KAYAK2U

February 10, 2010

A temporary reprieve

It's happy days at Vandam Manor, with a resounding defeat of the union cabal.  Yaay.

But it's a sure bet that, after a short period of frenzied and confused introspection, the proponents of the fifty million dollar scheme will be back.  Maybe they'll reduce the scope of their grab, or employ various diversionary or dishonest stratagems, but they'll be back.  And then the fight over the disposition of one's own wealth, subject to the whims of one's neighbors, will be taken up again.  At base, it's insane.

What's not insane, is the notion of doing away with bricks and mortar schools altogether (at least the "public", government ones), bringing learning around to twenty first century technology.  You can read Vandam on that, too.

MikeSoja - February 10, 2010 -- 01:16 pm    Filed in: Bureaucratic tyranny, Education  

January 19, 2010

The Essential Vandam

I trust that my few readers are already regulars at the Vandam emporium of impressively composed insight into the issues of the day, but I'm still behooved from time to time to make mark of the goings on there.

Thusly, while I can't swear to the connection, I report that I suffered two memorable nightmares during my extensive slumbers last night, and after eliminating all other possible causations, it occurs to me that they might have been caused by this, which I had viewed before bedtime.  

As a way of resetting the affected synapses, I suggest:  The Zombies, She's Not There.

And then, today, Vandam offers a "Thought for the day" on the continually developing tragedy that is the American public education system.  As he so precisely puts it:

The public schools are the ground zero of the potentially catastrophic dilemmas of American civilization.

I might argue about the "potentially" part, because I think the damage is already insurmountably extensive, but otherwise, the assessment is Vandam's usual bullseye.  One could do more good in this country in this one area, than any number of other "reforms" in any number of other areas.  Education keys almost everything else.  And that's irrespective of the vast amounts of wealth wasted on it.  Every generation that endures the current regime becomes slightly more barbaric, and barbaric isn't good.

The government should not be in the education business, at all.

 

Unfortunately, the seed has long been planted, and the harvest is unavoidable.  Reap it.

MikeSoja - January 19, 2010 -- 11:33 pm    Filed in: Education, Endarkenment  

December 17, 2009

Them poor girls…

I"m not sure how much Shelia Cotten is being paid by the University of Alabama at Birmingham, but it's certainly too much.  She's conducted a study, and written a report (copies of which "are available upon request").  Here's the nuts and bolts of it:

In a study of nearly 1,000 middle-school students, students were asked to rate the different ways they use their cell phone on a five-point scale, from zero meaning "Never" to 5 meaning "Several Times a Day." The study found that boys scored higher than girls for using their cell phones to play games, share pictures and videos, listen to music and/or send e-mails, even after accounting for how much the students liked using their phones and how skilled they were at using them, says Cotten, whose study appears in the current issue of the journal New Media & Society.

"It has a lot to do with gender socialization," says Cotten. "Boys are often taught to explore and be more creative with technology and not to be afraid to take things apart. So it leads to more advanced cell phone uses among boys. Boys tend to see and use the cell phone as a gadget."

Girls, on the other hand, used the phone as a phone book or contact list more often than boys did, says Cotten, who teaches in the UAB Department of Sociology and Social Work. But when UAB researchers looked at more traditional types of cell-phone use — how frequently children made calls and used text messaging — no gender differences were detected, with girls averaging 2 hours on the cell phone each day and boys averaging about 1.8 hours per day.

Catch that bit on "gender socialization" in there?  Boys are taught to be more creative with technology?  What the hell… ?

But, wait!  It gets worse!  The study author continues, telling parents how to coach their children in cell phone use, with other gender bender nonsense thrown in:

"By these study results, we aren't saying that parents should buy phones with fewer features for girls," says Cotten, "but it does point out how more needs to be done to teach girls about the technical and more advanced multimedia features of their cell phones. Females traditionally have perceived themselves as less skilled in terms of technology, especially with regard to computers.

"If you plan to get your child a cell phone, features and style are still going to be a personal choice," says Cotten. "The bigger issues that parents should think about are the age of the child and how mature they are. Is the child responsible enough to stay within time-use allotments, to charge the phone, not to lose it and to use the phone appropriately? Obviously more advanced features like Internet access and multimedia capabilities carry greater opportunity and consequences for misuse.

"Talk with the child about what the responsibilities are for owning a cell phone, the limits for making calls, and texting and behaviors that are appropriate and inappropriate," she said. "Parents need to have a good conversation with their child about the cell phone because it's much harder to control children's cell-phone activities unless they set rules or place parental controls on the phones."

Yikes.  Keep your kids away from the University of Alabama, I say.

MikeSoja - December 17, 2009 -- 09:41 pm    Filed in: Busybodies, Education, Morons  

December 4, 2009

America perverted

Let's hope that Kevin Jennings is quickly thrown out of the bus, and then run over with it several times.  Yes, it's another fucking outrage.

Start with Vandam, and prepare to be disgusted and disturbed.  And then wonder how that man can be friends with our president.

MikeSoja - December 4, 2009 -- 12:17 pm    Filed in: Corruption, Education, Endarkenment  

December 2, 2009

Freedom’s not just another word

Justin Logan at Cato gratuitously quotes Mencken:

Liberty means self-reliance, it means resolution, it means enterprise, it means the capacity for doing without. The free man is one who has won a small and precarious territory from the great mob of his inferiors, and is prepared and ready to defend it and make it support him. All around him are enemies, and where he stands there is no friend. He can hope for little help from other men of his own kind, for they have battles of their own to fight. He has made of himself a sort of god in his little world, and he must face the responsibilities of a god, and the dreadful loneliness.

