I've linked to several older articles pertaining to the way government has killed the free market vaccine manufacturing industry, but they're few and far between, even as two current flu vaccine shortages have various people asking a lot of uncomfortable questions. Unfortunately, a lot of people are asking the wrong questions, or promoting an uninformed view, or pointing fingers for political reasons claiming the answer is, as usual, more government intervention.
It was with surprise, then, that I stumbled upon the following in Canada's National Post:
It’s a bit counterintuitive, but really it’s because we’re unwilling to allow a price tag to be put on the H1N1 vaccine — because we see it as too important to be left to the vagaries of the market — that we’re seeing such unequal access to it.
Imagine if pharmaceutical companies were free to produce an H1N1 vaccine any way they saw fit and were allowed to charge people what ever they wanted for it. Given such an incentive, the pharmaceutical companies would quickly move from growing the vaccine in hens' eggs (which risk-averse government health agencies favour, but significantly slows down the process) to growing the vaccine in monkey cells, or to other faster methods.
The shortages would be a thing of the past, and no longer would being a celebrity or having an old university roommate who’s now a doctor be necessary prerequisites for getting access to the vaccine. Yes, you'd need money to get your hands on the shot. But as imperfect scenarios go, discrimination based on cash — rather than class or connections or social status or education or blood ties or the ability to pilot a puck around the ice — is probably the least dangerous inequity there is.
Pretty much right on, with only a few quibble-ables at the fringes. You may read the whole thing, if you like. The refreshing message is: let the free market do what it does best.
Unfortunately, what passes for the news is filled with less perspicacious fare.
For an example of blatant nonsense, there's the World Socialist Web Site:
President Obama determined that the best approach to the swine flu would be provided by “market solutions.” The White House entrusted production of the vaccine to a handful of pharmaceuticals (none of which are US-based firms, which find the production of flu vaccines insufficiently profitable.)
They go on to blame Obama for not being a better miracle worker, not understanding that having the government dictate prices, quantities, and a raft of regulations as sole purchaser of a couple hundred million doses, means there are no "market solutions" lurking anywhere near the thing. Government's decades long involvement in the vaccine business has driven almost all competitors from the field. That the few businesses capable of fulfilling orders of such magnitude ply other areas of their trade in the free market is immaterial. The "handful of pharmaceuticals" that the government has contracted with are the only ones left in the world willing to do business on the government's terms. The rest, and there used to be dozens, couldn't hack it, didn't want the endless hassle for relatively little profit, and closed up shop, driven out of the market, not by competition, but by an overbearing buyer who made doing business untenable. The stupid WSWS sneers with its "insufficiently profitable", but doesn't bother to wonder just who it was that insisted, over the course of a decade and a half, that vaccine production be something less than sufficiently profitable. It was stupid socialists in stupid government.
Then there is the simply inane crap thrown around as part of the usual political food fight. Here's the incompetent Media Matters trying to score points against the fool Sean Hannity:
Sean Hannity blamed the H1N1 vaccine shortage on the government and suggested that the shortage is indicative of the government's ability to reform health care.
[…]
Fact: CDC, Sebelius say private sector manufacturers' projections of available vaccines were too high.
Well, Hannity is still correct, even if he doesn't exactly know why (or maybe he does, I don't listen to or watch him), for all the reasons given higher up in this post. But Media Matters is doubly ridiculous for suggesting that erroneous projections are the cause of the shortage. Had the pharmaceuticals correctly predicted the manufacturing bottlenecks and low yields, there would still be a shortage. It just wouldn't have surprised anyone (not that anyone closely watching would have been surprised, anyway). The current swine flu vaccine has never been made before. No one knew for sure how it would go. It's not Obama's fault, per se, and it's not GlaxoSmithKline's, either. It's the nature of the business. Media Matters and the government are assigning blame for things that no one could have predicted, all the while completely missing the larger point about having all one's eggs in the government held basket. It is government's fault that there is a shortage of vaccine, but it's not because someone or other couldn't accurately predict the future, it's that there are so few players in the game, the most competent of them having decided it wasn't worth their time, effort, and investment to do the government's bidding. It is government's fault (and here, Obama is to blame) for thinking that one can order up a couple hundred million doses of something that has never been manufactured before, and that there won't be any problems, matched with the other utter failure in not recognizing that flu vaccine production is exactly the kind of thing that the free market excels at.
But there it is. One good article on the subject out of weeks and weeks of mindless drivel pushing sense out of the discourse. God help us all.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||