KAYAK2U

August 10, 2009

Klein Boggle – Unteachable

A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.

I don’t know when I’ve seen such confusion.  Ezra Klein, today (endless recriminations – link added!):

If we want teaching to be more competitive and respected, we could pay teachers a lot more money. If every teaching job paid $85,000 in its first year, and topped out at $200,00 for the best instructors, you’d have a lot more kids from Princeton applying for teaching gigs. And if a lot more kids from Princeton applied for teaching gigs, it would become the sort of job that’s associated with kids from Princeton, much like i-banking and law. How much we respect a profession has a lot to do with who we think goes into a profession.

Good lord.  What an idiot.  And double that for Sarah Fine, this morning’s object of Klein’s affection.

If donut shops were government owned and operated, and the guy in the back frying donuts was paid $200,000 a year, would donuts be any more or less a few bits of flour and milk with a sugary coating?  Would anyone care (stipulating to Klein’s nonsense that grads of Princeton are lured primarily with dollar bills) that the donut man went to Princeton?  "Oh, this is sooooo yummy baked by Princeton guy."  Or would everyone fucking wonder what the hell he was doing frying donuts?  And the donut fryer.  The Princeton grad.  He takes pride, day after day, in measuring those ingredients, and waiting until the fryer comes up to temperature?  Oh, yeah.  

Teaching’s the same, Klein.  It’s like making donuts.  Almost anyone can do it.  Even well.  Sure, some teachers are complete standouts.  But mostly it’s grunt work.  Year after year, the faces change, but two plus two is still four, the prepositions haven’t changed, and the condoms still go on with the reservoir tip at the end.

And Klein, toying with other people’s money in his square head, wonders, "[W]ould it be worth the investment?"

Read Sarah Fine’s story.  Klein linked it.  Besides being a moron who thought teaching would earn her "social recognition" on a par with doctors and lawyers (who, needless to say, have jobs more challenging than checking to see if Johnny turned in his homework), a large portion of the dissatisfaction she dropped out of teaching over had to do with the goddamned socialist government run educational bureaucracy.  Read the story.

Maybe she could seek out a teaching position in the private sector?  You know, where they reward competence.  Where her superiors might actually be interested in ideas that work.  Or maybe she just wasn’t that good.  Eh?

Here’s an idea:  Get the government out of the education business, and let the market decide what teachers are worth.  Mark my words, the market won’t be wrong, there will be no shortage of competent teachers, and the country will slowly fill up with a more educated, intelligent populace.

Klein, however, long past his formative years, is too big a bow wow to learn anything new.

MikeSoja - August 10, 2009 -- 11:56 am    Filed in: Education, Incompetents  

Klein Boggle – A briar patch of confusion

A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.

A mere three days ago, Ezra Klein entered the thickets under the title, "The Fear of Change".  It is a title, I admit, that is nearly masterful with its juxtapositioning of the tropes of the last years, but its weakness, inherited from the weakness of its progenitor, is the failure to discriminate as to the type of Change under consideration.  In KleinLand, all "progressive" change is good, and everything else is superstitious ignorance, or racism, or both.

Klein starts with a YouTube embedment of video featuring scuffling outside a Florida political event, the relevance of which Klein leaves to his readers’ imaginations.  Interpretations that I’ve seen of the widely posted viddy focus on the antics of the two fat boys, who may or may not be union skinheads, getting a little cute in the generally anti-health-care-takeover crowd, but the ruckus is pretty lame and then there’s chanting, interspersed with some rather low-key confusion.

Well.  That leads directly to Klein citing and quoting Nobel Prize winning ignoramus Paul Krugman’s easily discredited nonsense editorial inferring racism for the groundswell of disgust and anger at the Democrats’ socialist health care grab.  Here’s Klein’s lead-in to Krugman’s words:

I’m not sure how right Paul Krugman is about this. But I think the answer is at least fairly right.

Emphasis: Klein’s.  Is Klein claiming the video he embedded above Krugman’s words shows racism?  Or does the racism occur subliminally, in the flickering spaces between the shades of "right" that make up Klein’s world.  You see, Krugman couldn’t be wrong on the racism angle, because he and Klein are both cocksuckers for socialised medicine, so instead, Krugman must be some delicately nuanced degree of "right", somewhere south of completely right (which, in the old pre-progressive days, would have been called "wrong"), say, oh, somewhere around "fairly right".  At least that.  Though Klein makes sure we know it’s just an opinion, as a further hedge.