I like that quite a bit, but I excerpted it from a greater part which I deem makes a large point apropos of these declining times:  By sundry means, and I largely blame the country's government owned and operated education system, the numbers of inferior men have grown sufficiently large that they are now not to be stopped by any peaceful means, and our tiny, "precarious" territories are thus additionally beset on all sides, in grave danger of being overrun.  This madness of crowds, as ever, is not something easily turned, or may not be turnable at all.  It just may have to break upon some rock of sufficient hardness, wreaking what damage it may until it does.  I'm not optimistic, but then, I never have been.

MikeSoja - December 2, 2009 -- 07:34 pm    Filed in: Education, Freedom, Madness of Crowds  

November 12, 2009

What’s the difference?

Failure sticks its ugly neck out in down state New York:

During their first math class at one of CUNY's four-year colleges, 90% of 200 students tested couldn't solve a simple algebra problem, the report by the CUNY Council of Math Chairs found. Only a third could convert a fraction into a decimal.

It's funny to think that one could abolish the public school system, and that 90% number probably wouldn't get any worse.  What is the friggin' point of wasting all those years, and all that money, on people who have no interest in learning?

MikeSoja - November 12, 2009 -- 09:31 pm    Filed in: Education, Failure  

It’s morons all the way down

The title is my new cosmological construct, and here's a data point in support of the contention:

Selling candy didn't raise much money last year, so a Goldsboro middle school tried selling grades.

[…]

A $20 donation to Rosewood Middle School would have gotten a student 20 test points – 10 extra points on two tests of the student's choosing. That could raise a B to an A, or a failing grade to a D.

Susie Shepherd, the principal, said a parent advisory council came up with the idea, and she endorsed it. She said the council was looking for a new way to raise money. 

Susie Shepherd is a moron.  The "parent advisory council" is a bunch of morons.

I suppose some dim wag somewhere might refer to the ill-advised endeavor as a worthy sally into the free market, but it's an education that schools want to be selling and not just the intrinsically worthless tokens of achievement.

And as bad as that is, it gets worse:

Rebecca Garland, the chief academic officer for the state Department of Public Instruction, said she understands that schools are struggling in the recession.

Tight state and local budgets have put extra pressure on schools to raise their own money. Teachers giving extra test credit to students who bring in classroom supplies is a longstanding practice at some schools.

But Garland said exchanging grades for money teaches children the wrong lessons. She also said it is bad testing practice and is unfair to students whose parents can't pay.

[…]

Garland said she has heard of schools offering test credit to students who bring supplies to school. But "I've never actually heard of being able to purchase grades before," she said.

Rebecca Garland is a moron, too, of course.  She professes disdain for selling grades for filthy lucre, but apparently condones, or at least tolerates, the selling of grades for "classroom supplies".  On what basis she discriminates thusly we are not told.  But at least she admits that one or both of the practices is bad for herself.  Buying grades instead of acquiring learning "is bad testing practice", said practice appearing to be the sole tenuous tether tying Ms Garland to the responsibility of her position.  

Further, she's wrong about to whom it is "unfair".  It is deeply unfair to those who are continuously bled (under threats of impoverishment and incarceration) of their hard earned dollars in order to finance the various stupidities of Susie Shepherd and Rebecca Garland.   It's more aptly unjust to those whose grades are earned rather than bought.  Rather, selling grades shortchanges the recipient, who is, after all there to learn, and is unfair to those down the line who rely on metrics like grade scores to discriminate as to who is best suited to the needs being sought.  In other words, Ms Garland is deeply confused, albeit, (undoubtedly) highly paid with those commandeered tax dollars.

But wait!  It goes on.  The parents involved are idiots, too, but I've no time, and can only wish them what they earn.  Instead, here's Susie, again:

Shepherd, the Rosewood principal, said her school needs more technology. She said any money raised would help buy digital cameras for the school's computer lab and a high-tech blackboard.

The kids need math, English (reading and writing), and history.  Lots of all three.  YOU don't need digital cameras or programmable blackboards to teach them any of what they really need.  Regular, old fashioned blackboards can do anything the new ones can do, except suck up god awful amounts of money and time in software.  If you think otherwise, you're a moron, but we've already established that.

Good morning!

MikeSoja - November 12, 2009 -- 09:11 am    Filed in: Education, Morons  

October 20, 2009

Who’s being selfish, now?

They’re doing it to the children, out in How ah ya:

Teachers probably wouldn’t have voted for the contract if they had to work the same amount for less pay, paving the way for the shorter school year, said Hawaii State Teachers Association President Wil Okabe. He also said the state couldn’t get the necessary savings if teacher furlough days were scheduled for holidays—or workdays with schools kept open.

Selfish bastards.

And what of the hapless victims of this vile display of responding to monetary disincentives?  Something comes to mind about putting eggs in baskets, and how a decentralized private school system has got to have all kinds of advantages over the crumbling state behemoth.

