What hell are we seeing wrought? Harvard’s home page, in its rotating random spot of semi-coherent text, intones, "Harvard fosters a culture of public service that embraces students, faculty, and staff. Volunteerism and academics often work hand-in-hand." Countless grave denizens spin. I flinch.
But therein lies all we need to know about "Anthony P. Dedousis ’11, a Crimson editorial editor," who, "is an economics concentrator in Leverett House.."
Perhaps I shouldn’t pick on a college sophomore. Perhaps I shouldn’t even pick on a sophomore "concentrator" at that renowned institution, Harvard. Or, perhaps, I do everyone involved a service that might otherwise go undone.
The subject of Dedousis’s editorial is the coal ash spill that occurred near Kingston, Tennessee, last December, when a dike ostensibly maintained by the Tennessee Valley Authority failed, wreaking havoc across a relatively wide expanse of the local countryside, and down river.
Let’s skip over the first paragraph of Dedousis’s article, the content of which was quite easily rebutted in a letter to the Crimson editors (via which I arrived thusly) from a worm at the TVA.
Here’s Dedousis’s first sentence of his second paragraph:
Had this disaster been a nuclear accident, citizens and Congress would rightfully be up in arms.
I believe I wrote about the tendency to attempt to sway opinion with exaggeration in such regards before, but Dedousis is bold in his attempt. If the TVA had blown up a chunk of the eastern seaboard instead of only knocking three houses off their foundations and ruining the natural ambiance for a few hundred others, the great unwashed masses, and, more importantly, the slobbering political elite not too far up the road (or down the road, if one is writing from Cambridge) in Washington would really take notice. Pity that the ash spill involved only coal ash over a few acres, I guess, and not malfeasance at one of the TVA’s nuclear facilities. One can always dream, I guess.
Here’s Dedousis’s next sentence:
But the largest fly-ash spill in American history has marshaled little public opposition to coal.
That’s a loaded sentence, if I ever saw one. Do they teach that at Harvard, or does it just come naturally to our future leaders who are fortunate enough to find themselves there?
Hmmm. Could it possibly be that the "public" recognizes, rather more intelligently than does Mr Dedousis, that the reason that ash spilled into Tennessee rivers is not because of *COAL*, but because of the mismanagement of *COAL* at the hands of the incompetent government goons running the Tennessee Valley Authority?
A more logical statement would be: "The largest fly-ash spill in American history has engendered few public calls that the TVA be dismantled, privatized, or otherwise put out of the country’s misery." After all, it wasn’t coal that insisted its residue be stacked in incompetently maintained retention ponds. It was government morons working at the federally instituted and perpetuated Tennessee Valley Authority who piled years and years of noxious ash behind the incompetently engineered (government engineers! Cousins of the crew that built and maintained New Orleans’ dikes!) Kingston Steam Plant dike.
Two sentences on:
Despite significant advances in coal technology, commendable progress in reducing air pollution, and reductions in mining’s environmental impact, the Kingston spill demonstrates that coal is not yet a viable option for long-term “clean” fuel production.
That might be nice, except that the Kingston plant has nothing to do with clean coal technology. In fact, the TVA is an ardent laggard in adopting new technologies, often citing its privileged position as a government entity in avoiding or delaying the associated expenses.
Dedousis is batting very close to zero. Not everyone makes it through Harvard, you know.
His next sentence:
The accident should cause Americans to demand tighter regulation of fly-ash disposal as well as to re-examine the long-term role of coal in our energy supply.
Now that’s my Harvard boy! More government! Let’s make it reflexive. Hell, in a few years, let’s make it mandatory.
Dedousis goes on. He hits all the notes. We mustn’t make another step until the government has made sure we are safe, etc., etc.
I probably should say that when I was Dedousis’s age, I might have managed to write a similarly abject article as he managed, but then again, I knew better than to try.
Oh, and despite the rebuttal by the TVA to Dedousis’s article, the TVA did serious damage down here in Tennessee, and the people responsible have not been held accountable. If anyone has been fired or dunned, it would be news to me. The TVA, you see, is owned by everyone, and when everyone is on the hook, no one can be held accountable. The criminality just rolls on and on, with the public saps (me and Sweet Cheeks and a state full of others) on the hook for it.
Abolish the TVA, and kill all taxpayer grants, subsidies, "investments", and other payments to Harvard and Harvard’s ilk.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | ||||||