However, directly after Krugman’s quoted racialist nonsense, Klein gives his passive definition for "fairly right":

You can overstate the role of race in this.

Bada Bump.  So, which is it?  Is Krugman "how right",  "fairly right" or has he "overstate[d] the role of race"?  Klein spends the rest of his post seemingly drawing parallels to the non-racist opposition to the ClintonCare sortie of the 1990s.  Go figure.

If that weren’t enough, Klein then has to go and pretend he doesn’t understand why anyone would be so righteously opposed to something as wonderfully innocuous as "progressive change", decrying the "level of fury" ranging around the hinterland outposts.  He calls it "very, very ugly."  Still no word on what Klein saw in that video that put the fear in him.

But here’s a hint, Ezra:  You and the crowd you shill for are threatening to initiate force against a wide swath of the American citizenry, against the whole economy of the country.  If you and Krugman were to go door to door with your little pistols, trying to extract amounts commensurate to what the health care bill will force, you’d have your heads blown off before you got half a block.  At some dim level you know that, but because there’s that long "legitimized" enforcement arm of the U.S. government to do your dirty work for you, you can pretend to ignore the violence and force that are at the base of your goddamned "progressive change".  And your pretense is just as ignorant and malicious as the "change" you wish to siren song into place.  

It’s a wonder that people are being as peaceable as they are. (another Beck link)

MikeSoja - August 10, 2009 -- 11:03 am    Filed in: Commies  

August 8, 2009

Klein Boggle

A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.

In which Klein takes liberties with the truth.

On the 5th, Ezra Klein cited what he termed a "good editorial" in The Boston Globe concerning the Massachusetts health care fiasco.  Klein quoted, in part:

[The Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation] report this spring put the cost to the state taxpayer at about $88 million a year, less than four-tenths of 1 percent of the state budget of $27 billion.

Klein, allegedly an expert on health care matters (though I suspect he’s more an expert on left-wing political strategies than he is knowledgeable about any real world practical matter) swallows the number uncritically (or counts on his readers swallowing it uncritically), even though it’s as bogus as a number can be.  The anonymous op-ed writer, too, has either made a stupid mistake, or is just plain lying, and anyone familiar with the health care cost numbers coming out of Massachusetts should have seen it.

Here’s the relevant passage from the Mass. Taxpayers Foundation report (PDF) that The Globe and Klein have so badly mangled:

Based on actual and projected spending data for the first four years of health care reform, the Foundation concludes that state budget spending on health reform has grown from a base of $1.041 billion in fiscal 2006 to a projected $1.748 billion in fiscal 2010.  That is an increase of $707 million, half of which is supported by federal reimbursements.  The $353 million state share translates into an average yearly increase of only $88 million.

That’s a yearly INCREASE of $88 million, not total cost.  Are The Globe and Klein incompetent?  Or are they just common liars?  One never knows with these clowns, but squint your eyes, read the passage, and see if you can make the same mistake.

Hell, The Globe op-ed mentions in passing the lawsuit against the state by Boston Medical Center, a lawsuit being brought because the Center is facing a $100 million loss this year which it chalks up to the increased costs of RomneyCare, and neither The Globe nor Klein wonder how one hospital could lose more than the state’s entire health care budget?

Michael F. Cannon at Cato-at-liberty.org read the same Boston Globe editorial and was appalled: 

1.  According to the Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation, $88 million is not the annual cost of the law, but the average year-to-year increase in state spending due to the law.  It’s a marginal-cost estimate, not a total-cost estimate.

2.  The foundation used (uncertain) future spending cuts to make the average annual increase in spending appear smaller.  In 2009, the total cost to the state government, according to the foundation, will be $408 million, nearly five times what the Globe claims.

3.  That $408 million is just the cost to the state government.  According to the foundation’s estimates, the state government’s share amounts to just 20 percent of the law’s total cost of $2.1 billion in 2009. The remaining 80 percent is borne by the federal government (20 percent) and private individuals and employers complying with the law’s individual and employer mandates (60 percent).  Since Massachusetts taxpayers also pay federal taxes and must comply with the law’s mandates, state taxpayers pay much more than $88 million to comply with the law.  In fact, the total cost of the law is about 24 times what the Globe says it is.

Oops.  Mistakes were made.  Lies were told.  Just another day in Collectivist Land.

After citing the spurious (but "good") editorial, Klein made some of his own comments respecting "the Massachusetts effort":

It has been a success.