MikeSoja - October 20, 2009 -- 10:57 am    Filed in: Commies, Education, Failure  

October 8, 2009

Anything but teach

It’s all about breakfast in the Philadelphia schools, if you can believe it.  Yep, breakfast is key, you see, to gaming those pesky federally mandated No Child Left Behind testing regimes.  I always thought that it was OJ in the morning that raised one’s IQ, but now it’s the whole schlemiel (or whatever variation of the whole schlemiel passes for breakfast in Philadelphia schools, these days.)   So it’s "free" breakfast for all the kids (and less for those who do pay for it), and they better eat it, too.

"Are we going to get to forced feedings?"

That baleful question was asked by "Michael Lerner, president of Teamsters Local 502, Commonwealth Association of School Administrators," who presumably isn’t that concerned about the little tykes, but very worried about the expanded duties that will fall to "School Administrators" as they are forced to comply with another directive from on high without any indication of further remuneration for the trouble of it.  Whatever.  The question should be asked, even if it is asked insincerely.

The whole story is chock full of goodness, but the part that flips my lid is:

Just how food will be served in Philadelphia schools is up to principals. Studies show, however, that more children eat when breakfast is served in the first class of the day.

Last year, the vast majority of the district’s 267 schools served food in their cafeterias before the school day began, Grasela said. Just 47 served them in classrooms, he said.

Typically, principals have resisted such service, saying it detracted from instructional time.

Gosh, we had it tough in my day.  Eating breakfast uphill both ways and all.  But what a lark, breakfast during first period.  Nearly eighteen percent of Philly schools serve breakfast during the first instructional period.  Does the teacher monitor for bad manners?  So important, you know, for those children’s future as wards of the state… 

ps.  I’m calling bullshit on the 98% participation figure cited for kids partaking breakfast in some of Philly’s schools.  Maybe it’s that the schools are very small, but it seems more likely that someone has his or her hand in the till on that one.  Know what I mean, jelly bean?

MikeSoja - October 8, 2009 -- 11:07 pm    Filed in: Commies, Education, Incompetents  

September 12, 2009

Incompetent Socialism (The Harvard Way) vs. Abolish the TVA

What hell are we seeing wrought?  Harvard’s home page, in its rotating random spot of semi-coherent text, intones, "Harvard fosters a culture of public service that embraces students, faculty, and staff.  Volunteerism and academics often work hand-in-hand."  Countless grave denizens spin.  I  flinch.

But therein lies all we need to know about "Anthony P. Dedousis ’11, a Crimson editorial editor," who, "is an economics concentrator in Leverett House.."

Perhaps I shouldn’t pick on a college sophomore.  Perhaps I shouldn’t even pick on a sophomore "concentrator" at that renowned institution, Harvard.  Or, perhaps, I do everyone involved a service that might otherwise go undone.

The subject of Dedousis’s editorial is the coal ash spill that occurred near Kingston, Tennessee, last December, when a dike ostensibly maintained by the Tennessee Valley Authority failed, wreaking havoc across a relatively wide expanse of the local countryside, and down river.

Let’s skip over the first paragraph of Dedousis’s article, the content of which was quite easily rebutted in a letter to the Crimson editors (via which I arrived thusly) from a worm at the TVA.

Here’s Dedousis’s first sentence of his second paragraph:

Had this disaster been a nuclear accident, citizens and Congress would rightfully be up in arms.

I believe I wrote about the tendency to attempt to sway opinion with exaggeration in such regards before, but Dedousis is bold in his attempt.  If the TVA had blown up a chunk of the eastern seaboard instead of only knocking three houses off their foundations and ruining the natural ambiance for a few hundred others, the great unwashed masses, and, more importantly, the slobbering political elite not too far up the road (or down the road, if one is writing from Cambridge) in Washington would really take notice.  Pity that the ash spill involved only coal ash over a few acres, I guess, and not malfeasance at one of the TVA’s nuclear facilities.  One can always dream, I guess.

Here’s Dedousis’s next sentence:

But the largest fly-ash spill in American history has marshaled little public opposition to coal.

That’s a loaded sentence, if I ever saw one.  Do they teach that at Harvard, or does it just come naturally to our future leaders who are fortunate enough to find themselves there?

Hmmm.  Could it possibly be that the "public" recognizes, rather more intelligently than does Mr Dedousis, that the reason that ash spilled into Tennessee rivers is not because of *COAL*, but because of the mismanagement of *COAL* at the hands of the incompetent government goons running the Tennessee Valley Authority?

A more logical statement would be:  "The largest fly-ash spill in American history has engendered few public calls that the TVA be dismantled, privatized, or otherwise put out of the country’s misery."  After all, it wasn’t coal that insisted its residue be stacked in incompetently maintained retention ponds.  It was government morons working at the federally instituted and perpetuated Tennessee Valley Authority who piled years and years of noxious ash behind the incompetently engineered (government engineers!  Cousins of the crew that built and maintained New Orleans’ dikes!) Kingston Steam Plant dike.

Two sentences on:

Despite significant advances in coal technology, commendable progress in reducing air pollution, and reductions in mining’s environmental impact, the Kingston spill demonstrates that coal is not yet a viable option for long-term “clean” fuel production.

That might be nice, except that the Kingston plant has nothing to do with clean coal technology.  In fact, the TVA is an ardent laggard in adopting new technologies, often citing its privileged position as a government entity in avoiding or delaying the associated expenses.

