Now it’s Jerry Pournelle pimping McCain’s $300 million prize offering for new battery technology. He got upset listening to a couple of KFI commentators dissing the idea, and says…
Apparently neither of them bothered to look up "prizes" in any way. They both seem to think that a prize is some kind of contract that requires you to sign over all rights to your invention in order to get the prize. Why they would think anything like this is not known to me, but I blame the school system, which teaches not much.
[…]
The only obligation the winner of a prize should have is to win it: prize money does n0t purchase the rights to the invention.
McCain hasn’t said either way whether any strings will be attached to the offer, but let’s have it Pournelle’s way and see how it might play. Let’s start with this:
McCain said he could envision foreign automakers such as Honda and Toyota being eligible for the prize, since the Japanese companies have large manufacturing plants in the United States.
So, Toyota goes nuts for the gold, and develops a beautiful battery that wins the prize. They collect the $300 million, and start building and selling cars like crazy, all over the world. Well. Hasn’t the U.S. government then subsidized GM and Ford out of business? Tell me that Nancy Pelosi and Hillary Rotten Clinton and every other union supporting, demogoguing, half-wit, calling himself Honorable wouldn’t have a series of field days exacting their pounds of flesh over it.
A giant government prize with no strings attached is no different than any other government induced market distortion. Were Toyota to develop the battery and not win a prize, they would be in the hole the amount of their development costs, and that much more likely to want to strike licensing deals with those willing to pay. With a nice fat check in their coffers, they have less incentive to be nice with anyone. They could offer licensing deals for exhorbitant amounts, or not offer deals at all. Who’s to say?
And what of the practice in general? Since McCain made his idiotic proposal, all kinds of nuts are coming out of the woodwork with more prize proposals. The hybrid folks want theirs. Pournelle seems to want a prize for moon colonization. Someone somewhere, if he hasn’t already, will want a prize for carbon sequestration. Soon various prize appropriations will begin seeping into the last minute reems of pork barrel bills on Capitol hill, and the giant lottery will be on. But the question is: How much of the America economy does anyone want to divert into seeking each and every particular pet wish that someone has? By golly, if you offer a big enough purse, you could pursuade a large segment of the population to devote themselves to inventing that better battery, but all the people who don’t win could have been busying themselves with something not so quite pie in the sky. How many people will be pulled off hybrid research and told to go work on batteries in the hopes of winning the prize? How many people will want to join the carbon sequestration romp for a billion dollar payout, and then maybe find out that man made global warming was just an aspect of mass hysteria? Oops, but it was really fun playing with all that money we took from the hard working rubes across the land?
It’s just plain nuts, and ostensibly rational people like Pournelle and Adler ought to take second and third looks at this lipsticked pig that has so caught their fancy, and wake up.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||