Like "Cars for Clunkers", anytime you have people piling in to take advantage of that "free" government money, the program is a "success" of social engineering.  Of course, under RomneyCare, some of the "success" comes from the state threating impoverishment or incarceration to those who don’t qualify for the "free" care, if they don’t "volunteer" to play along and pay to make it all happen.

It has radically cut the number of uninsured residents.

Don’t you absolutely love that smarm?  The counter is that "it" has radically raised the number of insured residents that the state (ie., the taxpayer) has to treat for "free".

It has come in at about the cost predicted. It has proved popular.

Let’s turn those mind boggling comments over to the Treasurer of the State of Massachusetts, Tim Cahill, who spoke on CNBC a little over a week ago, as reported by the Washington Post, Ezra Klein’s own employer.  The points Cahill made: 

— The program has so far cost 30 percent more than anticipated.

— It already has a $9 billion shortfall projected over the next two years.

— Costs have risen 41 percent since the program’s inception, well outpacing the rise in healthcare costs nationwide, which stands at 18 percent.

— We thought this program would mean fewer people would go to hospitals, which is the highest cost any insurance plan has to pay. In fact, fewer people are not going to hospitals.

— A Harvard study shows 60 percent of state residents are unhappy with the plan. The most unhappy? Those whom it should be helping the most — those making $25,000 to $50,000 per year.

— To cut costs, the program is now having to kick out legal immigrants.

Remember, Klein is supposed to know this stuff.  But the boy goes on: 

And it has given Massachusetts the courage to contemplate much more aggressive cost control than anything that’s being consider at the national level, or in another state.

Courage?  Like you get from a couple of long draughts on a bottle of Thunderbird?  Courage?  More like the quaking fear of bankruptcy and political failure.

Are you boggled, yet?

MikeSoja - August 8, 2009 -- 01:51 pm    Filed in: Commies, Dishonesty  

August 7, 2009

Klein Boggle II

A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct “logical” and “reasonable” sides.

Q&A with Ezra Klein:

Re: Cash For Clunkers: Ezra, I don’t understand the Republican criticism (but when do I ever?) to this program, calling it a boondoggle because it already needs more money.

If my local store decides to boost sales with a special promotion and they clear the shelves of product, why is that a bad thing? Don’t you think their parent company would agree to give them more resources to keep the promotion going so they could sell more stuff?

I thought the Republicans understood capitalism.

Ezra Klein: It’s been confusing. There’s a legitimate criticism of cash for clunkers that it doesn’t do enough to force the purchase of high-mileage, environmentally friendly vehicles. But it’s hard to say that a bill that was meant to kickstart car sales is failing because it has kickstarted car sales.

Ezra’s acolytes are a dim bunch.  “Cash for Clunkers” is not “a boondoggle because it already needs more money.”  It’s a boondoggle because no matter how much money and resources are expended in its furtherance, it is a waste, a fraud, an economic travesty, useless, of no value, in fact, detrimental to any hoped for economic recovery.  In fact, “Cash for Clunkers” is worse than your ordinary boondoggle, which are usually mere excercises in waste and mismanagement.  With “Cash for Clunkers”, tax dollars are being used to purchase working automobiles at ridiculous premiums, and then those automobiles, which do have some value, are being unceremoniously destroyed.  Active value destruction.  With money forced from the citizenry, no less.

If my local store decides to boost sales with a …

[interjected circa 2015:] Local stores do not have the ability to boost sales by offering discounts backed by monies taken from non-customers, which is what the government did with Cash For Clunkers.

If your local store runs a promotion, its sales manager doesn’t come around to your house and put a gun to your head to solicit you for the difference between the regular and sales price, but that’s exactly what the government is doing to finance “Cash for Clunkers”.  Where the fuck do you think the three billion dollars for this joke of a program is coming from?

I thought the Republicans understood capitalism.

I got news for you, but “Cash for Clunkers” is not capitalism, which ought to be glaringly obvious, but, apparently, not so obvious that Klein would choose to so note.

Ezra Klein: It’s been confusing.

Yeah, I bet.

There’s a legitimate criticism of cash for clunkers that it doesn’t do enough to force the purchase of high-mileage, environmentally friendly vehicles.

Yeah, because if you’re going to dun working stiffs for three billion large, you want to be as big an asshole in directing people in your preferred direction as you possibly can.  Trouble is, there are numerous other truly legitimate objections to the stupid “Cash for Clunkers” program.  I even put some of them in earlier bloggings.

