitarian system of healthcare was good only for their personal interest as providers, managers, and rationers — but not as private users of the system.
Remember, it ain’t egalitarian if you’re not doing it of you’re own free will, and one of the big reasons these utopian fantasies fall short is that people (anyone, anywhere) have natural aversions to being forced to live someone else’s ditzy idea of how-it-ought-to-be.
Once again, I agree with Billy Beck: "It is not America," anymore. It most certainly isn’t. (Though McPhillips said, "This is France now, " more than eleven years ago. Time, it flies.)
This kind of shit doesn’t happen in America:
[Goodwill chief executive] Gibbons said the nonprofit group was accustomed to inspectors from the Consumer Product Safety Commission making unannounced visits to its stores.
Scott Wolfson, a spokesman for the agency, said it wouldn’t be dispatching bureaucratic storm troopers into private homes to see whether people were selling recalled products from their garages, yards or churches.
"We’re not looking to come across as being heavy-handed," he said. "We want to make sure that everybody knows what the rules of engagement are to help spur greater compliance, so that enforcement becomes less of an issue. But we’re still going to enforce."
The agency is working with eBay, Wolfson said, to help the online sales giant install software filters that will flag auction items subject to manufacturers’ recalls.
The commission’s Internet surveillance unit is monitoring Craigslist and other "top auction and reselling sites" for recalled goods. If the agency discovers that a recalled product has been sold online, it will try to find and inform the buyer, Wolfson said.
The federal "rules of engagement" for garage sale merchandise? You’ve got to be fucking kidding me. The Feds monitoring Goodwill, eBay, Craigslist, and everyone else? There are Americans sitting in little rooms somewhere surveilling other Americans trading used kiddy toys?
The land of the free. The home of the brave.
"Just step away from the Easy-Bake Oven, and put your hands up."
I’m glad I’ve lived as long as I have. I’m very glad I’m not a veritable tyke just out of college, say, staring at this shit and wondering how on earth I was going to run the gauntlet of it for so many years ahead.
It’s completely dismal, and it’s getting dismaller at a high rate of speed. We’ve gone from France straight to Leningrad, without the requisite stop in Berlin, surrendering all the way.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||