Dedousis is batting very close to zero.  Not everyone makes it through Harvard, you know.

His next sentence:

The accident should cause Americans to demand tighter regulation of fly-ash disposal as well as to re-examine the long-term role of coal in our energy supply.

Now that’s my Harvard boy!  More government!  Let’s make it reflexive.  Hell, in a few years, let’s make it mandatory.

Dedousis goes on.  He hits all the notes.  We mustn’t make another step until the government has made sure we are safe, etc., etc.

I probably should say that when I was Dedousis’s age, I might have managed to write a similarly abject article as he managed, but then again, I knew better than to try.

Oh, and despite the rebuttal by the TVA to Dedousis’s article, the TVA did serious damage down here in Tennessee, and the people responsible have not been held accountable.  If anyone has been fired or dunned, it would be news to me.  The TVA, you see, is owned by everyone, and when everyone is on the hook, no one can be held accountable.  The criminality just rolls on and on, with the public saps (me and Sweet Cheeks and a state full of others) on the hook for it.

Abolish the TVA, and kill all taxpayer grants, subsidies, "investments", and other payments to Harvard and Harvard’s ilk.

MikeSoja - September 12, 2009 -- 01:40 am    Filed in: Education, Morons, TVA  

September 7, 2009

The menu at the Cannibal Pot Cafe

There’s only one item on the menu, and all the ingredients used, and the methods of preparation practiced, are all arrived at via majority vote by a committee of morons who know nothing about food.  It’s always soup, and it’s always bland with a hint of rancid.  And there’s always much squabbling leading up to the next vote of the committee.

Or, as the Cato guy sez:

When government controls education, wrenching political and social conflict is inevitable. Americans are very diverse – ideologically, ethnically, morally, religiously – but they all have to support a single system of government schools. As a result, they are constantly forced to fight to have their values and desires respected, and the losers inevitably have their liberty infringed. In this case, reasonable people who want their children to hear the President must fight it out with equally reasonable people who do not want their children to watch the speech in school. It’s a situation completely at odds with a free society, but as we have seen not just with the current conflict, but seemingly endless battles over history textbooks, the teaching of human origins, sex education, and on and on, it is inevitable when government runs the schools. Which is why the most important lesson to be learned from this presidential-address donnybrook is that Americans need educational freedom. We need universal school choice or crippling conflicts like this will keep on coming, liberty will continue to be compromised, and our society will be ripped farther and farther apart.

I’m not sure what the author means by "universal school choice", as it sounds eerily similar to the school choice that government-sponsored vouchers are supposed to facilitate, and to my way of thinking, even that much government involvement is pretty stupid.

MikeSoja - September 7, 2009 -- 10:28 pm    Filed in: Commies, Education, The Collective, Unfreedom  

September 4, 2009

Dear Fearless Leader

If I had readers, I might enable comments (just kidding), but they do uplift the spirit (occasionally) on others’ blogs.

On the subject of Obama’s address to the nation’s captive public school audience (a few of them, impressionable youngsters), comment 14 at Richard Fernandez’s place:

my kids will be asking their teachers — during the video — why obama doesn’t send his kids to public schools.

And comment 15, somewhat askew, but nevertheless appropriate:

Someone said that the arabs had a saying, “If the Russians ever conquer Arabia then we will suffer from a shortage of sand.” 

Apply that to the Department of Education.

MikeSoja - September 4, 2009 -- 12:13 am    Filed in: Education  

September 3, 2009

Not so hot for teacher

Robert Stacy McCain on a big chunk of what’s wrong with the government owned and operated (i.e. "public") school system:

I oppose public schools, period. And none of my kids have attended a public school since my wife and I pulled our daughter (now 20) out of the system after kindergarten.

As for prayer, every public-school student should be praying, “Please, God, get me out of this public school.”

It quickly gets to numerous points and goes on for 3800 words, the whole thing eminently readable.

MikeSoja - September 3, 2009 -- 06:45 pm    Filed in: Education  

August 26, 2009

Klein Boggle – A blonde walks into a confusing situation…

A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.

Ezra Klein wonders, wonders, why another heavily subsidized (by whom?  Can you guess?) industry consistently shows ever rising costs that outpace the Consumer Price Index:

Niraj Choksi runs the numbers and finds something interesting: Education costs have been rising even faster than medical costs:

[important looking chart goes here]

Per capita spending on health care is more than $7,000. It’s nowhere near as high in education, and so this is less of a problem. But it’s still interesting. More broadly, I’d like to know what experts think is driving the numbers. Is this hiding a relatively benign story, in which a lot more people are going to college, or graduate school, or even just choosing a private school? Is it just the cost of human labor rising quickly? Or is it more problematic? Or both?

Hey, Klein, you moron:  It’s the subsidies.  It’s the government SUBSIDIES.  It’s the taking of hundreds of millions of dollars from productive and successful people and scattering them higgledy-piggledy across the educational land.  It’s basic economics.  Health care, education, housing, it makes no difference.  You subsidize something, the price of that thing will tend to rise.  You could look it up, even.  Yes, I know, it’s hard for a tin-plated policy wonk (who never actually gets to watch the police go out and enforce his policy) to wrap his head around, but it is true nonetheless.

And it’s really sad.

Only a couple of Klein’s commenters even come close to answering the point in his call for "experts", demonstrating another side effect of two generations of massive subsidies for education:  A completely watered down product; people with "educations" who are stone stupid.

Relatedly, in nosing around for the heck of it, I found the following argument against the subsidization of education, on a navy.mil page, interesting (though I don’t agree with every point made):

There are numerous reasons why governments may decide to sue [sic] subsidies as a policy tool. Somewhat cynically Houthakker (1972) has argued that a main reason has to do with political vote buying. From an economic perspective, the main purpose of subsidies is to reallocate resources, that is, to alter economic activity and behavior to achieve an outcome that is more desirable from what would occur otherwise.  Hence arguments for subsidies are often based on some concept of efficiency or economic justice. But even when subsidies generate a more desirable outcome, it does not mean that the entire value of the subsidy is corrective in nature, or that the particular type of subsidy used for a given purpose is best among the available policy alternatives.

Economic arguments for using government subsidies generally fall into three broad categories:

1.      Offsetting various market imperfections;
2.      Exploiting economies of scale in production;
3.      Meeting social policy objectives, including, for example protecting the poor,
4.      Changing the distribution of income, and increasing or retaining employment.

Oftentimes, however, those sectors receiving the largest subsidies do not clearly meet these criteria.  Education subsidies in the United States are a prime example.  In the early 1990s the government was spending nearly $300 billion on education or around 15% of all government spending, making it the third largest single type of government expenditure behind only national defense and social security.  Meanwhile, government revenue collected from education was only around $30 billion. This $270 billion subsidy was roughly 5.5% of net national product.  Clearly, the choice to subsidize education is an important one, and this choice seems to be widely accepted as a good decision. But the reasons why subsidizing education is a good choice are not so obvious.

Unlike a public good like national defense, markets can and do provide education. It is not clear why the government should subsidize this good rather than let markets work unimpeded. Several normative justifications for subsidizing education have been put forth.  There are four main types: equity, paternalistic, borrowing constraint, and externality arguments. None of these is completely compelling, however. For example, few would argue, other things equal, against economic equality, especially equality of opportunity. This value judgment justifies helping the disadvantaged gain access to education.  It does not, however, justify subsidizing the educational opportunities for all income classes.

Most economists find the second type of argument even less compelling. The various paternalistic arguments are based on the presumption that people do not fully recognize the benefits associated with education, and thus do not purchase enough education on their own. Therefore, those who are fortunate enough to fully recognize the benefits of education argue that the subsidy is necessary to induce the less enlightened to make better choices. There are two major problems with this argument, however. It is difficult to objectively justify why many people do not fully appreciate the benefits of education while there are some enlightened ones who do.

There is also a similar problem in objectively distinguishing the enlightened opinions from the unenlightened. The third justification argues that many students are constrained from borrowing against their potential future income to finance their education. This capital market imperfection (largely due to government-imposed constraints) may cause many students to acquire less than efficient amounts of education. This obstacle to opportunity may be viewed as inequitable as well. But if this borrowing constraint is the problem, then government-supported loans are the obvious solution. There is no reason to lower the private cost of education and redistribute income to all publicly educated students, as subsidies do.

The fourth justification has received the most attention by economists. If acquiring education produces spillover benefits, self-interested individuals will acquire less than socially efficient amounts of education. A subsidy internalizes the externality and encourages students to acquire more efficient amounts of education. A common view, however, is that although these external benefits probably do exist, it is unlikely their magnitude is large enough to warrant a subsidy as large as the one observed, particularly at the level of higher education. It seems improbable that the marginal external benefit is as substantial as the subsidy. If the above arguments are valid, one is apparently left with the disturbing conclusion that subsidizing education, particularly higher education, is mostly a redistribution that is inequitable by commonly accepted standards of equity.

It’s also wrong to steal from some people in order to enrich others.

MikeSoja - August 26, 2009 -- 12:46 am    Filed in: Commies, Education, Health care, Morons  

August 10, 2009

Klein Boggle – Unteachable

A Klein Boggle is a certain non-orientable argument, i.e., a contention (a one-dimensional manifest) with no distinct "logical" and "reasonable" sides.

I don’t know when I’ve seen such confusion.  Ezra Klein, today (endless recriminations – link added!):

If we want teaching to be more competitive and respected, we could pay teachers a lot more money. If every teaching job paid $85,000 in its first year, and topped out at $200,00 for the best instructors, you’d have a lot more kids from Princeton applying for teaching gigs. And if a lot more kids from Princeton applied for teaching gigs, it would become the sort of job that’s associated with kids from Princeton, much like i-banking and law. How much we respect a profession has a lot to do with who we think goes into a profession.

Good lord.  What an idiot.  And double that for Sarah Fine, this morning’s object of Klein’s affection.

If donut shops were government owned and operated, and the guy in the back frying donuts was paid $200,000 a year, would donuts be any more or less a few bits of flour and milk with a sugary coating?  Would anyone care (stipulating to Klein’s nonsense that grads of Princeton are lured primarily with dollar bills) that the donut man went to Princeton?  "Oh, this is sooooo yummy baked by Princeton guy."  Or would everyone fucking wonder what the hell he was doing frying donuts?  And the donut fryer.  The Princeton grad.  He takes pride, day after day, in measuring those ingredients, and waiting until the fryer comes up to temperature?  Oh, yeah.  

Teaching’s the same, Klein.  It’s like making donuts.  Almost anyone can do it.  Even well.  Sure, some teachers are complete standouts.  But mostly it’s grunt work.  Year after year, the faces change, but two plus two is still four, the prepositions haven’t changed, and the condoms still go on with the reservoir tip at the end.

And Klein, toying with other people’s money in his square head, wonders, "[W]ould it be worth the investment?"

Read Sarah Fine’s story.  Klein linked it.  Besides being a moron who thought teaching would earn her "social recognition" on a par with doctors and lawyers (who, needless to say, have jobs more challenging than checking to see if Johnny turned in his homework), a large portion of the dissatisfaction she dropped out of teaching over had to do with the goddamned socialist government run educational bureaucracy.  Read the story.

Maybe she could seek out a teaching position in the private sector?  You know, where they reward competence.  Where her superiors might actually be interested in ideas that work.  Or maybe she just wasn’t that good.  Eh?

Here’s an idea:  Get the government out of the education business, and let the market decide what teachers are worth.  Mark my words, the market won’t be wrong, there will be no shortage of competent teachers, and the country will slowly fill up with a more educated, intelligent populace.

Klein, however, long past his formative years, is too big a bow wow to learn anything new.

MikeSoja - August 10, 2009 -- 11:56 am    Filed in: Education, Incompetents  

March 10, 2009

Democrats: Screw the kids

How come it’s always "for the children", except when there are children involved?

Senate Democrats have dealt a setback to a Republican-sponsored school voucher program that gives schoolchildren in the nation’s capital the chance to attend private schools.

Oh, yeah, when it’s for the unions.  Gotcha. 

The best thing "for the children" would be to get the government out of the education business.  Out.  Completely.

MikeSoja - March 10, 2009 -- 11:48 pm    Filed in: Commies, Education  

February 26, 2009

The collectivist conveyor belt to the slag heap of mediocrity

Otherwise known as the U.S. public school system.

Malone Vandam, with his usual gristle, observes the making of something akin to sausage.

MikeSoja - February 26, 2009 -- 12:15 pm    Filed in: Education, The Collective  

December 11, 2008

“School For $6 A Month”

Chester E. Finn Jr. is a new believer in the quiet phenomenon of free market schools surpassing their government sponsored counterparts in the steamy reaches of the third world.  Via Cato.

MikeSoja - December 11, 2008 -- 05:15 pm    Filed in: Education  

October 16, 2008

It’s at least as simple as learning your ‘ABC’s…

The seething lizard horde at Little Green Footballs is attending to one of its regular 1000+ comment fests over someone somewhere trying to steer school’s toward teaching creationism.  I haven’t skimmed today’s comments, but there was a similar thread a few weeks ago that I did look at, and in all the jabbering there was no one wondering WTF the government is doing in the education business to start with.  It’s been the same every time Charles makes a similar post.

So, here’s the deal, Lizards.  Look at yourselves jabbering away at it every time the subject comes up.  If you were to take a vote (which you shouldn’t), it is likely that a majority would vote to kick creationism out of the science department, if not out of the entire school, but the vociferous minority would hardly be placated, and they’d still be wanting to jabber on and on about it, and to call new votes, and so on and so forth.  A vote or arbitrary ruling does not change what people want.

The thing you gotta realize is:  Putting education in the hands of government, automatically, by definition, turns the whole deal political.  Now you’ve got politicos enticing voters with promises of board appointments to sneak creationism in.  The next elected big shot will swing education his way, pandering to whatever easily swayed mob serves him best.

Do you people want the schools you want, or do you want the schools that someone else is going to choose for you?  If the former, demand government get out of the education business, altogether, and then pick for yourself the school with the curriculum you want, and let your neighbors pick the school they want, even if the curriculum consists of something so ridiculous you wonder what you’re doing living next door to them.

On the other hand, if you don’t mind risking your child’s education to the whims and druthers of, oh, say, someone like Barack Obama, then just keep on jabbering away about how silly or tyrannical or undiversified the other idiot is.

But understand, if you don’t get the government out of the many things it is in (education is just one corner of the mess), you’re going to be jabbering the same things over and over for a very long time.  Maybe that’s good enough for you, but it looks pretty stupid from here.

MikeSoja - October 16, 2008 -- 10:37 pm    Filed in: Commies, Education  

September 19, 2008

Gibberish for the kids

They’re playing games with education in Idaho.  The "scholastic director" of the United States Chess Federation has sweet-talked some helpful administrator into incorporating chess into the Idaho grade school curriculum.  "That’s pre-algebra," man. 

Luna acknowledges there’s little hard evidence students actually benefit from playing chess, and it could take a few years before Idaho can gauge whether students who learn chess are more successful in academics.

"But if we’re going to encourage innovation and new ideas," Luna said, "we have to give those new ideas time to produce results."

No word, yet, on which part of reading, writing, or arithmetic is going to be done without.

Or why the educational fate of an entire state’s worth of kids should hinge on the whim of a bureaucrat or two.

MikeSoja - September 19, 2008 -- 12:03 am    Filed in: Education  

May 12, 2008

For the kids

Coulson at Cato-at-liberty.org gives a pointer to the many-dimensioned story of New Jersey’s advancement of a bill allowing businesses to donate to scholarship funds to be used to facilitate school choice. 

Coulson’s angle concerns the opposition of the teacher’s union to the bill, with reference to a like endeavor in the 90s, when PepsiCo tried to help the kids in its own way:

In late October of 1995, officials of the Pepsi company announced at Jersey City Hall that their corporation would donate thousands of dollars in scholarships to help low-income children attend the private school of their choice. The immediate response of the local public school teachers’ union was to threaten that a statewide boycott of all Pepsi products could not be ruled out. Pepsi vending machines around the city were vandalized and jammed. Three weeks later, company officials regretfully withdrew their offer.

Now there’s enlightenment for ya.

Me, I wonder why the hell corporations or anybody else needs a law passed in order to donate their own money to people who will use it to buy a better education for themselves?  What happened to freedom in this country?  Does anybody know?

The usual quote that always makes me laugh (although in a derisive and not otherwise entirely healthy way) can be found by following the link in the link above:

Union officials said the measure, if it became law, would have a devastating impact on public education.

Yeah.  I would hope for it, but it’s going to take a lot more than a few tax write offs to pry the bureaucrat’s ignorant fingers off education.

MikeSoja - May 12, 2008 -- 11:50 pm    Filed in: Education, Freedom, Stupid Government  

February 4, 2008

The old goat keeps chewing the same old can…

Garrison Keillor, one of the barnyard’s more toothless old collectivists can be found plodding in increasingly far pastures, yet is still able to eruct from one of his common stomachs and ruminate upon the thin reapings that his way of non-thinking has sown for him:

And then there is the grief that old righteous people inflict on the young, such as our public schools. I’m looking at U.S. Department of Education statistics on reading achievement and see that here in Minnesota — proud, progressive Minnesota — on a 500-point test (average score: 225), 27 percent of fourth-graders score below basic proficiency, and black and Hispanic kids score 30-some points lower than white on average, and the 30 percent of public schoolkids who come from households in poverty (who qualify for reduced-price school lunches) score 27 points lower than those who don’t come from poverty. 

Reading is the key to everything. Teaching children to read is a fundamental moral obligation of the society. That 27 percent are at serious risk of crippling illiteracy is an outrageous scandal. 

This is a bleak picture for an old Democrat. Face it, the schools are not run by Republican oligarchs in top hats and spats but by perfectly nice, caring, sharing people, with a smattering of yoga/raga/tofu/mojo/mantra folks like my old confreres. Nice people are failing these kids, but when they are called on it, they get very huffy. When the grand poobah Ph.D.s of education stand up and blow, they speak with great confidence about theories of teaching, and considering the test results, the bums ought to be thrown out. 

There is much evidence that teaching phonics really works […] 

So Keillor chews his cud, without a clue.  The problem isn’t that there hasn’t been a suitable one-size-fits-all curriculum shoved down the nationwide throat of the education-seeking citizenry, but that old idiots like Keillor continue to think that one-size-fits-all solutions are, existing failure upon existing failure notwithstanding, what earnest citizens need more of.

Ah, "phonics".  Now there’s a clever idea; let’s force everyone to try that!

Never once do these people see that it’s the "forcing everyone to try that" that is the wrong thing, that is the inefficient thing, the incompetent thing, the anti-freedom thing.

But, Keillor says, "Reading is the key to everything."  No, it’s fundamentally important to Garrison Keillor, and to a great many people, but it certainly isn’t the "key to everything".  People like Garrison Keillor, for instance, can read and write just fine, but one can easily make the charge stick that many of them can’t think (evidence: imbuing the non-entity "society" with "moral obligation" is typical collectivist anthropomorphism, ie., nonsense), and I say that thinking is the key to everything.  And even as I say that, I know that that is just my opinion, and that I have no more right to try to force everyone else to try to think than Garrison Keillor has to try to force everyone else to undertake the adoption of whatever it is he comes up with to value.

At root, Keillor is complaining about the politicization of the education system, but what did collectivists like Keillor expect when they clamored over the course of a whole century for education to be increasingly swallowed by the political establishment?  What does Keillor expect now?  That decisions made by political bodies will be free of politics?  Expecting a thing to act outside its nature is ignorant.  But Keillor can read and write.  It’s not possible that he can read and write and still be stupid, is it?

The solution is, Keillor, simply to not inhibit free people deciding for themselves what is of value specifically to themselves.  Vis a vis education, that means getting government, lock, stock, and barrel, out of the education business.  Quit trying to decide for other people how best to teach their kids.  Quit trying to force everyone to attend your failing one-size-fits-all schools.  Quit trying to chain an erstwhile free people to another temple of your ignorant mediocrity.  Keillor complains about the 27% who show up in the test scores as functionally illiterate, but he zips right past the fact that the average score on those tests was 225 out of 500.  That’s a pretty dismal indictment right there.  When does a smarty pants like Garrison Keillor come to the conclusion that it isn’t the lack of "phonics" that is the problem?  What does it take for a big I-know-what’s-best guy like Keillor to figure out that if anyone he hired performed like the public schools perform he’d fire them on the spot, and hire someone else.  When will Mr. I Can Read and Write Keillor quit working to force his dim understanding of how the world really works onto his fellow citizens?

MikeSoja - February 4, 2008 -- 02:54 pm    Filed in: Commies, Education  

January 25, 2008

Stupid and Stupider…

One more sucker on the hydra of nationalized education:

A few years ago, Dennis DeTurck, an award-winning professor of mathematics at the University of Pennsylvania, stood at an outdoor podium on campus and proclaimed, "Down with fractions!"

"Fractions have had their day, being useful for by-hand calculation," DeTurck said as part of a 60-second lecture series. "But in this digital age, they’re as obsolete as Roman numerals are."

[…]

DeTurck is stirring the pot again, this time in a book scheduled to be published this year. Not only does he favor the teaching of decimals over fractions to elementary school students, he’s also taking on long division, the calculation of square roots and by-hand multiplication of long numbers.

[…]

DeTurck does not want to abolish the teaching of fractions and long division altogether. He believes fractions are important for high-level mathematics and scientific research. But it could be that the study of fractions should be delayed until it can be understood, perhaps after a student learns calculus, he said. Long division has its uses, too, but maybe it doesn’t need to be taught as intensely.

I’m not sure where DeTurck has been the last years, but he’s severely behind the times.  The U.S. public school system has been experimenting with not teaching fractions, long division, and other stuff deemed superfluous to the discipline of mathematics, for years now.

With great displeasure, please allow me introduce to you the Connected Mathematics Project, currently ruining lives in a public school near you:

The Overarching Goal of the Connected Mathematics Project:

All students should be able to reason and communicate proficiently in mathematics. They should have knowledge of and skill in the use of the vocabulary, forms of representation, materials, tools, techniques, and intellectual methods of the discipline of mathematics, including the ability to define and solve problems with reason, insight, inventiveness and proficiency. 

Notice they don’t claim that students should be able to solve problems with such esoteria as "fractions" or "long division" or even "mathematics", because the CMP isn’t about teaching the old rote methods.  Instead they teach to "communicate proficiently in mathematics", whatever the hell that means.  The program was developed with (you guessed it) federal funds over the last twenty or so years, and is currently the curriculum in a large number schools across the country, though exactly how many, no one knows.

What is known is that when parents become aware that programs like the CMP have taken the place of traditional math curricula at their own kids’ schools, and when parents get a load of what their kids aren’t learning, then the fun starts:

In Plano, Texas, 600 parents are suing the school district because of its exclusive use of the Connected Mathematics Project, or CMP, another "exemplary" program. I have received hundreds of requests for help by parents and teachers because of these and other programs now promoted by the Education Department (ED).

The same link spells it out:

The mathematics programs criticized by the open letter have common features. For example, they tend to overemphasize data analysis and statistics, which typically appear year after year, with redundant presentations. The far more important areas of arithmetic and algebra are radically de-emphasized. Many of the so-called higher-order thinking projects are just aimless activities, and genuine illumination of important mathematical ideas is rare. There is a near obsession with calculators, and basic skills are given short shrift and sometimes even disparaged. Overall, these curricula are watered-down math programs. The same educational philosophy that gave rise to the whole-language approach to reading is part of ED’s agenda for mathematics. Systematic development of skills and concepts is replaced by an unstructured "holism." In fact, during the mid-’90s, supporters of programs like these referred to their approach as "whole math." 

Disagreements over math curricula are often portrayed as "basic skills versus conceptual understanding." Scientists and mathematicians, including many who signed the open letter to Secretary Riley, are described as advocates of basic skills, while professional educators are counted as proponents of conceptual understanding. Ironically, such a portrayal ignores the deep conceptual understanding of mathematics held by so many mathematicians. But more important, the notion that conceptual understanding in mathematics can be separated from precision and fluency in the execution of basic skills is just plain wrong.

For a whole compendium of crtiques  of the already widespread CMP program, clicky here, and then wonder what the controversy about stupid Professor DeTurck’s upcoming book is about.  DeTurck and his compatriots have already turned your kid into a moron.

MikeSoja - January 25, 2008 -- 03:20 pm    Filed in: Education  

January 3, 2008

Throw the Bums Out…

The Great and Wise Malone Vandam makes some positive recommendations for his local school district.  He would like to relieve them of the responsibility that they have consistently shirked.  Amongst his usual astute observations, he refers to his local district’s web page wherein they brag:

[S]chools must still prepare students in the Three Rs, but they are no longer the reading, writing, and arithmetic of the traditional educational system. The new Three Rs are Rigor, Relevance, and Relationships.

The emphasis is the school districts’.  That is what modern education has come to.  Read Vandam’s answer to that pap.  He is instructive in a way that one suspects is beyond the ken of those who are now jockeying to cement their places at the public trough for the foreseeable future.

Note all the talk the district makes of “21st Century Education”.  I recall that Vandam has pointed out before, that irrespective of the immorality of the socialist underpinnings (sufficient in its own right for immediate dismantling), schools of the future will not be welded to the huge, expensive buildings with which district after district across the country are currently trying to saddle the serfs.  “21st Century Education” will undoubtedly take place instead on some sort of computer network.  Imagine it, and all the positives that would accrue from it.  And watch the entrenched powers kick and scream against it as they’ve never kicked and screamed before.

MikeSoja - January 3, 2008 -- 12:46 pm    Filed in: Education  
  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. 3
  5. 4
As Happy As A Clam

Kayak2U.com

msoja RSS 2.0

Other's Pages









Search

Archive

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  


  • Books4Sale



    Soja's GoodReads Books4Sale Cheap

  • Category Cloud


  • Tag Cloud