[I]t’s hard to say that a bill that was meant to kickstart car sales is failing because it has kickstarted car sales.

You think you’re eating a free lunch, Klein, but somebody is paying for the gristle in your mouth.  “Cash for Clunkers” is a failure because it begins with stolen productivity and ends with the destruction of real values in metal and plastic.  There are enough unintended consequences rattling around in the thing yet to come out to warrant a new passel of idiots to harangue the air for the government to DO something about them.

“It never ends, this shit…” (Beck link)

MikeSoja - August 7, 2009 -- 10:41 pm    Filed in: Capitalism, Commies  

Klein Boggle

A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.

Recently, Ezra Klein and Megan McArdle had a little back and forth about whether "health care reform" (the banal euphemism for the mighty grab by the government) might inhibit or stifle innovation and new discoveries in the private sector, and whether it might matter.

To begin, Klein, with his usual appeal to authority, trotted out one Dr. Jerry Avorn, who proceeded to emit one non sequitur after another, interspersed with unsupported contentions of various flavors.  To her credit, McArdle whacks Avorn around pretty well, a nice forward smash being, "This makes about as much sense as saying that Dr. Jerry Avorn cannot be that smart because his brain only weighs about three pounds."  Follow the links, read, and you’ll see that’s she right.

Unamazingly, Klein came back with new volumes of nonsense, leading to new appeals to authority under the names of Gruber and Finkelstein.  Asked whether "universal health care would retard medical technology innovation", Gruber said "No.  In fact, there is direct evidence to the opposite," and then passed the baton to Finkelstein, who said, "My prior belief would be the opposite."  Klein seems to assign importance to the fact that Finkelstein and Gruber each used the word "opposite".  I wonder what she meant by "prior".  It begs the question:  What is her current belief?  And, of course, we mustn’t wonder why she only has her "belief[s]", instead of say, a couple of nuggets of factoids that one could go out and verify.

There’s more nonsense in there, all on Klein’s side, to be sure ("If we want innovation and scientific discovery," [Avorn] said, "we should fund innovation and scientific discovery."  Ah, but of course!  If we want to fly to the ends of the galaxy, we should simply fly to the ends of the galaxy!  How utterly CLEVER!), but the whole reason I’ve bumped along this far is because of something posted by Dale Amon at Samizdata earlier today that might have some bearing on Klein’s preposterous contention that governments are perfectly acceptable alternatives (over that nasty private sector) in the drive for "innovation and scientific discovery".

Amon linked an article in New Scientist, and quoted:

In fact, the evidence shows otherwise. In 2003, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development published The Sources of Economic Growth in OECD Countries, reporting on a comprehensive regression analysis of the factors that might explain the different growth rates of the world’s 21 leading economies between 1971 and 1998. This indicated that only privately funded R&D led to economic growth, and that publicly funded R&D did not. Worse, the public funding of R&D crowded out private funding, and thus slowed economic growth.

A link in the article takes one to the 248 page PDF report:  The Sources of Economic Growth in OECD Countries.

Klein, I’m sure, could read that report and cherry pick quotes to buttress his feeble position, but there is much to support the New Scientist’s characterization.

And let us not forget, the most important reason for wanting to leave R&D, innovation, and the pursuit of scientific discovery in private hands is that that is what adherence to the concept of FREEDOM enjoins us to do.  It matters not a jot to me that the current hordes of meddling busy bodies wanting to write policy for the coming authoritarianism think they’re the world’s smartest people, or that they might actually back a winner on occasion.  Forcing people to do one’s bidding, no matter how noble that bidding might be, is wrong.  The fact that doing the wrong thing also very often leads to failure and ignominious waste, is just icing on the argument’s cake.

MikeSoja - August 7, 2009 -- 09:38 pm    Filed in: Commies, Freedom, Incompetents  

March 20, 2009

The dumbed down generation

So, basically, JournoList is Ezra Klein’s teleprompter.

MikeSoja - March 20, 2009 -- 11:21 am    Filed in: Commies, The Spectacle  

January 23, 2009

Learning disabled

Ezra Klein neatly encapsulates the sum total of his vapid incompetence in a single line link reference:

But I thought, in the U.S, we don’t have waiting lines!

Klein’s link goes to a David E. Williams, a medical biz consultant, who purports to undermine the argument that socialist health care leads to rationing and waiting lines by alleging that people in the U.S. already have to wait for health care.  (Briefly, let me point out that aside from any tangential arguments about whether socialist health care works better than free market care in some or any areas, the socialist model is morally wrong because it’s coercive at root and destructive of personal responsibility at the other end.  That it also, by most standards, fails, is merely ancillary.)  The trouble is, Klein either didn’t read past Williams’s shallow gloss, which seems like a stupid thing not to have done before shooting his mouth off, or he let bias cloud what little intellect he possesses, and failed to note the irony of trying to defend socialism by using examples of the failure of socialism, also not too smart.  Also, while it’s not preposterous to presume that Williams, whose business exists as a parasite of the health care industry, would stand to benefit from the institution of some sort of federally mandated health care scheme, Klein’s self-interest is a little harder to peg, but probably wells up out of that deep pool we call sheer ignorance.

In any event, Williams’s complaint is that at least one family has a six month wait to have "a child whose speech is delayed" looked at by the specialists at Boston’s Children’s Hospital.  Of course, Children’s Hospital is as far from a free enterprise facility as any hospital in the country.  First, it is closely entwined with Harvard U., a non-profit "corporation" that exists largely on the basis of the tax-evading privileges granted by law to its benefactors and to the treatment of its endowment capital gains.  Second, Children’s is a huge recipient of direct federal dollars.  From its own web site:

Our current initiatives have attracted a record $176 million in funding; including more federal funding than is awarded to any other pediatric facility.

Children’s Hospital is not a creature of the free market, but exists largely as an entity of political privilege.  Third, Massachusetts is home to Commonweath Care, the nation’s first universal, mandated, socialist, health care experiment.  Waiting times to see doctors are increasing in all areas all over the state.  Demand for free or subsidized care is up, up, up, and the supply of doctors is stagnant or declining.  Fourth, complaining that a child can’t get into Children’s Hospital is like complaining that a prospective college student can’t get into Harvard.  It’s but one place, it’s only so big, and there is a lot of demand for its subsidized (i.e., demand-stimulating/supply-inhibiting) services and products.  Fifth, Williams doesn’t say, but it’s a good guess that the family with the kid who’s too ashamed to talk is looking to Children’s for some of that free health care.  In other words, they’re looking the gift horse in the mouth and complaining about what they see.  In the few comments on Williams’s post (second link from top) one can get an inkling of the insanity in which the whole modern health care debate steeps.  Stefanie sez…

We went through the same thing in Houston, a city of a large number of medical facilities, including a superb childrens’ hospital. During the tbd wait, we paid out of pocket for speech therapy and other therapies that I researched ( Web 2.0) and that made the difference. I am convinced that the TBD wait would have been irreversible, with a resultant cost of society far in excess of what I had to pay out of pocket. Scary and sad!

And Ann follows with… 

I have found in my career as a parent that paying out of pocket for some kinds of consultation services is an excellent use of funds. I live in a Metropolitan area, and oddly these specialized resources are available if the pay is cash.

Zounds!  Paying with your own money is "an excellent use of funds"!  And, moreover, it gets you the services you want!  How odd!  And they don’t make the connection.  And who’s to help them?  Klein?  Williams?  Not on your life.  Or, more precisely, very much on your life, with your money, to boot, and no qualms about it, all the while wondering why the money they work so hard to steal (but dispense with frivolously) isn’t buying what they think it should.

Here’s Williams again, two weeks ago, beating the same tin can of "waiting times", pretending it’s the big drum of moral rectitude:

[P]atients in Boston wait an average of 10.5 weeks to see a dermatologist for a “changing mole” –perhaps the closest thing in dermatology to an emergency.

Go to the link he provides, though, and buried in the depths you’ll find this:

Meanwhile, the federal government limits the number of residents hospitals can train, and hospitals would have to create more dermatology slots at the expense of other specialties.

How utterly stupid do Klein and Williams have to be not to understand exactly why there is a shortage of dermatologists (or anything else) in Boston?

Hey, I know!  How about forcing me to pay for Klein and Williams to go have their learning disabilities evaluated?  Yes!

Later:  David E. Williams, whose insinuations I skewer above, has commented on my post here and here, but, outside a little clowning, a remark on the tags on my posts, and that I have comments disabled, doesn’t take issue with a single point I made.  What can I say?  Thanks for the links?  Thanks for making my point?

MikeSoja - January 23, 2009 -- 11:30 am    Filed in: Commies, Incompetents  
  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. 2
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud